9 Best Painters Near Port Chester, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

J & S Painting Plus Inc leads the Port Chester, NY area with a Chooz Score of 87.5%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 140 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating - a volume that is hard to maintain without delivering consistent results. Their reputation extends across platforms: over 300 reviews on Angi with a 4.9-star rating and over 25 reviews on Yelp at 4.6 stars. Accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2006 and recipients of multiple Angi Super Service Awards, owner Jay Gisonni and his team have spent over 24 years in business building deep roots across Westchester County and into Connecticut. J & S Painting Plus Inc runs a full team that includes project managers Sheki and Omar, office coordinators Pam and Kathie, and painters like Mauricio, Jose, Luis, Victor, Juan, and Sergio.

A pattern that surfaces clearly when reading through the reviews is how many first-time homeowners and new buyers turn to J&S under tight move-in deadlines. Multiple customers describe closing on their home and having Jay's crew ready to start within 24 hours, completing entire interior paint jobs before furniture arrived. Several reviewers also describe Jay's personal involvement in helping them navigate color selection, working through indecision patiently without rushing. The company's service area runs well beyond Port Chester, with clients in Greenwich and Norwalk, CT reporting the same experience as local customers.

• The office team - Pam and Kathie - earns specific praise by name across dozens of reviews, which is uncommon for a painting contractor; customers credit them with prompt follow-up emails, clear scheduling communication, and reliable responsiveness throughout each job.
• Sheki arrives to estimates with a prepared folder containing licenses, insurance certificates, and a written summary of how the work will be done - a level of upfront documentation that several reviewers said they had never seen from a painting contractor before.
• The company handles more than just painting; customers describe deck staining, carpentry on damaged wood trim, drywall repair, and wallpaper removal all completed as part of their projects.
• Repeat business shows up clearly across reviews, with customers returning years later and noting the original work still held up well before calling J&S back for the next project.

"In a world where we all have a lot going on, you will have one less headache to worry about if you hire them. They are professional, consistent, affordable and a great team from top to bottom." - Jon Spellman, Google Review

If you are a homeowner looking for a painting contractor with strong communication, a well-organized crew, and a track record of repeat customers, J & S Painting Plus is a good fit.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

Professionalism and communication are consistently the first things customers mention when reviewing painting contractors in Port Chester, NY, and J & S Painting Plus Inc is the company that earns top marks across both. From the initial estimate to the final walkthrough, reviewers describe an organized and thorough experience. Jay arrives to estimate appointments promptly, walks through the full scope of the project, explains exactly what work will be done, and follows up with a written quote within 24 hours. Customers note that Sheki comes to estimates with a prepared folder of licenses, insurance documents, and a summary of the crew's approach - a standard that reviewers regularly single out as unlike any other contractor they had hired.

Communication stays strong throughout the job itself. Pam and Kathie in the office handle scheduling, send follow-up emails after conversations, and remain accessible when customers have questions during the project. On-site, Sheki and Omar check in frequently and respond quickly by phone or text. Customers who work from home during projects also note how little disruption the crews create - arriving on time, working efficiently, and keeping things quiet and organized throughout the day. For homeowners in the Port Chester, NY area who want consistent, professional communication from start to finish, J & S Painting Plus is a strong choice.

"Jay was immediately responsive and helped guide us through the painting process. J&S was able to schedule painting the same week, which is very rare." - Shari Franklin, Google Review"Jay and his wife Kathie were on top of all the details of our many color selections and requests." - Toby London Levine, Google Review~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Scheduling reliability is one of the strongest themes running through reviews for painting contractors in Port Chester, NY, and it is a consistent strength for J & S Painting Plus Inc. Reviewers describe crews arriving when promised - often before the stated start time - and completing projects within or ahead of the agreed schedule. This holds across different project types: new homeowners describe having full interior jobs completed before their moving trucks arrived, and exterior customers report crews finishing a full day ahead of the projected timeline. One customer noted that when the crew said they would arrive at 8:00 AM, they were already waiting at 7:55.

The reliability extends to daily consistency as well. Across multiple reviews, customers describe the crew showing up on time every morning, working full days, and keeping the work site organized and clean before leaving each evening. For customers coordinating painting around contractor schedules, move-in deadlines, or work-from-home situations, the predictability of J&S crews is something reviewers mention as a key reason they would hire J & S Painting Plus again. The company also handles quick-turn scheduling, with several customers noting they were able to book within the same week they called - described as genuinely rare in the Westchester market.

"Not only were they the best priced, they finished a day earlier than originally quoted, and they were incredibly easy to work with and had great communication. When they said they would be there at 8:00am, they were waiting at 7:55am!" - Matthew Stephan, Google Review"Luis and his painting crew did high-quality work and were very professional, reliable, and friendly - and even finished ahead of schedule." - Janet Kraybill, Google Review~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing comes up in a high share of reviews for painting contractors in Port Chester, NY, and the consistent takeaway for J & S Painting Plus Inc is that the price is fair and clearly communicated from the start. Jay is described across reviews as thorough in his estimate walk-through, taking precise measurements, reviewing the full scope, and following up with itemized written quotes. Customers comparing multiple bids note that J&S is not always the absolute lowest, but the detail in the estimate and the clarity of what was included made the price feel well-justified. In several cases, J&S came in as the best-priced option among all contractors considered.

What customers seem to value most is that the price holds. Reviewers who added work mid-project describe Jay as accommodating, adjusting the scope without making the customer feel uneasy about the change. There are no reports of surprise charges that exceeded what was discussed upfront. One customer noted their realtor commented positively on the quality of the finished work and the value it represented. For homeowners who want a fair upfront price and no mid-project surprises, J & S Painting Plus is a company worth getting an estimate from in the Port Chester, NY area.

"Jay was very professional and very accommodating. We ended up expanding our scope and he accommodated us every step of the way." - Alexandra F., Angi Review"Jay is a consummate professional who goes above and beyond to accommodate his customers' every request. He is knowledgeable, informative, communicates beautifully, and thinks out of the box." - Candace Silver, Google Review~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Angi