9 Best Painters Near Elmsford, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Elmsford, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors who consistently earn praise for reliable communication, clean job sites, and finished work that holds up over time. Whether you need a full interior refresh, cabinet refinishing, or exterior restoration, the companies below have built strong reputations across Westchester County and beyond.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Paint Track Painting Services had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 89.7%. With over 20 years in business since 2004, this Briarcliff Manor-based company is PCA Certified, EPA RRP lead-safe certified, and holds manufacturer certifications from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe. Reviews consistently highlight how founder Ray Rahni and Project Manager Jess Molina stay involved from estimate through final walkthrough. If you want a company where the owner personally checks in on your project and the same experienced crew shows up each day, Paint Track is a strong fit.

What stands out across dozens of reviews is how many customers describe coming back for second, third, and even fourth projects. Repeat business is the norm here, not the exception. Homeowners also frequently mention the team by name, with painters like Sergio, Alberto, and Chris earning individual praise for their work ethic and skill.

• Kitchen cabinet refinishing is a specialty, with multiple homeowners describing 20- and 30-year-old cabinets that guests mistake for brand-new installations after Paint Track finishes
• Several reviewers mention leaving keys or garage codes with the crew for the duration of work, a sign of deep trust in the team
• Wallpaper installation and deck staining projects also receive consistent praise, showing a range of capabilities beyond standard interior and exterior painting

"Ray, Jess, Sergio and his team were such a pleasure and delight to work with. We had the ideal kitchen of the 90s (cherry wood, dark granite) and PaintTrack turned it into a bright airy showpiece of the 2020s." - Gary Springer, Google Review

For homeowners specifically looking to update their kitchen without the cost of full cabinet replacement, NYCA Contractors, LLC has built an entire business around cabinet refinishing. They earned a Chooz Score of 88.9% with over 115 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Angi with over 40 reviews and 100% recommended on Facebook. NYCA uses an off-site spray process with professional-grade paints, removing cabinet doors and drawers, transporting them to their shop, and returning them with a factory-level finish. If you want cabinet work that looks like a full kitchen remodel at a fraction of the price, NYCA is a strong choice.

Owner Albano (Al) is personally involved in every project, from the initial text or phone estimate through final installation. Customers frequently describe a fast turnaround, often under two weeks, with the kitchen remaining functional throughout the process since only the doors and drawers leave the home.

• Many reviewers specifically note that visitors assume the cabinets were completely replaced rather than refinished
• Al accommodates building management requirements for co-op and condo residents, including weekend scheduling to minimize disruption
• Customers with 20- to 30-year-old cabinets consistently report results that look brand new

"If I could give higher than 5 stars I would. Al and his team were extremely communicative from the very beginning about the process, timeline and what they needed us to do to prep." - Tim Reid, Google Review

With over 24 years in business, J & S Painting Plus Inc handles everything from full exterior house painting to interior refreshes and cabinet work. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5% with over 140 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2006), and over 300 reviews on Angi at a 4.9-star rating. If you are a first-time homeowner who wants a responsive, organized team that can handle a full house paint on a tight timeline, J & S is a reliable pick.

What comes through clearly in the reviews is the dual leadership of owners Jay Gisonni and Sheki (also spelled Shecki), who each manage their own projects and crews. Customers regularly describe Jay as warm and straightforward in person, while Sheki earns praise for arriving with a folder of licenses, insurance certificates, and a written summary of how work will be done before any painting begins.

• Multiple first-time homebuyers describe J & S completing full interior paint jobs within days of closing, sometimes with just a few days notice
• Crew members like Jose, Omar, Luis, and Mauricio are named individually across reviews, suggesting a stable, in-house workforce
• Several reviewers mention competitive pricing, with some noting J & S came in as the most affordable bid among multiple estimates

"Jay and his team were fantastic to work with, from start to finish. Super professional, well-organized, plus great work product for a very fair price." - Caitlin Foran, Google Review

A husband-and-crew operation led by owner Johnny Acosta, Pier Painting Services takes a hands-on approach that shows in their reviews. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.1% with over 60 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, 5.0 stars on Yelp, and 100% recommended on Facebook. With over 25 years in business serving Westchester County, Johnny runs every estimate, supervises every job, and often works alongside his crew. If you want a contractor you can trust to be on-site and personally accountable, Pier Painting is a great fit.

Beyond painting, Pier also handles light carpentry, drywall repair, power washing, and handyman tasks, making them a convenient one-call solution for homeowners with multiple needs. Real estate professionals in the area recommend Johnny to their clients, and several reviewers describe not needing to take time off work because they trusted Johnny to handle everything independently.

• Customers describe Johnny arriving on time, presenting clear options, and communicating regularly throughout each project
• Repeat customers are a recurring theme, with several homeowners returning for their 2nd, 5th, and even 10th project over the years
• Wallpaper installation, deck refinishing, and door painting are frequently mentioned alongside standard interior and exterior work

"Working with Johnny means I don't have to worry. I retained Johnny to perform maintenance on my house. I did not have to take off work to micromanage the project." - Jennifer Colby, Google Review

When it comes to larger-scale residential projects across Southern Westchester, CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY stands out with the highest review volume in the area. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 175 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating. Operating as WKM Choice Painting, Inc. for over 16 years, they hold a Westchester County Home Improvement Contractor License and offer a two-year warranty on all services. If you have a large exterior project, an older home that needs lead-safe handling, or multiple rooms to complete on a schedule, CertaPro brings the team size and systems to deliver.

Reviews consistently highlight how carefully crews protect furniture, cover floors, and clean up each day before leaving. Named crew members like Jose, Ricardo, Fernando, and Katherine appear across reviews from different customers, suggesting a stable workforce rather than rotating subcontractors. Several reviewers have used CertaPro multiple times over the years, with one customer noting she called them back after a 15-year gap for a new project.

• One reviewer described the experience of having CertaPro restore a 135-year-old home, calling the process well-managed and the results impressive
• Deck staining, cabinet painting, and drywall repair are commonly mentioned alongside standard painting services
• EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certified for work on pre-1978 homes, an important credential for older Westchester properties

"This is a story of truly outstanding customer service. Years ago, seven, we hired CertaPro Painters of Westchester for a full exterior paint job. When we needed painting again, we called CertaPro back." - Suzy Allman, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Elmsford, NY, Five Star Painting of White Plains is a newer operation that has built momentum quickly. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.4% with over 95 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating and 94% recommended on Facebook. Owner Dennis personally handles every estimate and stays involved from first call to final walkthrough. If you are on a tight timeline between closing on a new home and moving in, Five Star has a track record of meeting compressed deadlines without cutting corners.

Several real estate brokers in the area refer clients to Dennis and his team, describing them as trustworthy enough to work inside client homes unsupervised. Crew members like Sergio, Stive, Rob, Angel, and Roger are praised by name across reviews, indicating consistent staffing.

• Wallpaper installation is a notable specialty, with one customer praising a complete redo after initial results did not meet expectations
• Exterior projects include rotted wood replacement on older homes, with one reviewer describing restored wood trim on a 1920s-era property
• Multiple reviewers describe the team finishing ahead of schedule and under budget

"It was such a great experience working with Dennis and the whole team. He handled our whole new home getting painted between closing and our move-in date on a very tight deadline." - Nina Lerman, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook

Cabinet refinishing is one of the most in-demand painting services in the Elmsford, NY area, and several local contractors have built strong reputations for delivering results that make old cabinets look factory-new. NYCA Contractors, LLC specializes almost exclusively in cabinet work, using an off-site spray process that produces a smooth, even finish. Customers regularly describe 20- and 30-year-old cabinets coming back looking completely new. Paint Track Painting Services also earns high marks for cabinet refinishing, with owner Ray and his team handling everything from sanding and crack repair to the final coat.

"The quality of work never disappoints. Paint Track painted our kitchen cabinets a few years ago and the cabinets look better than the factory finish." - Jack Davis, Google Review. "Al and his team were fantastic! I had my kitchen cabinets painted and I was blown away at how great they look. It is like having a new kitchen." - Bill Harris, Google Review. J & S Painting Plus Inc and CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY also handle cabinet projects, with customers like Patty Kondub describing 20-year-old cabinets looking "better than brand new" after J & S finished the work, and Kelliann Daly praising CertaPro for a kitchen cabinet project where Fernando was "incredibly neat and punctual."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication is one of the most frequently praised qualities among painting contractors serving Elmsford, NY. Paint Track Painting Services has a structured team approach, with Project Manager Jess and estimator Sarah coordinating schedules and providing progress updates throughout each project. J & S Painting Plus Inc earns similar praise, with owner Jay responding quickly to initial inquiries and providing detailed written estimates. Reviewer William A. noted that as first-time homeowners, they "wanted a team we could trust" and found exactly that in J & S.

"From the start Johnny arrives on time, goes over everything you want done, and communicates very well about when they would arrive, what was done each day, and when they would return." - Theresa Z., Google Review, describing Pier Painting Services. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY also earns consistent marks for communication, with reviewer Thandi Chase describing the process as running "seamlessly." "Certa Pro just finished staining and painting our entire exterior. Jose and his team communicated on a consistent basis, started on time, and cleaned up entirely." - Aria Friedman, Google Review. Five Star Painting of White Plains rounds out the group, with owner Dennis keeping customers informed throughout, as reviewer Bill DeSanto noted: keeping him "informed and up to date throughout the project" was the most important part.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Cleanup and prep work are among the most frequently mentioned positives in reviews for painting contractors near Elmsford, NY. Paint Track Painting Services earns repeated praise for thorough surface preparation, including sanding, crack repair, caulking, and the use of dust-extracting sanders. Reviewer Debra Blaustein described the workers as "so nice, quiet, clean, thorough and helpful," adding that "you can tell they take pride in their work." CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY also stands out, with multiple reviewers describing furniture carefully covered, floors protected, and daily end-of-day cleanup as standard practice.

"We hired Pier for several painting and carpentry projects around our old house and keep going back because they are responsive, always show up when they say they will, take pride in their work, and charge reasonable fees." - Matt Allyn, Google Review, describing Pier Painting Services. J & S Painting Plus Inc customers also highlight cleanliness, with reviewer Jay Twyman noting that "if anything was not just right, Sheki came back and addressed it. The team cleaned up daily." "His team was clean and respectful of my home and did a pristine job." - Lindsey Kerrigan, Google Review, describing Paint Track Painting Services.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

Value and fair pricing come up regularly in reviews for painting contractors serving Elmsford, NY. J & S Painting Plus Inc receives some of the strongest pricing praise, with multiple reviewers noting they compared several bids before choosing J & S. Reviewer Matthew Stephan described them as "not only the best priced" among several painters they considered, and Sarah Dobsevage called it "a great price." Pier Painting Services also earns consistent mentions for reasonable rates, with reviewer Michael Cherkasky noting a "fair estimate" and Fred Mehlman describing fair daily pricing.

NYCA Contractors, LLC customers frequently describe the cabinet refinishing service as an affordable alternative to full cabinet replacement, with reviewer oleg khaykin praising the "unbeatable price" alongside great quality. "His pricing was very reasonable, his team was always on time and worked efficiently." - kyle kelly, Google Review, describing J & S Painting Plus Inc. Five Star Painting of White Plains also draws pricing praise, with reviewer Ephraim Leiderman calling it "a fair price and excellent work." "Professional service at a fair price!" - Jessica Furer, Google Review, describing NYCA Contractors, LLC.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

Timeliness is a consistent strength among the top-rated painting contractors near Elmsford, NY. NYCA Contractors, LLC is known for fast cabinet turnarounds, often completing projects in under two weeks. Reviewer Alberto Carrillo noted that Al and his team "finished our kitchen within a week." Five Star Painting of White Plains also earns praise for meeting tight deadlines, with owner Dennis coordinating move-in schedules for new homeowners and completing jobs ahead of the original estimate.

J & S Painting Plus Inc has a track record of accommodating rushed timelines, with reviewer Matthew Conway describing how Jay "got a team in to paint our house with a few days notice" before the moving truck arrived. "They finished a day earlier than originally planned and the quality of the work was excellent." - Matthew Stephan, Google Review, describing J & S Painting Plus Inc. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY also delivers on schedule, with reviewer Richard Leroy noting they told him "it would take a week and that is what it did." Paint Track Painting Services customers describe well-coordinated scheduling with Sarah and Jess managing timelines and keeping projects on track.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Angi

Repeat business is one of the strongest patterns across painting contractors serving Elmsford, NY. J & S Painting Plus Inc has some of the most documented repeat customers in the area, with several reviewers describing their 2nd, 3rd, and even 4th project with the company. Reviewer Peter Sarian noted using J & S for "3 jobs in the last 20 months," and SS described working with both owners across separate projects. Pier Painting Services shows similar loyalty, with reviewer Lara Silvas describing multiple projects over three years and reviewer Angela Wilens returning for a second project after a "wonderful experience" the first time.

Paint Track Painting Services customers describe a pattern of expanding their scope over time, starting with one room and eventually having the entire home painted. Reviewer Ellen S. described using Paint Track "several times for our own house and a rental property." "We have used them many times, for big and small projects. They are professional, organized, trustworthy and friendly." - Amy Goldfinger, Google Review, describing Paint Track Painting Services. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY also shows strong retention, with reviewer Patricia Mitchell noting she has used them "for several projects over the years" and Roger Coleman describing multiple positive experiences. "This is the second project that I hired NYCA Contractors for. They are extremely professional, on time and the results are the best I have encountered." - Leslie Ross, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook