Best Painters Near Tappan, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners and business owners in Tappan, NY have solid options when it comes to finding a reliable painting contractor. The companies serving this corner of Rockland County bring a range of specialties, from whole-house interior and exterior repaints to deck restoration, wallpaper installation, cabinet refinishing, and drywall repair. What stands out across these four top performers is the depth of their repeat customer bases - people who come back not just once, but for years of ongoing projects.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, C.E.T. Painting had over 240 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 90.9%. Based in Elmsford and serving the broader Westchester and Rockland County area, C.E.T. brings a notably wide range of capabilities. Reading through the reviews, one pattern that stands out is how often customers mention being able to leave for errands or continue working in nearby rooms without disruption. Owner Carlos leads a crew that includes John, Pablo, Maria, and an administrative team that handles the paperwork side - including the complex requirements for NYC co-op and condo buildings. The company holds active licenses including NYC's Home Improvement Contractor License No. 2114838-DCA and Westchester County License No. WC-29252-H16, and has been BBB accredited since 2022. At the time of our analysis, they also held 4.7 stars on Yelp, 5.0 stars on Angi, and were 100% recommended on Facebook. If you need a contractor who can handle both residential projects and commercial spaces - including institutional settings like libraries and automotive shops - C.E.T. is a strong fit.

• Reviews frequently cite specific crew members like John, Pablo, and Maria by name, with multiple customers mentioning they called the team back specifically for a named painter.
• Several reviewers note C.E.T. managed projects in active co-op and condo buildings in New York City, coordinating all building requirements without issue.
• The company handles multi-service projects combining drywall repair, water damage work, and painting in a single visit.
• Customers across both commercial and residential reviews note that Carlos personally monitors scheduling and responsiveness throughout each project.

"Punctual, polite, neat, professional are just a few words that describe my experience. The bonus - I was still able to work in a nearby room without disruption." - Joey K., Google Review

For homeowners looking for an owner-led team that personally checks on work daily, Pro Painting Plus has built a strong following in the area with a Chooz Score of 87.6%. Owner Rob McRae is a recurring figure in reviews - customers mention he walked the job personally during estimates, pointed out issues they hadn't noticed, and returned throughout the project to verify quality. His crews - which have included Dario, Eric, Oscar, Luis, Miguel, Herbie, and Juan across various projects - draw particular praise for their work on specialty and challenging surfaces. Reading through the reviews, several notable projects emerge: a 1865 tin roof restoration, cedar siding work on a log cabin, and exterior painting on a historic church. Multiple reviewers have come back for a second and even third engagement. If you're dealing with a surface type that stumped other painters or need someone who will personally follow up at every stage, Pro Painting Plus earns strong recommendations.

• Owner Rob visited job sites regularly and confirmed quality standards throughout, not just at the start and finish.
• Reviews mention the company handled emergency timeline situations - such as stepping in four days before a client's move-in after another contractor walked off the job.
• Specialty work on historic homes, log cabins, and unusual roofing materials appears across multiple independent reviews.

"Rob and his crew are great. Very professional. They did a fantastic job painting my dining room and kitchen. Would highly recommend!" - JoEllen D., Google Review

Also serving the Tappan, NY area, MGP Painting Inc. earned a Chooz Score of 87.2%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi with over 10 reviews, and were 96% recommended on Facebook. Based in Orangeburg, MGP has been operating in Rockland County since 2012, putting them at over 13 years in business. Owner Moises leads a team that includes crew members Galo, Caesar, and Orlando, who are called out by name in reviews for their attention to detail on trim, edges, and wallpaper installation. What stands out from reading through the reviews is the company's capacity for handling complex spaces - one reviewer describes a job involving popcorn ceilings, 28 steps across multiple levels, and high ceilings with recessed lights and fans, all handled without issue. The repeat customer rate here is notable: multiple reviewers are on their third or fourth project with MGP. A good fit for homeowners who want a contractor experienced with wallpaper, specialty finishes, and larger-scale interior repaints.

• Named crew members Galo, Caesar, and Orlando are cited for precise edge work and careful prep across multiple independent reviews.
• Wallpaper installation and removal appear more frequently in MGP reviews than in other local contractors, suggesting this is a genuine specialty.
• Moises is noted for thorough prep-stage walkthroughs where he identifies issues and explains the scope clearly before work begins.
• Prep work protection - covering floors, furniture, and fixtures - is mentioned consistently across reviews spanning several years.

"I searched and vetted several potential painters before selecting MGP. To paint several custom new closets. They did an outstanding job." - Chris, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Tappan, NY, Aquinas Painting Contractors earned a Chooz Score of 86.3% and brings something few companies in the area can match: a history that stretches back to nearly 40 years in business since 1987. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 80 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. Currently led by Alex Solis, the company operates with all painters holding OSHA certification and carries Rockland County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H-25-030. Reading through the reviews, a standout observation is the sheer scale of jobs they routinely handle - one reviewer mentions Aquinas painted a 10-room house and front porch in just three days. The company serves Rockland, Westchester, Bergen County NJ, and Orange County NY. For homeowners who value deep local roots and institutional-level credentials alongside quality residential work, Aquinas is a strong option.

• Alex Solis leads the team today, continuing work the company began with founder Jim Dugandzic in 1987.
• All painters carry OSHA certification - an unusual credential for a residential painting contractor that signals formal safety training.
• Reviews note Aquinas handles institutional projects including a convent exterior, alongside typical residential work.

"They were thorough, clean, quiet and respectful of our belongings. We highly recommend them." - Sean M., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Quality of finished work is the top theme that surfaces across reviews of painting contractors serving Tappan, NY and surrounding Rockland County communities. Customers consistently note that results exceeded what they expected coming in, particularly on projects where surfaces were in poor condition or had unusual materials. C.E.T. Painting draws strong praise for detailed prep work and clean edges - one reviewer describes having an exterior stucco house painted for the first time in its nearly 100-year history, and still smiling at the results a full year later. Another reviewer notes they had extensive water damage and drywall repaired alongside a multi-room repaint and called the seamless finish remarkable.

At Pro Painting Plus, quality observations often come with specific before-and-after context. One reviewer describes hiring Rob's team to salvage a deck that a previous contractor had sanded and painted while wet, then walked off the job. The Pro Painting Plus crew sanded everything back and restored it properly. Another reviewer details a color-matching challenge on cedar siding with multiple wood types - cedar, teak, and pine - and describes the finished result as almost unrecognizable from the original. MGP Painting Inc. earns similar praise for technical precision, particularly on wallpaper installation and the kind of prep work that determines how well paint holds over time. Multiple reviewers note that MGP's crews covered floors, furniture, and fixtures carefully before beginning, and that the protection itself was a sign of the care that followed. Aquinas Painting Contractors handles large-scope interior and exterior projects with consistent quality over decades - one reviewer's family has used them for over 20 years and notes they have always been satisfied with the finished work.

"CET painting did a really excellent job interior painting in my home. Competitively priced, they were efficient, cleaned up nicely at the end of each day and the finished result is exactly what I was hoping for." - Fiona M., Google Review "Pro Painting Plus pays such amazing attention to details, very clean and professional. Bobby and his team arrive on time their work ethic is above and beyond." - Alla S., Google Review "Just had my house painted by MGP. I rate this company a 10 plus from the initial estimate through completion. Our place was a tough job." - Helene C., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Across the top-rated painting contractors serving Tappan, NY, professionalism and communication are themes that customers bring up frequently and often unasked. At C.E.T. Painting, the admin side of the business gets specific praise - one reviewer highlights that Debbie handled all the paperwork requirements for a New York City co-op project seamlessly, including building-specific compliance requirements. The crew is consistently described as courteous and low-disruption, with multiple reviewers noting they were able to work from home or run errands during the job without concern. Pro Painting Plus owner Rob McRae earns praise for communication from the estimate stage forward. Several reviewers note he identified issues during the initial walkthrough that the homeowner hadn't noticed, and then circled back daily to verify the work matched the plan. One reviewer mentions Rob was responsive via calls and texts throughout, without delays.

At MGP Painting Inc., owner Moises has built a reputation for personalized responses to reviews that reference specific project details - not generic replies. During projects, reviewers note the team is communicative about what they're doing each day and responsive when additional requests come in mid-project. One reviewer mentions that Moises remembered them from a project two years prior and picked up the conversation naturally. Aquinas Painting Contractors earns consistent marks for being easy to work with - multiple reviewers note that Alex Solis responded quickly to quote requests and rearranged scheduling to meet tight timelines when needed. For homeowners who have had frustrating communication experiences with other contractors, all four companies here draw repeated praise specifically for being reliable and reachable.

"From start to finish, the team showcased exceptional communication and professionalism. Carlos, the owner, was prompt, and his crew was efficient, ensuring that all site preparations were handled thoroughly." - Angela F., Google Review "Alex worked with me to quickly provide a reasonable quote and then rearranged his schedule to meet our needs. Alex did a terrific job communicating throughout the project." - Stephen P., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Cleanup and end-of-day tidiness are themes that run through reviews for all four top-rated contractors serving Tappan, NY. At C.E.T. Painting, multiple reviewers specifically mention that the crew left spaces clean at the end of every working day, not just at the completion of the job. Furniture was moved back, drop cloths removed, and work areas left tidy before the crew departed each evening. One reviewer who hosted a painting crew during a home renovation notes the team worked without creating dust in adjacent rooms. Another reviewer, who had CET complete a full whole-house repaint after a move-in, mentions that the crew returned for touch-ups after the moving company brought furniture in without any argument or renegotiation - and left the space clean afterward.

At Pro Painting Plus, cleanup is noted as a consistent part of the job routine. One reviewer says the crew covered all plants on the property during an exterior job, and cleaned up the yard afterward. Another reviewer who had flooring and painting done simultaneously mentions the crew cleaned up upon completion. MGP Painting Inc. customers note that prep protection is part of the cleanup story - floors, furniture, and fixtures were carefully covered before work began, and returned to proper condition when the job was done. At Aquinas Painting Contractors, multiple reviewers note that crews leave spaces cleaner than they found them, with furniture moved back into place and no residue left on adjacent surfaces. One reviewer notes the crew was specifically described as "quiet" and "respectful of our belongings" throughout a multi-day project.

"The job was professionally handled and very well done! They did a fantastic job with cleanup. Everything was back in its place." - Michelle K., Google Review "Painters showed up on time and painting was very neat. I needed some sanding done and the furniture and other rooms were protected so that there would be no dust in these rooms." - Christine W., Facebook Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Pricing and value observations from customers hiring painting contractors in Tappan, NY suggest the top local companies compete well on price without cutting corners on quality. At C.E.T. Painting, multiple reviewers describe estimates as reasonable and itemized, and several note that the final result exceeded what they expected for what they paid. One reviewer who had a full exterior repaint on a house in poor condition notes the estimate was detailed, questions were answered thoroughly, and the result was worth the price. Reviewers also note that the company doesn't charge extra for mid-project adjustments - touch-ups after a move-in were included without renegotiation. Pro Painting Plus earns similar marks, with reviewers describing estimates as fair and well-explained. Several customers note they received quotes from multiple companies and chose Rob's team based on the combination of price and confidence in the process, not just the low number.

At MGP Painting Inc., customers describe pricing as competitive and note that Moises provides detailed pre-project walkthroughs that explain exactly what will be done, which helps set expectations. One reviewer describes getting several quotes and selecting MGP based on "track record, attention to detail during the initial survey and the competitive price." At Aquinas Painting Contractors, the value observation that comes up repeatedly is that nearly 40 years of experience doesn't translate to premium pricing - multiple reviewers describe the rates as reasonable for the quality and scope delivered. For homeowners in the Tappan area shopping multiple bids, the overall picture from reviews is that these four companies price competitively while delivering results that customers consistently describe as worth it.

"They are also well priced. We've been happy with the work performed." - donnyc121, Google Review "Quoted a very reasonable price and followed through. The team was very professional, and my entryway looks fantastic." - Paul L., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Timeliness and scheduling reliability are consistent strengths across the top-rated painting contractors serving Tappan, NY. At C.E.T. Painting, punctuality comes up in a large share of reviews without being prompted. Reviewers mention crews showed up when scheduled, jobs started and finished on the promised dates, and communication came through when any scheduling adjustments were needed. One commercial reviewer noted that CET arrived exactly when they said they would to complete drywall and paint repairs at a business - no delays, no surprises. Another reviewer describes having a crew that accommodated their schedule on an interior project, working around the homeowner's availability rather than requiring them to vacate. Pro Painting Plus is similarly cited for showing up reliably and managing timelines well. One reviewer hired Rob's team for a project that needed to be completed within 48 to 72 hours and noted the deadline was met. Another reviewer mentioned the crew showed up first thing in the morning both days of a Sullivan County job, despite the travel distance involved.

MGP Painting Inc. earns notes for being responsive at the scheduling stage and for arriving within a short window of signing a contract - one reviewer notes work began within a week of signing. Aquinas Painting Contractors receives consistent praise for prompt scheduling responses and for delivering on timelines, including several reviewers who describe jobs completed in three days or fewer. For homeowners who have dealt with contractors who reschedule or go quiet after the estimate stage, the reviews for all four companies suggest that reliability is a consistent part of how they operate in the Tappan, NY area.

"C.E.T. painting did a great job. Always showed up on time, very professional workmanship and cleaned up at end of each day." - David P., Google Review "I cannot say enough great things about Carlos and his team. Punctual, polite, neat, professional are just a few words that describe my experience." - Joey K., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook