8 Best Painters Near Hartsdale, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Hartsdale, NY have access to several well-reviewed painting contractors serving the Westchester County area. Across hundreds of verified reviews, customers highlight reliable scheduling, thorough prep work, and painters who treat homes with care. Here are the top-rated contractors based on Chooz Painters data.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Paint Track Painting Services had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 89.7%. With over 20 years in business, this Westchester-based company employs full-time W2 painters rather than subcontractors, and reviewers frequently mention crew members like Sergio and Chris by name. Their cabinet refinishing work stands out, with multiple homeowners describing outdated kitchens that now look factory-fresh. They also hold PCA and EPA RRP lead-safe certifications along with manufacturer certifications from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe. If you have an older home and want a company with certified, dedicated crews, Paint Track is a strong choice.

What comes through in the reviews is how many customers hand over their house keys and leave for the day, completely comfortable with the team on-site. Several reviewers also note the detailed written estimates that break down every cost line by line, so there are no surprises at the end.

• Kitchen cabinet projects consistently generate praise, with homeowners describing 18- and 30-year-old cabinets that guests mistake for new installations
• Skim coating and drywall repair are called out as a specialty beyond standard painting
• The office team, including project manager Jess and estimator Sarah, receives frequent praise for keeping projects on track

"The quality of work never disappoints. Paint Track painted our kitchen cabinets a few years ago and the cabinets look better than the factory finish." - Jack Davis, Google Review

For homeowners specifically looking at cabinet refinishing, NYCA Contractors, LLC has built a reputation around an off-site spray process using Italian-brand paints that produces a smooth, factory-level result. They earned a Chooz Score of 88.9% with over 115 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Angi with over 40 reviews and 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Al (Albano) handles every estimate personally and is mentioned by name in a large share of reviews. If your kitchen cabinets need a refresh and you want the convenience of keeping your kitchen functional during the work, NYCA is a good fit.

A pattern that stands out in their reviews is how many initially skeptical customers become enthusiastic advocates after seeing the finished product. Several note they found NYCA through Angi and were unsure about hiring an out-of-area contractor, but the results won them over completely.

• Doors and drawers are removed and taken to a spray shop, then returned and reinstalled, so kitchens stay usable throughout the project
• Multiple reviewers describe the turnaround as under two weeks from start to finish
• Al accommodates building management requirements and weekend schedules without extra charges

"The best contractor I have ever worked with. Period. Al and his team were simply amazing. They were truly the bright spot during my renovation process." - Gary Rizzo, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for J & S Painting Plus Inc. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5% with over 140 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating and are accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2006, with over 300 reviews on Angi at a 4.9-star rating. With over 24 years in business, owner Jay and lead painter Sheki (also spelled Shecki) are names that come up again and again. Several customers describe hiring J & S for a second or third project years after the first. If you want a long-established company with a deep local track record, J & S is a solid pick.

What first-time homebuyers in particular seem to appreciate is Jay's willingness to work on tight move-in timelines. Multiple reviewers describe closing on a house and having J & S start painting within days, sometimes the very next day.

• New homeowners frequently mention Jay accommodating rush timelines between closing and move-in day
• Carpentry and deck staining are offered alongside painting, handled by dedicated crew members like Jose
• The crew cleans up at the end of each work day, a detail noted across many reviews

"We have been home owners in New Rochelle for close to forty years, and have used many different trades people. It is my pleasure to recommend J&S Painting Plus. Their workmanship and attitude was top notch." - Howard M., Google Review

With over 25 years in business serving Westchester County, Pier Painting Services is a one-man-show led by owner Johnny Acosta, who runs every estimate, supervises every job, and often works alongside his crew. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.1% with over 60 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp and 100% recommended on Facebook. Johnny is a Larchmont Chamber of Commerce member, and word-of-mouth referrals between neighbors run through many of the reviews. If you value working directly with the owner on every step of the project, Pier Painting is a great option.

Beyond painting, Johnny handles a variety of handyman tasks, including carpentry, grouting, and even chandelier installation. Several reviewers mention hiring him for one project and quickly adding more work because of how smoothly things went.

• Real estate professionals in the area refer Johnny to their clients regularly, trusting him inside vacant and occupied homes
• Reviewers consistently describe transparent pricing with no surprise charges at the end
• Many customers note they never needed to take time off work because they trusted Johnny to manage everything independently

"In 25 years we have had a lot of contractors in and out of our house and we would rate this as one of our best experiences." - Richard D., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Hartsdale, NY, CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY handles both residential and light commercial work across the area. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 175 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, and hold a Westchester County Home Improvement Contractor License along with EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification. With over 16 years in business as WKM Choice Painting, Inc., they also offer a two-year warranty on all services. If you have a larger home or need coordinated interior and exterior work, CertaPro has the crew size and project management structure to handle it.

A standout detail in their reviews is how many customers describe the daily cleanup routine. Crews cover furniture carefully, protect floors, and leave rooms ready to use at the end of each work day. Customers with children and pets mention this as a deciding factor.

• Multiple project managers, including Tanner, Mitch, and Karina, are mentioned for helping customers plan scope and color selection before work begins
• Crews led by Jose, Ricardo, and Fernando each receive individual praise across separate reviews
• Several reviewers describe hiring CertaPro for emergency or time-sensitive projects with fast turnaround

"Choosing someone to bring our beloved 135-year-old house back to life was initially very intimidating, and we're absolutely delighted that we decided to go with CertaPro." - Charlie Hensley, Google Review

A husband-and-wife favorite among real estate professionals, Five Star Painting of White Plains takes a hands-on approach led by owner Dennis, who is mentioned by name in nearly every review. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.4% with over 95 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating and 94% recommended on Facebook. With over 5 years in business serving Westchester County, they have built strong momentum with consistent recent reviews. If you need fast scheduling and a responsive owner who personally oversees the project, Five Star is worth a call.

Several reviews come from real estate brokers who use Dennis as their go-to referral for clients buying or selling homes. Tight turnarounds between closing and move-in are a common theme, with Dennis accommodating last-minute requests and late-night calls.

• Crew members Sergio, Stive, and Rob are called out individually for quality exterior and interior work
• Wallpaper hanging is offered alongside painting, an uncommon service among competitors

"It was such a great experience working with Dennis and the whole team. He handled our whole new home getting painted between closing and our move in date on a very tight deadline." - Nina Lerman, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Angi, Yelp, Facebook

Quality and workmanship are the most frequently praised aspects of painting contractors serving Hartsdale, NY. Across reviews for the top-rated companies, customers describe results that exceed expectations, particularly when it comes to prep work and finish quality. Paint Track Painting Services receives consistent praise for their surface preparation, including sanding, crack repair, and caulking before any paint goes on. NYCA Contractors, LLC earns similar recognition for their spray-applied cabinet finishes that customers describe as smooth and even. J & S Painting Plus Inc reviewers frequently note clean lines, even coverage, and attention to trim and edges.

Several contractors in the area go beyond basic painting. Pier Painting Services handles carpentry repairs alongside paint work, ensuring damaged wood is replaced rather than just painted over. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY reviewers mention drywall repair and plaster work completed to a high standard before painting begins. Five Star Painting of White Plains also offers wallpaper installation, and customers describe careful, bubble-free results. "Ray and his team did a truly outstanding job repainting the exterior of our home. They also brought in an excellent carpenter to take care of some necessary soffit and fascia repairs, rather than just trying to patch and paint over areas that had suffered water damage." - Ivan Kline, Google Review. "Our kitchen cabinets look amazing! Al and his team were very professional. Throughout the entire process they were very courteous, neat, clean and respectful of our property." - Joe Bonventre, Google Review. "We recently had a truly outstanding experience with Shecki and the paint crew. From start to finish Shecki and his team were incredibly professional, reliable, excellent communicators." - Jordan Marsh, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Scheduling and timeliness rank among the most common themes in reviews for painting contractors near Hartsdale, NY. J & S Painting Plus Inc stands out for accommodating tight move-in timelines, with multiple first-time homebuyers describing Jay and his team starting work within days of closing. Five Star Painting of White Plains earns similar praise, with owner Dennis known for fitting jobs into narrow windows between real estate closings and move-in dates. NYCA Contractors, LLC reviewers note that cabinet refinishing projects are typically completed in under two weeks, with Al coordinating pickup and delivery of doors on schedule.

Paint Track Painting Services customers describe a well-organized process where project manager Jess and estimator Sarah coordinate scheduling and provide updates throughout. Pier Painting Services owner Johnny Acosta earns praise for showing up on time consistently and communicating clearly about daily plans. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY reviewers appreciate that crews arrive on schedule and finish within quoted timelines, with project managers like Tanner setting clear expectations upfront. "Jay was the best and was always there if we had any questions, from start to finish everything went perfect. They got it done in time for us to move in." - Eleanor Keiser, Google Review. "They started well within the date range provided when we hired them, and completed the work in a timely manner." - Ivan Kline, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value and fair pricing come up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Hartsdale, NY. J & S Painting Plus Inc reviewers consistently describe competitive quotes, with several customers noting that Jay's pricing was among the most reasonable after collecting multiple bids. Pier Painting Services earns similar praise, with customers describing transparent estimates and no surprise charges at the end of projects. NYCA Contractors, LLC reviewers note that Al's pricing is straightforward and in line with the quality of work delivered.

Paint Track Painting Services customers appreciate the detailed written estimates that break down costs line by line, and several mention that while not the cheapest option, the quality and professionalism justify the price. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY reviewers describe fair pricing for the scope of work, particularly on larger projects. Five Star Painting of White Plains is described as competitively priced, especially by real estate professionals who compare quotes regularly. "Sheki and his team were fantastic! The work is very high quality. The crew did a very detailed thorough job on our home. Very competitive pricing." - Jay Twyman, Google Review. "The price was fair and the work was excellent. Honestly just a pleasure to work with from estimate through scheduling and completion." - Ephraim Leiderman, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication and professionalism are consistent strengths across the top painting contractors near Hartsdale, NY. NYCA Contractors, LLC owner Al earns praise for being responsive from the initial estimate through project completion, with customers noting he answers texts and calls promptly and explains every step of the process. Paint Track Painting Services reviewers highlight the coordinated communication between owner Ray, project manager Jess, and estimator Sarah, describing a team that keeps homeowners informed without requiring constant check-ins.

CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY stands out for its structured project management approach, with dedicated project managers who conduct walk-throughs and provide updates at each stage. Five Star Painting of White Plains owner Dennis is praised for personal availability, including taking late-night calls and responding quickly to scheduling questions. J & S Painting Plus Inc and Pier Painting Services both receive praise for owner accessibility, with Jay and Johnny described as easy to reach and quick to address any concerns. "From start to finish, Ray and The Paint Track crew were on point. Extremely helpful and knowledgeable." - Michael Tome, Google Review. "Al and his team were extremely communicative from the very beginning about the process, timeline and what they needed us to do to prep." - Tim Reid, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and site care are a frequent topic in reviews for painting contractors serving Hartsdale, NY. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY earns some of the most detailed praise in this area, with reviewers describing furniture covered carefully, floors protected, and daily end-of-day cleanup as standard practice. Customers with children and pets specifically mention this as a key reason for choosing CertaPro. Paint Track Painting Services uses dust-extracting sanders during prep work and reviewers describe job sites left clean each evening.

J & S Painting Plus Inc crew members are praised for cleaning up every night before leaving, a detail multiple reviewers call out. Pier Painting Services customers note that Johnny and his team leave areas well-organized and clean throughout multi-day projects. Five Star Painting of White Plains and NYCA Contractors, LLC both receive similar feedback, with reviewers describing neat, respectful crews who protect surrounding surfaces. "They covered everything and moved things as needed. We are very pleased." - Linda Newman, Google Review. "Natalia noted the job was done well and she immediately rented out the place. Also easy personalities and no attitudes, which is a big plus." - Natalia Gourari, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Several painting contractors near Hartsdale, NY offer services that go well beyond standard interior and exterior painting. Paint Track Painting Services is known for cabinet refinishing, skim coating, and drywall repair, with multiple reviewers describing comprehensive surface preparation that includes crack repair and caulking. NYCA Contractors, LLC specializes in off-site cabinet refinishing using a professional spray process, and also handles general contracting work. Pier Painting Services owner Johnny Acosta takes on carpentry, grouting, bathroom fixture installation, and general handyman tasks alongside painting.

J & S Painting Plus Inc offers deck staining, carpentry, and exterior wood repair through dedicated crew members. CertaPro Painters of Southern Westchester NY handles drywall repair, plaster work, and staining in addition to painting, with EPA RRP certification for safe work on pre-1978 homes. Five Star Painting of White Plains adds wallpaper hanging to their service list, a less common offering in the area. "Johnny just finished replacing water damaged exterior wood panels and bathroom grouting. It was my first time working with him and it was a great experience." - Jodi Smart, Google Review. "Dennis and his team did an amazing job painting several rooms in our house as well as hanging wallpaper in one room." - Denise Garbo, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google