10 Best Painters Near Tarrytown, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Tarrytown, NY have access to a well-established group of painting contractors who consistently earn high marks for both results and reliability. Whether it's a historic Victorian needing careful exterior restoration or a kitchen cabinet refresh, the top-rated painters in this area stand out for attentive communication, thorough prep work, and clean job sites. Here are the highest-scoring contractors on Chooz Painters serving the Tarrytown, NY area.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Paint Track Painting Services had over 150 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating - a score that's difficult to sustain at that volume. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.7%. Based in nearby Briarcliff Manor and in business for over 20 years since 2004, Paint Track is PCA Certified and EPA RRP lead-safe certified, with additional certifications from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe. The company also holds a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation. For homeowners planning a full interior repaint, detailed cabinet refinishing, or an exterior restoration, Paint Track is a strong choice.

What sets Paint Track apart in the reviews is the depth and consistency of its full-time crew. Owner Ray, project manager Jess, and estimator Sarah each handle specific roles, while painters like Sergio, Alberto, and Chris are called out by name in dozens of independent reviews. Several customers mentioned handing over a key or garage code and returning to find the work complete and the space spotless - a level of trust that's only built through a reliable, vetted team.

• Multiple reviewers noted they were referred to Paint Track by the previous owners of their home - a telling sign of community-level trust
• Ray personally got involved when unexpected issues arose beyond the original scope, including a plumbing-related wall repair that wasn't part of the original project
• Reviews mention Paint Track handling skim coating, deck restoration, wallpaper installation, and stain matching in addition to standard painting
• The company's lead-safe protocols were specifically noted by a parent who had a young child tested after the job - with clean results

"Ray and his team did a truly outstanding job repainting the exterior of our home. Paint Track is a real professional painting company that excels in all aspects of the project, including communications and of course top quality work, both for necessary preparation/repairs and the painting itself." - Ivan K., Google Review

For homeowners looking to refresh their kitchen without the cost and disruption of full cabinet replacement, NYCA Contractors, LLC has built a specialty reputation around cabinet refinishing that's hard to find elsewhere in the region. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, NYCA had over 115 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Angi with over 40 reviews and 100% recommended on Facebook. They earned a Chooz Score of 88.9%.

NYCA's process is distinctive: cabinet doors and drawer fronts are removed, transported off-site to a shop in Norwalk for professional spray application, then returned and reinstalled. This produces a factory-level finish that on-site brush painting can't replicate, and keeps the kitchen functional throughout the project. Owner Al is personally involved from estimate to completion, and Romino is praised by name across multiple reviews for his on-site work.

• Al responded to scheduling requests via text with same-day or next-day quotes - multiple reviewers mentioned how unusually fast the process started
• When a chemical reaction issue occurred during one project, Al immediately offered to redo the entire job at no additional cost
• The turnaround is consistently described as two weeks or less, even for full kitchen door sets
• Several customers noted getting referred by a friend, calling it the best referral they had ever received

"Cannot say enough good things about NYCA Contractors. I had my kitchen cabinets painted and they came out absolutely beautiful. The whole process from start to finish was less than two weeks. They were professional, on time and very CLEAN!!!" - Deb M., Google Review

While Paint Track and NYCA have strong cabinet refinishing followings, J & S Painting Plus Inc has carved out a reputation for full exterior work and whole-house interior painting across Westchester County. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 140 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, plus over 300 reviews on Angi at a 4.9-star rating. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5%. With over 24 years in business and BBB accreditation since 2006, J&S has built a multi-generational client base across the region. If you're a first-time homeowner who needs fast turnaround before a move-in, or planning a major exterior project, J&S is worth a call.

Project manager Sheki, owner Jay, and office coordinators Pam and Kathie draw consistent praise for communication and organization. Sheki is specifically noted by multiple reviewers for arriving to estimates with a prepared folder containing licensing, insurance certificates, and a written plan for how the work will proceed.

• Sheki arrives to estimate appointments with a folder containing license and insurance documents - multiple reviewers cited this as immediately building their confidence
• Jay scheduled a full interior paint job within 24 hours of a new homeowner's closing date when they needed the work done before moving in
• Reviewers noted that J&S crew members proactively flagged concerns on surrounding surfaces, not just the areas being painted
• Multiple customers mentioned J&S was not the cheapest bid but described the quality as clearly worth the difference

"We recently had a truly outstanding experience with Shecki and the paint crew. From start to finish Shecki and his team were incredibly professional, reliable, excellent communicators, and their price was more than competitive." - Jordan M., Google Review

A hands-on owner-run team, Pier Painting Services is operated by owner Johnny Acosta and brings personal involvement that comes through consistently in the reviews. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Pier had over 60 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp and 100% recommended on Facebook. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.1%. With over 25 years serving Westchester County and a Larchmont Chamber of Commerce membership, Pier draws much of its business from neighbor-to-neighbor referrals. If you're looking for a contractor equally comfortable with a small repair and a full interior or exterior project, Pier fits the profile.

Johnny handles every estimate personally, walks customers through cost and scope up front, and checks in throughout the project. At least one local realtor now refers clients to Johnny for pre-listing prep work, describing the team as "completely dependable."

• Johnny's team handles work well beyond basic painting - floor refinishing, chandelier installation, drywall repair, and carpentry all appear in the reviews
• Several reviewers noted that Johnny offered cost-saving suggestions when he spotted issues, advising on the smarter approach rather than just doing what was asked
• The crew cleaned up daily and left the site organized at the end of each workday, mentioned consistently across both interior and exterior projects
• At least two reviewers noted the job finished ahead of the original timeline

"Johnny and his team were reliable and attentive to our needs and requests. Johnny took the time to explain everything and was very responsive. Costs were transparent, quote was respected." - Veronique V., Google Review

With over 16 years serving Southern Westchester as WKM Choice Painting, Inc., CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY brings a structured project management approach and a two-year warranty that smaller operators often can't match. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 175 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%. The company holds Westchester County Home Improvement Contractor License No. WC-15781-H04 and a Connecticut Home Improvement Contractor License for cross-border work, along with EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for pre-1978 homes. One Tarrytown, NY homeowner hired CertaPro seven years ago for Victorian window trim work and returned for additional projects. For larger or more complex exterior projects, CertaPro's scale and experience make them well-suited.

Crew leads Fernando, Jose, and Ricardo are praised by name across multiple independent reviews. The company's structured workflow - detailed estimate, pre-work walkthrough, in-progress updates, and post-project follow-up - is highlighted repeatedly as reducing stress for customers managing projects remotely.

• CertaPro completed a project that included an active wasp nest discovered mid-job, without disrupting the timeline or charging extra
• Repeat customers describe the company as a "well oiled machine" with no surprises from estimate to completion
• The two-year warranty on all services provides a level of security that comes up repeatedly in reviews when comparing options
• Reviewers noted crews moved furniture, covered floors and fixtures, and restored everything to original position before leaving each day

"This is a story of truly outstanding customer service... Years ago - seven! - we hired CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester to paint the window trim on our Victorian house in Tarrytown." - Suzy A., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Tarrytown, NY, Aquinas Painting Contractors brings nearly 40 years of experience to the area, having operated continuously since 1987. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Aquinas had over 80 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.3%. Based in Valley Cottage and holding Rockland County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H-25-030, Aquinas covers Westchester, Rockland, Bergen County NJ, and Orange County NY, with all painters OSHA certified. For homeowners who value long-standing relationships and want a contractor they can rely on for years, Aquinas fits the profile.

Partner Alex Solis runs daily operations alongside a crew that reviewers consistently describe as fast, thorough, and respectful of the home. Several long-term customers have used Aquinas across multiple properties over decades, including both residential homes and institutional exteriors.

• Alex personally rescheduled to meet urgent customer timing needs, including a deck staining project that required a tight window
• Reviewers noted the crew went beyond the painting scope - replacing unreachable light bulbs, fixing spindle damage, and addressing ceiling cracks noticed during prep
• Aquinas has handled both residential painting and larger commercial and institutional work, including a full convent exterior
• The crew consistently returns furniture to its original placement and completes a final cleanup pass before leaving

"Aquinas painting is a very professional outfit. They provided both interior and exterior painting services in a timely manner with pristine results and fair pricing. They were friendly, accommodating and finished by thoroughly cleaning the premises." - Steven R., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Customers across the Tarrytown, NY area consistently single out careful prep work as the marker of a quality paint job. Paint Track Painting Services and J & S Painting Plus Inc draw particular praise for surface preparation, with reviewers describing thorough sanding, crack repair, caulking, and the use of premium paints from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe. Multiple Paint Track customers note that kitchen cabinets - some 20 to 30 years old - came out looking better than the original factory finish, with visitors assuming the cabinets had been replaced rather than refinished. NYCA Contractors, LLC stands out for its off-site spray process, which produces a factory-level finish on cabinet doors and drawer fronts that on-site brush painting can't replicate. Customers regularly describe the finished product as indistinguishable from new cabinetry.

Pier Painting Services and Aquinas Painting Contractors both receive detailed mentions of careful prep work, with reviewers noting painters addressed wall cracks, patches, and surface irregularities before any color went on. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY earned specific praise for restoration work on a 135-year-old home, where neighbors described the finished results as stunning. One Aquinas reviewer noted their painter was "exceptionally skilled" and handled bathroom cracks, chipping, and rough patches "quickly and efficiently" while others simply would have painted over them. "Their crew went above and beyond to make sure everything was done perfectly and I was happy with the work him and his team did. They even came back the next day to work on touchups perfecting everything." - Amanda E., Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

Communication is one of the most consistent themes across reviews of painting contractors serving Tarrytown, NY. Customers repeatedly describe contractors who answered questions promptly, showed up to estimates with documentation in hand, and kept clients informed throughout. J & S Painting Plus Inc is frequently noted for this: project manager Sheki arrives to estimate appointments with a prepared folder containing licensing, insurance certificates, and an overview of how the job will proceed - something multiple reviewers mentioned as an immediate trust-builder. Paint Track Painting Services runs a structured team where owner Ray, project manager Jess, and estimator Sarah each handle a defined role, giving customers a named contact for each phase of the project. The company's transparency on pricing and materials has been specifically called out across multiple reviews.

CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY coordinates through a similar structure: sales, scheduling, on-site supervision, and post-project follow-up are handled by different people, with regular updates throughout. Pier Painting Services takes a more personal approach - owner Johnny Acosta handles every estimate and stays in regular contact from start to finish. Aquinas Painting Contractors draws consistent praise for quick responses and an easy scheduling process that returning customers describe as reliably smooth. NYCA Contractors, LLC owner Al responds to every review with project-specific details, and customers describe him as reachable by text with fast turnaround on quotes. "Jay was so great to work with. He worked with my schedule and his team was always on time. Jay was quick to respond to any questions. You can see why Jay has been in this business for so long and has been so successful." - Liz M., Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

On-time arrivals and projects completed within the quoted timeframe are mentioned across dozens of reviews for contractors serving Tarrytown, NY. J & S Painting Plus Inc has built particular goodwill around scheduling: multiple reviewers describe Jay's team completing jobs a day ahead of the original timeline, and at least two first-time homebuyers were accommodated within 24 to 48 hours of requesting a start date. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY uses project coordinators to manage scheduling across multiple crews, which helps maintain predictable start and completion dates even on larger exterior jobs. Multiple reviewers noted the company delivered the project in exactly the timeframe they had estimated, with one reviewer describing the experience as "punctual down to the minute."

Pier Painting Services and Aquinas Painting Contractors both draw consistent reviews noting on-time arrivals and faster-than-expected completions. Aquinas completed a 10-room house and front porch in three days, which drew specific mention from the homeowner as a standout. NYCA Contractors, LLC is praised for its two-week-or-less turnaround on cabinet refinishing jobs that involve off-site fabrication - faster than customers expected given the quality of the result. "Aquinas responded immediately to our call and got the work done in less than a day. We are very pleased. They were thorough, clean, quiet and respectful of our belongings." - Sean M., Google Review. Paint Track Painting Services receives similar marks for reliability, with multiple customers noting Ray checked in regularly and kept projects moving forward without delays.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

End-of-day cleanup and careful protection of belongings are consistent themes in reviews for painting contractors serving Tarrytown, NY. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY receives specific praise for daily cleanup practices: crews cover and move furniture before starting, and customers note they return to a clean space at the end of each workday throughout multi-day projects. Multiple reviewers described CertaPro's cleanup standards as a pleasant surprise. Aquinas Painting Contractors is similarly noted for thoroughness, with reviewers describing furniture returned to its original position and the premises left spotless after each visit. Crew members have drawn praise for going beyond the painting scope to leave spaces in better condition than they found them.

Paint Track Painting Services uses dust-extracting sanders and careful prep procedures that minimize mess during surface work - a detail specifically called out by reviewers with young children or concerns about air quality. Pier Painting Services crews clean up and organize the workspace before leaving at the end of each day, mentioned consistently across both interior and exterior projects. J & S Painting Plus Inc receives high marks for protecting floors, trim, and adjacent surfaces throughout the process. "The team was punctual, clean, careful and did an excellent job. They cleaned up meticulously and returned furniture to its proper place." - Robbi A., Google Review. NYCA Contractors, LLC specifically removes cabinet doors off-site rather than spraying in the home, which eliminates overspray entirely - a cleanup benefit customers frequently highlight.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Contractors serving Tarrytown, NY draw consistent praise for transparent pricing and written estimates that hold through to project completion. J & S Painting Plus Inc stands out for itemized quotes that detail the scope and allow customers to ask questions before committing. Multiple reviewers noted that while J&S was not always the lowest bid, the quality and reliability made the pricing feel worth it. Aquinas Painting Contractors is frequently described as fairly priced and competitive, particularly for larger exterior and interior projects. Several reviewers described getting multiple quotes and selecting Aquinas based on the combination of price, responsiveness, and reputation.

CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY provides detailed written estimates and includes a two-year warranty on all services - something reviewers factor into the overall value rather than comparing upfront cost alone. Pier Painting Services is consistently described as reasonably priced, with estimates that are quoted and honored with no surprises. NYCA Contractors, LLC earns specific mention for competitive pricing on cabinet refinishing - multiple customers described the price as fair given the quality of the off-site spray finish. "Nyca's prices are fair and in line with the time and effort that was invested in the job. My 30 year old cabinets look like new!!" - Yossi P., Google Review. Paint Track Painting Services is positioned at a slightly higher price point, but multiple customers describe the quality and longevity of their finished work as justifying the difference - including one homeowner whose original exterior paint job held up long enough to bring them back for a second project over a decade later.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

Repeat business and referrals are a defining pattern across reviews for painting contractors serving Tarrytown, NY. Aquinas Painting Contractors has some of the most striking retention numbers in the area: Frank O has used the company for over 20 years, working with both the original founder and current partner Alex Solis. Frank Cataldo hired Aquinas three times within a year and a half. J & S Painting Plus Inc shows a similar pattern: Phil's most recent project was his fourth time hiring J&S, and Len Toscano returned after a decade with the original paint job still holding up well. Multiple J&S reviewers describe a pattern of returning every few years as new rooms or exterior areas need attention.

CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY has customers who return across multiple homes and multiple years: one repeat customer has used them at both of his homes multiple times, while another first hired them over 15 years ago and called them back recently for trim work. Pier Painting Services draws repeat customers across a wide range of project types - the same homeowner often hires Johnny for painting one season and for ceiling repairs, floor refinishing, or fixture installation the next. Paint Track Painting Services maintains a similar track record, with returning customers mentioning projects across multiple rooms, exterior work, wallpaper installation, and stain matching over several years. "We have used Paint Track several times for our own house and a rental property. We are always thrilled with the work that Ray and his team do." - Ellen S., Google Review. NYCA Contractors, LLC has earned second-project business from customers who originally hired them for cabinets and returned for additional refinishing or wall unit work.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi