3 Best Painters Near Valley Cottage, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Valley Cottage, NY have access to a competitive group of painting contractors, with several companies earning top marks across Google, Yelp, and other platforms. Reading through the reviews, a few patterns stand out: crews that show up on time consistently, owners who stay personally involved through the final walkthrough, and a level of post-job cleanup that customers often describe as exceeding expectations. Here are the top-rated painters in the area based on Chooz Painters data.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, C E T Painting had over 240 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 90.9%. With 9 years in business, they hold 100% recommended on Facebook, a 4.7-star rating on Yelp, a 5.0-star rating on Angi, and accreditation with the Better Business Bureau since 2022. The scope of work in the reviews is broad: whole-house repaints, siding installations, deck staining, commercial buildings, and wraparound porch painting. Owner Carlos shows up for estimates, responds promptly, and multiple reviewers describe using the same crew across years of projects. One reviewer brought the team in to repaint a historic library section during regular business hours with minimal disruption to patrons. If you have a deadline-sensitive or multi-phase project, C E T Painting is a strong choice.

• Reviewers describe getting itemized, detailed estimates with every question answered upfront before work begins
• Commercial projects are well-documented, including auto shops, office spaces, and a commercial building in Bedford Hills
• Crews clean up at the end of each day on multi-day jobs, a detail noted consistently across both interior and exterior projects
• The company holds NYC DCA License No. 2114838-DCA and Westchester County License No. WC-29252-H16

"I had an entire house to paint on a very tight timeline to prepare for staging and listing - and Carlos and his team at CET Painting delivered beyond all expectations. Not only did they accommodate my strict deadline, but they also completed the entire project in just 4 days - faster than their own initial estimate." - Amit R., Google Review

For homeowners who need a painter experienced with complex interiors or specialty finishes, MGP Painting Inc. brings over 13 years in business and a Chooz Score of 87.2%. At the time of our analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Angi and 96% recommended on Facebook. The range of finishes in their review record stands out: custom cabinet painting, patterned wallpaper installation, specialized matte paint application, and prep work on homes with high ceilings, popcorn ceilings, and complex stair configurations. Owner Moises personally responds to reviews, visits during projects to check on progress, and does a final walkthrough. Rachel in the office receives shout-outs in multiple reviews for keeping clients informed on scheduling and materials. If you are comparing quotes and want documented follow-through from office to field, MGP Painting Inc. is worth contacting.

• Wallpaper installation appears across multiple reviews, covering powder rooms, water closets, and specialty surfaces
• Several customers note returning for second, third, or additional projects over a span of years - across different project types each time
• Moises provides a time estimate from beginning to end before work starts, a detail reviewers call out as reassuring

"MGP Painting, Inc. has been a pleasure to work with. They painted several rooms in my home and my mother's town house that we are selling. The owner made suggestions for the town home that ended up saving us over $2000." - Barbara McC., Google Review

While MGP Painting Inc. stands out for specialty finishes, Aquinas Painting Contractors brings the deepest local roots in Rockland County, with nearly 40 years in business since 1987 and a Chooz Score of 86.3%. Their review record includes over 80 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. All painters carry OSHA certification and the company holds Rockland County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H-25-030. Alex Solis leads day-to-day operations, with crew members Pablo, Walter, Miguel, Roberto, and Manuel called out by name across reviews. The project range goes well beyond standard residential painting: a warehouse interior, a pool deck restoration, ceiling repairs, and exterior painting of a convent. Aquinas Painting Contractors is a good fit for homeowners looking for a locally established company with a proven track record across Rockland and Westchester counties.

• Multiple reviewers describe hiring Aquinas for both interior and exterior work across a span of years, with consistent results each time
• Alex rearranges his schedule to meet client timelines, noted in more than one review as a deciding factor when selecting the company
• Crews return furniture to its exact place and clean thoroughly at the end of every visit
• Projects include commercial and institutional spaces in addition to single-family homes

"We have used Aquinas Painting three times now. They did the outside of our convent, the kitchen and a number of our bedrooms. Their work is always perfect. Their workers are polite, thoughtful and respectful. You will not be disappointed." - Veronica M., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Valley Cottage, NY, Precision Painting NY Inc earned a Chooz Score of 83.0% with a perfect 5.0-star rating across over 65 Google reviews and 5.0 stars on Yelp, plus a Houzz Award recognition. With 10 years in business, owner Nakia Dunn is present for estimates, stays accessible throughout the project by text and phone, and follows up after completion. The specialty work in the review record is notable: historic homes over 100 years old, bathtub resurfacing, kitchen cabinet refinishing including 1968 solid oak originals, wallpaper installation, and a commercial showroom renovation in New York City. One reviewer noted the crew self-reported additional prep work needed during the job and handled it without being asked. If you have an older home or specialty surfaces that require careful handling, Precision Painting NY Inc is a strong fit.

• Nakia gives on-the-spot quotes regardless of project size and schedules within a reasonable timeframe
• The review record includes both residential and commercial work, including a high-end NYC showroom renovation completed on a tight, fixed deadline
• The crew self-identifies additional prep work needed and handles it without raising the price

"Nakia and his crew were AMAZING! They are wonderful, caring people and great craftsmen. My house is over 100 years old, and they were so thoughtful and careful in the process of repairing and painting it. Their price is fair, and it feels good to work with hard working, amiable, communicative men." - Jac O., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality of finish is the most consistent theme across reviews for painters serving Valley Cottage, NY, with customers regularly describing work that held up better than expected and came in looking cleaner than what they pictured during the estimate. C E T Painting earns detailed quality notes across a wide range of projects: one reviewer had the team repaint a vaulted ceiling that required matching the texture and color of original cedar or redwood - a technically complicated job that came out seamlessly. Another customer brought in Carlos and the crew to paint an exterior that had not been painted in 12 years and described the finished result as impressive given how deteriorated the surface was. At Aquinas Painting Contractors, quality observations often come paired with prep notes: sheetrock repairs done so well that one customer said the finished product looked like nothing had ever happened, and a pool deck restoration that came out looking like new from an outside observer.

MGP Painting Inc. draws consistent praise for going beyond what was originally contracted. One customer came home to find the crew had fixed a damaged window sill at no additional cost. Another said the team carefully matched original deck paint and got the color right the first time. Precision Painting NY Inc stands out for technically demanding work: a reviewer had 1968 solid oak kitchen cabinets refinished and described them as truly restored rather than just painted over. The company also handles Venetian plaster and lime wash finishes, specialty applications that require a different skill set than standard painting, and reviewers note these jobs being done correctly without needing touch-ups afterward.

"John and his painters did a wonderful job at my business G&A Automotive. When the fire sprinkler repairs were finished, CET came to replace the damaged drywall and then painted to match. I'm very happy and I would use them again." - Garrett O., Google Review"Best painting crew I've ever used. Hard-working and thorough; they went above and beyond. Quick update: It's been almost a year later; and our home still looks great. Thanks again to Nakia and his crew!" - Dennis F., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Timeliness comes up frequently across all four contractors serving Valley Cottage, NY, and reviewers tend to treat showing up on time and finishing on schedule as near-equal to quality in how they describe their overall experience. C E T Painting earns consistent notes for arriving when they say they will and maintaining a steady pace on multi-day projects. One customer who needed their home painted on a tight timeline before a real estate listing had the entire job completed in 4 days - faster than the crew's own initial estimate. MGP Painting Inc. typically starts within days of a signed contract; Moises provides a time estimate from start to finish before work begins, and several reviewers describe that estimate as accurate to the day. Multiple customers also note that their project started within a week of signing the contract.

For Aquinas Painting Contractors, timeliness appears in nearly every review. Alex is repeatedly described as willing to rearrange his schedule to meet client needs, and the crew arrives on time each day. One reviewer had a 10-room house and front porch fully painted in just 3 days. Another had the team respond the same day and complete interior roofline work in a single visit. Precision Painting NY Inc consistently schedules within a reasonable window after the estimate, shows up on time, and finishes ahead of schedule on multiple documented projects. Nakia stays reachable by text and phone throughout the job, and reviewers note that communication about timing continues even after the project is complete.

"Aquinas responded immediately to our call and got the work done in less than a day. We are very pleased. They were thorough, clean, quiet and respectful of our belongings." - Sean M., Google Review"Communication was great, they started quickly and finished ahead of schedule. They did a beautiful job, will definitely be using them again for future projects." - Elyse G., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Professionalism and clear communication are among the most frequently mentioned themes across reviews for painters serving Valley Cottage, NY. C E T Painting owner Carlos is described as responsive and communicative from the estimate through completion. One reviewer noted receiving progress updates and consistent communication throughout a large exterior project that also involved carpentry repairs. Several customers mention that Carlos listened carefully to their concerns and addressed each one before work started. The crew is frequently described as quiet and professional on the job site - a detail that stands out in reviews from homeowners who stayed in the house during painting or continued working from a home office while the team was nearby. MGP Painting Inc. draws separate attention for its office communication: Rachel, who handles scheduling and client contact, receives her own mentions in multiple reviews for keeping clients updated on dates, paint brands, and materials throughout the process.

Aquinas Painting Contractors receives consistent notes for the way Alex communicates before and during jobs. Reviewers describe him as easy to reach, quick to respond, and willing to work through color selection together before committing. One customer had a color change mid-job and noted the team handled it without any pushback. Precision Painting NY Inc owner Nakia Dunn is described across multiple reviews as honest, patient, and genuinely helpful throughout the decision-making process. Several reviewers note that Nakia walked them through exactly what to expect before starting and stayed reachable throughout the project. One customer specifically credited clear communication as what made a large multi-surface project feel smooth and stress-free from start to finish.

"Alex was extremely professional from the first contact. I was provided a very fair estimate, a short wait time. His crew arrived on time each day. Pablo and Walter were clean and awesome painters." - John V., Google Review"Nakia is a super responsive and friendly professional who walked me through the project clearly and concisely. Nakia's quote was timely and fair. His team, Dwayne and Lloyd, are professional, quick, adept painters who are willing to take the extra step." - Kathy K., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Post-job cleanup is one of the most consistent themes across the painting contractors serving Valley Cottage, NY, with multiple reviewers independently describing the same result: they could barely tell the crew had been there. C E T Painting earns cleanup notes on both interior and exterior projects. On multi-day jobs, the crew cleans up at the end of every workday, not just at project completion. One reviewer had sanding done and noted that furniture was protected and other rooms were sealed off so there was no dust anywhere in the house. Another reviewer said everything was back in its proper place when the job was finished, from furniture to floor coverings. MGP Painting Inc. is particularly noted for cleanup on cabinet and interior projects, where careful daily prep prevents paint residue from reaching floors or adjacent surfaces. One customer praised the team for carefully draping and protecting their newly refinished floors throughout the entire painting process.

Aquinas Painting Contractors customers describe crews that return furniture to its exact place and leave the space clean enough that it is hard to believe work was done there. One reviewer had delivery damage repaired on a wall and archway, and said the finished product looked like nothing had ever happened. Another customer, Brian E., who had painting done on a home with decades of accumulated paint neglect, described it as "A+ service on a difficult paint + prep." Precision Painting NY Inc customers consistently note the crew leaving the home in better shape than it was found. Sally R., a repeat customer, says the team completed the job and put everything back as though they were never there. A reviewer on a multi-room project also noted thorough daily cleanup throughout the entire job.

"His worker was efficient, clean and friendly and best of all we were very satisfied with the pricing. Would happily use Carlos again and plan to do so for some future projects." - Samantha B., Google Review"Aquinas Painting is a very professional outfit. They provided both interior and exterior painting services in a timely manner with pristine results and fair pricing. They were friendly, accommodating and finished by thoroughly cleaning the premises." - Steven R., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Value for price is a consistent theme in reviews for painting contractors serving Valley Cottage, NY, and the specific ways reviewers describe it offer useful context when comparing estimates. C E T Painting earns frequent notes for detailed, itemized estimates that match the final invoice with no hidden costs added after the fact. One reviewer collected four quotes and described CET as the most responsive and professional of the group, with the finished product matching what was promised at the agreed price. Another customer who needed a home staged and listed on a tight timeline described the outcome as exceeding expectations at a price that was fair given the urgency of the job. MGP Painting Inc. is described as competitive across a wide range of project types. One customer noted the estimate was the most cost-effective of three quotes received; another said owner Moises made suggestions during a townhouse project that saved the client over $2,000 outright.

Aquinas Painting Contractors is described as fairly priced across residential and commercial work alike, with customers noting that quality holds up well over time. Rick D. described everything promised as done neatly, on time, and at a reasonable price, adding there was "no reason to shop around." Michael T. has hired Aquinas twice over many years and calls the pricing affordable on both occasions. Precision Painting NY Inc earns consistent praise for transparent pricing: Nakia provides a detailed written quote within hours of the estimate walkthrough, and the final cost consistently matches what was stated. Multiple reviewers note that extra prep work discovered mid-project was handled without any additional charges added to the final bill.

"After a great experience with the exterior of our home, MGP did an excellent interior job on our kitchen cabinets, wainscoting, crown molding, island and built in. Everything looks bright and fresh now. Moises is super responsive and his team is attentive to detail." - Savannah L., Google Review"Aquinas is fantastic. They are well priced and do an impeccable job. Beautiful work in a short time. I would absolutely use them again." - Connie F., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp