8 Best Painters Near Valhalla, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Contractors serving Valhalla, NY draw from a deep pool of Westchester talent - several of the companies on this list have been operating for decades and have expanded their service areas well beyond county lines. Across hundreds of reviews, the themes that come up most often are responsive ownership, detailed prep work, and crews that customers call back for project after project.

C.E.T. Painting leads the rankings with a Chooz Score of 90.9%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 240 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. With 9 years in business, the company holds BBB accreditation since 2022, is 100% recommended on Facebook, and maintains 4.7 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. What stands out reading through the reviews is range: this crew handles co-op buildings with NYC documentation requirements, exterior stucco that hadn’t been painted in nearly a century, deck staining, and drywall repair all at the same level of care. Owner Carlos stays in contact throughout every project and responds promptly when follow-up is needed. If you need a versatile, responsive crew for a multi-phase project, C.E.T. Painting is a strong starting point.

• Navigates NYC co-op and condo painting requirements, with building documentation handled by office staff
• Took on an exterior stucco home that had never been painted in nearly 100 years, managing prep and details carefully
• Touch-up visits after move-ins or drywall repairs are included at no additional charge
• Owner Carlos monitors progress throughout each project and responds to follow-up needs quickly

“Carlos and his team went above and beyond meeting my expectations. I got 4 total quotes and they were the most responsive and professional of them all. Carlos communicated with me each step of the way and even finished ahead of when they were scheduled. When the work was completed, I saw a very minor spot that needed to be touched up so I reached out to Carlos. It was done less than 24 hours later and was perfect.” - Tricia A., Google Review

For homeowners looking to update their kitchen cabinets without the cost of full replacement, Paint Track Painting Services has earned a Chooz Score of 89.7%. At the time of our analysis, they had over 150 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating - remarkable to maintain at that volume. With over 20 years in business since 2004, they hold PCA certification, EPA RRP lead-safe certification, and manufacturer certifications from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe. They also carry 4.6 stars on Yelp and a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation. Project Manager Jess Molina is singled out repeatedly by reviewers for communication and problem-solving. If precision interior work and careful cabinet refinishing are your priorities, Paint Track is worth a call.

• PCA certified with EPA RRP lead-safe certification and manufacturer certs from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe
• Project Manager Jess Molina is praised across reviews for client communication and going above and beyond
• Brought in a carpentry specialist for soffit and fascia repairs rather than painting over water damage
• Addressed a family’s concern about their child’s asthma by minimizing dust throughout the painting process

“Ray and his entire team are phenomenal. We have used them many times - for big and small projects. They are professional, organized, trustworthy and friendly. They are also focused on excellence and detail. We enthusiastically recommend Paint Track!” - Amy G., Google Review

The policy that appears most consistently in Pro Painting Plus reviews is owner Rob McRae’s daily job-site visits - customers note he stops by to check progress and make sure they’re happy throughout the project. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%, with over 75 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. Rob - also called Bobby - has overseen projects on everything from 1865 original tin roofs to cedar-and-teak-and-pine exteriors to epoxy garage floors. Crew members Dario, Eric, Luis, and Miguel are praised by name across reviews. If you’re dealing with a challenging surface or need a crew that can mobilize quickly when a job goes sideways, Pro Painting Plus is a good choice.

• Rob stepped in after another painting company abandoned a job just four days before a client’s scheduled move-in date
• Has tackled a 1865 original tin roof and a complex cedar-teak-pine exterior, both with excellent results
• Crew members Dario, Eric, Luis, and Miguel are praised by name for attention to detail and follow-through
• Also delivers epoxy garage floors - one described as “showroom quality” with the exact color requested

“Always a pleasure to have Rob and Pro Painters Plus on-site. I am always impressed with the prep work - which gives that professional finish. Plus Rob visits the site, reviews the work and has any imperfection corrected. All of the painters were easy to work with, respectful and professional. PPP are my go-to painters. I don’t call anyone else.” - Tracey B., Google Review

With over 24 years in business, J & S Painting Plus Inc has built the kind of track record that spans multiple rounds of homeownership - customers who hired Jay a decade ago are returning for full-house paint jobs, noting the original coat still held up well. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.5%, with over 140 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating and over 300 reviews on Angi at the same rating. They hold BBB accreditation dating back to 2006. Project manager Sheki arrives to estimates with a professional folder containing licenses, insurance certificates, and process documentation. If you’re a new homeowner on a tight timeline or need a reliable crew you can count on year after year, J & S is consistently praised.

• Sheki arrives to estimates with a folder containing licenses, insurance certificates, and process details
• Jay came for a walk-through the same day a homeowner closed on their house and had painters on-site the next morning
• Office staff Pam and Kathie are praised across reviews for prompt communication and consistent follow-through
• The crew was so quiet during a weeklong interior job that the work-from-home reviewer forgot they were in the house

“Shecki stopped at the house frequently to check on the job. He was extremely generous with his time spent answering our questions. Mauricio and his team of painters were hard working, efficient and respectful. The quality of their work is top notch!!” - Jordan M., Google Review

Also serving the Valhalla, NY area from their Rockland County base, MGP Painting Inc. brings over 13 years in business of cross-regional experience spanning Westchester, Bergen County NJ, and Orange County NY. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.2%, with over 200 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Angi with over 10 reviews and 96% recommended on Facebook. Owner Moises Penafiel personally responds to virtually every Google review. One customer hired MGP after noticing the crew’s professional work at a local library - impressed enough to walk in and book them. If you have a complex interior project covering cabinets, drywall, wallpaper, and walls together, MGP handles it all.

• A customer hired MGP directly after seeing the crew working at a local library and being impressed on the spot
• Moises personally remembered a returning customer from a prior job two years earlier
• Office staff Mable, Elena, and Rachel are praised across reviews for organized scheduling and quick communication
• The team corrected a paint store error - wrong sheen delivered - on-site without any additional charge

“Just had my house painted by MGP. I rate this company a 10 plus from the initial estimate through completion. The estimate was on a Thursday, the work was started that Monday! They arrived on time every day. There weren’t any phone calls with excuses of being late or canceling...I just couldn’t be happier.” - Helene C., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Valhalla, NY, Pier Painting Services earned a Chooz Score of 87.1%, with over 60 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating - every single review a five-star. With over 25 years in business, the company holds 5.0 stars on Yelp and is 100% recommended on Facebook. What distinguishes Pier from most painting contractors is scope: owner Johnny Acosta’s team handles carpentry, drywall, chandelier installation, floor refinishing, and general handyman work alongside painting. Neighbor-to-neighbor referrals run throughout the reviews. If you want a dependable all-around contractor who can handle painting alongside maintenance and repairs, Pier Painting Services is worth contacting.

• Johnny went out of his way to help diagnose a window leak unrelated to the painting project, at no additional charge
• Clients specifically hire Pier because they trust the crew to work unsupervised in their homes
• Handles carpentry, chandelier installation, floor refinishing, and TV mounting alongside painting work
• Multiple-project customer Matt Allyn calls Pier “easily the best contractor I’ve worked with in Westchester”

“We had Johnny and his team paint our master bedroom which has incredibly high vaulted ceilings. They did a fantastic job and I was impressed by how they were both very quick AND attention oriented. I would definitely use them again and highly recommend them!” - Amanda L.H., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Reviewers throughout the Valhalla, NY area consistently point to quality that holds up over time, not just on the day the crew packs up. C.E.T. Painting earned praise from one customer who had the exterior of a stucco home painted for the first time in nearly a century - a year later, he noted the house still drew smiles every time he pulled into the driveway. Paint Track Painting Services is cited repeatedly for cabinet work that prompts guests to assume new cabinets were installed entirely - not just refinished. Several reviewers describe asking guests not to touch surfaces because they look so much like factory finishes.

The pattern continues with Pro Painting Plus and J & S Painting Plus Inc. Rob McRae’s crew handles complex exterior work - cedar siding, historic shingles, aged wood surfaces - with a prep-first approach that reviewers say is the difference between good results and results that last. Over at J & S, Jay’s crew has painted homes in such detail-oriented fashion that a commercial realtor described the work as raising the home’s value for listing. Both companies draw out named crew members - Dario and Mauricio in particular - who show up in reviews as craftspeople, not just painters.

• “Carlos and his crew did a great job. They were thorough with the prep work. They took the time to make sure the details came out right. One year on, we still smile when we see the house.” - Michael M., Google Review
• “Their workmanship was so good, all of our friends think we had new cabinets installed. Refinishing our existing 20-year cabinets was a major savings and Paint Track’s pricing was very reasonable and well worth it.” - Roger E., Google Review
• “The care and professionalism exhibited by these workers was exemplary. Everything was done to perfection. My neighbors noticed how thorough they were and couldn’t be more complimentary.” - Lucia A., Google Review
• “The team’s craftsmanship was exceptional and you could see their expertise and dedication to their craft. Every step of the painting process was handled with precision and care.” - Kyle K., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication is one of the most frequently mentioned strengths across reviews for contractors serving Valhalla, NY. MGP Painting Inc. owner Moises Penafiel responds personally to virtually every Google review and is described by reviewers as someone who “communicates clearly, sticks to the projected timeline.” Office staff members Mable, Elena, and Rachel are praised by name for picking up the phone, returning emails quickly, and keeping scheduling organized. Pier Painting Services owner Johnny Acosta draws similar praise - reviewers note he explains what will be done before work begins, provides transparent cost estimates, and goes so far as to come back after a painting job to help diagnose an unrelated window leak.

The office operations at J & S Painting Plus Inc get singled out for a level of documentation that surprises first-time customers: project manager Sheki arrives to estimates carrying a folder with licenses, insurance certificates, and a written description of how the work will be carried out. At C.E.T. Painting, office staff member Debbie handles the administrative coordination for co-op and condo buildings in New York City - including building-specific requirements - freeing up the crew to focus on the job. Paint Track Painting Services project managers Jess and Sarah are described across reviews as present throughout projects, not just at the start and end.

• “From start to finish, the team showcased exceptional communication and professionalism. Carlos, the owner, was prompt, and his crew was efficient. Debbie managed the administrative side flawlessly, ensuring everything ran smoothly with the various requirements for working in NYC’s co-ops/condos.” - Angela F., Google Review
• “Johnny is incredibly organized, knowledgeable, and trustworthy. He’s also just a genuinely great person to work with. We noticed a window leak, and Johnny didn’t hesitate to come over right away.” - Michelle & Jon, Google Review
• “Moises communicates clearly, sticks to the projected timeline and does a great job!” - Sally G., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup discipline shows up as a consistent theme across reviews for painters serving Valhalla, NY. At C.E.T. Painting, reviewers describe the crew cleaning up at the end of each workday and returning the space to its original arrangement when the project is complete - furniture moved back, surfaces wiped down, no evidence of a painting crew having been there. One reviewer who had the crew in her home office specifically noted she was still able to work in a nearby room without any disruption. Pro Painting Plus gets similar praise: Cathie Swyka described crew members Herbie and Juan wiping down floors after each segment of work, and another reviewer noted the crew cleaned, sanded, and protected their refinished floors before the painting began.

Both Pier Painting Services and MGP Painting Inc. draw consistent mentions of cleanup as a strength. Johnny Acosta’s crew at Pier covers the work area thoroughly before starting and cleans up at the end of each day - multiple reviewers note you would barely know the crew had been there. At MGP, the team covered furniture, wrapped fixtures, and removed and replaced wall-mounted TVs as part of their standard prep, then cleaned up so thoroughly on departure that one customer wrote she expected to find at least a paint drip and found none.

• “They did a fantastic job with cleanup. Everything was back in its place.” - Michelle K., Google Review
• “Each time an area was finished, any dust or debris was thoroughly cleaned up including wiping down the floors. Our 45-year-old walls now look like new construction.” - Cathie S., Google Review
• “They were very thorough in prep and cleanup, you would barely know they had been there by the time they left for the day. Amazing value for the service.” - Nick P., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Several reviewers in the Valhalla, NY area describe getting multiple quotes before choosing one of these contractors - and consistently landing on the same conclusion: the price was competitive, and the quality more than justified it. At J & S Painting Plus Inc, Mike Faix put it plainly after having his entire main floor painted: the value went beyond the work itself. Pro Painting Plus earns similar mentions for pricing that customers describe as fair, particularly for the level of service - Rob shows up daily, the crew is named and accountable, and the finished product holds up. Multiple reviewers specifically compare Pro Painting Plus favorably against other quotes they received.

At MGP Painting Inc., pricing comes up as a selling point across dozens of reviews - not because it’s the cheapest, but because the work stands behind the price. A seller who hired MGP to refresh a condo before listing it noted that her real estate agent recommended raising the asking price after seeing the result. C.E.T. Painting is described as “reasonably priced” and “competitively priced” across dozens of reviews, with several customers noting the final bill matched the estimate without hidden additions. Pier Painting Services is described as “fair” by multiple reviewers, with Johnny Acosta known for quoting transparently and sticking to what was agreed.

• “I’d say ‘you get what you pay for’, but with Jay and his team, you get more than what you pay for, a perfect job & peace of mind.” - Mike F., Google Review
• “Quality work, attention to detail, efficient, professional, and courteous. They do a great job at an affordable price.” - Ryan T., Google Review
• “When the real estate agent saw the work they did she suggested we increase our price. The quality of MGP’s work added value to the home.” - Clythie F., Yelp Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

On-time arrival and clear scheduling stand out as strengths across reviews for contractors serving Valhalla, NY. At C.E.T. Painting, Tricia A. got four quotes before choosing Carlos and his crew - and noted that not only did the team communicate at every step, they finished ahead of the original schedule and turned around a touch-up within 24 hours of her follow-up call. Several reviewers emphasize that Carlos commits to a start date and keeps it. At J & S Painting Plus Inc, the scheduling process starts before work even begins: Jay provides a detailed project scope with time estimates, and multiple reviewers describe crews finishing a day or more ahead of the projected end date. New homeowners especially praise Jay’s ability to mobilize quickly.

Pier Painting Services owner Johnny Acosta is described repeatedly as someone who arrives when he says he will and provides a realistic project timeline upfront. One reviewer noted the crew finished three days ahead of schedule while still maintaining quality throughout. At Paint Track Painting Services, the scheduling process includes a detailed written quote and timeline provided before work begins. Job coordinator Jana in the office is praised for handling insurance paperwork and building requirements quickly, keeping project timelines on track even when administrative details need coordination.

• “Carlos communicated with me each step of the way and even finished ahead of when they were scheduled.” - Tricia A., Google Review
• “Luis and his painting crew did high-quality work and were very professional, reliable, and friendly - and even finished ahead of schedule.” - Janet K., Google Review
• “He gives you a time estimate of how long the job will take (finished 3 days early), cleans up at the end of every day and the quality of their work is exceptional.” - Theresa Z., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Repeat business is one of the clearest signals in the reviews for contractors serving the Valhalla, NY area - and it shows up across every company on this list. At C.E.T. Painting, Peter Frankel has worked with Carlos and his team for many years across multiple projects and describes the relationship as one built on consistency: “He never disappoints.” Carlos himself tends to remember returning customers and picks up follow-up jobs with the same approach as the first. At J & S Painting Plus Inc, Len Toscano hired Jay for a full house paint job, came back over a decade later for the same project again, and noted the original coat had “still wore that paint quite well” when it was time for a refresh. Phil hired J & S for the fourth time across different rooms in his home and noted he plans to continue using them “for years to come.”

At Pier Painting Services, the repeat pattern is especially visible. Johnny Acosta has clients who return for painting, then call again for carpentry, then again for water damage repair - building a full maintenance relationship over years. Angela Wilens used Pier for a dining room ceiling repair and repaint, then came back for deck work, and plans to continue. At MGP Painting Inc., Bob Spence describes his entire family as repeat customers “for many years.” Paint Track Painting Services has customers like Amy G. and Ellen S. who have hired the team for multiple properties across several years and continue recommending them to neighbors.

• “We have been working with Carlos for many years and he never disappoints. His work is excellent; professional, prompt, great craftsmanship and always willing to go the extra mile to make certain we are happy.” - Peter F., Google Review
• “This is the second time we selected J&S for our complete house painting. The first time we had them paint the house was over 10 years ago, and it still wore that coat of paint quite well.” - Len T., Google Review
• “This is the 2nd time we’ve used Pier Painting after such a wonderful experience repairing our Dining Room ceiling and then repainting the room. As before, Johnny and his team were a pleasure to work with.” - Angela W., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google