Homeowners and commercial clients in Staten Island, NY have no shortage of strong options when it comes to painting contractors. The companies earning the highest Chooz Scores here share a few things in common: owners who stay personally involved from estimate to final walkthrough, crews who are named by customers in review after review, and a consistency that drives repeat business and referrals across the borough.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, CertaPro Painters of Staten Island had over 165 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 87.8%. Owner Todd Geoghan personally handles every estimate, walking customers through the full scope - primer coats, top coats, and what repairs will be addressed before paint goes on. Office Associate Antonella Vecchio manages scheduling and places mid-project check-in calls, creating a two-layer communication system that reviewers describe as a standout quality. With 5 years in business, BBB accreditation since 2020, and Staten Island Chamber of Commerce membership, the company covers Staten Island and select Brooklyn neighborhoods. If you want structured communication and an owner who stays visible throughout your project, CertaPro Painters of Staten Island is a strong fit.
Crews led by Julio, Mike, and Joel appear consistently across reviews, suggesting stable team assignments. Plastic sheeting in doorways during sanding prep is a recurring detail that reflects their approach to dust control, and multi-room interiors frequently wrap in a single day.
- Named crew members Julio, Mike, and Joel appear in Google and BBB reviews spanning different years, indicating consistent team deployment
- Plastic sheeting hung in doorways during prep work is a specific detail mentioned in BBB reviews, pointing to consistent dust containment practices
- Multi-room interiors frequently complete in a single day, with customers noting no disruption to their household
- BBB accreditation since 2020 and Staten Island Chamber of Commerce membership complement the 5.0-star Google rating
"Todd and Antonella were a pleasure to work with and most of all the painters were quick, efficient and clean. The spaces came out awesome and the walls are flawless." - jay mala, Google Review
Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Premier Painting Pros, which earned a Chooz Score of 87.1% with over 85 Google reviews averaging a 5.0-star rating. Owner Bartosz is personally named in nearly every review, handling estimates, keeping communication going throughout jobs, and following up after completion. The range of work is notable: exterior siding and soffit spraying, interior room painting, mahogany door staining, custom wooden fence refinishing, cabinet spray refinishing, and drywall repair all appear across reviews. If you are looking for a hands-on owner with diverse skills in both interior and exterior work, Premier Painting Pros is a reliable choice.
Several reviewers mention returning for a 5th, 6th, or 7th project with Bartosz, and referrals from friends and family come up across multiple reviews. The company also offers a 2-year rust-free guarantee on applicable exterior work, and at least one reviewer confirmed Bartosz showed up promptly to honor it when rust spots appeared.
- Cabinet spray refinishing returns factory-smooth results; customers describe 17-year-old cabinets looking brand new after spray treatment
- Bartosz explains paint selection, appropriate coatings, and application methods to customers before starting - product knowledge that draws specific praise
- Last-minute scheduling flexibility is documented by repeat customers, including one who described Bartosz completing several urgent jobs on short notice
- A 2-year rust-free guarantee on exterior work is offered, with at least one confirmed warranty follow-through described in a Google review
"This is probably my 6th or 7th time using Bartosz for various projects around my houses. One, don't look any further, he's an excellent painter with reasonable prices. He's super responsive, reliable and has done a few jobs for me last minute which has helped me out greatly." - Stephen Giambrone, Google Review
While both CertaPro Painters of Staten Island and Premier Painting Pros focus primarily on residential projects, Design Painting Of Staten Island takes on a broader commercial scope alongside home work - and still earned a Chooz Score of 85.5%. At the time of our analysis, they had over 175 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, along with 4.9 stars on Angi with over 25 Angi reviews, and are 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Jeremy leads the operation, with foreman Miguel handling most residential jobs and Maurice specializing in cabinet and specialty refinishing. If you manage a rental property, run a commercial space, or need a crew familiar with historic or specialty structures, Design Painting Of Staten Island has documented experience across all three.
Commercial clients include rental property owners with multiple units in north Brooklyn, a commercial deli that required full renovation during a 48-hour closure, and a 143-year-old landmark church that needed specialty door restoration. On the residential side, Jeremy is consistently praised for quick responses to questions throughout the job, and crew members like Miguel, Maurice, Frank, and Javier appear across reviews spanning multiple years - a sign of stable staffing rather than rotating workers.
- Commercial and institutional work including deli renovations and historic building door restoration is documented in Google and Angi reviews
- Lead paint removal with specialized coatings for residential clients is among their confirmed service types, per Google reviews
- Jeremy personally responds quickly to questions during the project rather than going silent after the estimate is signed
- Crew members Miguel, Maurice, Frank, and Javier appear across reviews spanning several years, reflecting long-term employee retention
"Design Painting is my go-to for contracting and painting work at my three-unit north Brooklyn rental property. Jeremy and his team quote competitive prices, show up to and finish jobs on time and always do outstanding work (with cleanup!)" - Ken K., Angi Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, BBB, Facebook, Angi
