Hearts & Hands Painting
About Hearts & Hands Painting
When April Fleming's deck coating failed after a previous contractor's $8,000 "lifetime warranty" proved worthless, she found herself searching for someone willing to tackle the mess. Jonathan Price and his team at Hearts & Hands Painting took on the challenge. They stripped the rubbery failed coating, sanded everything down, and applied fresh stain. April now calls them "very professional crew at a very reasonable price" and says they will "forever be taking care of my house."
Jonathan and his wife Ashley founded Hearts & Hands Painting in Butler, Kentucky in 2016. The husband-and-wife team handles projects ranging from cabinet refinishing and deck restoration to full interior transformations. Ashley has developed a reputation for repair work that customers describe as "nothing short of a miracle." Crew members Rob, Doc, and Nathan round out the team. The company uses Benjamin Moore paints and Renner Wood Coatings for cabinet work.
Hearts & Hands Painting serves Northern Kentucky and the Greater Cincinnati area. The company operates as a sole proprietorship with an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and zero complaints on file.
Updated: 01-02-2026
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Hearts & Hands Painting
Q: Why do customers trust Hearts & Hands Painting to fix other contractors' mistakes?
Multiple reviews describe Hearts & Hands rescuing failed projects. April Fleming hired them after a Kong Armor deck coating disaster, noting Jonathan "patiently listened to my dilemma" before stripping and refinishing her three-story deck. Another customer mentioned they "fixed issues with trim from another contractor." The team approaches these situations without judgment and focuses on making things right.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: What makes Ashley's repair work at Hearts & Hands Painting stand out?
Ashley Price handles specialized repair work that consistently surprises customers. Jody C hired them for a full interior project and described Ashley's door frame repairs as "nothing short of a miracle." The same review noted the team "did drywall repair flawlessly." Customers specifically mention Ashley by name when praising the company's ability to fix damaged trim, frames, and walls before painting.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Hearts & Hands Painting actually show up when scheduled?
Punctuality appears throughout the reviews as a defining characteristic. Isaiah Maines booked them in fall for a spring porch project and was impressed that "this contractor followed through" months later. Natasha Thompson noted the team was "punctual, respectful of our home." Multiple customers mention Jonathan's habit of confirming schedules and showing up exactly when promised.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: How does Hearts & Hands Painting handle communication during projects?
Jonathan Price maintains direct communication throughout every project. Jody C stated that "Jonathan's daily communication about what is happening is unmatched." Marissa Glahn appreciated that he "always kept in communication about weather and when the project would start and finish." Customers consistently mention receiving updates via text and knowing exactly what to expect each day.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What do customers say about Hearts & Hands Painting's cabinet refinishing results?
Cabinet work represents a specialty for the company. Amanda Wright described her transformed cabinets as looking "better than brand new cabinets." One customer with 1970s oak cabinets said Jonathan "made them look brand new" and "changed the look of the room." The company uses Renner Wood Coatings specifically formulated for cabinetry and offers dustless sanding with HEPA-certified filters.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Facebook
Q: Does Hearts & Hands Painting recommend what customers actually need or just what costs more?
Several reviews highlight the company's honesty about product recommendations. Marissa Glahn was leaning toward translucent deck stain but Jonathan convinced her to use solid stain because "it will last longer and need to be stained less often." She noted they "could have easily just went with a translucent and hoped to gain business again in 2 years instead of 5, but they were honest with me."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How thorough is the prep work at Hearts & Hands Painting?
Preparation stands out as a consistent theme. Jim Neeley was "amazed at the amount of prep work they did before painting" and noted "they made sure the walls were free of imperfections." Carol Bales had significant plaster wall damage requiring mudding and described the team as "meticulous and professional in every aspect." The company treats surface preparation as essential rather than optional.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Do Hearts & Hands Painting crews clean up properly after working?
Cleanup practices receive frequent praise. Carol Bales noted "they cleaned up every evening and made sure everything was back in order before leaving for the day." Nick Kramer described the finished result with "not a speck of anything out of place." Kate Cummins mentioned the crew was "super respectful of my landscaping" during exterior work. The pattern shows consistent attention to leaving homes better than they found them.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Updated: 01-02-2026