3 Best Painters Near New City, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Finding a reliable painting contractor in New City, NY takes more than a quick search - the area has a strong pool of options, and the best ones have built their reputations review by review across multiple platforms. Based on Chooz Score rankings and an analysis of hundreds of customer reviews, here are the top-rated painters serving New City, NY.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, C E T Painting had over 240 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 90.9%. Owner Carlos leads a crew that handles everything from interior repaints to commercial and institutional work - one reviewer noted the team handled a full repaint at a local library during regular business hours with minimal disruption to patrons. With 9 years in business, the company holds an A+ accreditation with the Better Business Bureau since 2022, a 4.7-star rating on Yelp, 5.0 stars on Angi, and is 100% recommended on Facebook. They also hold active contractor licenses in both New York City (License No. 2114838-DCA) and Westchester County (License No. WC-29252-H16). If you need a contractor who can handle an unusually wide range of project types without missing a beat, C E T Painting is a strong choice.

The diversity of work in their review history stands out: wallpaper removal, deck staining, drywall repair, commercial spaces, and even a historic exterior that had never been painted since the home was built nearly 100 years earlier. Several reviewers mention being able to continue working in adjacent rooms while the crew was on site - a sign of a team that doesn't upend your day.

• Owner Carlos is personally reachable and responsive throughout the job, with multiple customers praising same-day communication from the initial inquiry through project wrap-up.
• The crew took on a full repaint of a historic library during open hours, completing the work without disrupting daily library visitors.
• Wallpaper removal is a highlighted strength, with customers noting zero trace of where old paper once was after the project wrapped.
• Multi-day projects consistently include daily cleanup, leaving each work area organized at the end of every session.

"Punctual, polite, neat, professional are just a few words that describe my experience. The bonus - I was still able to work in a nearby room without disruption. You will not be disappointed in their work." - Joey K., Google Review

For homeowners looking to refresh their kitchen without the cost of a full renovation, NYCA Contractors, LLC has built a focused reputation around cabinet refinishing that delivers results that look like new cabinetry. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 115 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 88.9%. Their ratings are consistent across platforms: 5.0 stars on Angi with over 40 reviews, and 100% recommended on Facebook. If your cabinets are dated but structurally sound, NYCA Contractors, LLC is worth a serious look.

Their process involves removing cabinet doors, numbering each one, and transporting them off-site for professional spray painting using high-quality paints - keeping your kitchen functional throughout. Owner Al (Albano) handles estimates personally and consults on color selection. Reviewers consistently describe visitors assuming the cabinets were fully replaced after the project finished.

• The off-site spray process eliminates brush marks and produces a smooth, factory-level finish that on-site brush painting typically cannot match.
• Most projects complete within one to two weeks from start to finish, and at least one customer noted their job wrapped ahead of schedule.
• Cabinets as old as 20 to 30 years come back looking brand new, based on multiple independent customer reviews.

"My 30 year old cabinets look like new!! Bravo Al." - Yossi P., Google Review

A hands-on owner and a crew that shows up prepared are the patterns that run through every Pro Painting Plus review. Owner Rob McRae leads the team personally and stops by job sites daily to check on progress and confirm client satisfaction. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%. For homeowners who want someone accountable from estimate to final walkthrough, Pro Painting Plus is a reliable choice.

The project scope in their review history is wide: standard interior rooms, a 160-year-old tin roof, cedar and teak siding, painted gutters, refinished cabinets, finished basements, and an epoxy garage floor. Wall and ceiling repairs - cracks, seams, nail pops - are treated as part of the job before paint ever goes on. Multiple customers describe Pro Painting Plus as their default contractor for any future home project.

• Rob visits active job sites daily, checking quality and checking in with clients - something multiple reviewers single out as unusual and reassuring.
• The crew handles challenging surfaces beyond standard painting, including historic tin roofs and specialty floor finishes.
• Surface preparation is built into every project: cracks, water damage, and wall blemishes are repaired before any paint is applied.

"I am always impressed with the prep work - which gives that professional finish. Plus Rob visits the site, reviews the work and has any imperfection corrected. PPP are my go-to painters. I don't call anyone else." - Tracey B., Google Review

With over 13 years in business, MGP Painting Inc. has built one of the most consistent records in the area. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, a Chooz Score of 87.2%, 5.0 stars on Angi with over 10 reviews, and are 96% recommended on Facebook. Owner Moises leads a company where the office staff - including scheduling coordinator Mable - receives specific praise alongside the field crews. If you're working with a complex interior featuring high ceilings, popcorn ceilings, or multiple levels, MGP Painting Inc. is practiced at handling exactly those challenges.

Repeat customers are common across the review history, with several returning for second, third, and more projects over multiple years. Named crew members Galo, Caesar, and Orlando appear independently across reviews for their care with edges, trim, and detailed work. Moises responds to virtually every Google review with personalized notes.

• The front office handles scheduling, color coordination, and client updates - several customers give specific praise to staff for keeping them informed throughout the project.
• The team tackles technically complex interiors: popcorn ceilings, 28-step staircases, wall-mounted equipment, and high rooms with recessed lighting.
• Services extend beyond painting: cabinet refinishing and wallpaper installation are part of their regular project scope.

"I have worked with Moises and his people for 3 big home painting projects over the last 5 years. They consistently do a professional and reliable job." - Barbara S., Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Aquinas Painting Contractors, a Rockland County company with roots going back to 1987. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 80 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 86.3%. Their platform presence includes 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi with over 9 reviews. The company holds a Rockland County Home Improvement Contractor License (No. H-25-030) with all painters carrying OSHA certification. With nearly 40 years in business, this company has the depth of experience to show across Rockland, Westchester, Bergen County NJ, and Orange County. If you want a contractor with a decades-long track record and verifiable credentials, Aquinas Painting Contractors is a strong fit.

Partner Alex Solis leads active projects today, continuing the company's long-established foundation. The range of work in their review history goes well beyond standard residential - power washing, pool deck restoration, warehouse interior repaints, condo common areas, convent exteriors, and multi-year relationships with the same homeowners. Large jobs move quickly: one customer describes a 10-room house plus front porch completed in just three days.

• Large residential projects are completed at an impressive pace without cutting corners on quality.
• The crew handles a wide range of project types, from residential interiors to institutional exteriors to commercial warehouse spaces.
• Mid-project color changes are handled without complaint - a flexibility called out in more than one review.

"Best painting staff in the tri-state area! Alex was extremely professional from the first contact." - John V., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Across hundreds of reviews, the quality of the finished work is the most consistently praised aspect of painting contractors in the New City, NY area. C E T Painting receives repeated descriptions of flawless edges, smooth finishes, and results that hold up over time - one customer returned to the same contractor after nearly a year, still pleased with a stucco exterior that hadn't been painted since the home was built close to 100 years prior. NYCA Contractors, LLC stands out for their off-site spray technique on kitchen cabinets, which produces results so polished that multiple customers report visitors assuming new cabinetry was installed rather than repainted. Pro Painting Plus earns strong marks for the condition of the finished surface before any paint is applied, with reviewers describing careful crack and seam repair as standard practice on every job.

MGP Painting Inc. is praised for handling technically complex interiors - including popcorn ceilings and multi-level staircases - without sacrificing quality on any surface. Aquinas Painting Contractors brings nearly four decades of craft to their projects, with customers describing homes that look completely refreshed after decades of wear. Precision Painting NY Inc covers a wide range of surface types, from full interior repaints to specialty finishes like Venetian plaster and lime wash, with customers in New City, NY and beyond describing results that consistently exceed what they expected going in.

"Rob quickly assessed and identified my needs during the estimate and the next day Dario and Eric executed the job beautifully. The wall repairs and paint job were done with precision, professionalism, and expertise. It was a joy to return home to see quality work." - Taryn D., Google Review"We had quite a lot of ceiling and walls in desperate need of repair/paint and MGP delivered excellent, professional service for a very reasonable price. We reached out to MGP on a recommendation from a friend who gave us the same review." - Erik D., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

Communication and professionalism are consistent themes across reviews for painting contractors in the New City, NY area. C E T Painting owner Carlos is praised for being personally reachable from the initial inquiry through project completion, with reviewers describing quick responses, detailed project updates, and direct access to the owner throughout the job. NYCA Contractors, LLC owner Al is mentioned by name in the majority of reviews, handling estimates, color consultations, and schedule adjustments - including weekend availability and building management requirements - without pushback. Multiple reviewers describe his communications as clear and timely from the first phone call through final follow-up.

Pro Painting Plus gets frequent credit for transparency during the estimate walk-through, with several customers noting that Rob identified issues during the visit they hadn't spotted themselves. MGP Painting Inc. earns praise from customers who worked with both the field crew and the front office, with specific compliments for scheduling staff who kept clients informed on project dates, paint brands, and color choices throughout. Aquinas Painting Contractors is noted for consistent follow-up after project completion, with partner Alex Solis credited for checking in to confirm satisfaction once the crew wraps up. In New City, NY, the top-rated contractors treat client communication as part of the job specification, not an afterthought.

"He schedules you within a reasonable time frame, actually shows up and on time. Before starting my job he explained to me what he was going to do, introduced me to all of his guys." - Tanya Y., Google Review"The office did a really great job keeping me posted on dates, paint brands and colors. I would recommend them to anyone." - Scotty H., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Post-project cleanup is one of the most frequently mentioned details across reviews for painting contractors in the New City, NY area. C E T Painting reviewers consistently describe the crew leaving each work area organized at the close of every day on multi-day projects. One customer who had an interior updated while still working from home noted the crew completed the job cleanly enough that they could remain in adjacent rooms without disruption. Pro Painting Plus crews are described as thorough on prep before paint is applied - floors, furniture, and adjacent surfaces are covered and protected as standard practice, and each completed segment of a multi-day job is cleaned up before the crew leaves for the day.

Aquinas Painting Contractors earns some of the most specific cleanup praise in the review pool, with customers describing belongings protected and returned to their proper positions after each session, and rooms left spotlessly clean across multi-day projects. MGP Painting Inc. is called out for particular care when working in homes with freshly refinished floors, with reviewers pointing to how carefully the crew worked around delicate surfaces. Precision Painting NY Inc receives repeated mentions of thorough daily cleanup across multi-room projects, with customers noting complete removal of materials and a tidy space left behind even after extensive interior work. Homeowners in New City, NY can expect protection of their space as a standard part of the process.

"Herbie and Juan repaired cracks, seams, nail pops, and other wall blemishes. The job was completed in segments and each time an area was finished, any dust or debris was thoroughly cleaned up including wiping down the floors. Our 45-year old home looks wonderful." - Cathie S., Google Review"The job was professionally handled and very well done! They did a fantastic job with cleanup. Everything was back in its place." - Michelle K., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

On-time project delivery is a consistent theme across reviews for painting contractors in the New City, NY area. C E T Painting is noted repeatedly for arriving when promised and completing projects within the quoted timeframe - commercial clients mention the crew met strict scheduling requirements, including working during business hours at an operating library without causing any disruption. NYCA Contractors, LLC stands out for speed as well as quality: most cabinet refinishing projects complete within one to two weeks, and at least one reviewer described their project finishing ahead of schedule. Al accommodates weekend schedules and tight timelines without issue.

Aquinas Painting Contractors earns specific praise for how quickly their crews move on large jobs - one customer describes a 10-room house plus front porch finished in just three days. The team also rearranged their schedule to fit in a full power wash and deck stain within a short window for a customer with a tight timeline. Pro Painting Plus is praised for staying on track even when the project scope grew mid-job, with reviewers describing add-ons absorbed without slowing the overall timeline. For customers in New City, NY, the top-rated contractors treat your schedule as part of the project specification.

"CET came when they said they would and on time to replace the damaged drywall and then painted to match. I'm very happy and would definitely recommend." - Garrett O., Google Review"Despite a day missed due to a snow storm, they still finished the project on time." - Liz M., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Fair pricing and strong value come up consistently across reviews for painting contractors in the New City, NY area. C E T Painting is described as competitively priced across a wide range of project types, with multiple customers noting the final invoice matched the quote exactly. NYCA Contractors, LLC positions cabinet refinishing as a cost-effective alternative to full cabinet replacement - several customers describe the result as delivering far more than they expected for the price, with one noting the project cost a fraction of what new cabinetry would have run. Aquinas Painting Contractors is frequently described as well priced relative to the quality delivered, with customers noting detailed, honest estimates and no unexpected charges at close.

MGP Painting Inc. provides detailed written proposals before work begins, and customers describe owner Moises as straightforward about exactly what the quote covers. The company is commonly described as affordable given the level of service and scope of work delivered. Precision Painting NY Inc earns consistent high marks for transparent quoting from owner Nakia Dunn, who provides estimates on the spot and is praised as competitive on price for both residential and commercial jobs. Across the board, contractors serving New City, NY combine reasonable pricing with high follow-through, giving customers the full value of what they paid for.

"After getting 3 quotes they were right where we needed to be. Working with Precision was great from start to finish." - Craig F., Google Review"Albano and his company saved the day for an affordable price. The workmanship is fabulous and the result for my kitchen cabinets is magnificent." - Madalyn F., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp