3 Best Painters Near South Huntington, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving South Huntington, NY have earned strong reputations for thorough prep work, clean job sites, and results that hold up over time. The top-rated companies on Chooz Painters share a common thread: customers who hire them once tend to come back, often referring neighbors and family members along the way. Whether the project involves a single room, a full interior repaint, kitchen cabinets, or exterior work, these contractors consistently receive top marks across multiple review platforms.

Frank's Painting of LI LLC leads the South Huntington, NY area with a Chooz Score of 87.6%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Angi with over 340 reviews, 4.7 stars on Yelp with over 70 reviews, and 98% recommended on Facebook. Operating since 2015 and holding Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H3811120000, Frank's has completed over 3,000 residential projects across Nassau and Western Suffolk Counties. A detail that stands out across reviews is the company's color consultation process - Frank works with an interior designer and color specialist named Dyane, a step reviewers describe as genuinely helpful when planning a full interior refresh. If you want a large-scale painting company with a structured process and a wide service range, Frank's is a good fit.

Reading through reviews, a consistent pattern emerges: customers who were initially anxious about having contractors in their home describe leaving for errands mid-project with complete peace of mind. Frank's also handles a wide variety of work beyond standard interior painting, including kitchen cabinet painting, power washing, skim coating, crown molding installation, and wallpaper removal on century-old homes.

• Color consultation with designer Dyane is available for larger projects, helping customers arrive at a confident color selection before the crew arrives.
• The company does not subcontract - reviewers mention the same foremen and crew members by name across projects spanning multiple years.
• Frank responds personally to estimate requests, often the same day, with many reviewers reporting scheduling within one to two weeks of first contact.
• Repeat business is common - a number of reviewers note this was their second or third time hiring Frank's, with plans to return for more work.

Also earning top marks in the area, Big Expert Painting LLC achieved a Chooz Score of 87.0%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 130 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, along with consistent praise on Yelp. Owner Denis holds Suffolk County Home Improvement License No. HI-68388 (active through 2027) and carries EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work in pre-1978 homes. Denis answers calls himself, and several reviewers describe same-day or next-day responses to quote requests, including on weekends. For homeowners who want an owner-led operation that stays easy to reach from first call to final walkthrough, Big Expert is a strong fit.

A pattern that surfaces repeatedly in Big Expert reviews is customers expanding their original scope mid-project. One reviewer originally hired Denis for three rooms, was so impressed she immediately booked two more. Another has relied on Denis for over 7 years across projects ranging from porch columns to full interior repaints. Big Expert also handles a broader range of work than strictly painting, with reviews mentioning ceiling and sheetrock repairs, deck staining, power washing, and door installation.

• EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification makes Big Expert a particularly solid choice for homes built before 1978, where lead paint removal requires special handling.
• Multiple reviewers describe finishing ahead of the estimated timeline - one reviewer noted a 3-day estimate completed in 2 days.
• Denis personally follows up after projects wrap - one reviewer recalled a check-in call a month later confirming everything was still looking good.

With over 25 years in business, Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting has built one of the deepest loyalty bases of any painting contractor on Long Island. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.7%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 245 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, along with 4.8 stars on Yelp with over 25 reviews and 5.0 stars on Angi with over 80 reviews. Walker holds Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H3807630000 with zero complaints on file, plus an NYC DCWP license. Sal Sciame handles estimates and is frequently named in reviews - customers describe him providing same-day quotes after same-day site visits.

Walker's reviews tell a story of long-term relationships rather than one-time transactions. Customers describe using them for two decades and contracting them repeatedly for exterior painting, kitchen cabinets, wallpaper removal, deck staining, and full interior repaints. Crew members like Hugo, Alfredo, Juan, Martin, and Luis appear by name across dozens of reviews, with customers specifically requesting familiar faces for return work. For homeowners looking for one company to handle all painting needs for years to come, Walker is a strong fit.

• Wallpaper removal and skim coating are a regular part of Walker's scope - several reviewers describe wall repair and surface prep as part of the job, not an add-on.
• Crews handle furniture removal and restoration including drapes as part of the project - reviewers with full-house repaints describe walking back in to find everything back in place.
• Sal consistently earns praise for providing honest opinions on scope and budget rather than simply agreeing to whatever the customer suggests.

Rounding out the top contractors in South Huntington, NY, JRT Pro Painters LLC earned a Chooz Score of 84.3%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 65 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Brayan Rivas Ticas holds Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor License No. HI-66725 and the company has been serving Long Island homeowners for 4 years. Brayan's responsiveness earns frequent mention - reviewers note quick replies to messages, flexibility around scheduling, and willingness to accommodate adjustments as the project unfolds. If you're looking for a contractor who stays accessible and hands-on throughout, JRT is a good fit.

JRT handles a broad scope of work. Reviews mention deck painting and staining, kitchen cabinet repaints, crown molding installation, ceiling repairs from water damage, and complete interior repaints. Brayan is noted for going beyond the original scope when unexpected issues arise - including identifying and repairing drywall nail pops left by a prior contractor before starting the paint work. The crew also hauls away debris and prep materials at the end of each job, leaving the home clean without extra coordination on the homeowner's part.

• Kitchen cabinet painting is a strength, with multiple reviewers calling it a cost-effective alternative to full cabinet replacement.
• Deck and exterior staining work earns strong reviews alongside interior projects, making JRT a versatile choice for multi-scope projects.
• The crew handles debris removal as part of the job - reviewers appreciate not having to arrange additional cleanup after the project ends.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Across all four top-rated contractors serving South Huntington, NY, quality of finished work is the most consistently praised element in reviews. Customers frequently describe results that exceed their expectations, with specific details like smooth wall surfaces, crisp lines on trim and molding, and paint that looks professionally applied rather than rolled on by hand. Frank's Painting of LI LLC draws particular praise for work on complex surfaces - reviewers describe crews tackling stucco exterior finishes, plaster walls in older homes, and cabinet painting that leaves doors looking factory-fresh. One reviewer described hiring Frank's to work on a nearly 100-year-old house, noting how the team handled difficult prep on aged wood and prior coatings. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting earns consistent mention for painter Hugo's cabinet and island work, with one reviewer writing that Hugo "made our island and cabinetry look brand new" - a finish that typically requires careful surface prep and multiple thin coats to achieve cleanly. Reviewers also frequently comment on Walker's wall prep, describing sanding, skimming, and hole-filling as a standard part of the process rather than something they needed to request separately.

Big Expert Painting LLC and JRT Pro Painters LLC also draw strong marks for finished quality, particularly on jobs involving damage repair. Big Expert reviewers describe sheetrock repairs on basement ceilings and walls that came out clean and seamlessly blended with surrounding surfaces. JRT customers mention ceiling work after water damage where the finished result showed no trace of the original problem. For homeowners in South Huntington, NY dealing with a combination of surface repairs and painting, both companies appear equally comfortable handling the full scope.

• "The team prepped the walls thoroughly and finished beautifully. Pricing was very reasonable for the quality and attention to detail." - D. G., Google Review (Frank's Painting)
• "Brayan and his coworker are neat, extremely punctual, precise and perfectionist at what they work on." - Christina S., Google Review (JRT Pro Painters)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Prep work and cleanup are among the most frequently mentioned strengths across reviews for painting contractors in South Huntington, NY. Customers who have had poor experiences with other painters before tend to call out these details explicitly. For Frank's Painting of LI LLC, the standard process described in reviews includes spreading drop cloths throughout, carefully covering all furniture and plants, hanging dust barriers between rooms, and completing daily cleanup before leaving. Several reviewers note that Frank's crews finish one section at a time and restore it to order before moving on. Multiple reviews from repeat customers describe returning after errands to find the house in better condition than expected, with crews having vacuumed and wiped down work areas before departing. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting draws similar comments, with one reviewer describing the prep process in detail: "Its about the prep and the time they took filling holes, sanding and skimming where necessary made all the difference. Our walls look like new!" Walker crews are also noted for handling furniture removal, floor protection, and restoration of drapes and furnishings as part of the job on larger whole-house projects.

For JRT Pro Painters LLC, prep work earns specific praise in multiple reviews. Customers describe spackling, priming, skim coating, and protecting all furniture and floors before any paint goes on. One reviewer noted that Brayan and his crew identified and repaired drywall nail pops from a prior contractor before starting the paint work, going beyond the original scope without being asked. JRT also takes care of debris removal at the end of each job. Big Expert Painting LLC reviewers echo these themes, describing a fast-moving crew that still makes time to protect personal items, move quickly, and clean up before leaving. If detailed prep work and clean job sites matter to you in South Huntington, NY, all four of these contractors deliver consistently on both counts.

• "They thoroughly protected the work area and cleaned up when they were finished." - Janette P., Google Review (JRT Pro Painters)
• "They covered everything, cleaned up at the end of every day and did every little thing we asked for." - Judy N., Google Review (Walker Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Professionalism and communication are two of the most consistently praised qualities across reviews for painting contractors in South Huntington, NY. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting earns strong marks here through Sal Sciame's estimate process - reviewers describe calling one evening and having Sal at the house for a walkthrough the next morning, with an estimate in hand the same day. Sal is frequently described as honest, responsive, and straightforward about what work is actually needed. One reviewer credited Sal with checking in even after the project was complete to confirm everything was still meeting expectations. Big Expert Painting LLC draws similar reviews around owner Denis, who answers calls directly and responds to quote requests on weekends. Denis is personally mentioned in the majority of Big Expert reviews, and customers consistently describe him as easy to reach before, during, and after projects. One reviewer noted a follow-up call from Denis a month after completing a job to make sure everything was still looking good, which several customers specifically called out as unusual and appreciated.

JRT Pro Painters LLC earns consistent praise for Brayan's responsiveness and flexibility. Reviewers describe quick replies to messages and a willingness to accommodate scheduling adjustments as the project unfolds. One reviewer noted that Brayan worked with them through a medical delay without issue. Frank's Painting of LI LLC draws strong marks for Frank's pre-project communication and estimate responsiveness, though one reviewer mentioned a preference for more direct contact once the project was underway - worth asking about if ongoing communication throughout the job is a priority for you. Overall, homeowners in South Huntington, NY can expect professional, courteous crews and accessible owner contact from each of these top-rated contractors.

• "Brayan was very accommodating with all the little extras I asked him to do." - Kathy P., Google Review (JRT Pro Painters)
• "Sal is amazing to work with! He was very responsive, flexible and reliable - always called back promptly." - Patrick D., Google Review (Walker Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Pricing comes up frequently in reviews for painting contractors in South Huntington, NY, and the general consensus across multiple platforms is that the top-rated companies offer fair value for the quality of work delivered. Big Expert Painting LLC draws particular mention for competitive pricing - reviewers consistently describe Denis's quotes as reasonable and several note that pricing is a factor in returning for additional projects. One reviewer who has maintained a relationship with Denis for over 7 years described the pricing as "more than fair" across jobs ranging from small detail work to full interior repaints. JRT Pro Painters LLC earns similar comments, with one repeat customer noting that while Brayan's rates are not the cheapest available, the quality of work justifies the price. A number of reviewers describe getting multiple quotes and finding JRT's pricing in the middle range - neither the lowest bid nor the highest, but competitive given the results delivered.

For Frank's Painting of LI LLC and Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting, pricing commentary tends to frame the cost as "reasonable for professional work" rather than budget-level. Frank's reviewers frequently note that pricing is fair given the volume of prep work included. Walker reviewers, some of whom have contracted the company over many years, tend to describe pricing as consistent and honest, with Sal providing accurate estimates that reflect the actual scope of work. For homeowners in South Huntington, NY evaluating bids, these contractors are generally positioned as professional-grade contractors with pricing that reflects the quality and consistency their reviews demonstrate.

• "Of all the price quotes we received, theirs was right in the middle. We definitely got high value for the price we paid." - Kent C., Google Review (JRT Pro Painters)
• "Frank and his team were professional, reliable and everything came out great." - Sarah W., Google Review (Frank's Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Timeliness and scheduling reliability earn consistent praise across reviews for top-rated painting contractors in South Huntington, NY. Frank's Painting of LI LLC draws frequent mention for prompt crew arrivals - one reviewer noted the crew arrived early rather than simply on time - and for fast turnaround from estimate to project start, often within one to two weeks of first contact. Frank personally responds to estimate requests quickly, and multiple reviewers describe scheduling as smooth and easy to coordinate. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting is noted for Sal's quick response to inquiries and his ability to get estimates done the same day he visits the site. Reviewers describe projects completed on or ahead of schedule, and Walker's long-standing customers particularly appreciate that the company remains easy to schedule for follow-up work even years after the initial project.

JRT Pro Painters LLC earns strong marks for showing up as promised, putting in full 8-9 hour days, and completing within the estimated timeframe. One reviewer described a 2.5-day project where the crew arrived each day as scheduled, worked full days, and cleaned up before leaving each evening. For Big Expert Painting LLC, reviewers repeatedly note that Denis and his crew finish ahead of the estimated timeline - one reviewer noted a 3-day estimate wrapped in 2 days. Multiple reviewers also describe Denis as flexible about scheduling, available on weekends, and willing to fit in smaller jobs without a long wait. For homeowners in South Huntington, NY who need a project completed on a specific timeline, these four contractors have strong track records for reliability.

• "They were at my house for 2.5 days, they arrived as scheduled and put in full 8-9 hour days, cleaning up at the end of each day." - Sher, Google Review (JRT Pro Painters)
• "Gave me an estimate of 3 days to complete and they finished in 2 days." - Chantel B., Google Review (Big Expert Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Repeat business and long-term customer loyalty stand out as one of the most consistent themes across all four top-rated painting contractors in South Huntington, NY. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting has built particularly deep roots in this regard - reviewers describe relationships spanning 20 years or more, with multiple customers noting they've lost count of how many projects Walker has completed for them. One reviewer has contracted Walker for exterior painting, a full kitchen including cabinets, and a studio apartment over multiple seasons. Others mention referring Walker to siblings, neighbors, and friends who then became longtime customers themselves. Big Expert Painting LLC has similar retention numbers, with one customer maintaining a working relationship with owner Denis for over 7 years and another returning for a seventh project. Jackie H. originally hired Big Expert for a few rooms, was pleased, and immediately asked Denis to come back for additional work - a pattern that appears across multiple reviews.

For Frank's Painting of LI LLC, repeat customer reviews frequently mention returning after a positive first experience, with several noting they tried other painters in between and came back to Frank's. Reviewers like Christine M. explicitly describe this experience, calling Frank's "so much better" than the other painters they'd tried in between projects. JRT Pro Painters LLC has built repeat business over its four years in operation, with Christina S. describing Brayan as having painted her entire house over multiple years, starting with a single project before Thanksgiving and returning multiple times until the whole house was done. For homeowners in South Huntington, NY looking for a contractor they can call back year after year, all four of these companies have demonstrated the consistency that keeps customers returning.

• "Miriam used him twice and would not hesitate to call him back for more painting." - Miriam R., Google Review (JRT Pro Painters)
• "I have been using Walker Painting for the last 20 years. Sal always gives me an honest opinion on what the work will cost." - Linda D., Google Review (Walker Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi