This is an image from Andy’s Painting Company, located in New Mexico. The logo for Andy’s Painting Company features bold black lettering with a red paintbrush stroke and the red Zia sun symbol, representing its New Mexico roots.

Andy's Painting Company

Own this business?Claim profile
This is an image from Andy’s Painting Company, located in New Mexico. The logo for Andy’s Painting Company features bold black lettering with a red paintbrush stroke and the red Zia sun symbol, representing its New Mexico roots.
Andy's Painting Company gallery image 1
Andy's Painting Company gallery image 2
Andy's Painting Company gallery image 3
Andy's Painting Company gallery image 4

Chooz Score Insights

Company review dateJanuary 2026

A Reputation Built Over Time

Over 190 Angi reviews with a 4.9-star rating and over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating reflect more than two decades of consistent work. Andy's Painting Company earned a Chooz Score of 68.0%. With over 20 years in business, they've established deep roots in the Albuquerque and Santa Fe areas:

Score breakdown

Platform Reviews
18.8/20
Review Quality & Engagement
26/40
Website & Digital Presence
13.7/20
Business Authority
9.5/20
  • A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, accredited since 2006
  • The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, reviews spanned multiple platforms including Google, Angi, and Yelp
  • Albuquerque Hispano Chamber of Commerce member

"The most amazing experience of any company in the past 10 years! They far exceed expectations!" - Maryanne M., Google Review

Crews You Can Trust

The same foremen and crew members appear across reviews spanning months and years. Jose, Cody, Rafael, Kris, Hector, Pedro, and Richard receive specific praise for quality work. The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators are strong: reviewers mention these crew members by name with specific project details:

  • Rafael Castilo "ensured that all the work was done with very high quality" on exterior projects
  • Cody Leyba praised for attention to detail and ensuring all finishing touches were complete
  • Jose manages projects personally and follows up to ensure satisfaction

"Foreman on the job was Cody, who was great to work with. He has a keen eye for detail." - Martin A., Google Review

They Treat Your Home Like Their Own

Multiple reviewers mention crews arriving on time, cleaning up daily, and leaving homes better than they found them. The company uses Sherwin-Williams professional-grade products across all projects. Customers note:

  • Daily cleanup during multi-day projects and removal of all materials upon completion
  • Text notifications when crews are en route each morning
  • Cabinet doors removed and painted off-site for factory-smooth finishes

"Crew was very professional, on time, and cleaned up after themselves. The doors were removed and painted off site, which provided very smooth finish." - Martin A., Google Review

Questions to Ask Andy's Painting Company

Floor and furniture protection

Several reviews mention concerns about floor protection during projects, with some customers reporting paint on hardwood floors or carpet. This appears to be an inconsistent issue rather than universal, but worth addressing upfront. Ask them directly: "What specific floor protection protocols do your crews follow, and can you walk me through how you'll protect my floors during the project?"

"Painters removed floor coverings before finishing, resulting in paint splatters on our brand-new hardwood floors." - cbaker4141, Google Review (no owner reply)

Worked with this company?

All verified feedback is published, positive or not. Identity and project verified before publication. Direct submissions are unpaid; invited customers may receive a disclosed $50 thank-you that never depends on their answers.