Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Five Star Painting of White Plains
Owner Dennis leads Five Star Painting of White Plains out of Elmsford, running a consistent crew that includes painters Sergio, Rob, Angel, Roger, and Stive. Dennis handles estimates and color consultations for each project, walking customers through paint selection before the crew takes over execution.
The company specializes in interior and exterior residential painting, cabinet refinishing, deck and fence staining, wallpaper installation and removal, and drywall repair. Projects range from single-room refreshes to multi-week whole-home repaints. The portfolio includes wood rot replacement on 1920s-era homes, emergency ceiling repairs completed within 24 hours, and commercial work for offices, medical facilities, and property management companies throughout Westchester County.
The fully insured team operates as part of the Neighborly family of home service brands, using Sherwin-Williams and Behr paints on every project. A two-year warranty covers all residential and commercial workmanship. Five Star Painting of White Plains serves Ardsley, Armonk, Dobbs Ferry, Elmsford, Harrison, Hartsdale, Hastings On Hudson, Irvington, Larchmont, Mamaroneck, Purchase, Rye, Scarsdale, West Harrison, White Plains, and surrounding Westchester County communities.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Urgent requests appear to be handled with notable speed. One customer recounts how another contractor damaged a ceiling during pre-sale preparations and Five Star Painting of White Plains completed the repair within 24 hours, with the home selling in under three days at multiple offers above asking. A separate homeowner describes Dennis "immediately answered my call late at night" with a crew dispatched the following morning.
The company has drawn reviews from multiple Westchester County real estate professionals endorsing its pre-sale preparation work. Homeowner Luke Joachim describes choosing Five Star Painting of White Plains despite their estimate not being "the lowest bid," citing responsiveness and professionalism as the deciding factors. His home sold in under three days with multiple offers above asking price after the crew completed the pre-listing work.
Surface repair before painting is a consistent pattern across reviews. Bruce Kaufman describes the crew making "perfect repairs to water damaged walls and ceilings before proceeding to paint everything." John Beeler and other reviewers note similar prep work completed as part of the project scope. The willingness to address structural prep before touching paint is referenced across multiple independent reviews as a distinguishing practice.
Lindsay Friedman's review documents the process directly. Initial wallpaper installation results were unsatisfactory, so she raised the issue with the company. Five Star Painting of White Plains returned and redid the entire installation from scratch. She describes the final result as "perfection." Several other reviewers also note the crew's willingness to return and correct any areas needing touch-up before considering a job complete.
Multiple reviewers describe pricing as fair and competitive rather than the lowest available option. Luke Joachim chose Five Star Painting of White Plains despite their estimate not being the lowest bid, and Maria Bailey praised the "reasonable price" alongside work completed ahead of schedule. Noah Simon echoes similar sentiments about value relative to cost, suggesting pricing sits in the mid-range for Westchester County with quality and responsiveness justifying the investment.
Charlene Emmanuel Evans left a 2-star review in November 2025 citing communication gaps around scheduling, a project component she says was "not included in the quote," and a final timeline roughly double the original estimate. A single painter was assigned rather than a crew. Dennis responded professionally, thanking her and offering to discuss concerns further. No other reviews from the same period reflect similar scheduling or scoping issues.
Named crew members appear across independent reviews spanning multiple years, pointing to an in-house team rather than rotating subcontractors. Painter Stive received praise from G Heller for exterior work that included replacing "rotted wood from the 1920s." Sergio and Rob are named together by a separate reviewer in a different year. The same individuals surfacing across unconnected reviews is a strong indicator of consistent crew composition at Five Star Painting of White Plains.
Five Star Painting of White Plains holds Westchester County Home Improvement Contractor License WC-29386-H17, as listed on the company website at fivestarpainting.com/white-plains. Westchester County requires all home improvement contractors to hold a county license before performing work. The license number and business address at 65 East Main Street, Room 100, Elmsford are displayed in the site footer. Verification is available through the Westchester County Department of Consumer Protection at consumer.westchestergov.com/trades/find-a-licensed-contractor.
-Verification Sources: Company website (fivestarpainting.com/white-plains), Westchester County Department of Consumer Protection
Updated: 04-07-2026