Homeowners in Hastings on Hudson, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each bringing a different mix of specialties and service styles. Whether you need kitchen cabinets refinished, a historic exterior restored, or a quick interior refresh before a move, the top-rated companies in the area consistently earn praise for quality prep work, clear communication, and reliable crews.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Paint Track Painting Services had over 150 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.7%, the highest among painters serving Hastings on Hudson, NY. With over 20 years in business, Paint Track has built a reputation for cabinet refinishing and detailed surface preparation. Reviews also show strong multi-platform presence, including 4.6 stars on Yelp and a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation. They are PCA Certified, EPA RRP lead-safe certified, and hold manufacturer certifications from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe. If you have older cabinets you want to keep rather than replace, Paint Track is a good choice.
What stands out across reviews is how often customers describe repeat projects. Several homeowners started with a single room or cabinet job and returned for exterior painting, staircase staining, or full-home interior work. One family trusted the crew enough to have them work around a child with asthma, noting the team completed the project with very little dust. Crew members like Alberto, Sergio, Chris, and project coordinator Jess are mentioned by name across independent reviews.
- Repeat customers frequently describe returning for progressively larger projects after a positive first experience
- Multiple reviewers highlight stain-matching skills, including a staircase where two different wood types were blended seamlessly
- Homeowners with older or historic properties praise the crew's comfort with plaster walls, Victorian-era exteriors, and detailed trim work
"We've now had two excellent experiences with Ray and his team. Most recently, they stained my staircase and flawlessly matched stains on two different types of wood." - Elizabeth Feeney, Google Review
For homeowners who value responsiveness and a hands-on owner, Pro Painting Plus earned a Chooz Score of 87.6% with over 75 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. Owner Rob McRae is named in the majority of reviews, and customers consistently describe him visiting the job site daily to check on progress and ensure satisfaction. If you are working on a tight deadline or need someone who can mobilize quickly, Pro Painting Plus is a good fit.
Several reviews describe emergency or last-minute situations where Rob stepped in after another contractor failed to deliver. Deck staining, cabinet refinishing, and exterior cedar work appear frequently in the review record. Crew members like Dario, Luis, Miguel, Herbie, and Juan are praised individually for wall repair work and careful prep. A number of homeowners also note that Rob offers helpful suggestions beyond the original scope, pointing out fixes they had not noticed.
- Customers who hired Pro Painting Plus for deck and cedar staining frequently describe results that made aging surfaces look almost new
- Several reviews mention Rob arriving within hours of a phone call and starting work the following day
- A historic church and a log cabin are among the more unusual projects praised in reviews
"Rob showed up one hour after my phone call and mapped out the entire job for us. Paint was ordered hours later and work began the following day." - R M, Google Review
When it comes to fast turnarounds and move-in deadlines, Five Star Painting of White Plains stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.4% with over 95 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. They are also 94% recommended on Facebook. Owner Dennis is mentioned by name in nearly every review and stays involved from the initial estimate through the final walkthrough. If you are buying a home and need painting completed between closing and move-in, Five Star has handled that exact scenario for multiple customers.
Real estate professionals refer clients to Five Star regularly, and several reviews come from brokers who trust Dennis inside their clients' homes. The crew includes Sergio, Stive, Rob, Angel, and Roger, names that appear across reviews from different customers and different time periods. Wallpaper installation is another specialty that earns strong praise. With over 5 years in business, they have grown quickly while maintaining consistent ratings.
- Multiple real estate brokers describe Five Star as their go-to referral for clients needing painting services
- Customers who needed tight-deadline work praise the team for completing entire apartments in just a few days
- Dennis is described as available for late-night calls and early morning site visits to accommodate urgent timelines
"He handled our whole new home getting painted between closing and our move in date on a very tight deadline, his communication was great, and our home is beautiful!" - Nina Lerman, Google Review
With nearly 40 years in business, Aquinas Painting Contractors has built the kind of long-term loyalty that few companies achieve. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.3% with over 80 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. They also hold 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. If you are looking for a contractor you can rely on for years, Aquinas is a strong choice, as several reviewers describe relationships spanning a decade or more.
The company was originally founded by Jim Dugandzic and is now led by partner Alex Solis, who is named in the majority of reviews. Customers consistently describe crews that leave spaces cleaner than they found them, with furniture covered, floors protected, and thorough daily cleanup as standard practice. Crew members Pablo, Walter, Miguel, and Manuel are praised individually. Projects range from quick bathroom ceiling repairs to full exterior painting of historic homes with decades of paint buildup.
- One long-time customer has used Aquinas for over 20 years, starting with the original founder and continuing with Alex
- A religious community hired Aquinas for exterior convent work, a kitchen, and multiple bedrooms across separate projects
- Reviewers frequently mention fair pricing and quick turnarounds, with one 10-room house and porch completed in just 3 days
"Aquinas painted the outside of my house last year and just finished my basement. They are the best painters I have ever worked with. So professional, reliable and immaculate." - Robert Ebel, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook
