When Danielle Feliciano called multiple contractors for a project on a tight timeline, it was Courtnay at Another Man's Treasures who changed her expectations. Out of every company she contacted, Courtnay "made me feel like a client, not as another job to schedule." That level of personal attention defines how this St. Augustine operation runs, with office coordinator Courtnay managing the first impression while dedicated project managers handle execution on site.
Owner Brent Monger founded Another Man's Treasures, LLC in 2019, growing the company from a paint and stucco operation into a full-service general contractor. The team includes commercial project manager Richie Reyes, estimator and project manager Isabella Robitaille, and crew leaders Tim and Jeremiah. The company handles residential stucco repair, whole-home repaints, commercial projects, home additions, deck construction, and remodeling across Northeast Florida.
The fully insured team carries workers compensation coverage and holds a Florida Registered Building Contractor license along with specialty stucco licenses. They serve St. Augustine, Jacksonville, Palm Coast, Ponte Vedra, Orange Park, and surrounding communities across St. Johns, Duval, Flagler, Putnam, and Clay Counties. The company is FEMA and SAM certified.
Updated: 04-08-2026
Courtnay appears across reviews more than any single crew member, with customers praising her before work even begins. Ashley Parker wrote that "from the moment we spoke with Courtnay we knew we picked the right company." Maria Espitia described Courtnay's "wealth of knowledge and professionalism" as making the entire process smooth. Karina Benziger noted Courtnay "has not left me wondering what's next at any point." Her role as office coordinator shapes the company's first impression.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The company assigns dedicated project managers rather than rotating supervisors. Melanie Piper described Richie as "fantastic. Super professional, quick to respond, and kept us updated the entire time." Isabella drew similar praise from Cody Miller, who noted she "showed me pictures of current jobs" to explain his stucco damage. Blake Ware called Isabella "the best person to be in the position" for her communication and transparency. Each manager stays with a project from start to completion.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Pricing feedback varies. Cody Miller acknowledged "the price was more than others" but chose Another Man's Treasures because Isabella's estimate was "extremely detailed and clear about what the issue was." Conversely, Dianne Lambert said the cost was "around HALF of what we thought." Joan Carper and Carole Bettini both described pricing as fair and reasonable. The pattern suggests pricing depends on project complexity rather than across-the-board premium rates.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Three negative reviews cite missed estimate appointments. Mike described repeated rescheduling ending with a no-show, calling it a "wasted day of work." Daniel Burkhardt experienced Richie no-showing twice, with the office explaining "something else came up." Owner Brent responded to both, apologizing and offering to prioritize rescheduling. The pattern appears limited to the estimate phase rather than active projects, and the company responded to all three complaints offering to make things right.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Stucco color and texture matching is a recurring theme. Tony Lott had the wing walls re-stuccoed on his 25-year-old home and reported "great job matching the stucco and the color to the original stucco." Heaven Scent Housekeeping described the repair as having "blended seamlessly with the existing finish." Denis Caissie noted the work "blended in perfectly with the old where you could not tell there had been a repair done." The company's stucco repair page emphasizes their texture-matching process.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Reviews consistently reference the same crew names across projects. John Harmon confirmed the company has an "in house design team" and noted on-site workers were "clean and respectful of our property." Del Osburn named six crew members (Isabella, Richie, Tim, Jeremiah, Juan, and Leo) on a single project. Patti Famularo's Facebook review praised "Richie and his crew" for their stone facade work. The careers page actively hires painters as employees, and crew consistency across reviews supports an in-house model.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
John Harmon's review captures it best, calling the company "a 1 stop shop" after they completed a whole home addition with an in-house design team, blueprints, and a full design center for fixtures, cabinets, and flooring. Amy M had stucco repair, window replacement, gutter installation, and painting done in one project, saying "it looks brand new." The company holds a Registered Building Contractor license, allowing them to take on structural work that painting-only contractors cannot.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Florida does not require a state-level painting-specific license, but Another Man's Treasures holds a Registered Building Contractor license (RB29003943) and specialty stucco licenses (ST-9745, ST-9746) through the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation, which exceeds standard painting contractor requirements. The company is registered as a Florida Limited Liability Company, ANOTHER MANS TREASURES LLC, under Document No. L19000096149, filed 4/9/2019 with ACTIVE status. The registered agent is Kevin B. Monger II. The principal address is 101 E Town Pl, Ste 110-D, St. Augustine, FL 32092.
-Verification Sources: FL DBPR License Lookup, FL Sunbiz Entity Search
Updated: 04-08-2026