Homeowners in Mamaroneck, NY have access to some of the most consistently reviewed painting contractors in Westchester County. Across hundreds of reviews, a clear pattern emerges: crews that show up on time, communicate throughout the process, and leave the home looking better than they found it. Below are the top-rated painting companies serving Mamaroneck, NY based on their Chooz Score rankings.
With over 20 years in business, Paint Track Painting Services has built one of the strongest reputations in Westchester. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 150 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 4.6 stars on Yelp and a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation. This company earned a Chooz Score of 89.7%. What stands out across the reviews is the degree of trust customers place in the crew - multiple reviewers describe leaving their homes entirely in the team's hands, handing over keys or garage codes without hesitation. Owner Ray Rahni, Project Manager Jess, and estimator Sarah each play well-defined roles, while painters like Sergio, Alberto, and Chris appear by name across independent reviews spanning years. Paint Track Painting Services holds PCA Certification, EPA RRP lead-safe certification, and manufacturer certifications from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe. If you're looking for a full-service team with a deep bench of vetted, experienced painters for interior or exterior work, Paint Track Painting Services is a strong choice.
- Cabinet refinishing work is a recurring theme, with customers describing results that look factory-new on cabinets 20 to 30 years old - a number of reviewers note their kitchen guests assume the cabinets were replaced entirely
- Customers consistently note Ray's personal involvement throughout projects, from the estimate walk-through to quality checks during the work
- Skim coating and plaster repair appear alongside painting in multiple reviews, showing the crew handles surface prep as part of their standard process
"Ray and his crew are simply the best! The amount of prep work that goes into any job they take on is impressive, and it's also key to how long the work lasts. The people we bought from recommended Paint Track, and we now recommend them to everyone." - Barbara T., Google Review
For homeowners focused specifically on kitchen cabinet refinishing, NYCA Contractors, LLC has carved out a specialty that draws customers from across the region. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 115 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi with over 40 Angi reviews, and are 100% recommended on Facebook. This company earned a Chooz Score of 88.9%. What separates NYCA Contractors, LLC from standard on-site painters is their off-site spray process - cabinet doors are removed, transported to their shop for professional spray application, then returned and reinstalled. The result is a factory-level finish reviewers say is indistinguishable from brand-new cabinetry. Owner Albano handles estimates, color consultations, and scheduling personally, while Romino leads the on-site installation. If your primary goal is refreshing the look of your kitchen at a fraction of the cost of full replacement, NYCA Contractors, LLC is well worth a call.
- Multiple reviewers note their kitchen remained fully functional throughout the project since doors are removed for off-site spray work
- Al is consistently described as same-day or next-day responsive for estimates via text or phone, with detailed quotes that leave little ambiguity
- Customers in co-ops and condos with strict building management requirements describe the team navigating those rules without pushback
- Reviewers spanning several years describe consistent quality with no drop-off in results over time
"If I could give higher than 5 stars I would. Al and his team were extremely communicative from the very beginning about the process, timeline and what they needed us to do to prep. They kept in communication throughout the entire project." - Tim R., Google Review
While NYCA Contractors, LLC focuses on cabinet work, J & S Painting Plus Inc covers the full range - interior, exterior, deck staining, and carpentry - with a track record stretching back over 24 years in business. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 140 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2006), over 300 Angi reviews at a 4.9-star rating, and 4.6 stars on Yelp with over 25 Yelp reviews. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.5%. One detail that stands out across their reviews: project manager Sheki arrives to job sites carrying a folder with licenses, insurance certificates, and a written summary of how the work will be done - before any brush is picked up. Owner Jay Gisonni is frequently described as warm and direct during estimate visits, and the combination of clear upfront communication and quality execution has made J & S Painting Plus Inc a long-term contractor for many Westchester homeowners. If you want a company with a wide range of capabilities and a well-documented reputation across multiple platforms, J & S Painting Plus Inc is a reliable option.
- Several reviewers describe using J & S for the same full-house project more than a decade apart, returning because the original work still looked good
- Crew members Sheki, Omar, Jose, and Mauricio appear by name across independent reviews from different customers, a sign of a stable, consistent team
- New homebuyers appear frequently in the reviews, with same-week turnaround on full interior projects completed ahead of move-in dates
"Sheki comes prepared with a folder including licenses, insurance certificates, summary of how work will be done. Very helpful and glad to not have to ask." - Ruth H., Google Review
A husband-and-wife operation, Azul Painting Corp takes a hands-on approach that comes through clearly in their reviews. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 60 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi with over 25 Angi reviews, and hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (accredited since 2020). This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.2%. Co-owners Cinthya Aguilar and Mainor Barrantes are present throughout every project - Cinthya handles estimates, color consultations, and check-ins while Mainor regularly works alongside the crew on-site. With 6 years in business serving Westchester and Fairfield Counties, their service scope goes beyond standard painting, with reviews covering wallpaper installation, flooring, tile work, and even window reinforcement. If you want a company where the owners are personally engaged on your project from day one, Azul Painting Corp is a standout choice.
- Commercial property managers and community organizations appear in the reviews alongside residential customers, describing consistent results across different project types
- Reviewers frequently mention planning their next project before the current one wraps up - a strong signal of confidence in the team
- At least one reviewer noted a final invoice that came in below the original estimate when the scope was smaller than anticipated, reflecting honest scope management
"I have NEVER, in all of my years renting and owning homes, encountered a better painting company than Azul! They couple the warmth and individualized attention of a family run business with expert skill." - Leticia W., Google Review
Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Pier Painting Services. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 60 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, 5.0 stars on Yelp, and are 100% recommended on Facebook. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.1%. Owner Johnny Acosta has been in business for over 25 years as a Larchmont Chamber of Commerce member, and his name appears in nearly every review. What stands out in the pattern is how often new customers arrive through word-of-mouth from neighbors - reviewers describe being referred by a friend or real estate professional, then going on to recommend Johnny to their own network. The work described across reviews is broad: exterior painting, wallpapering, drywall repair, light carpentry, and door refinishing all appear, reflecting a team comfortable with handyman-adjacent work alongside painting. If you want a local, owner-operated contractor with deep Westchester roots and a reputation built on referrals, Pier Painting Services is a solid option.
- Realtor and interior designer clients appear in the reviews, with several recommending Johnny to their own clients as a trusted go-to painter
- Multiple reviewers describe not needing to take time off work to supervise because they trusted Johnny to handle decisions on-site and keep them informed
- Water damage repair, drywall patching, and chimney flashing work appear alongside painting projects, reflecting a versatile skill set beyond standard painting
"Johnny and his crew did a fantastic job painting our doors, baseboards, and trim. Great communication, smart suggestions, and impressive attention to detail - every chip, ding, and scratch is gone." - Anne T., Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors in Mamaroneck, NY, CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY brings the structure of a larger regional operation with over 16 years in business as WKM Choice Painting, Inc. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 175 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating and 4.2 stars on Angi with over 20 Angi reviews. This company earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%. A consistent theme across their reviews is daily cleanup - multiple customers describe furniture carefully covered, floors protected, and end-of-day tidying as standard practice. Named crews like Jose's, Ricardo's, and Fernando's appear across dozens of reviews, and project managers Tanner and Karina handle client communication throughout. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY holds a Westchester County Home Improvement Contractor License (No. WC-15781-H04), EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for pre-1978 homes, and a two-year warranty on all services. If you're looking for a company with the scale to handle large exterior projects or multi-room interiors with a structured, well-coordinated process, CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY is worth considering.
- An emergency chimney trim project is described in one review where a quote arrived within a week and the work was completed the following week - reflecting responsive scheduling
- Cross-state projects are handled under both New York and Connecticut licenses, useful for homeowners near the border
- Multiple reviewers who specifically mentioned comparing bids describe CertaPro's pricing as competitive, with the coordination process cited as a key differentiator
"Choosing someone to bring our beloved 135-year-old house back to life was initially very intimidating, and we're absolutely delighted that we decided to go with CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester." - Charlie H., Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi
