Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for A G Williams Painting Company
When Bob H. needed his Scarsdale home painted for the sixth time in thirty years, he returned to A.G. Williams Painting Company without hesitation. His experience reflects the kind of multi-generational loyalty this fourth-generation, family-owned contractor has built over more than a century. Brothers George P. Williams (CEO) and Arthur G. Williams (COO) now lead the operation their great-grandfather founded, maintaining the same commitment to craftsmanship that has kept families returning for decades.
The company operates from 411 Fifth Avenue in Pelham, NY serving Westchester, Rockland, and Putnam counties, with a Greenwich office handling Fairfield County projects. Services span interior and exterior painting, cabinet refinishing with a dedicated five-year warranty, concrete floor coatings, wallpaper installation, decorative finishes, and commercial work.
The team of 40+ fully insured, background-checked employees includes estimators Anthony Conklin and Jim, color consultant Liane, and experienced crew leaders like Ezequiel. The company is EPA RRP lead-safe certified and all residential painting carries a five-year workmanship warranty.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Bob H. represents the multi-decade loyalty pattern visible throughout reviews. After thirty years and six projects, he describes the company as his go-to choice for painting needs. This repeat customer pattern appears frequently, with Brian Nadel noting "five or six jobs" and K. Kneis returning for over a decade. Customers cite consistent quality and the "efficient, thorough" approach as reasons they keep coming back rather than shopping around.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Anthony Conklin, one of the company's estimators, receives specific praise across multiple reviews. David B. noted Anthony put together "a detailed and comprehensive proposal that included everything we needed at very good price." Unlike vague quotes from competitors, customers describe receiving itemized estimates with clear scope. Multiple reviewers mention requesting Anthony specifically for repeat projects based on this thorough approach to the estimate process.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
One reviewer described contacting "close to 10 painting contractors" and narrowing to five before choosing A.G. Williams "even though they were the most expensive." The deciding factors were reputation and detailed proposals rather than price. This pattern repeats across reviews. K. Kneis, a decade-plus customer, summarizes the sentiment as "you get what you pay for" with quality and follow-through that outlasts cheaper alternatives.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
A reviewer with a fixer-upper in a pre-war building described walls requiring extensive plaster work. After comparing contractors, they chose A.G. Williams specifically because "they have been around for over 100 years and they stand by their work." The company handled the complex restoration, and when the co-op hired cheaper contractors for a different project, the customer noted seeing "the sort of poor quality of work" that confirmed their original decision.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Michael P. from Yorktown Heights described Ezequiel as "friendly, helpful" and noted he "walked me through everything the team had done each day and what they would do the next day." This daily communication from crew leaders appears throughout reviews as a distinguishing practice. Customers describe knowing exactly what happened and what to expect, contrasting with experiences where contractors left without updates.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Multiple reviewers specifically mention the cleanup process as exceptional. One customer noted finding their home "cleaner than it was when they started." Reviews describe crews covering furniture and floors with fresh drop cloths, removing debris daily, and repositioning items each evening. The words "neat" and "clean" appear repeatedly as distinguishing factors compared to previous experiences with other painting companies.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Paul A. described the technicians as "extremely knowledgeable and cooperative" and noted the process matched "exactly as described" during the sales visit. Other floor coating customers call the experience "smooth and easy" with results exceeding expectations. The company provides care instructions after installation, and reviews mention the polyurea coating specifically. This service line has generated multiple detailed positive reviews.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
A.G. Williams Painting Company holds Westchester County Home Improvement Contractor License No. WC-11487-H01. The affiliated management entity, GAW Management LLC, is registered with the New York Department of State as an active Domestic Limited Liability Company (DOS ID 4294573) since September 11, 2012. The registered address is 411 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803. All crews carry workers compensation and general liability insurance coverage.
-Verification Sources: Westchester County Department of Consumer Protection, NY Department of State Division of Corporations
Updated: 04-07-2026