4 Best Painters Near Nyack, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Finding a skilled painting contractor in Nyack, NY means drawing from a strong pool of talent across Rockland County and into Westchester County. The top-rated painters in the area cover a broad range of project types - from kitchen cabinet refinishing and historic exterior restoration to garage floor coatings, commercial work, and specialty exterior surfaces. Whether the job involves a century-old stucco house or a standard interior refresh, the best contractors in the area share a common thread: owners who stay involved from estimate through completion, crews who clean up each day, and results that hold up long after the project wraps.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, C E T Painting had over 240 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 90.9%. The Elmsford-based company holds 100% recommended on Facebook, a 4.7-star rating on Yelp, and 9 years in business. Owner Carlos handles estimates personally and stays reachable throughout each job - a quality that comes up in reviews from first-time customers and repeat clients alike. The company is licensed through both the NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection and Westchester County. If you want a single contractor who can bundle painting alongside carpentry repairs or take on commercial work, C E T Painting is a strong option.

Beyond standard interior and exterior painting, the team takes on commercial work - a library renovation in Bedford Hills, automotive shop ceiling repairs, and commercial buildings each appear alongside residential jobs in the review record. Several customers describe projects finishing ahead of the estimated date, including one staged home completed in just 4 days. Carpentry repairs - door and window trim replacement, shoe molding, siding - get bundled into painting scopes so homeowners avoid coordinating a separate contractor.

• Commercial and residential projects run side by side in the review history, including libraries, automotive shops, and office buildings - with the same quality standard across all of them
• Deck and exterior wood restoration comes up consistently: weathered cedar decks, Brazilian hardwood restoration, deck board replacement, and fence staining all appear across the review record
• Multiple customers report finishing ahead of the original schedule - including a tight staging deadline where the full project was wrapped in 4 days
• Carpentry work gets folded into painting jobs, including trim replacement, door refinishing, and siding, so customers work with a single point of contact

"Carlos and his team went above and beyond meeting my expectations. I got 4 total quotes and they were the most responsive and professional of them all." - Tricia A., Google Review

With over a century in business, A G Williams Painting Company is one of the most established contractors in the greater Nyack, NY area, operating out of Pelham with a client base spanning Westchester and Rockland counties. At the time of our analysis, they held over 280 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, over 80 reviews on Angi, and 96% recommended on Facebook, earning a Chooz Score of 89.1%. The company has earned Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite recognition in both 2022 and 2023. Sales consultants Jim, Carey, and Anthony each get named across different customer reviews as thorough and easy to work with through the estimate process. If you want a contractor with deep community roots or specialty work like garage floor coating and entry door restoration, A G Williams is a reliable choice.

• Garage floor coating with a 15-year guarantee draws reviewers specifically for that project type - and several customers came back for painting work after a positive floor coating experience
• Entry door and specialty woodwork restoration shows up as a niche the team fills when other contractors won't take on ornate or difficult projects
• Sales consultants Jim, Carey, and Anthony are each named in reviews for thorough and responsive intake - a strong front-end experience that customers call out alongside the quality of the finished work

"You will not find a more professional, experienced group of workers anywhere else. The AG Williams team was on time every morning, worked until the time was up, cleaned up after themselves daily." - Francesca D., Google Review

When it comes to kitchen cabinet refinishing, NYCA Contractors, LLC has built a focused reputation across the greater New York metro area. They earned a Chooz Score of 88.9% with a perfect 5.0-star rating across over 115 Google reviews and 5.0 stars on Angi with over 40 reviews - a perfect rating held across every review on record. The company is 100% recommended on Facebook. Rather than general painting, NYCA specializes in cabinet refinishing using an off-site spray process with Italian-brand paints, producing a factory-level finish. Cabinet doors are removed, numbered, and transported to the shop for spray application, then returned and reinstalled precisely - the kitchen stays usable throughout. If you are focused on cabinet refinishing and want results that look like new cabinetry, NYCA Contractors is the right fit.

• The off-site spray process keeps the kitchen functional while the work is underway - doors go to the shop while base cabinets are sanded and prepped in place
• Projects run 1 to 2 weeks from start to finish, consistently faster than customers expect for the level of quality delivered
• Owner Al (Albano) handles estimates, color consultations, and project coordination personally - reviewers note his direct involvement as a welcome departure from the typical handoff-to-crew model

"The best contractor I have ever worked with. Period. Al and his team were simply amazing. They were truly the bright spot during my renovation process in NYC." - Gary R., Google Review

For homeowners with specialty exterior projects or unusually tight timelines, Pro Painting Plus has earned a reputation for both range and quick mobilization. Based in Monroe, the company earned a Chooz Score of 87.6% with a perfect 4.9-star rating across over 75 Google reviews. Owner Rob McRae visits job sites throughout each project and performs his own quality checks before sign-off - multiple reviewers across different project types describe this as a consistent practice. If you have an unusual exterior project or need a contractor who can move quickly on short notice, Pro Painting Plus is worth a call.

The project variety here is broader than most: an 1865 original tin roof, a 52-year-old lakeside dock, historic church shingles, a cedar home with mixed wood species (cedar, teak, and pine), and epoxy garage floors all appear in the review record. Quick mobilization is a real pattern - one reviewer described paint ordered and a crew starting within 24 hours of an emergency call after another contractor fell through days before a move-in.

• Rob visits job sites throughout each project and reviews finished work himself - reviewers credit this practice with imperfections being caught and corrected before final sign-off
• The project record spans specialty and historic exterior work: a tin roof from 1865, a 52-year-old dock, church shingles, and mixed-species cedar homes all show up alongside standard interior and exterior jobs
• The company has mobilized within hours for emergency situations, including a full house paint job delivered in under 72 hours on short notice

"I am always impressed with the prep work - which gives that professional finish. Plus Rob visits the site, reviews the work and has any imperfection corrected... PPP are my go-to painters. I don't call anyone else." - Tracey B., Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for MGP Painting, Inc.. Based in Orangeburg, the company earned a Chooz Score of 87.2% with over 200 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi, and 96% recommended on Facebook. With over 13 years in business in Rockland County, owner Moises responds to every Google review with personalized messages referencing the specifics of each customer's project. The back-office team - Rachel, Mable, and Cristiana each appear by name in reviews as helpful and responsive - reflects a well-organized operation that customers notice from the first call. If you have a larger or more complex project requiring wallpaper installation, specialty finishes, or detailed coordination, MGP Painting, Inc. is a dependable option.

• Wallpaper installation - including patterned designs - shows up alongside painting work in multiple reviews, making MGP a single point of contact for full wall finish projects
• The project record includes a historically landmarked home from the late 1700s, a hair salon with specialty spray finishes, and a local library - a range that goes beyond typical residential painting
• The back-office staff (Rachel, Mable, and Cristiana) are each named by customers as responsive and organized, reflecting support beyond just the field crew

"Outstanding Quality at a great price! The Painting Crew was Professional, Courteous and Accommodating to your requests. My entire family are repeat Customers of MGP Painting, Inc for many years now." - Bob S., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in the Nyack, NY area, Aquinas Painting Contractors brings nearly 40 years in business since 1987, with roots in Valley Cottage and service spanning Rockland, Westchester, Bergen County NJ, and Orange County NY. The company earned a Chooz Score of 86.3% with a perfect 5.0-star rating across over 80 Google reviews, 5.0 stars on Yelp, and 5.0 stars on Angi. All painters carry OSHA certification and the company holds Rockland County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H-25-030. If you are in Rockland County and want a contractor with nearly four decades of local history and verifiable field credentials, Aquinas Painting Contractors is worth calling.

• Efficiency stands out across the reviews - one customer describes a 10-room house completed in 3 days, well ahead of what they anticipated
• Named crew members Pablo and Walter appear independently across reviews from different customers and different timeframes, pointing to a stable in-house team rather than rotating labor

"They are the best painters I have ever worked with. So professional, reliable and immaculate. The work is outstanding. I wish I could do ten stars." - Robert E., Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Quality of workmanship is the most consistently praised aspect across the top painters in Nyack, NY. C E T Painting customers describe results that exceed expectations on complex projects: one reviewer who commissioned a whole-townhouse repaint - multiple colors, significant repairs, and hard-to-reach surfaces - specifically noted there were no sloppy edges or visible brush strokes throughout. The team's color-matching work also stands out: when one customer needed a new vaulted ceiling addition to match an existing cedar surface, the crew blended stain colors until the new section was indistinguishable from the original. "They worked with different colored stains to get a perfect match." - John M., Google Review. NYCA Contractors, LLC, which focuses on cabinet refinishing, delivers a factory-level spray finish that customers describe as indistinguishable from new cabinetry - even on box sets that were 20 to 30 years old. "After years of our kids running into them with various objects, they now shine like new. I didn't even recognize them." - Tim R., Google Review

A G Williams Painting Company applies the same quality standard to specialty projects - including stripping and re-finishing ornate oak entry doors and restoring garage floors to a like-new surface with a 15-year protective coating. Pro Painting Plus has impressed customers on difficult material challenges: one reviewer who owns a cedar home with mixed wood species (cedar, teak, and pine) describes a result that made the house look brand new. "I could never believe what they have done with my cedar house and different woods cedar, teak and pine... I can not recommend them enough." - Mike J., Google Review. Aquinas Painting Contractors produces careful, finished results on compressed schedules - reviewers note that speed does not come at the expense of precision. "I am amazed at how efficiently and meticulously these guys can get a room completely painted!" - Christine C., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work and post-job cleanup come up unprompted across nearly every highly rated contractor review in the Nyack, NY area. C E T Painting customers describe finding their homes virtually undisturbed at the end of each workday: one reviewer who had an exterior restoration completed described a crew that worked efficiently and quietly, leaving no visible trace of the work process when they packed up. "We hardly knew they were here, the crew went to work, cleaned up thoroughly and left. We are very pleased with the job." - Florence R., Google Review. MGP Painting, Inc. crews protect floors, cover furniture, and tape surrounding surfaces as a standard step on interior work - multiple reviewers of multi-day projects note the crew cleaned up before leaving each evening without being asked, and that Moises came by at the end for a walkthrough. "They cleaned up everyday before they left. Moises came by for a final walk through to make sure we were happy with the final result." - Kay C., Google Review

The cleanup standard at Aquinas Painting Contractors surfaces in nearly every review: customers describe furniture returned to its exact position, floors swept, and no sign that painters had been working. "They cleaned up meticulously and returned furniture to its proper place. I had a change with the color and they were so easy to work with." - Robbi A., Google Review. Pro Painting Plus crews run structured daily cleanup on multi-day projects - one reviewer who had a first-floor interior painted across several segments described each finished section cleared of dust and debris, including floors wiped down, before the team moved to the next area. "Each time an area was finished, any dust or debris was thoroughly cleaned up including wiping down the floors." - Cathie S., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication and professionalism consistently separate the top painters in Nyack, NY from contractors in general. C E T Painting customers specifically call out Carlos's responsiveness from first contact through post-job follow-up: one customer who noticed a minor touch-up needed after the project was complete described Carlos finishing it within 24 hours of a single message, without being pressed. "Punctual, polite, neat, professional are just a few words that describe my experience. The bonus - I was still able to work in a nearby room without disruption." - Joey K., Google Review. At A G Williams Painting Company, the structured approach runs from the sales team through foremen and crew: one reviewer who appreciated the thorough intake process described a feeling that everyone at the company does their part to put the customer first. "It's really obvious to me that this is a company where everyone does their part to make sure the customer is put first." - Nicholas D., Google Review

Aquinas Painting Contractors customers highlight consistent communication from estimate through completion, with partner Alex Solis staying reachable throughout the project. "We are very happy. They were responsive and quick but did an excellent job. Consistent communication throughout the entire process." - Conor K., Google Review. Pro Painting Plus owner Rob checks in personally at each job site and reviews finished work himself before sign-off - multiple reviewers across different project types describe this as a reliable practice, not an exception. MGP Painting, Inc. extends professionalism to the back-office level: the front desk team is named in reviews, and Moises responds personally to every Google review with specific references to each customer's project details. "Professional, punctual and attentive to detail are three descriptions among others to describe the Pro Painting Plus team. Because I had a good prior experience with Rob's company, my decision to hire again was easy." - Jean K., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Customers across the top painters in Nyack, NY consistently describe fair, transparent estimates that held without surprise charges at invoice time. NYCA Contractors, LLC draws repeated comment on value relative to quality: the off-site spray refinishing process costs a fraction of new cabinetry while producing results most reviewers describe as indistinguishable from new cabinet boxes. "Nyca's prices are fair and in line with the time and effort that was invested in the job. My 30 year old cabinets look like new!!" - Yossi P., Google Review. C E T Painting customers note that final invoices matched estimates, with several reviewers specifically calling out competitive pricing as a factor in choosing the company after gathering multiple quotes.

MGP Painting, Inc. has stood out for adding value through advisory guidance: one customer described Moises's suggestions during a pre-sale staging project as saving them over $2,000 compared to the original scope they had planned. "The owner made suggestions for the town home that ended up saving us over $2000. The painters were neat, fast and very nice." - Barbara M., Google Review. Aquinas Painting Contractors and Pro Painting Plus customers both describe pricing as fair relative to quality, with several noting they got multiple quotes and found these contractors competitive without any drop in workmanship. A G Williams Painting Company's garage floor coating draws particular comment on value - the 15-year guarantee frames the cost as a long-term investment with a transparent, fixed price.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

On-time arrival and schedule reliability are patterns that run consistently through the top contractor reviews in Nyack, NY. C E T Painting customers mention punctual arrival across the review record, and several describe jobs that finished ahead of the original estimate - including one whole-house painting project wrapped in 4 days for a homeowner staging a property for listing. "John and his painters did a wonderful job at my business... CET came (when they said they would and on time) to replace the damaged drywall and then painted to match." - Garrett O., Google Review. MGP Painting, Inc. owner Moises sets clear timelines during the estimate process, and multiple reviewers note that work completed on or before the projected date. "Moises communicates clearly, sticks to the projected timeline and does a great job!" - Sally G., Google Review

Aquinas Painting Contractors crews arrive on time across different reviewers and project types, from small condo jobs to large multi-room projects - one customer describes a 10-room house completed in 3 days, well ahead of what they expected. A G Williams Painting Company maintains scheduling discipline across crew types: reviewers who hired the company for separate interior and exterior projects describe both teams arriving without delays. Pro Painting Plus stands out for emergency mobilization - one reviewer described a previous contractor falling through days before a move-in, with Rob showing up within an hour of the call and crews starting work the following morning. "Rob showed up one hour after my phone call and mapped out the entire job for us. Paint was ordered hours later and work began the following day." - R M., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google