12 Best Painters Near New Rochelle, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving New Rochelle, NY and Westchester County range from off-site cabinet specialists to full-service exterior crews with decades of local roots. Across hundreds of reviews, the same themes keep surfacing: personally involved owners, reliable scheduling, and a strong pattern of repeat business from homeowners who found a team they trust.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Paint Track Painting Services had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 89.7% - the highest among painters in New Rochelle, NY. They also carry 4.6 stars on Yelp and a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation. Owner Ray Rahni employs a full-time W2 crew, holds PCA Certification, EPA RRP lead-safe certification, and credentials from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe, with over 20 years in business. Project manager Jess handles color consultations and progress checks throughout every job, giving customers a named point of contact from start to finish. If you want a certified, long-established team where the same crew returns each time, Paint Track is a strong fit.

• Prep work is a signature strength: thorough patching, crack repair, and caulking before any paint is applied - multiple repeat customers credit this for the long-lasting results that bring them back years later.
• The team handles specialty work beyond standard painting, including wallpaper hanging, stain-matching across different wood types, and skim coating - all appearing across separate reviews.
• Several customers describe coming home after errands to find the work done and the space fully cleaned - a sign of a crew that operates independently without hand-holding.

"Ray and his crew are simply the best! The amount of prep work that goes into any job they take on is impressive, and it's also key to how long the work lasts." - Barbara Tierney, Google Review via Chooz Painters

For homeowners focused on kitchen cabinet painting or refinishing, NYCA Contractors, LLC brings a specialist's process. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 115 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 88.9%. They carry 5.0 stars on Angi with over 40 Angi reviews and are 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Al (Albano) uses an off-site spray process: cabinet doors are transported to the shop, spray-finished with Italian-brand paints, and reinstalled - producing factory-level results that on-site brushwork can't match. If cabinet refinishing is your primary need, NYCA is the specialist in this group.

• The off-site process keeps the kitchen fully functional throughout - no spray dust in the home and no disruption to daily routines.
• When a chemical reaction affected one customer's cabinet doors, Al contacted the homeowner proactively and resolved it at no extra cost.

"If I could give higher than 5 stars I would. Al and his team were extremely communicative from the very beginning about the process, timeline and what they needed us to do to prep." - Tim Reid, Google Review via Chooz Painters

While NYCA focuses on cabinets, J & S Painting Plus Inc handles interior, exterior, decks, and repairs - and has done so for over 24 years. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 140 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 87.5%. Their cross-platform reach is strong: BBB accredited since 2006, over 300 reviews on Angi at a 4.9-star rating, and 4.6 stars on Yelp with over 25 Yelp reviews. Owner Jay Gisonni handles estimates; project manager Sheki leads on-site work and arrives at estimates with a professional folder including licenses, insurance certificates, and a written scope - something multiple reviewers specifically appreciated not having to ask for. J & S fits first-time homeowners needing a tight-turnaround move-in paint and longtime owners who want to stay with a proven team.

• Sheki checks in throughout the job rather than only at the end - several reviewers call this out as different from their experience with other contractors.
• Multiple Angi Super Service Awards from 2009 through 2015 document a consistent track record that pre-dates the era of widespread online reviews.

"Sheki comes prepared with a folder including licenses, insurance certificates, summary of how work will be done. Very helpful and glad to not have to ask." - Ruth Harkin, Google Review via Chooz Painters

A husband-and-wife operation, Azul Painting Corp takes a hands-on approach that shows throughout their reviews. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 60 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 87.2%. Based in New Rochelle, they've built solid local standing in just 6 years in business: BBB accredited since 2020, with 5.0 stars on Angi and over 25 Angi reviews. Co-owner Cinthya handles estimates and color consultations; co-owner Mainor works alongside the crew on-site daily. One reviewer received a final invoice lower than the quote when the stucco scope came in smaller - the company adjusted the bill without being asked. Azul is a good fit for homeowners who want both owners personally present throughout.

• Cinthya personally walks through color selection with customers, which reviewers consistently describe as making the planning process smooth from the start.
• Project types span cedar shingle exteriors on New Rochelle waterfront homes, multi-room interior repaints, wallpaper, and commercial exterior work on large buildings.

"I have NEVER, in all of my years renting and owning homes, encountered a better painting company than Azul!" - Leticia Warner, Google Review via Chooz Painters

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Pier Painting Services. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 60 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - every review a five-star - earning a Chooz Score of 87.1%. Based in Pelham, they carry 5.0 stars on Yelp and are 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Johnny Acosta has run Pier for over 25 years, personally handling every estimate and often working alongside his crew. Beyond painting, reviews cover chimney work, deck refinishing, carpentry, and drywall repair - all by the same team. If you want an owner-led operation with flexibility for a range of home maintenance, Pier is worth a call.

• One customer describes relying on Johnny for over 10 years across multiple visits, with more work already scheduled - a loyalty level that reflects sustained quality over time.
• Realtors now recommend Pier to clients getting homes market-ready, citing the team's dependability as the reason they trust the referral.

"I had the pleasure of working with Johnny from Pier Painting to paint my house this year, and I truly could not be happier with the results! From start to finish, Johnny was professional, punctual, and went above and beyond." - Ray S., Google Review via Chooz Painters

Rounding out the top contractors in New Rochelle, NY, Paintworks & Decorating brings the largest review base of any company in this group. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 86.1%. They also carry 4.7 stars on Yelp with over 65 Yelp reviews and are 100% recommended on Facebook. Over 12 years in business, Paintworks holds an NYC Home Improvement Contractor License, EPA RRP lead-safe certification, and OSHA 30 certification. Project manager Ryan is named in over 20 reviews and handles everything from quotes to post-job follow-up. The scope extends to tile work, custom carpentry, wallpaper, skim coating, and commercial spaces. Paintworks is a strong fit for multi-trade projects that go beyond paint alone.

• Multiple customers brought Paintworks back for carpentry and custom build-outs after an initial painting project went well, expanding their scope with the same trusted team.
• The team's experience with pre-war brownstones includes replacing rotten exterior wood with composite materials - a lasting fix rather than a painted-over cosmetic patch.

"Luis was a master at cutting tile, grouting, sanding, painting and finishing. Can't recommend Paintworks highly enough - and he left my bathroom cleaner than when he came." - Michelle Adams, Google Review via Chooz Painters

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook, Angi

Quality of finished work is the most consistently mentioned topic in reviews for painting companies in New Rochelle, NY. Paint Track Painting Services earns repeated praise for kitchen cabinet results that visitors mistake for brand-new installations - customers describe guests asking whether they got new cabinets rather than had the old ones painted. Thorough prep work gets credited as the driver of those lasting results. NYCA Contractors, LLC achieves similar cabinet finishes with their off-site spray process, and reviewers consistently describe walking into the kitchen after installation and being genuinely surprised at the level of change. J & S Painting Plus Inc draws strong marks for exterior work, with customers noting careful wood repair and surface prep on homes ranging from newer construction to decades-old stucco.

At Azul Painting Corp, reviews highlight careful attention to detail on both interior and exterior work - customers describe the finished results exceeding what they pictured when they first called. Pier Painting Services receives specific compliments on trim and detail work; customers describe baseboards, doors, and molding where every chip and ding has been addressed rather than painted over. Paintworks & Decorating handles specialty finishes requiring extra skill - including wallpaper on textured walls where other companies declined the job, skim coating popcorn ceilings, and tile work alongside painting. Across all six companies, customers consistently feel their homes were treated with care rather than moved through a production timeline.

"We are very pleased with the painting project performed by Paint Track at our home. The team members were pleasant, neat, on time and efficient." - Joanne, Google Review via Chooz Painters"Their work is flawless. I couldn't be happier with the results." - Joe, Google Review via Chooz Painters"Azul did a fabulous job painting virtually every room in a large home to prepare for sale. From detailed, accurate estimates through changes and updates to finishing on time - everything was exactly right." - C.S. Taleb, Google Review via Chooz Painters

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook

Communication is one of the most consistently praised aspects of working with painting contractors in New Rochelle, NY. At J & S Painting Plus Inc, customers describe Jay being immediately responsive to inquiries and project manager Sheki staying in contact throughout, often responding within minutes. Paint Track Painting Services runs a structured communication process with owner Ray, project manager Jess, estimator Sarah, and office coordinator Jana each covering distinct roles - multiple reviewers note they had a named point of contact at every phase. NYCA Contractors, LLC owner Al is described as explaining the full process upfront, setting clear timelines, and reaching out proactively when anything changed during the project.

Azul Painting Corp's co-owner Cinthya is consistently cited for responsiveness during both planning and execution. Pier Painting Services owner Johnny Acosta is praised for following through exactly as described - one customer noted they did not take time off work to supervise because they trusted Johnny to handle things. Paintworks & Decorating project manager Ryan draws consistent praise for sending updates before crew arrivals, answering questions quickly, and following up after completion - with several reviewers noting he responds to inquiries even during evening hours.

"J&S was one of the better bids we got for painting the exterior of our house and staining our deck. Communication was excellent throughout." - Obadiah Eaves, Google Review via Chooz Painters"From my initial call until the finished product, they displayed professionalism and courtesy. I was given an estimate with a description of the work to be completed." - Sandy Kopman, Google Review via Chooz Painters"From the start, he provided a clear and detailed estimate with pricing and timeframes, making the entire process seamless." - Michelle & Jon, Google Review via Chooz Painters

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook

Cleanup and surface preparation come up consistently in reviews for painting companies in New Rochelle, NY. Paint Track Painting Services is noted for thorough prep before any paint is applied - wall patching, crack repair, caulking, and dust-minimizing sanding are called out across multiple separate reviews as standard steps, not extras. Several customers describe coming home to find the job done and the space already restored to normal. Azul Painting Corp earns consistent mention for cleaning up at the end of every working day on multi-day projects - customers with children or daily routines particularly appreciated this. J & S Painting Plus Inc customers note the crew always covers and protects surfaces before starting, and reviewers describe whole-house interior projects completed without paint on anything unintended.

Pier Painting Services earns compliments for cleanup after drywall work and water damage repairs as well as painting itself - the crew tidies after patching as thoroughly as after painting. Paintworks & Decorating crew member Luis was specifically called out for leaving a customer's bathroom cleaner after tile work than it was before the project started. NYCA Contractors, LLC inherently minimizes on-site disruption with their off-site spray process - no spray dust in the home and the kitchen stays usable throughout the entire project.

"Their team was thorough in their approach and maintained good communication throughout. The team left our space spotless." - Roxanne Greenstein, Google Review via Chooz Painters"The crew did a great job. They were courteous and totally professional. They even came back quickly to do patch-ups." - Janet Schechter, Google Review via Chooz Painters"The techs were professional, courteous, worked steady and left the place spotless." - Chuck Pagesy, Google Review via Chooz Painters

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

Punctuality and schedule reliability are highlighted across reviews for painting companies in New Rochelle, NY. J & S Painting Plus Inc gets consistent marks for arriving on time and finishing within stated timelines - one reviewer notes the team completed a full house exterior a day earlier than originally scheduled. Pier Painting Services owner Johnny Acosta is described across multiple reviews as arriving exactly when promised; one customer notes that after a quote, Johnny was ready to begin work within two days. Paint Track Painting Services schedules through a dedicated office team and customers describe a structured process that prevents the gaps common with smaller solo operations.

NYCA Contractors, LLC consistently delivers within the one- to two-week turnaround quoted at the start. Azul Painting Corp earns scheduling mentions on commercial work as well - their 10,000-square-foot building project was completed in under two weeks. Paintworks & Decorating is cited for fast response to urgent requests, with multiple customers describing same-day or next-day scheduling and one reviewer describing an inquiry, quote, and completed job all within 24 hours.

"Jay was so easygoing and very professional. He was always available to answer any questions. His price was super reasonable. Job was completed on time." - Michael Vega, Google Review via Chooz Painters"He gave me a quote and within 2 days was ready for work." - James Freeman, Google Review via Chooz Painters"They were quick, precise, efficient of time and energy and got the job done in a 1 week timeline like they committed to." - Caryl Mitsch, Google Review via Chooz Painters

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook

Pricing observations appear across reviews for most painting companies in New Rochelle, NY, and the pattern is consistent: customers describe fair, competitive pricing rather than the lowest possible cost - and most note the value held up because the quality matched what they paid. J & S Painting Plus Inc draws the most direct pricing mentions, with multiple reviewers getting several bids and selecting J & S as the most competitive among professional-quality options. NYCA Contractors, LLC customers frequently describe the price as reasonable for the factory-level cabinet finish they received, several noting they expected to pay more.

Paintworks & Decorating positions in the mid-to-higher range but earns marks for delivering on speed, quality, and cost simultaneously - which one reviewer describes as rare. Azul Painting Corp stands out for proactive billing: one reviewer received a final invoice below the original estimate when the stucco scope came in smaller, with the company adjusting the bill without being asked. Paint Track Painting Services is described by some as not the lowest price in the area, with reviewers framing this in terms of what they received: thorough prep, licensed professionals, and lasting results. Pier Painting Services customers describe fair, transparent pricing with quotes that accurately reflect the final scope.

"You usually pay for two of three: quick, quality, cost. The painters satisfied all three after comparing with other crews." - Hide Harashima, Google Review via Chooz Painters"We were impressed when the final invoice came in lower than the original estimate, reflecting the smaller scope of the job. This shows a great level of integrity." - Behrouz Khoshnevis, Google Review via Chooz Painters"Reasonable price. If you are looking for a professional painting company, look no further than Paint Track." - Tucker and Barbara Johann, Google Review via Chooz Painters

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

Repeat business is one of the strongest signals in the review data for painting companies in New Rochelle, NY. J & S Painting Plus Inc shows the clearest pattern: one reviewer has hired them four separate times for various rooms over the years, while others describe returning a decade or more later, noting the original finish held up well before they called again. Pier Painting Services has similar loyalty: one customer describes working with Johnny Acosta for over 10 years across multiple visits with more projects already planned. Paint Track Painting Services repeat customers appear throughout the review base, including a household that has used the team across both their own home and a rental property over several years.

Azul Painting Corp shows commercial and residential clients alike describing follow-up work planned before the current project is even finished - a commercial property manager describes using Azul repeatedly for a Westchester multifamily building. Paintworks & Decorating reviews include 5-year-plus relationships, with one customer starting with painting and later bringing the team back for a custom bar build and custom shelving installation. NYCA Contractors, LLC shows repeat patterns from customers with second properties, booking Al again without considering alternatives based entirely on their first experience.

"We have used Paint Track several times for our own house and a rental property. We are always thrilled with the work that Ray and his team do." - Ellen S., Google Review via Chooz Painters"This was the 4th time I have hired J&S to paint various rooms in my home. Very reliable, good work and reasonably priced. I will continue to use them for years to come!" - Phil The Magic Man, Google Review via Chooz Painters"Paintworks has been my go-to for 5+ years. They are efficient, flexible and professional. I never use anyone else." - Oona Haas, Google Review via Chooz Painters

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook