10 Best Painters Near Rye, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Rye, NY and Westchester County have built strong reputations across interior and exterior projects of every scale. The top-rated painters in the area consistently earn praise for hands-on ownership, named crews, and long-term customer loyalty.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Paint Track Painting Services had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus a 4.6-star rating on Yelp and a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.7% with over 20 years in business. Owner Ray Rahni supervises personally, and crew members like Sergio, Alberto, and Jonathan are called out by name across dozens of reviews. They hold PCA Certification, EPA RRP lead-safe certification, and manufacturer authorizations for Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe. A standout pattern: customers regularly hand over keys and garage codes for multi-day jobs - a level of trust that builds quickly.

• Cabinet refinishing is a core specialty, with reviewers describing decades-old cabinets that look freshly installed after the job.
• Services extend to deck staining, hardwood stain matching, wallpaper installation, and exterior shingle restoration.

"Ray and crew were great to work with. Professional, friendly, efficient, quality work. An excellent job on the exterior of our 1880 Victorian home and several interior rooms." - Susannah Johnston, Google Review

For homeowners focused on kitchen cabinet refinishing, NYCA Contractors, LLC brings a process most local painters can't match. They earned a Chooz Score of 88.9% with over 115 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi with over 40 reviews, and are 100% recommended on Facebook. Cabinet doors are removed, transported to their shop for off-site spray application, and returned installed - producing a factory-level finish on-site painting can't achieve. Owner Al handles every consultation personally. One reviewer noted the team proactively reached out when a chemical reaction caused an issue and redid the work before being asked. If you're focused on cabinet refinishing rather than a full-house paint job, NYCA Contractors is a good choice.

• Turnaround is typically under two weeks, including the off-site spray days.
• Guests regularly assume cabinets were fully replaced rather than refinished.

"If I could give higher than 5 stars I would. Al and his team were extremely communicative from the very beginning about the process, timeline and what they needed us to do to prep." - Tim Reid, Google Review

While NYCA focuses on cabinet work, J & S Painting Plus Inc handles the full range of interior and exterior projects with a remarkably loyal customer base. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5%, over 140 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau since 2006, and over 300 Angi reviews at a 4.9-star rating with over 25 Yelp reviews at 4.6 stars. With over 24 years in business, owners Jay Gisonni and Sheki each lead their own crews - and reviewers who worked with either describe the same organized, responsive experience. Sheki arrives to estimates with a folder of licenses and insurance certificates, which first-time homeowners consistently cite as reassuring. If you need a full exterior, a whole-house interior, or a quick pre-move-in paint, J & S Painting Plus is worth a call.

• Multiple reviewers are on their 3rd, 4th, or later project with J&S, spanning different project types across several years.
• Named crew members - Sheki, Omar, Jose, Mauricio, and Luis - each appear positively across reviews, reflecting consistent standards across the whole team.

"Jay and his team were great! We were first time homebuyers not knowing what we were doing and Jay got a team in to paint our house with a few days notice to get it painted before the moving truck came." - Matthew Conway, Google Review

A husband-and-wife operation based in New Rochelle, Azul Painting Corp earned a Chooz Score of 87.2% with over 60 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating, Better Business Bureau accreditation since 2020, and 5.0 stars on Angi. Co-owner Cinthya Aguilar handles communication and scheduling; co-owner Mainor Barrantes works on-site alongside the crew. They serve residential and commercial clients alike and handle wallpaper, flooring, and stucco repair in addition to paint. On at least one project, the final invoice came in below estimate when the scope was smaller - something reviewers specifically praised as honest. If you want a family-run company that handles more than just painting, Azul Painting Corp is a good fit.

• Reviewers frequently plan their next project before the current one wraps up, reflecting strong repeat-business trust.
• Commercial property managers and multifamily building owners appear alongside residential homeowners in the reviews.

"I have NEVER, in all of my years renting and owning homes, encountered a better painting company than Azul! They couple the warmth and individualized attention of a family run business with expert skill." - Leticia Warner, Google Review

With over 25 years in business, Pier Painting Services has built the kind of name that travels neighbor to neighbor through Westchester. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.1% with over 60 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating - every single review a five-star - plus 5.0 stars on Yelp and 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Johnny Acosta attends every estimate, arrives with credentials in hand, and often works alongside his crew. Real estate agents have hired Pier to prep properties before listing. Beyond painting, the team handles carpentry, drywall, power washing, and handyman repairs. If you want a versatile contractor with deep Westchester roots, Pier Painting Services is a strong choice.

• Several customers have relied on Johnny for over a decade, returning for a wide range of projects beyond standard painting.
• Challenging spaces - high vaulted ceilings, plaster walls, historic exterior woodwork - appear throughout the reviews without complaints about execution.

"Working with Johnny means I don't have to worry. I retained Johnny to perform maintenance on my house (painting, light carpentry, etc). I did not have to take off work to micromanage him which was such a relief." - Jennifer Colby, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Rye, NY, CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY brings over 16 years in business as WKM Choice Painting, Inc. and a structured operation that handles scale well. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 175 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating and 4.2 stars on Angi. Licensed in both Westchester County and Connecticut, EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certified, and backed by a two-year warranty on all services. Named team members - estimators Tanner, project leads Karina and Jose - make the coordination feel organized even on large jobs. If you're looking for a painting contractor with a proven track record and a multi-year warranty, CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester is a reliable option.

• Services include garage floor coating, deck staining, Sheetrock finishing, and exterior carpentry - well beyond standard paint.
• Connecticut homeowners can use CertaPro through their separate Connecticut Home Improvement Contractor License.
• A two-year warranty on all services is backed by over 16 years of operation in Southern Westchester.

"Over the years I have used CertaPro Painters for several projects at my home. I always find them to be reasonably priced and professional in scheduling, execution and clean up." - Patricia Mitchell, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Quality of workmanship is the most consistently praised theme across reviews for painters serving Rye, NY. Paint Track Painting Services earns repeated praise for prep work: caulking, crack repair, and thorough sanding before any paint is applied are mentioned across dozens of reviews as the foundation for results that hold up over years. J & S Painting Plus Inc draws similar feedback, with multiple reviewers noting crews finished projects a day ahead of schedule without cutting corners on detail work. Pier Painting Services' attention to prep on specialty surfaces - plaster walls, cedar shingles, and historic exterior woodwork - is described in specific terms rather than general praise.

Cabinet work brings out particularly strong language. NYCA Contractors, LLC produces results customers describe as factory-level, with guests routinely assuming cabinets were replaced rather than refinished. Azul Painting Corp has handled stucco repair, wallpaper installation, and interior painting on the same project and earned praise for all three. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY handled the exterior restoration of a 135-year-old home and received specific praise for bringing the old woodwork back properly without shortcuts. Across the area, the common thread is prep work that shows up in the finished result - and in how long it lasts.

"The quality of work never disappoints. Paint Track painted our kitchen cabinets a few years ago and the cabinets look better than the factory finish." - Jack Davis, Google Review"Choosing someone to bring our beloved 135-year-old house back to life was initially very intimidating, and we're absolutely delighted that we decided to go with CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester." - Charlie Hensley, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

Communication is one of the most frequently mentioned strengths across reviews for painters serving Rye, NY. Paint Track Painting Services uses a project manager and office coordinator to handle scheduling updates and progress check-ins throughout each job. Multiple reviewers describe texting or calling mid-project and getting same-day responses. J & S Painting Plus Inc earns specific praise for project manager Sheki's practice of arriving to estimates with a full documentation folder - licenses, insurance certificates, and a project summary - which customers describe as reassuring before any work starts. Owner Jay is noted for responding quickly to estimate requests and working around customer schedules for walkthroughs.

Pier Painting Services' owner Johnny Acosta is cited repeatedly for being reachable by phone or text throughout a project, with some reviewers noting he responds within minutes. Azul Painting Corp's Cinthya Aguilar is described as consistently responsive from first contact through final walkthrough. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY's layered team structure - estimators, project managers, crew leads each handling their piece - is credited by customers for keeping communication clear on larger or multi-phase projects. One homeowner coordinating a project from out of state specifically praised CertaPro's communication for making it manageable from a distance.

"From the moment I contacted them, their team was professional, friendly, and knowledgeable. They explained every step and kept me informed throughout." - Hana Mustafa, Google Review"He made the entire process run seamlessly which was important since we were working from out of state." - Thandi Chase, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook

Repeat business is one of the clearest signals in the review data for painters serving Rye, NY. J & S Painting Plus Inc has some of the most striking numbers: one reviewer describes his most recent project as his fourth time hiring J&S for rooms in his home, and another returned for a full-house repaint after more than 10 years away, noting the original coat had held up well. Pier Painting Services' owner Johnny Acosta has customers who have relied on him for a decade or longer, returning for interior painting, exterior work, carpentry repairs, and handyman tasks across multiple seasons.

CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY has customers who first hired them over 15 years ago and called again recently. One reviewer hired CertaPro numerous times in a single year for different projects and wrote that she wished she had more rooms to paint. Azul Painting Corp reviewers frequently mention planning their next project before the current one is done. Paint Track Painting Services has homeowners who have used them for both their primary home and a rental property across different years. The repeat-customer pattern across all of these companies suggests customers trust the process - not just the finished product.

"This is the second time we used J & S Painting. The first time was with Jay, and this time it was with Sheki. Both owners are equally excellent. The entire J & S team, from the office to on site, are all top notch." - SS, Google Review"I have used Pier Services multiple times in my home, 3 years ago for exterior painting and earlier this spring for a full-house interior paint job, with kitchen cabinet stripping and repainting and other handyman visits, and have more projects planned." - David Lacher, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Prep work and daily cleanup are recurring themes in reviews for painters serving Rye, NY, with customers describing how carefully their homes were protected before work started and how they found things each afternoon. Paint Track Painting Services receives consistent mention for surface preparation specifically: caulking, crack repair, and sanding before painting are described as the norm rather than optional extras, and several reviewers connect the longevity of the finished work directly to the prep standard. J & S Painting Plus Inc crews cover work areas at each stage - drop cloths, plastic sheeting, and protection of adjacent finishes - and reviewers who hired them for exterior work describe landscaping and walkways being protected throughout.

Pier Painting Services customers describe finding their rooms organized and clean at the end of each workday, with no dust or paint remnants left behind. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY moves and protects furniture as part of the standard process and cleans thoroughly before the crew leaves each afternoon. Azul Painting Corp reviewers describe the team as careful with the space whether working indoors or out, including on projects that combined painting with stucco repair or wallpaper installation. For homeowners who are particular about cleanliness, the standard across these contractors appears consistently high.

"The team was very professional and took great care to make sure everything was properly covered during the job and tidy before they left each day." - Michael Szarpa, Google Review"His team was always on time and worked efficiently. They always covered the area to ensure cleanliness." - Caroline Bilal, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook

Reliable scheduling is a consistent strength across top painters serving Rye, NY. J & S Painting Plus Inc is described by multiple reviewers as accommodating tight timelines, including a move-in paint job organized on just a few days notice. Crews arrive when they say they will and complete projects on or ahead of the quoted timeline - one reviewer noted the team finished a full interior a day early. Pier Painting Services' owner Johnny Acosta is known for fast follow-through: one reviewer described receiving a quote and having a crew on-site within two days. Johnny's punctuality is mentioned consistently enough that reviewers specifically call it out as unusual compared to other contractors they've worked with.

Paint Track Painting Services uses a project manager and office coordinator to keep scheduling on track even during busy seasons. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY is described by multiple customers as a "well oiled machine" for scheduling - estimates, crew assignment, and project completion all follow a defined process. Azul Painting Corp's Cinthya communicates clearly about start dates and any adjustments, with crews arriving ready rather than late or unprepared. Across all of these companies, customers describe a level of scheduling reliability that makes projects easier to plan around - and that holds up across multiple jobs over multiple years.

"Johnny is very professional and diligent. He gave me a quote and within 2 days was ready for work." - James Freeman, Google Review"His pricing was very reasonable, his team was always on time and worked efficiently. The team's craftsmanship was exceptional." - kyle kelly, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Pricing and value come up frequently in reviews for painters serving Rye, NY, with customers who gathered multiple quotes before hiring consistently noting that the top-rated companies came in at competitive or better-than-expected prices relative to the quality delivered. J & S Painting Plus Inc is described across multiple reviews as one of the better-priced options among the bids collected, with costs matching the quote and no surprises at final invoice. Azul Painting Corp impressed at least one customer by sending a final invoice below the original estimate when the project scope was smaller than expected - something reviewers described as honest and fair. Estimates from Cinthya are described as clear and itemized.

CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY customers describe competitive pricing paired with a two-year warranty, adding long-term value beyond the upfront cost. Paint Track Painting Services is not positioned as the lowest-priced option in the area - some reviewers acknowledge it - but add that the quality and crew reliability make the cost worth it. NYCA Contractors, LLC earns specific praise for pricing cabinet refinishing at a fraction of what full replacement would cost, with owner Al described as transparent about what's included. Across the area, customers describe feeling that what they paid matched what they received - not just the lowest number, but fair value for the work done.

"Excellent professionals!! Went above and beyond to do amazing work at an affordable price. Would highly recommend!" - Dianne Tinelli, Google Review"Cinthya and Mainor gave a fair estimate and promptly answered all my questions as the work progressed." - James Glessmann, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi