Jays Pro Painting LLC
About Jay's Pro Painting
Serving the unique architectural styles of Beacon, Fishkill, Wappingers Falls, and the greater Hudson Valley, Jay's Pro Painting understands the painting challenges that New York homeowners face. Owner Jay brings over ten years of professional painting experience to every project, personally handling each job from initial estimate through final walkthrough.
What distinguishes this Dutchess County contractor is the owner-operator model. Jay completes all work himself rather than sending rotating crews, ensuring consistent quality and direct accountability. Customers regularly mention this personal approach as a deciding factor in hiring.
The company specializes in residential interior painting, deck staining and restoration, drywall repair, wallpaper removal, popcorn ceiling removal, and decorative trim installation including wainscoting and chair rail. Jay works exclusively with premium paints from Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore, offering color consultation to help clients achieve their vision.
Fully insured with a satisfaction guarantee, Jay's Pro Painting serves communities throughout Dutchess, Putnam, and Orange Counties within approximately 25 miles of Beacon.
Updated: 12-19-2025
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Jay's Pro Painting
Q: What types of painting projects does Jay's Pro Painting handle best?
Reviews show particular strength in interior painting and deck work. Kitchen and bathroom transformations appear frequently, with one customer calling their kitchen results "absolutely stunning." Deck staining projects receive strong praise, with a reviewer noting their weathered deck "looks brand new" after restoration. High ceiling work also stands out, with one customer praising Jay for tackling their "20-foot vaulted ceiling" with confidence.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Jay's Pro Painting compare on pricing according to customers who received multiple estimates?
Customers frequently mention fair, transparent pricing. One reviewer stated Jay provided a "reasonable price" that fit their budget, while another appreciated receiving a "detailed estimate with no surprises." Multiple reviews note the value received, with one customer writing that the quality was "worth every penny" and another mentioning Jay "worked within our budget" while still using premium Benjamin Moore paints.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How did Jay's Pro Painting handle the negative reviews that appeared in July 2025?
Three one-star reviews appeared within days of each other from variations of the same name, none containing service details or project information. Jay responded to each with professionalism, stating "please contact me directly" to discuss concerns. The pattern suggests these were not legitimate customers. Jay's responses demonstrated accountability rather than defensiveness, inviting dialogue rather than arguing in public.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How thorough is Jay's Pro Painting when it comes to surface preparation and protecting the home?
Surface preparation and home protection are recurring themes across reviews. Customers describe Jay covering furniture, floors, and fixtures with great care. Multiple reviewers mention their homes were "cleaner than before he started" after project completion. Jennifer noted Jay was "meticulous with prep work" on her kitchen ceiling project, while Tom praised how "everything was covered and protected" during his living room repaint.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Jay's Pro Painting show up on time and finish work as scheduled?
Punctuality and reliability appear in dozens of reviews. Customers report Jay arriving "exactly when he said he would" and completing projects "on schedule or ahead of time." One reviewer with a tight timeline noted Jay "finished a day early" on their multi-room project. Another mentioned he "never had to wonder when he'd show up" because arrival times remained consistent throughout a week-long job.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What do reviews say about communication when working with Jay's Pro Painting?
Communication is among the most praised aspects. Customers describe Jay as a "great communicator" who keeps them informed at every stage. One reviewer appreciated that Jay "explained each step of the process" before starting work. Another noted he was "always responsive to texts and calls" and provided updates without being asked. The consistency of this praise suggests a deliberate business practice.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Jay's Pro Painting use the owner or crews for jobs?
Jay completes every project himself rather than sending crews, and customers highlight this as a major advantage. One customer noted he is a "master of his craft" while another described him as a "consummate professional." Sarah emphasized that having the owner present meant "no miscommunication" and direct accountability throughout her whole-house project. This hands-on approach appears throughout the reviews.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Do customers come back to Jay's Pro Painting for additional projects?
Repeat business intent runs throughout the reviews. Customers state they "will definitely use Jay again" and "already have him booked for our next project." One reviewer who hired Jay for a bathroom noted they "immediately scheduled him for the kitchen." Referral mentions are common, with customers writing they found Jay through "a neighbor's recommendation" or word of mouth from satisfied friends.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Updated: 01-12-2026