Sebastian Montejo runs Custom Paint Jobs LLC out of Columbus, Ohio. When homeowners reach out for a free estimate, Sebastian or one of his coordinators schedules an on-site walkthrough so the team can see the home, talk through color preferences, and write up a clearly itemized proposal. Reviews note that Sebastian "responded immediately" to estimate requests and that customers receive a "clearly written proposal for a reasonable amount" with no surprise extras.
The crew handles interior repaints, exterior repaints, cabinet refinishing, deck staining, drywall and wood rot repair, wallpaper removal, pressure washing, and polyurea garage and basement floor coatings across Central Ohio. Customers regularly name returning crew members including Otto, Mira, Edgar, Aurelio, Jamie, and Gladys, which points to stable in-house teams rather than rotating subs.
The company is fully licensed, bonded, and insured and offers a 1-year conditional labor warranty on interior work and a 2-year conditional labor warranty on exterior work. Custom Paint Jobs is a BBB Accredited Business and a City of Columbus Certified Small Business Enterprise, serving 38 Central Ohio communities including Bexley, Upper Arlington, Worthington, and New Albany.
Updated: 05-12-2026
Sandy Haught describes the work as having "no drips, no paint on baseboards, no paint on cabinets, ceilings or floors," and Chris D writes that "every night they cleaned up before they left." Mary Butts adds the crew was "careful... cleaned up and were courteous." The pattern across reviews shows end-of-day tidying rather than leaving disorder until the project's final day.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Customers consistently name the same crew. Felicia Miskow-Stump writes "Jamie was my contact person and he went above and beyond," Victoria O'Neil says "Otto & Mira were the painters that did the job & they were wonderful," and Unparalleled Eye Designs notes "Edgar & Aurelio were my team and they were fabulous, timely, kind, efficient, and thorough." Owner Sebastian Montejo handles many estimates directly.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Many reviews praise the prep stage. Vilmarie Rodriguez writes "Crew takes time to prepare before painting," and Sue Gunn says the team "spent a lot of time prepping for painting. Very detailed." One Angi customer (Gary C.) disputes whether two full coats were applied on his Reynoldsburg exterior job, writing "I got charged for two coats of paint" but feeling only one was applied; that review has not received a public response.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Angi
Several customers hired the company specifically for cabinets. Ashley Allen writes they "painted the entire interior of our home, including our kitchen and bathroom cabinets, and everything turned out beautifully," and Miszaelt Campuzano says the crew "did a really amazing job and helped me choose the color for the perfect match of everything in my kitchen." Sandy Haught praises the clean finish on her kitchen cabinets too.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Exterior repaints regularly include carpentry work. Ryan Shenigo writes the crew "replaced all the damaged wood, caulked everything and did a superb" job. Chris D says they "made sure any open areas where the wood met wood were caulked and then were so precise with the painting." Melissa Reta hired the team for "wood replacement on the exterior of my home" alongside the paint job.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Repeat customer language shows up across multiple reviews. Vicki Brougher Miller writes "I have used them twice now. Once to paint the exterior of my house and once to paint the inside," Becky Salyer says "We have used Custom Paint Jobs now twice, this is our 2nd home exterior," and Peter notes "I've used Custom Paint Jobs on two painting projects so far and have been very pleased with the results."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Several reviewers comment directly on price versus other bids. Steve R writes they gave a "reasonable bid for the project with all work included and no caveats for extras as with some other contractors." Gregory Schultheis says they were "much more budget friendly than the competition," and Jill notes "their prices are unbeatable as well as the quality of paint job."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Ohio does not require a state-level painting contractor license, and the City of Columbus exempts painting-only work from its Home Improvement Contractor registration. Custom Paint Jobs LLC is registered as an active Ohio domestic LLC with the Ohio Secretary of State under Entity No. 2121468, filed 7-12-2012. The company is also a BBB Accredited Business (since 6-30-2022) and a City of Columbus Certified Small Business Enterprise.
-Verification Sources: Ohio Secretary of State, Better Business Bureau, City of Columbus SBE program
Updated: 05-12-2026