6 Best Painters Near Pelham Manor, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painters serving Pelham Manor, NY represent some of the strongest-reviewed contractors in Westchester County. From whole-house repaints and exterior painting to deck staining, cabinet refinishing, and garage floor coatings, the contractors below have built durable reputations across Google, Yelp, Facebook, and Angi. Here are the top-rated painters on Chooz Painters for the area, ranked by Chooz Score.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, C.E.T. Painting had over 240 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and a Chooz Score of 90.9% - the highest in the Pelham Manor, NY area. They are 100% recommended on Facebook, hold 4.7 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi, and carry an active Westchester County contractor's license on file. Owner Carlos runs a team that handles interior and exterior painting, deck staining, carpentry repairs, drywall, and siding. What stands out when reading through their reviews is the volume of repeat customers who return for a third, fourth, or even seventh project - often within the same year.

Reviewers describe Carlos as reachable and responsive, estimates as detailed and accurate, and crews as working cleanly from first day to last. Homeowner Amit Rajani had the entire interior prepped, repaired, and finished in just four days for a staging deadline. Commercial client Jim DiMauro noted the crew painted a historic library section during regular business hours without disrupting patrons. If you need a versatile crew that communicates well and stays on deadline across a wide range of project types, C.E.T. Painting is a good choice.

• Deck restoration reviews describe power washing, board replacement, staining Brazilian hardwood, and replacing rotted spindles - not just surface painting
• Commercial and residential clients describe the same experience: on-time starts, clean daily wrap-ups, and no hidden costs at completion
• Several reviewers came to C.E.T. from other painters and called out the difference in cleanliness, communication, and edge quality

"From start to finish, the team showcased exceptional communication and professionalism. Carlos, the owner, was prompt, and his crew was efficient, ensuring that all site preparations were handled thoroughly." - Angela F., Google Review

With over a century in business, A.G. Williams Painting Company brings the kind of institutional knowledge and community trust that most painting companies never see. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.1% with over 280 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, 96% recommended on Facebook, and 4.9 stars on Angi across over 80 reviews. A Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in 2022 and 2023, they are deeply woven into the Westchester County community. Multiple reviewers describe returning for their fifth, sixth, or even eighth project.

Their scope goes well beyond standard painting. Reviews describe custom garage floor coatings, wallpaper installation, exterior carpentry, entry door refinishing, and detailed floor preparation for hardwood installations. Named crew members - including Ezequiel, Hugo, Jorge, Gabriel, Luis, and Pedro - are called out across dozens of reviews. Sales representatives Anthony Conklin, Jim, and Carey get consistent praise for thorough, itemized proposals. A.G. Williams Painting Company is a good fit for homeowners who want a full-service team with deep Westchester roots and a broad range of capabilities.

• Garage floor coating reviews frequently mention the 15-year guarantee and compare finished floors to a showroom
• Wallpaper installation praised by more than one reviewer as far exceeding quality they had received from prior vendors
• A rare negative review raised concerns about project manager inconsistency - confirm upfront who manages day-to-day and how warranty claims are handled

"Outstanding, professional, beautiful paint job by Pedro, Marco and Pablo! My new hardwood floors were covered with paper and drop cloths perfectly and the team was sincerely a pleasure to work with." - Vanessa C., Google Review

For homeowners who prefer the structure and accountability of a larger organization, CertaPro Painters of Westchester NY and Southern CT operates with a layered project management system that many homeowners find reassuring. They earned a Chooz Score of 88.4% with over 500 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating. They are 94% recommended on Facebook and hold a 4.7 rating on Angi. With over 27 years in business, they serve Westchester, Putnam, and Dutchess counties as well as Southern Connecticut.

Dedicated account managers Kevin Ponce and Frank Benedetto, alongside Production Manager Jai LaPorte, stay engaged from estimate through final walk-through. Color consultants come to your home during the estimate phase - multiple reviewers cite this as a stress-reducer for color selection. One customer, Barbara Policastro, called the office two years after her project to ask about the paint color used and received a return call within half an hour. CertaPro Painters of Westchester is a good fit for larger projects that benefit from structured oversight and a named point of contact for every phase.

• Services extend to garage floor coating, kitchen cabinet refinishing, wallpaper removal and installation, and power washing alongside interior and exterior painting
• Scheduling flexibility noted by multiple reviewers - one had the crew delayed a week at her request, then received a larger team to finish on schedule

"Truly a 5-star experience from beginning to end. Kevin, our project manager, was incredible - organized, responsive, and proactive every step of the way." - Sharareh N., Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for J & S Painting Plus Inc. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5% with over 140 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau since 2006. With over 24 years in business and over 300 reviews on Angi at a 4.9-star rating, plus 4.6 stars on Yelp with over 25 reviews, they hold a strong cross-platform record. Owner Jay Gisonni and project manager Sheki are the two most frequently named individuals - both described as attentive, communicative, and present on-site throughout each project.

The office team - Pam and Kathie - gets consistent praise for prompt responses and clear scheduling communication. When Sheki arrives for an estimate, he brings a folder with licenses, insurance certificates, and a project summary already prepared. For new homeowners with urgent timelines, J & S has mobilized within 24-48 hours of a closing on multiple occasions. J & S Painting Plus Inc is a good choice for homeowners who want hands-on owner presence, clear communication from office to crew, and a proven multi-decade track record.

• Multiple first-time homebuyer reviews praise the crew for explaining the process and guiding color decisions without pressure
• Jay personally assists with paint color selection and is described as patient while homeowners work through choices
• Projects are consistently completed at or under the original estimate with no surprise charges at completion
• New homeowners with urgent move-in timelines appear frequently in reviews - the crew has mobilized within days of closing on several occasions

"From start to finish, Shecki and his team were incredibly professional, reliable, and excellent communicators, and their price was more than competitive." - Jordan M., Google Review

A husband-and-wife operation, Azul Painting Corp rounds out the top contractors in the Pelham Manor, NY area. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.2% with over 60 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating and 5.0 stars on Angi across over 25 reviews. Accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2020, co-owners Cinthya Aguilar and Mainor A. Barrantes have built Azul in just 6 years into a company serving residential, commercial, and community properties across Westchester and Fairfield Counties.

Cinthya handles estimates, color consultation, and client communication - she is mentioned by name in the overwhelming majority of reviews. Mainor works on-site alongside the crew and conducts quality checks throughout each project. One detail from a reviewer stands out: the final invoice came in lower than the original estimate because the project scope was slightly smaller than anticipated, and the company adjusted the bill without prompting. Azul Painting Corp is a good choice for homeowners who want owner-level attention on every project and appreciate a family-run business with commercial-grade professionalism.

• Services extend to wallpaper installation, powder room tiling, and flooring work in addition to interior and exterior painting
• Commercial and community clients - including multifamily buildings and a church - have returned for large-scale repeat projects

"I have NEVER, in all of my years renting and owning homes, encountered a better painting company than Azul! They couple the warmth and individualized attention of a family run business with expert skill and professionalism." - Leticia W., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook, Angi

Painting quality and workmanship are the most consistently praised qualities across all five contractors serving the Pelham Manor, NY area. At C.E.T. Painting, customers describe edge work as precise and note the crew's willingness to tackle unusual challenges - like blending a new vaulted cedar ceiling stain to match an older section of the same house. At A.G. Williams Painting Company, prep work is frequently called out as unusually thorough: Hugo and Jorge's kitchen cabinet refinishing received praise for "amazingly detailed" preparation, and the crew's work on a weathered oak entry door - filling, sanding, and painting a surface that had been gray and peeling for years - was described as nothing short of "masterful."

For larger-scope projects, CertaPro Painters of Westchester NY and Southern CT draws consistent praise for attention to detail across multi-room, multi-surface assignments - one reviewer described the crew as refusing to leave a single spot until it was perfectly done. J & S Painting Plus Inc reviewers mention that Sheki and Jay address any quality concern the same afternoon it is raised, sometimes returning to touch up a minor area within hours of a call. At Azul Painting Corp, reviews describe quality work on difficult surfaces including cedar shingles, old stucco, and decorative trim, with Cinthya personally conducting quality walk-throughs throughout each project.

"Their workmanship is excellent. Cinthya and her husband won't leave a job until we were 100% satisfied." - Anthony F., Google Review (Azul Painting Corp)"John and his painters did a wonderful job. They came when they said they would and on time." - Garrett O., Google Review (C.E.T. Painting)"The floor in my garage was transformed from boring to beautiful." - Catherine D., Google Review (A.G. Williams Painting Company)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi

Communication and project management stand out across reviews for painting contractors serving Pelham Manor, NY. At C.E.T. Painting, multiple reviewers describe Carlos as reachable throughout each job and note that touch-up requests are addressed within 24 hours. One homeowner asked for a minor spot fix after completion and had it done the following day. A.G. Williams Painting Company uses a team of sales representatives and a dedicated scheduler to manage project flow, with Liane consistently praised for responsive billing and scheduling communication. Several reviewers note receiving a daily briefing from the crew lead on what was done and what would happen the next morning.

CertaPro Painters of Westchester NY and Southern CT brings a layered contact system: reviewers describe receiving an introductory message naming the full crew before work began, knowing who to call for any concern, and having production manager Jai LaPorte handle follow-up warranty visits personally. J & S Painting Plus Inc gets consistent praise for its office team (Pam and Kathie), and Sheki arrives for estimates with a folder containing licenses, insurance certificates, and a project summary already prepared. Azul Painting Corp's co-owner Cinthya is described as transparent about timelines, changes, and billing - proactively adjusting one invoice downward when the scope came in smaller than estimated, without the customer asking.

"Every time I had a question, Jose took the time to answer thoroughly and made sure I felt comfortable with the process." - John S., Google Review (J & S Painting Plus Inc)"Cinthya is very responsive and transparent. She replied to all communication in a timely manner throughout the entire project." - Brendan N., Google Review (Azul Painting Corp)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook

Timeliness and scheduling reliability are among the most frequently praised qualities across painting contractors serving Pelham Manor, NY. C.E.T. Painting reviewers consistently note the crew arrives when scheduled and finishes within the projected window - one homeowner had the entire interior prepped, repaired, and painted in four days, faster than the original estimate. At A.G. Williams Painting Company, multiple reviews describe the team arriving on time every morning throughout multi-day projects, and larger crews are occasionally sent to recover a delayed start without missing the agreed completion date.

CertaPro Painters of Westchester NY and Southern CT has accommodated scheduling changes at customers' requests - one homeowner delayed the start date by a full week, and CertaPro sent a larger crew to finish on the originally promised date. J & S Painting Plus Inc is specifically sought out by new homeowners with urgent move-in timelines: one reviewer had the full interior finished within four days of closing, and another noted the crew was waiting at the door at 7:55 a.m. when the agreed start time was 8:00. At Azul Painting Corp, reviewers describe early daily starts, consistent progress updates, and project completions that matched or beat projected dates, even when working around rain and busy homeowner schedules.

"Not only were they the best priced, they finished a day earlier than originally quoted. When they said they would be there at 8:00am, they were waiting at 7:55am!" - Matthew S., Yelp Review (J & S Painting Plus Inc)"They were always on time and willing to work around the rainy weather and our busy schedule." - Zareen K., Google Review (Azul Painting Corp)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook

Prep work and daily cleanup are recurring themes in reviews across all five contractors serving Pelham Manor, NY. At C.E.T. Painting, reviewers note that furniture is moved and protected before work begins, dust is contained to the work area, and rooms are left clean at the end of each shift. One reviewer specifically described sanding being completed in a way that kept dust out of adjacent rooms. At A.G. Williams Painting Company, fresh drop cloths over hardwood floors, daily vacuuming, and rooms left looking finished rather than mid-project are themes that appear across multiple reviews. Hugo and Jorge's kitchen cabinet refinishing was praised for preparation work described as "amazingly detailed."

CertaPro Painters of Westchester NY and Southern CT receives praise for pre-paint work that extends to the structural: one exterior project involved addressing bee nests, cracked shingles, and rotted trim before any paint was applied. J & S Painting Plus Inc reviewers describe in-progress cleanliness as remarkable - one noted that the "only indication that work was being done was the wall itself" when the painter wrapped for the day. At Azul Painting Corp, reviewers describe painstaking prep on cedar shingles and stucco, including scraping every inch of peeling paint before priming, with daily clean-up that left the property spotless each evening.

"The painter came on time, protected my floors leading to both bathrooms, worked diligently throughout the day and finished promptly." - Jeannette B., Google Review (C.E.T. Painting)"Painters showed up on time and painting was very neat. I needed some sanding done and the furniture and other rooms were protected so that there would be no dust in these rooms." - Christine W., Facebook Review (C.E.T. Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook

Value and pricing come up consistently across reviews for painting contractors in the Pelham Manor, NY area. C.E.T. Painting reviews frequently describe estimates as "reasonable" and note that final invoices matched original quotes with no surprise charges. A.G. Williams Painting Company reviews describe pricing as fair for the scope and quality delivered, with multiple reviewers noting they chose A.G. Williams after receiving several competing bids. While not always the lowest quote, reviewers consistently describe the value as high given the quality, reliability, and breadth of services provided.

CertaPro Painters of Westchester NY and Southern CT is noted by some reviewers as a premium option, but long-term customers who have used them for over a decade describe them as the best value for the consistency and professionalism delivered. J & S Painting Plus Inc gets strong praise for competitive pricing and honest, itemized quotes - one reviewer described the estimate as the best among several bids, while the crew still finished a day early. Azul Painting Corp stands out for a specific billing practice: in at least one documented case, the final invoice came in lower than the estimate because the scope was slightly smaller, and the company proactively adjusted the bill rather than charging the full amount - a level of integrity that reviewers find notable.

"Fair price and then executed timely and as promised." - Sarah L., Angi Review (J & S Painting Plus Inc)"We were impressed when the final invoice came in lower than the original estimate, reflecting the smaller scope of the job. This shows a great deal of integrity and customer care." - Behrouz K., Google Review (Azul Painting Corp)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook