Homeowners searching for painting contractors near Montrose, NY have access to some of the most consistently reviewed crews in the Hudson Valley region. Across hundreds of customer reviews, a few priorities come up again and again: careful prep work, clear pricing with no surprises, and crews that arrive when they say they will and clean up every day. Here are the top-rated painters serving Montrose, NY as ranked by Chooz Painters.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, C.E.T. Painting had over 240 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and earned a Chooz Score of 90.9%. Based in Elmsford, the company holds both a NYC Home Improvement Contractor License (No. 2114838-DCA) and Westchester County License No. WC-29252-H16. Carlos and his crew are BBB accredited since 2022, 100% recommended on Facebook, and hold 4.7 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi. Reading through the reviews, a few patterns stand out beyond routine praise. Homeowners preparing a property for sale have called C.E.T. specifically when under tight timelines - one customer had a full house painted in just 4 days, ahead of the crew's own projected schedule. The scope of work regularly extends well past paint: deck boards, trim carpentry, drywall repair, hardie board siding, and sheetrock replacement all appear throughout the review history. If you have a multi-trade job or an older home with condition issues to address before painting, C.E.T. Painting is a strong choice.
- Several reviewers describe seeing C.E.T. crews working on a neighbor's property and reaching out based on that in-person observation - the team's visible professionalism on the street generates its own referrals.
- Historic and architecturally complex properties appear frequently in the portfolio, including a 100-year-old stucco exterior, cedar-and-teak homes with multiple wood types, and a commercial library interior painted during regular operating hours with minimal disruption to patrons.
- Customers who needed to work from home during painting jobs report that the crews operate quietly and cleanly enough that they stayed productive in adjacent rooms throughout multi-day projects.
- Carlos and his team routinely provide itemized, detailed estimates and respond to mid-project questions and schedule changes the same day they are raised.
"I cannot say enough great things about Carlos and his team. They came to update my home office space. Punctual, polite, neat, professional are just a few words that describe my experience. The bonus - I was still able to work in a nearby room without disruption." - Joey K., Google Review
For homeowners considering a kitchen update without the cost of full replacement, Paint Track Painting Services has earned a reputation across Westchester County for cabinet refinishing results that leave guests guessing whether the units are brand-new. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.7% with over 150 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and hold 4.6 stars on Yelp along with a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation. Owner Ray Rahni has been in business for over 20 years, holds PCA Certification, EPA RRP lead-safe certification, and manufacturer certifications from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe. If finish quality and thorough surface preparation are your top priorities, Paint Track Painting Services is a good fit.
One detail that stood out in the review history: several families with young children specifically noted the crew's handling of dust and air quality during surface preparation. Paint Track uses dust-extracting equipment, and at least one reviewer had their toddler tested after the project and reported clean results. Project Manager Jess Molina and team members Sarah and Alberto are named almost as frequently as Ray himself - reflecting a structured team operation rather than a one-person shop.
- Cabinet refinishing results are consistently described as indistinguishable from new - multiple customers note that houseguests assumed the cabinets had been fully replaced, sometimes at a quarter of the cost of buying new units.
- The company regularly works on older homes with plaster walls, Victorian-era architecture, and buildings with co-op requirements that affect what materials and methods can be used.
- Customers frequently hire Paint Track for a second or third project after the first experience, with the scope expanding from interior painting to deck restoration, exterior repaints, wallpaper installation, and stain work.
"Ray and his entire team are phenomenal. We have used them many times - for big and small projects. They are professional, organized, trustworthy and friendly. They are also focused on excellence and detail. We enthusiastically recommend Paint Track!" - Amy G., Google Review
Owner Robert McRae runs Pro Painting Plus as a hands-on operation where he personally visits every job site and checks in throughout the project - a habit his customers notice and frequently mention. The company earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%. The range of work in their reviews is notably broad: a historic church shingle exterior, a 52-year-old lake dock, a home with an original tin roof dating to 1865, full-cedar exteriors, and kitchen cabinets that customers report looking just as sharp six months after completion. If you have an unusual or challenging property that other contractors have turned down, Pro Painting Plus is worth calling first.
A pattern worth noting from the reviews: Pro Painting Plus has been called in multiple times to finish or correct work left incomplete by another contractor. Rob has arrived within an hour of the first call to assess and begin in at least one documented case. Named crew members including Herbie, Juan, Dario, Oscar, Luis, and Miguel appear across reviews, and customers consistently describe each worker as punctual, efficient, and thorough at end-of-day cleanup.
- Unusual and challenging jobs appear throughout the portfolio - steep tin roofs, lakeside docks, full-cedar and multi-wood exteriors with teak, pine, and cedar all handled in the same project.
- Several customers hired Pro Painting Plus specifically because another contractor had abandoned or poorly completed a job; Rob has mobilized his crew within hours of receiving those calls.
- Cabinet refinishing results hold well over time - one customer described being just as impressed six months after the project as on the day it was finished.
"Another painting company left us high and dry 4 days prior to our move into our new home. Rob showed up one hour after my phone call and mapped out the entire job for us. Paint was ordered hours later and work began the next morning." - R.M., Google Review
Also serving the Montrose, NY area, MGP Painting Inc. has built a cross-county reputation stretching from Rockland County into Bergen County, NJ, and Northern New Jersey. At the time of our analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating and earned a Chooz Score of 87.2%. With over 13 years in business since incorporating in 2012, their cross-platform standing includes 5.0 stars on Angi and 96% recommended on Facebook. If you want a contractor with documented multi-platform credibility and an owner who stays in close contact from estimate through final walkthrough, MGP Painting Inc. is a reliable choice.
Several observations from the reviews stand out. A local homeowner first noticed MGP crews painting her neighborhood library and hired them based on what she saw in person. Commercial and institutional jobs - including a hair salon and library interior - appear alongside standard residential work, and the same level of care appears in reviews for both. Owner Moises Gallegos has been noted by at least one customer for proactively suggesting a scope change that saved over $2,000 on the project.
- Beyond home interiors, MGP has completed commercial projects including library interiors and salon spaces, applying the same process and standards as residential work.
- Moises personally responds to virtually every Google review with individualized messages; customers who return after years note that he remembered their previous project details when they called back.
- Written proposals are described as detailed and itemized - multiple customers mention that MGP's estimate level of detail was a key reason they chose the company over competitors.
- Several reviewers mention seeing MGP crews at work in a nearby space - a library, a neighbor's home, or a local property - and hiring them based purely on that observation.
"Absolutely fantastic. Our gutters and siding look brand new. We highly recommend MGP Painting. Will be using them Spring 2026 for our house and pool decks and patio. Can't go wrong. Professional and thorough." - Donna M., Google Review
With over 25 years in business, Pier Painting Services has built the kind of community trust that only comes from consistent delivery across years of work. Owner Johnny Acosta earned a Chooz Score of 87.1% with over 60 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating - every review a five-star. Their multi-platform standing includes 5.0 stars on Yelp and 100% recommended on Facebook. For homeowners looking for an experienced local contractor who handles painting alongside repairs, carpentry, and light handyman work in a single visit, Pier Painting Services covers it all.
Real estate agents in Westchester have used Pier Painting Services to prepare listings for the spring market - a sign of confidence in both quality and reliability under deadline pressure. Johnny frequently identifies additional repairs during a project and addresses them on the spot, and multiple homeowners describe leaving the property while his crew is on site with complete confidence in the team.
- Real estate agents recommend and use Pier Painting to prepare homes for the market, reflecting trust in the crew's ability to meet tight listing deadlines.
- Johnny regularly identifies and addresses additional items during a project visit - turning a single painting call into a full maintenance session covering carpentry, fixtures, and repairs.
- Mid-project add-ons and changes are handled without pushback - customers regularly describe requesting additional items after work had already begun.
- Multiple homeowners describe leaving the property for the day while the Pier crew was on site, comfortable enough not to supervise or check in.
"Working with Johnny means I don't have to worry. I retained Johnny to perform maintenance on my house. I did not have to take off work to micromanage him, which was such a relief." - Jennifer C., Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors serving Montrose, NY, Aquinas Painting Contractors brings nearly 40 years in business - founded in 1987 - to every project. At the time of our analysis, they had over 80 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and earned a Chooz Score of 86.3%. Their cross-platform standing includes 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi, and all painters carry OSHA certification. For homeowners who need a contractor with the experience and crew size to handle large or complex projects, Aquinas Painting Contractors is worth contacting.
The range of work in their reviews goes well beyond standard residential painting. Aquinas has completed projects in condominiums, convents, warehouses, and pool decks. Partner Alex Solis continues the business originally founded by Jim Dugandzic, and long-term customers who have used Aquinas for over 20 years describe the quality and process as consistent across both owners. When a delivery company damaged a homeowner's walls and archway during an appliance delivery, Alex and his crew handled the repair so cleanly that the homeowner described the result as if the damage never happened.
- Beyond residential work, Aquinas has completed institutional projects including convent exteriors, condo associations, and a warehouse converted to a commercial workspace.
- For demanding prep scenarios - surfaces with decades of accumulated paint, water-damaged ceilings, and complex patch work - the crew handles structural repairs alongside the painting.
- Before beginning one project, Alex and his team visited the property multiple times just to help the homeowner finalize a paint color selection - no pressure and no additional charge.
- Post-project touch-up visits happen without pushback - customers note that if something didn't look right after the crew left, a return visit was arranged quickly.
"They are the best painters I have ever worked with. So professional, reliable and immaculate. The work is outstanding. I wish I could do ten stars." - Robert E., Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook
