9 Best Painters Near Pleasantville, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Pleasantville, NY have access to some of the most reviewed and consistently rated painting contractors in Westchester County. The companies below were evaluated using the Chooz Painters scoring methodology, which weighs review authenticity, platform consistency, business credentials, and customer engagement quality.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Paint Track Painting Services had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score maintained across a high volume of reviews. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.7%, the highest among painters serving Pleasantville, NY. Based in Briarcliff Manor and operating since 2004, owner Ray Rahni runs a team of full-time W2 employees rather than rotating subcontractors - a detail reviewers mention unprompted. Certifications include PCA, EPA RRP lead-safe, and manufacturer recognition from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe, supported by a 4.6-star rating on Yelp and a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation. The crew handles cabinet refinishing, wallpaper, shingle restoration, plaster repair, and full interior overhauls, often within the same job.

What stands out across the reviews is how many customers describe unexpected situations - burst pipes, surprise wall damage - where Ray and the crew adapted without complaint. Several reviewers also note that Ray conducted personal quality checks after the job was finished.

• Multiple reviews come from customers who used Paint Track for both a primary residence and a rental property, citing consistent results across both.
• The crew has tackled restoration work on historic homes, including an 1880 Victorian exterior, with the same care applied to routine interiors.
• Owner Ray personally checks in during and after jobs, which reviewers cite as a primary reason they return.
• Crew members Sergio, Alberto, John, Jonathan, and Chris are named individually across dozens of reviews - a sign of the W2 employee model's stability.

"Ray and crew were great to work with. Professional, friendly, efficient, quality work. An excellent job on the exterior of our 1880 Victorian home and several interior rooms." - Susannah Johnston, Google Review

For homeowners looking for a family business with deep roots in the region, Pro Painting Plus has been serving the Hudson Valley since 1980 and earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%. Based in Monroe, NY, owner Rob (also known as Bobby) runs a family-operated company that specializes in high-end interior painting and kitchen cabinet spray finishes. Reviews consistently describe Rob conducting thorough walk-throughs during estimates, identifying wall and ceiling issues that customers hadn't noticed. Crew members Dario, Eric, Herbie, and Juan each appear by name in reviews for attentive prep and finish work.

Cabinet spray refinishing is where reviewers tend to be most enthusiastic. The spray technique produces a smooth, factory-like finish that reviewers compare to brand-new cabinetry. Beyond cabinets, the team handles full interior repaints, wallpaper removal, deck staining, and cedar and log home refinishing. If you want a multi-generational family painting company with a specialty in spray-finish cabinet work, Pro Painting Plus is a strong choice.

• Rob personally flags repair needs during the estimate walk-through, identifying issues before work begins.
• Cabinet spray finishes consistently draw comparisons to brand-new results, with multiple reviewers reporting that guests don't believe they're the same cabinets.
• The crew handled added scope on several projects without impacting the original schedule, a pattern noted by multiple reviewers.

"I can't speak any higher of the job well done that Rob and his crew provided. The attention to detail was TOP NOTCH. They were very patient and professional. They moved very quickly through the project and even with additional add ons to our service they didn't break a sweat at all." - bracyml, Google Review

While Pro Painting Plus is especially known for cabinet work, J & S Painting Plus Inc has built its reputation across a wider range of services and a cross-platform presence that's unusual for a regional contractor. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5%, with over 140 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, over 300 reviews on Angi at a 4.9-star rating, and 4.6 stars on Yelp with over 25 reviews. Owner Jay's Port Chester company has been in business for over 24 years and has held BBB accreditation since 2006, earning Angi Super Service Awards from 2009 through 2015. Crew lead Sheki is requested by returning customers across multiple years of reviews.

New homebuyers appear as a distinct customer segment in the J & S review history. Multiple reviewers describe calling Jay the day they closed on a new home and having an entire interior painted before the moving truck arrived. If you need a painting contractor who can move fast on a tight timeline without sacrificing quality, J & S Painting Plus Inc is worth contacting first.

• New homebuyers are a recurring customer type - several reviews describe same-week scheduling to get interiors done before furniture arrived.
• Sheki leads many projects and is specifically requested by returning customers, reflecting consistent crew stability over time.
• The cross-platform footprint on Google, Angi, Yelp, and BBB is broader than most regional painting contractors.

"Jay and his team were fantastic to work with, from start to finish. Super professional, well-organized, plus great work product for a very fair price. We are so happy with all of the rooms they painted." - Caitlin Foran, Google Review

Also serving the Pleasantville, NY area, MGP Painting Inc. earned a Chooz Score of 87.2%, backed by over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi, and 96% recommended on Facebook. Owner Moises has led the Orangeburg-based company for over 13 years since incorporating in Rockland County in 2012. Repeat business runs deep here - customers describe returning for three or four projects over multiple years, and family referrals are common throughout the review history. Crew members Galo, Caesar, and Orlando are each named for edge and trim detail work.

MGP handles a broader service range than many painting contractors, with wallpaper installation in powder rooms and home offices generating specific praise. Reviewers with challenging spaces - high vaulted ceilings, 28-step interiors, wall-mounted TV areas - describe the crew navigating the complexity smoothly. If you want a painting company with a strong Facebook and Angi presence and an owner who stays actively involved in customer communication, MGP Painting Inc. is a good fit.

• Family referrals are common - customers recommend MGP to relatives who then become separate long-term clients.
• Wallpaper installation in tight or decorative spaces is a noted specialty, with Orlando frequently named for precise pattern work.
• Moises personally responds to reviews with project-specific details referencing each customer's location and scope.

"I have worked with Moises and his people for 3 big home painting projects over the last 5 years. They consistently do a professional and reliable job." - Barbara Strauss, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Pier Painting Services. Owner Johnny Acosta has run this Pelham-based company for over 25 years, and the reviews reflect that depth of community trust. Every single one of over 60 Google reviews is a five-star rating - a 5.0-star rating held across the full volume. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.1%, with 5.0 stars on Yelp and 100% recommended on Facebook. Pier is a Larchmont Chamber of Commerce member, and realtors appear in the reviews as both clients and referral sources who send buyers to Johnny after a sale.

Johnny personally handles every estimate and often works alongside his crew on-site. The scope of work extends beyond painting - TV mounting, fixture installation, grouting, and water damage repair all appear in reviews alongside standard jobs. If you want a local Westchester contractor with personal owner involvement and the flexibility to handle small repairs alongside painting work, Pier Painting Services is a strong choice.

• Several reviewers were referred by neighbors and then went on to refer Pier to others in the same neighborhood.
• Realtors use Pier for client listings and recommend Johnny to buyers looking to update before moving in.
• The company regularly handles handyman tasks alongside painting in the same visit, reducing the need for multiple contractors.

"Johnny and his team were fabulous. They painted the exterior of my home and we could not be more happy. Everything worked well, they were on time. Johnny communicated very well about when they would arrive and they cleaned up daily." - Miriam Lori Morrow, Google Review

Rounding out the top painters in Pleasantville, NY, Paintworks & Decorating brings a licensed, insured operation with over 200 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, over 65 Yelp reviews at a 4.7-star rating, and 100% recommended on Facebook. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.1%. Based in Long Island City and operating for over 12 years, the company holds NYC Home Improvement Contractor License No. 2093229-DCA and carries EPA RRP lead-safe and OSHA 30 certifications. Project manager Ryan is named in a large number of reviews for handling quotes, scheduling, and communication throughout each project.

Paintworks' work extends well beyond painting - custom carpentry, tile and grouting, vanity installations, drywall repair, and fire escape refinishing all appear in the review history alongside residential interiors. Commercial clients are present alongside residential ones. If your project involves more than paint - wallpaper, drywall, carpentry, or commercial work - and you want a licensed team with strong project management, Paintworks & Decorating is worth contacting.

• Ryan's consistent presence as project manager across dozens of reviews reflects an organizational structure that customers describe as a key differentiator.
• The team handles fire escapes, metal railings, and commercial spaces alongside standard residential work.
• Several reviewers describe receiving same-day or next-day estimates, with crews arriving shortly after for smaller scopes.

"Paintworks has been my go-to for 5+ years. They are efficient, flexible and professional. I never use anyone else." - Oona Haas, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook, Angi

Quality and craftsmanship are among the most frequently mentioned themes across reviews for painters serving Pleasantville, NY. Reviewers rarely stop at calling the work "good" - they get specific about what they observed, citing prep work, surface finishing, color accuracy, and how results looked weeks or months later.

Paint Track Painting Services draws particular attention to cabinet refinishing quality. Multiple reviewers describe 30-year-old cabinets passing as brand new after the Paint Track team finished. For exterior work, the crew's shingle restoration on older homes comes up across multiple reviews, with homeowners noting they were advised to restore rather than replace. J & S Painting Plus Inc reviewers cite the quality of both painting and carpentry on plaster-wall interiors, noting that Jay's crew handled older home surfaces with care that contractors who specialize in newer construction often don't bring. Pro Painting Plus consistently earns praise for cabinet spray finishes, with reviewers describing results that look factory-produced rather than hand-applied. Pier Painting Services reviews reflect the breadth of Johnny's experience - whether the project is a full-house interior or exterior trim on a complex property, reviewers describe results that hold up well over time.

"We honestly can't thank PaintTrack enough for their help restoring the shingles and front porch of our home. We considered replacing every shingle but after reading these reviews we gave PaintTrack a call for their opinion." - Shane McCarthy, Google Review"Sheki and his team recently painted the interior of our house... The team's craftsmanship was exceptional and you could see their expertise and dedication to their craft. Every step of the painting process was handled with precision." - Kyle Kelly, Google Review"I hired Rob and his team to give my kitchen cabinets a professional paint job... The spray finish they used came out absolutely flawless and my cabinets look like they just came from the factory." - HomeAdvisor Reviewer, Pro Painting Plus"They do quality work and the house looks beautiful! Johnny is also easy to communicate with, which is not true of all contractors." - Lara Nicolau, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Angi

Strong communication is one of the most consistent themes across reviews for painting contractors serving Pleasantville, NY. Reviewers mention responsiveness at the estimate stage, updates during the job, and follow-through on promised schedules as key factors in their satisfaction.

At Paint Track Painting Services, the coordination structure is clearly defined - owner Ray handles project oversight, estimator Sarah manages quotes and scheduling, and project manager Jess provides updates throughout. Reviewers describe receiving prompt responses to questions and proactive communication when anything changed. J & S Painting Plus Inc earns specific praise for owner Jay's responsiveness, with multiple reviewers describing same-day or next-day callbacks and estimates. For new homebuyers who needed fast turnarounds, Jay's communication about timelines was cited as a reason they felt confident moving forward. Paintworks & Decorating reviewers consistently mention project manager Ryan by name as the primary point of contact, describing clear text updates before crew arrivals and organized communication from quote through job completion. Pier Painting Services owner Johnny Acosta is praised for arriving on time, reviewing scope clearly during the estimate, and staying communicative throughout multi-week projects.

"Your project is in great hands with Ray, Sarah and the entire Paint Track team. They were very responsive with all of my projects. I hired them for painting and wallpaper. They are very honest and reliable." - Jennifer Bolnick, Google Review"The Paintworks team was very professional, easy to work with and did a beautiful job on painting and wallpaper installation. They are incredibly responsive and organized. I highly recommend their service." - Court Whisman, Google Review"They are extremely professional and responsive, showing up on time every day and going above and beyond to communicate concerns and to provide helpful suggestions." - Fred Mehlman, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup quality comes up consistently in reviews for painters serving Pleasantville, NY, and it's typically framed as part of the overall professionalism of the crew rather than just a finishing step. Reviewers describe daily cleanup during multi-day projects, careful protection of floors and furniture before work begins, and thorough removal of materials when the job wraps.

Paint Track Painting Services reviewers describe crews arriving with protective coverings for floors and furniture, and cleaning up at the end of each workday on longer projects. Several note being comfortable leaving the crew in their home unsupervised for the day, a level of trust that reflects both cleanliness habits and crew conduct. Pier Painting Services reviews frequently cite daily cleanup during exterior jobs that ran over multiple weeks, with Johnny's team leaving the property organized each evening. MGP Painting Inc. reviewers with newly refinished floors describe the crew taking particular care to protect the surfaces before painting nearby walls - a detail that not all contractors think to address. Pro Painting Plus reviewers highlight the crew's prep habits as a marker of quality, noting that careful wall repair and surface preparation before applying paint reflects standards that show in the finished result.

"Workers were so nice, quiet, clean, thorough and helpful. You can tell that they take pride in their work." - Debra Blaustein, Google Review"His men are careful and leave the area well organized and clean. Recommend without reservation." - Veronica Kurian, Google Review"They seamlessly patched all of the holes in our ceiling and walls and took great care prepping the interior and our newly refinished floors to avoid any damage to them." - Valerie Gruber, Google Review"Herbie and Juan carefully repaired cracks, seams, nail pops, and other wall blemishes. They were hard workers, polite, and professional. The job was completed in segments and each time an area was finished it was left clean." - Cathie Swyka, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Scheduling and timeline reliability are strong points for painting contractors serving Pleasantville, NY. Reviews routinely mention that crews arrived on time, that project schedules were communicated clearly before work began, and that final completion dates aligned with what contractors promised at the estimate stage.

Paint Track Painting Services reviewers describe consistent punctuality across both short and multi-week projects. J & S Painting Plus Inc stands out for fast turnarounds when needed - multiple reviewers, particularly new homebuyers, describe Jay scheduling a crew within days of first contact to meet a move-in deadline. Pro Painting Plus reviews highlight that even when customers added scope mid-project, the crew adapted without missing the original completion date. Pier Painting Services owner Johnny Acosta provides clear timeline estimates at the outset of every project, and reviewers describe him showing up on time each day throughout multi-week exterior jobs. Across these contractors, the pattern suggests that companies serving Pleasantville, NY with the highest Chooz Scores are also the most reliable when it comes to keeping a schedule.

"Always on time, professional and a good value and excellent quality!! Highly recommend." - Jim Semmelman, Google Review"Jay came same day to do a walk through to paint the interior of our house and the price was very reasonable. He was able to get his team here to start work the next morning at 10am!" - Eleanor Keiser, Google Review"Everyone was professional, personal and punctual. Quality painting at a fair price. Highly recommend and will use Pro Painting Plus again for future projects." - Stacey Punch, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing and value come up frequently in reviews for painters serving Pleasantville, NY, and the consistent theme is that customers who paid mid-range to higher-end prices felt the quality justified the cost. Reviewers who collected multiple quotes before choosing one of these contractors frequently describe feeling confident after the job that the decision was right.

J & S Painting Plus Inc earns repeated praise for competitive pricing alongside strong quality - reviewers describe fair estimates and no surprises on the final bill. Pro Painting Plus reviewers who compared quotes before selecting the company tend to note that Rob's pricing was reasonable relative to the level of detail and the quality of finish delivered. Paintworks & Decorating reviews reflect a similar pattern: customers acknowledge paying for quality and describe the result as justifying the cost. Pier Painting Services reviewers mention cost transparency as a specific positive - Johnny provides clear estimates that match the final invoice, which customers cite as a factor in recommending him. One Paint Track reviewer noted that while the company is not the cheapest option in Westchester, the prep work and crew quality make the pricing worthwhile compared to lower-cost alternatives.

"You may be able to find less expensive work elsewhere, but you get what you pay for and the quality work that they deliver is worth every penny." - Lindsey Kerrigan, Google Review"Quality painting at a fair price. Highly recommend and will use Pro Painting Plus again for future projects." - Stacey Punch, Google Review"You usually pay for two of three: quick, quality, cost. The painters satisfied all three after comparing with other crews." - Hide Harashima, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Repeat business is one of the clearest indicators of long-term quality among painting contractors, and the companies serving Pleasantville, NY with the highest Chooz Scores show strong patterns of returning customers. Reviews from repeat clients are common across the top-rated companies, with many explicitly noting they've hired the same contractor two, three, or four times over several years.

J & S Painting Plus Inc has the strongest documented repeat customer base in the review history, with several customers describing their current project as the third, fourth, or even tenth engagement with Jay's team. One reviewer noted hiring J&S to paint his entire home, then returning over 10 years later for the same job - with the original coat still holding up well. Pier Painting Services has customers who have used Johnny Acosta's team for over a decade, calling him back for exterior painting, interior overhauls, cabinet work, and even chandelier installation over the years. MGP Painting Inc. sees family referrals convert into separate long-term client relationships, with owner Moises personally maintaining those connections through his practice of responding to every review. Paintworks & Decorating has customers who have used the company five or more years as their default choice for all painting and home improvement projects.

"This was the 4th time I have hired J&S to paint various rooms in my home. Very reliable, good work and reasonably priced. I will continue to use them for years to come!" - Phil, Google Review"I have used Pier Services multiple times in my home, 3 years ago for exterior painting and earlier this spring for a full-house interior paint job, with kitchen cabinet stripping and repainting and other related repairs." - David Lacher, Google Review"We have worked with Ryan and Ricky on two occasions. They are very responsive both when planning a job and during the process. Their prices are fair and the work good quality." - Jennifer Siegel, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google