Chooz Score Insights
A Reputation Built Over Time
Over 190 Angi reviews with a 4.9-star rating and over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating reflect more than two decades of consistent work. Andy's Painting Company earned a Chooz Score of 68.0%. With over 20 years in business, they've established deep roots in the Albuquerque and Santa Fe areas:
- A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, accredited since 2006
- The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, reviews spanned multiple platforms including Google, Angi, and Yelp
- Albuquerque Hispano Chamber of Commerce member
"The most amazing experience of any company in the past 10 years! They far exceed expectations!" - Maryanne M., Google Review
Worked with this company?
All verified feedback is published, positive or not. Identity and project verified before publication. Direct submissions are unpaid; invited customers may receive a disclosed $50 thank-you that never depends on their answers.
Additional Questions Answered
Does Andy's Painting Company actually arrive when scheduled unlike other contractors?
Punctuality appears consistently in customer feedback. An Angi reviewer noted crews "arrived about 7 AM, finished before 3 PM" as promised. Google reviewer Martin Alires confirmed the team "showed up on time every day" throughout his whole-house interior project. Multiple customers mention receiving text notifications when crews are en route, eliminating the guesswork that frustrates homeowners with other contractors.
How does Andy's Painting Company handle daily cleanup compared to typical painters?
Cleanup practices receive frequent praise. Customers report crews "cleaned up their work after they left every day" rather than leaving debris until project completion. One Angi reviewer specifically appreciated "not having to clean up after them" compared to previous painting companies. Teams use drop cloths throughout work areas and remove all materials and equipment daily before leaving.
What makes Andy's Painting Company's cabinet refinishing process different?
The cabinet refinishing approach sets them apart from competitors. Pedro and Richard earned praise for results that "came out great" with customers noting a "smooth finish" impossible to achieve painting cabinets in place. The process involves removing all doors and hardware to paint off-site in controlled conditions. Martin Alires described receiving doors back looking "factory finished" with no brush marks or drips.
Have there been floor protection problems at Andy's Painting Company projects?
Floor protection has been inconsistent across projects, and potential customers should address this directly during estimates. Reviewer cbaker4141 documented "paint on new hardwood floors and carpet" while Anna Praamsma reported the crew "did not properly protect carpet" despite her concerns. An Angi reviewer described damage totaling "$622.08" to new flooring. These complaints indicate floor covering protocols vary by crew and require explicit discussion upfront.
Does Andy's Painting Company fix problems when customers raise concerns?
Response to issues shows mixed results. Positive experiences include crews who "went above and beyond to make it right" when problems arose, with teams that "immediately correct" issues during final walk-throughs. One business owner reported that after emailing photos of concerns, "the manager called me within 15 minutes" and sent experienced painters the same day. However, some negative reviews indicate complaints went unaddressed, suggesting outcomes depend on escalation approach.
How does Andy's Painting Company pricing compare when customers get multiple quotes?
Value perception appears favorable for larger projects. Multiple reviewers obtained competing bids and found Andy's "the most reasonable" for comparable scope. An Angi customer stated the "cost was very reasonable for the amount of painting" on extensive interior work. However, reviewer Gale Borkenhagen felt "totally scammed" on a smaller job, suggesting pricing satisfaction correlates with project size and complexity.
Does Andy's Painting Company provide anything for future touch-ups after project completion?
Yes, providing leftover paint is standard practice that many contractors skip. An Angi reviewer noted the crew chief "left us additional paint for future touch-ups, labeled each container clearly" so homeowners know exactly which paint goes where. The company website confirms this as part of their Home Care Paint Touch-up Kit included with completed projects.