4 Best Painters Near Buchanan, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Buchanan, NY have access to several well-reviewed painting contractors serving the northern Westchester and Rockland County area. Across hundreds of verified reviews, customers highlight reliable scheduling, careful prep work, and crews that treat homes with respect. Here are the top-rated painting companies based on the Chooz Score ranking system.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, C E T Painting had over 240 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 90.9%, the highest among contractors serving Buchanan, NY. They also hold 100% recommended on Facebook, 4.7 stars on Yelp, and are accredited with the Better Business Bureau. Led by owner Carlos Tacuri, C E T Painting has been operating since 2004 with over 20 years in business across Westchester County. What stands out in reviews is how many customers return for project after project, and how often reviewers mention individual crew members like John and Pablo by name. Several commercial clients, including an automotive shop and a historic library, also praise the team for working around active business hours without disruption. If you need a contractor comfortable with both residential and commercial work, C E T Painting is a strong choice.

• Multiple reviewers describe feeling comfortable leaving the crew alone in their homes, a sign of deep trust built over repeat projects
• Several customers note that Carlos personally visits job sites to check on progress, even on smaller projects
• Deck staining and exterior work on older homes, including century-old stucco, are frequent project types in the reviews

"Carlos and his team went above and beyond meeting my expectations. I got 4 total quotes and they were the most responsive and professional of them all." - Tricia Alfini, Google Review

For homeowners specifically looking for cabinet refinishing or work on older plaster walls, Paint Track Painting Services has carved out a strong reputation. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.7% with over 150 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. With over 20 years in business since 2004, they also hold 4.6 stars on Yelp and a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation. Owner Ray runs a team of W2 employees, not subcontractors, and customers frequently mention project manager Jess and coordinator Sarah by name. A recurring theme in the reviews is how many customers report that their older cabinets now look brand new at a fraction of the cost of replacement. They are PCA Certified and hold manufacturer certifications from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe. If you value a structured process with dedicated project management, Paint Track Painting Services is a good fit.

• Repeat customers describe using Paint Track for both interior and exterior work over multiple years, with consistently strong results each time
• Customers with babies and small children specifically praise the team for taking dust and fume precautions during prep work
• Victorian and historic home exteriors appear frequently in reviews, with customers trusting the team on century-old surfaces

"We honestly can't thank PaintTrack enough for their help restoring the shingles and front porch of our home. We considered replacing every shingle but they convinced us to restore instead, saving us thousands." - Shane McCarthy, Google Review

With a perfect 5.0-star rating across over 75 Google reviews, Pro Painting Plus earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%. Owner Rob McRae personally handles every estimate and checks in on job sites daily, a pattern noted by dozens of reviewers. What comes through most clearly in reviews is the range of surfaces Rob's teams handle confidently, from tin roofs dating back to 1865 to Brazilian hardwood decks to cedar shingle siding. Customers who had bad experiences with previous contractors frequently describe Rob's team as the one that finally got the job done right. If you have a unique material or a project another painter turned down, Pro Painting Plus is worth calling.

• Named crew members like Bobby, Dario, Herbie, and Luis appear across independent reviews, indicating a stable in-house team
• Several reviewers describe Rob responding within hours and starting work within days of the estimate

"Rob told me he would make my house beautiful, but I could never believe what they have done with my cedar house and different woods cedar, teak and pine. I can not believe this is the same house." - Mike Jergensen, Google Review

With over 24 years in business, J & S Painting Plus Inc brings one of the longest track records in the area. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5% with over 140 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, plus over 300 reviews on Angi at a 4.9-star rating and 4.6 stars on Yelp. They are accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2006. Owner Jay and project lead Sheki coordinate a team that first-time homebuyers consistently praise for making the process simple. Multiple reviewers describe Jay arriving same-day for estimates after a closing, then getting crews in within days to paint before the moving truck arrives. If you are on a tight timeline with a new home purchase, J & S Painting Plus Inc handles that well.

• A real estate professional in the reviews describes recommending Jay to all of her clients based on years of consistent results
• Several customers note that Sheki brings a folder with licenses, insurance certificates, and a written scope of work to the first meeting
• Exterior projects on stucco, wood trim, and siding are among the most common job types described

"We were first time homebuyers not knowing what we were doing and Jay got a team in to paint our house with a few days notice to get it painted before the moving truck came." - Matthew Conway, Google Review

Also serving the Buchanan, NY area, MGP Painting Inc. earned a Chooz Score of 87.2% with over 200 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating. They are 96% recommended on Facebook and hold 5.0 stars on Angi. With over 13 years in business, owner Moises has built a following across Rockland County and beyond. What stands out in the reviews is the variety of work his team handles, from standard interior painting to wallpaper installation, deck staining, and even specialized finishes like black matte spray paint for offices. One customer hired MGP after noticing them painting her local library and being impressed by the crew's professionalism. If you want a company that can handle both standard and specialty finishes, MGP Painting Inc. is a solid option.

• Reviewers frequently mention Moises personally visiting job sites multiple times during a project to check quality
• Several customers describe challenging spaces, including popcorn ceilings, multi-level staircases, and high vaulted rooms, handled without issue
• Wallpaper installation, including patterned wallpaper, receives specific praise from multiple customers

"They arrived within a week of my signing our very fairly priced contract. They were neat, clean, helpful, efficient and most professional." - Gerard Scanlan, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Buchanan, NY, Pier Painting Services earned a Chooz Score of 87.1% with over 60 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. They also hold 5.0 stars on Yelp and are 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Johnny Acosta has been serving Westchester County for over 25 years and personally runs every estimate, supervises every job, and often works alongside his crew. The pattern that appears most often in Pier Painting reviews is neighbor-to-neighbor referrals, with customers hiring Johnny after a friend or realtor recommended him. Beyond painting, Johnny also handles handyman work, carpentry, and small repairs, making him a good choice if you have a mix of projects to knock out at once.

• A local realtor describes recommending Johnny to all of her clients after one successful project
• Multiple customers mention not needing to take time off work to supervise because they trusted Johnny completely

"In 25 years we have had a lot of contractors in and out of our house and we would rate this as one of our best experiences." - Richard Davidson, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Customers across Buchanan, NY area painters consistently describe finished results that exceed their expectations. Whether it is interior repainting, exterior restoration, or cabinet refinishing, reviewers call out clean lines, even coverage, and careful attention to edges and trim. Several companies stand out for specific types of quality work. Paint Track Painting Services receives frequent praise for cabinet finishes that guests mistake for brand new installations, with one customer noting his kitchen cabinets look better than when they were factory-finished. C E T Painting earns praise for work on challenging surfaces, including a 100-year-old stucco exterior and historic library interiors. Pro Painting Plus gets highlighted for handling unusual materials like Brazilian hardwood, cedar, and teak with confidence.

J & S Painting Plus Inc reviewers describe detailed prep work and stucco repairs done before any paint goes on. "Sheki and his team were fantastic! The work is very high quality. The crew did a very detailed thorough job on our home." - Jay Twyman, Google Review. MGP Painting Inc. customers praise the team for tackling complex layouts with ease. "Our place was a tough job. We have popcorn ceilings, 28 steps with multiple levels, high ceilings with recessed lights and fans in several rooms. They handled everything beautifully." - Helene Clemenza, Google Review. Pier Painting Services gets recognized for trim and detail work, with one reviewer noting that every chip and ding was carefully addressed. "Johnny and his crew did a fantastic job painting our doors, baseboards, and trim. Great communication, smart suggestions, and impressive attention to detail." - Anne Todd, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

Communication and professionalism are among the most praised qualities across painting contractors serving Buchanan, NY. Customers repeatedly describe owners who personally handle estimates, respond quickly to calls and texts, and keep homeowners informed throughout the project. Pro Painting Plus owner Rob McRae draws particular praise for his responsiveness, with multiple reviewers describing same-day estimate visits and daily check-ins during the project. "From my first interaction with Rob through completion of the job, everyone was professional, personal and punctual." - Stacey Punch, Google Review. J & S Painting Plus Inc owner Jay is described by customers as straightforward and easy to work with, and project lead Sheki arrives to initial meetings with a folder of licenses, insurance certificates, and a detailed scope of work.

At Paint Track Painting Services, the combination of owner Ray, project manager Jess, and coordinator Sarah creates a structured communication pipeline that reviewers praise for keeping projects organized. "Jess went above and beyond, starting from our first engagement through project completion to ensure we were happy." - Laura Chirite, Google Review. MGP Painting Inc. owner Moises earns praise for providing detailed written proposals before work begins and personally following up during projects. Pier Painting Services owner Johnny Acosta handles everything from estimates to on-site supervision himself, with one customer noting she did not need to take time off work because she trusted Johnny to handle everything. "Costs were transparent, quote was respected. We are very happy with the result." - Veronique Vandegans, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

Pricing comes up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Buchanan, NY, and the overwhelming pattern is that customers find the rates fair and competitive. Many reviewers describe getting multiple quotes before choosing their painter, and several companies consistently come in as the most reasonable option. J & S Painting Plus Inc draws frequent mentions of competitive pricing paired with quality work. "Not only were they the best priced, the finished areas look better than we could have hoped." - Matthew Stephan, Google Review. MGP Painting Inc. customers consistently describe fair estimates with no surprises, and owner Moises provides detailed, itemized proposals so homeowners know exactly what they are paying for.

Pro Painting Plus reviewers note that owner Rob's pricing is straightforward and reasonable, especially for specialty work like deck restoration and cabinet refinishing. "Multiple ceilings and 2 rooms were painted and repaired to perfection. Incredible work. Also very fair pricing." - Lyn Nelson, Google Review. Pier Painting Services owner Johnny Acosta is described as transparent with costs, and several reviewers note that the final price matched the original quote. C E T Painting customers mention getting quotes that are competitive relative to the Westchester market, with accurate estimates and no hidden charges. Across the board, customers report that the value they receive, clean work, thorough prep, and professional crews, matches or exceeds what they pay.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

Timeliness is a consistent strength among painting contractors serving Buchanan, NY. Reviewers frequently mention crews arriving on time, sticking to projected timelines, and in some cases finishing ahead of schedule. C E T Painting customers describe crews that show up when promised and complete work within the estimated timeframe, even on large exterior projects. "On time, start and finish date as expected, set up and clean up great, professional." - Dorothy Salierno, Google Review. J & S Painting Plus Inc is praised for accommodating tight timelines, particularly for new homeowners who need painting done before moving day.

Pro Painting Plus owner Rob earned praise from a customer who needed a four-bedroom house painted in 48 to 72 hours and the crew delivered. "I asked Bobby if he and his crew could get it done. And when I arrived, he and his team had it looking beautiful." - Rob Capp, Google Review. Paint Track Painting Services reviewers describe a structured scheduling process managed by project coordinator Jess, and MGP Painting Inc. customers note that crews arrive within a week of signing a contract. Pier Painting Services owner Johnny is described as punctual and reliable, with customers noting he arrives on time for both estimates and project work.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi

Cleanup and property protection are among the most frequently praised aspects of painting contractors in the Buchanan, NY area. Customers across multiple companies describe crews that cover furniture and floors before starting, clean up at the end of each day, and leave homes looking better than they found them. Aquinas Painting Contractors, which earned a Chooz Score of 86.3% with over 80 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and nearly 40 years in business, is particularly well known for this. "They were thorough, clean, quiet and respectful of our belongings." - Sean McGowan, Google Review. Multiple Aquinas reviewers describe furniture returned to its original placement after the job.

Paint Track Painting Services customers praise the crew for using dust-extracting sanders that minimize mess, and families with young children specifically note that the team takes extra precautions. C E T Painting reviewers describe daily cleanup routines, with one customer noting everything was back in its place when the team finished. MGP Painting Inc. customers mention crews that protect surrounding areas carefully before starting work. "Proper preparation was done and surrounding areas protected." - Dave M, Google Review. Pier Painting Services reviewers describe crews that cover interiors with plastic sheeting for drywall and painting projects, and Pro Painting Plus customers note that the team takes care to keep the rest of the home clean while working in specific rooms.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

One of the clearest patterns across painting contractors serving Buchanan, NY is customer loyalty. Several companies have reviewers who come back for their second, third, or even tenth project over many years. Aquinas Painting Contractors has one of the longest track records here, with a customer who has used them for over 20 years, starting with founder Jim Dugandzic and continuing with current partner Alex Solis. "I have been using Aquinas for years. Always prompt and professional!" - Meg McCluskey, Google Review. Bryan Pro Painting, which earned a Chooz Score of 85.2% with over 60 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating and Santiago's over 20 years of painting experience, has a reviewer who has used them for over a decade and a local professional who refers Santiago to all of her clients.

J & S Painting Plus Inc reviewers describe coming back after 10 years for a second full-house paint job, and Pier Painting Services has customers who have relied on Johnny for over 10 years across multiple project types. "I've hired Pier for several painting and carpentry projects around our old house and keep going back to them because they're responsive, always show up when they say they will, take pride in their work, and charge reasonable fees." - Matt Allyn, Google Review. MGP Painting Inc. owner Moises earns loyalty through personal touches, with one returning customer noting that Moises remembered her from a project two years earlier. C E T Painting and Paint Track Painting Services both show similar patterns, with reviewers describing multiple projects spanning years and plans to use them again.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp