3 Best Painters Near West Nyack, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in West Nyack, NY have access to a strong group of painting contractors serving Rockland and Westchester counties, with crews covering everything from interior repaints and deck staining to cabinet refinishing and specialty finishes. Based on Chooz Score analysis - which draws on cross-platform reviews, business authority, and digital presence - here are the top-rated painters currently serving the area.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, C E T Painting had over 240 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 90.9% - the highest among contractors featured on this page. Based in Elmsford, NY, the company is BBB accredited since 2022, 100% recommended on Facebook, and holds 4.7 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Carlos runs a versatile crew that handles exterior painting, interior repaints, siding installation, deck staining, and drywall repair across both residential and commercial properties - carrying NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection Home Improvement Contractor licensing as well as Westchester County licensing. If you need a contractor who handles a wide range of home improvement work under one roof with verifiable professional credentials, C E T Painting is a strong choice.

What stands out in CET reviews beyond repeat business is how often the team gets called in under pressure. Homeowners staging homes for sale, facing tight deadlines, or dealing with water damage call on Carlos and crew to accommodate difficult circumstances without compromising finished quality. Commercial clients, including a public library and an auto shop, describe the same professionalism as residential customers. John and Pablo are frequently named alongside Carlos across reviews spanning different project types and years.

• Several reviewers describe leaving for work or errands while the crew was on site, returning to a completed and cleaned job - a level of trust that speaks to the team's reliability.
• Estimates are itemized and detailed, with customers consistently noting the final bill matched the original quote without hidden charges.
• The crew handles drywall repair, carpentry, and siding alongside painting - a breadth of services that reduces the need to hire separate contractors for related work.

"Not only did they accommodate my strict deadline, but they also completed the entire project in just 4 days - faster than their own initial estimate." - Amit R., Google Review

For homeowners looking to take on demanding exterior or specialty projects, Pro Painting Plus has built a following for high-end finish work. Based in Monroe, NY and serving the Hudson Valley since 1980, the company focuses on cedar and log home refinishing, cabinet spray painting, deck staining, and epoxy coatings. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.6% on Chooz Painters. Owner Rob McRae - also called Bobby by regular customers - is known for making daily site visits to check on progress and correct any imperfections before the job wraps. If you have a cedar-sided home, a historic structure, or cabinets needing a factory-quality spray finish, Pro Painting Plus is a natural fit.

A pattern throughout this company's reviews is Rob stepping in to rescue projects that other contractors left incomplete or damaged. At least two reviewers describe calling Pro Painting Plus after a previous contractor walked off a job or caused damage, with Rob responding within hours and beginning work the following day. Crew members Dario, Oscar, Herbie, and Juan appear across multiple reviews for interior work, while Luis and Miguel handle repair and paint-matching projects.

• The company has painted an 1865 tin roof and restored historic church shingles, bringing experience with demanding surfaces to challenging residential exteriors.
• Color matching precision is a recurring theme, with customers praising results that blend seamlessly with existing paint or siding.
• Cabinet spray finishes are described by multiple reviewers as looking factory-new - a result that brush-and-roll methods cannot match.
• Rob personally checks in on active jobs daily, reviewing work in progress and correcting imperfections before the crew moves to the next area.

"I am always impressed with the prep work - which gives that professional finish. Plus Rob visits the site, reviews the work and has any imperfection corrected." - Tracey B., Google Review

Also serving the West Nyack, NY area, MGP Painting Inc. has been operating out of Orangeburg since 2012, earning a Chooz Score of 87.2%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, 96% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Angi. Owner Moises personally handles estimates, responds to virtually every Google review, and makes site visits throughout larger jobs. If you are comparing multiple bids and want a detailed, itemized proposal delivered the same day as the walkthrough - and a contractor who follows through on every line of it - MGP Painting Inc. is worth a call.

Reviews highlight the office side of this business as particularly well-run. Office coordinator Rachel is mentioned by name for keeping scheduling on track and communicating proactively about timing and paint selections. Crew members Galo, Caesar, Alex, Walter, and Orlando are named across reviews for specialty work including wallpaper installation, cabinet refinishing, and demanding multi-level interior projects.

• Loretta Jara noticed MGP painting her local library, hired them based on what she observed on the job, and reported the same quality on her home project.
• The company has completed commercial spaces including hair salons and offices alongside standard residential work.
• Prep protection goes beyond basic drop cloths - multiple reviews describe the crew carefully covering newly refinished floors before any painting begins.

"They seamlessly patched all of the holes in our ceiling and walls and took great care prepping the interior and our newly refinished floors to avoid any damage to them." - Valerie G., Google Review

With nearly 40 years in business since 1987, Aquinas Painting Contractors out of Valley Cottage has built a loyal customer base across Rockland County, Westchester County, Bergen County NJ, and Orange County NY. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.3% with over 80 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. All painters carry OSHA certification, and the company holds a Rockland County Home Improvement Contractor license. If longevity matters to you and you want a contractor whose reputation has been built across decades rather than months, Aquinas Painting Contractors is a reliable option.

The company's history spans two generations of leadership - founder Jim Dugandzic built the business, and partner Alex Solis now runs daily operations. Frank O. has used Aquinas for over 20 years through that leadership transition and describes consistent quality throughout. Other long-term customers return across multiple properties, including a convent exterior, residential kitchens, and bedrooms. Crew members Pablo, Walter, Miguel, Manuel, and Roberto are named in reviews for clean, precise work and a respectful presence in the home.

• The company has handled commercial warehouse painting and work on religious institutions, demonstrating capability beyond standard residential projects.
• Alex is repeatedly credited with scheduling flexibility - rearranging his calendar to accommodate customer timelines on short notice.
• Several reviews describe furniture returned exactly to its original position after cleanup, a standard that long-term customers have come to expect.

"I have used Aquinas 3 times in the past year and a half. Alex and his crew are excellent. The job gets done quickly with no messes left behind." - Frank C., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving West Nyack, NY, Precision Painting NY Inc. out of Monroe brings specialty finish expertise to the area, earning a Chooz Score of 83.0% with over 65 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. The company holds a Houzz Award and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Nakia Dunn is known for giving on-the-spot fair quotes and scheduling promptly - two qualities reviewers consistently mention together. If you have a historic home, a specialty finish in mind, or a commercial space that needs painting on a tight timeline, Precision Painting NY Inc. is worth considering.

The company's scope goes well beyond standard paint work. Nakia's team handles Venetian plaster, lime wash, wallpaper installation, stucco repair, and cabinet refinishing alongside interior and exterior painting. One reviewer hired the crew for both their residential exterior and a commercial showroom renovation in New York City, describing consistent results across very different project types. The team also completed a job at a retail store in West Nyack under late-hour scheduling, carefully protecting all inventory and equipment throughout. Crew members Eduardo, Dwayne, and Lloyd are named across reviews in unrelated projects spanning multiple years.

• Nakia's crew self-reports issues discovered during the project - such as surfaces needing additional sanding - and addresses them without raising the cost.
• The company coordinates complementary services like flooring and bathtub refinishing alongside paint work, reducing the need to source separate contractors.
• Historic home experience is a genuine differentiator, with the crew approaching older structures with care for original materials and surfaces.

"My house is over 100 years old, and they were so thoughtful and careful in the process of repairing and painting it. Their price is fair, and it feels good to work with hard working, amiable, communicative men." - Jac O., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Customers across West Nyack, NY consistently describe painting results that exceed initial expectations in aesthetics, durability, and surface preparation quality. C E T Painting customers note precisely finished edges on complex projects, from full interior repaints to exterior stucco work on homes that had not been painted in over a decade. Laura Buckley describes hiring the crew for a house "in poor condition" after 12 years, finding Carlos addressed every concern with a thorough, careful result. Pro Painting Plus earns particular praise for work on challenging materials - Mike Jergensen hired the crew for cedar, teak, and pine siding and wrote "I can not believe this is the same house." Cabinet spray finishes at this company are described by multiple reviewers as looking factory-new, with a level of preparation and sealing that sets the result apart from standard brush-and-roll finishes.

The other top contractors in the area show similar patterns. MGP Painting Inc. customers describe excellent results on technically demanding interiors, including homes with popcorn ceilings, multiple levels, high ceilings, recessed lighting, and wall-mounted fixtures throughout. Owner Moises makes site visits on larger jobs, and review authenticity indicators in the Chooz Score show customers consistently describing finished results in specific terms rather than general praise. Aquinas Painting Contractors customers regularly describe interiors and exteriors that look genuinely new upon completion - Robert Ebel wished he could leave ten stars after using Aquinas for both a full exterior repaint and a basement project. Precision Painting NY Inc. specializes in finishes requiring additional expertise, including Venetian plaster, lime wash, wallpaper installation, and careful surface repair on century-old homes where preserving original materials is part of the job.

"I can not believe this is the same house." - Mike J., Google Review, Pro Painting Plus

"The precision around the molding and other trim was amazing." - Jay C., Google Review, Precision Painting NY Inc.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Responsive communication is one of the most consistently praised qualities among top-rated painting contractors serving West Nyack, NY. C E T Painting owner Carlos is described as reachable throughout projects, providing progress updates and responding to questions without the customer needing to follow up. Angela Frere describes exceptional communication "from start to finish," with the crew handling all site preparation and ongoing updates proactively. Pro Painting Plus owner Rob visits active job sites daily and keeps customers updated on progress and any adjustments needed. Jean Kenny describes being guided through color selection before the crew took over - a level of customer involvement that extends from the estimate through the final walkthrough. MGP Painting Inc. owner Moises provides written, itemized quotes on the day of the estimate and responds to nearly every Google review with personalized messages referencing specific project details.

Aquinas Painting Contractors partner Alex Solis is consistently credited with proactive scheduling and clear communication throughout each project. Samantha H. describes Alex as "very communicative" even across a job that included extensive patching work alongside painting, with regular updates on timing and progress. Precision Painting NY Inc. owner Nakia Dunn is noted for transparent communication, including informing customers when the crew identifies additional issues during the project and addressing those repairs without raising the price. Theresa Figueroa notes Nakia "communicated with us before, during and after the work was done" - a consistent standard across reviews spanning scheduling, material decisions, and post-completion follow-through.

"Moises communicates clearly, sticks to the projected timeline and does a great job!" - Sally G., Google Review, MGP Painting Inc.

"Met deadlines, responsive to texts and calls, very dependable." - Deborah T., Google Review, Precision Painting NY Inc.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Cleanup quality is one of the most frequently mentioned points of differentiation among top-rated painting contractors in West Nyack, NY. C E T Painting customers across different project types describe the same end-of-day routine: covered furniture, protected floors, and rooms left clean before the crew leaves. Jeannette Boccini describes the painter protecting her floors on the way to both bathrooms, completing the job diligently throughout the day, and leaving everything ready for immediate use. Pro Painting Plus customers praise the preparation process as foundational to the finished quality. Charlotte Mifsud notes the crew took careful steps to protect adjacent areas of the home throughout the project, and multiple reviewers describe rooms left clean at the end of each session across multi-day jobs.

MGP Painting Inc. reviews include specific descriptions of the crew laying protection on newly refinished floors before any painting begins - a level of care that goes beyond standard drop cloths. Gail Saretto describes the painters as "very respectful of our furniture and home" throughout a multi-room project, with neat, professional results from start to finish. Aquinas Painting Contractors is repeatedly described by long-term customers as leaving homes spotless, with furniture returned exactly where it was found. Robbi Anderson describes a mid-project color change that the crew handled easily, maintaining the same careful cleanup standard through the adjustment. Precision Painting NY Inc. customers describe daily cleanup as a consistent standard across multi-day projects, with the crew removing all materials and tools at the end of each session and leaving spaces ready to use the following morning.

"The team was punctual, clean, careful and did an excellent job. They cleaned up and returned furniture to its proper place." - Robbi A., Google Review, Aquinas Painting Contractors

"They clean up when done and put in a full day!" - Michele P., Google Review, C E T Painting

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

On-time arrival and schedule reliability are both well-documented across the top painting contractors serving West Nyack, NY. C E T Painting customers consistently describe crews arriving when promised and finishing within the stated timeframe, often ahead of schedule. Amit Rajani describes Carlos completing a full-house project in 4 days - faster than the original estimate - to meet a tight listing deadline. Tricia Alfini notes the team finished ahead of schedule after responding to her inquiry faster than any other contractor she had contacted. Pro Painting Plus customers describe punctual arrival as a standard expectation, with Kimberly Austin noting the crew showed up "first thing in the morning both days" even while traveling to a job in Sullivan County.

MGP Painting Inc. earns consistent punctuality mentions across exterior, interior, and deck projects. Sandi Turnipseed hired the team across two separate years, describing reliable arrival on both prep and staining visits, with Moises remembering the project details from the prior engagement. Susan K. notes the crew "began on the date scheduled" and completed an exterior paint job ahead of deadline. Aquinas Painting Contractors customers regularly describe crews finishing in fewer days than expected - Charles Lynch describes a 10-room house and full front porch completed in just 3 days. Precision Painting NY Inc. owner Nakia Dunn is noted for scheduling promptly after estimates, with Elyse Gibberman noting the team started the job quickly and finished ahead of the projected schedule.

"On time, start and finish date as expected, set up and clean up great." - Dorothy S., Google Review, C E T Painting

"Started quickly and finished ahead of schedule." - Elyse G., Google Review, Precision Painting NY Inc.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Pricing across the top-rated painting contractors in West Nyack, NY is broadly described as fair and transparent, with most customers citing accurate estimates, no hidden charges, and results they feel were worth the investment. C E T Painting customers note that estimates are itemized and detailed, and that final bills matched the original quote without additions. Carl Melella describes "no hidden costs" alongside a punctual, neat crew. Several reviewers note CET was not the cheapest bid they received, but that the combination of professionalism, communication, and finished quality made the price feel competitive relative to the alternatives. Pro Painting Plus is described as fairly priced for the caliber of work delivered, particularly on specialty jobs like cedar home refinishing and cabinet spray finishing, where lower-cost results that need early redoing are ultimately more expensive.

MGP Painting Inc. receives consistent value praise, with owner Moises noted for identifying cost-saving alternatives during project planning. Barbara McConnell describes Moises recommending an approach for a townhome they were preparing to sell that saved the family over $2,000 - the kind of customer-first involvement that stands out from contractors who simply execute the original scope. Aquinas Painting Contractors is consistently described as well-priced for the quality and reliability delivered. Brian Ecclefield specifically notes a "fair price from the start" on a job involving decades of paint buildup and substantial prep work. Precision Painting NY Inc. customers describe Nakia Dunn delivering fair, on-the-spot quotes that hold through project completion - with no price increases added when the crew identifies additional issues and handles them independently.

"The owner made suggestions for the town home that ended up saving us over $2000." - Barbara M., Google Review, MGP Painting Inc.

"No hidden costs. Crew was punctual and neat." - Carl M., Google Review, C E T Painting

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook