5 Best Painters Near Shelbyville, KY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Shelbyville, KY have built strong reputations through consistent quality and customer care. Homeowners across Shelby County praise these companies for professional crews, clear communication, and work that stands the test of time.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Alarcon Pro Painting had over 180 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 90.1%. This family-owned company is known for hands-on owner involvement, with Bryan and his father Raul frequently mentioned by name in reviews. Customers consistently describe a team that identifies issues other painters would simply cover up. If you want a company where the owners personally handle estimates and follow up after completion, Alarcon Pro Painting is a strong choice.

Looking through the reviews, their specialty in kitchen cabinet refinishing stands out. Multiple customers describe factory-quality finishes that make dated cabinets look brand new. The team also earns praise for transparent pricing and same-day responses to estimate requests.

• 5.0 stars on Facebook with customers praising the family business atmosphere
• Repeat customers are common, with several reviewers mentioning multiple projects
• Known for completing work ahead of schedule while maintaining quality

"Painted the entire main floor including ceilings, fixing cracks and drywall tape. They did an excellent job and did it in two days. Their quote was significantly lower than the three other estimates I had received." - Ryan Sapp, Google Review

For homeowners looking to update their exterior or cabinets without the cost of full replacement, Spray-Net Lexington offers a specialized approach. They've earned a Chooz Score of 89.1% with reviews across Google, Facebook, Angi, and Yelp. What sets them apart is their 15-year no-peel warranty that's transferable to future homeowners. Owner Chris handles consultations personally and stays involved throughout each project. If you want a warranty that gives you peace of mind for years to come, Spray-Net is worth considering.

Reviewers describe dramatic improvements to vinyl siding, brick, and garage doors. Several customers mention neighbors stopping to compliment the results. The team's ability to re-coat surfaces and bring them back to life has earned them repeat business from customers who started with one project and came back for more.

• Written warranty terms provided upfront, covering both cabinets and exterior surfaces
• Projects frequently completed ahead of schedule
• Multiple customers describe booking second and third projects with the company

"We partnered with Chris and Spray-Net twice in 2024. First, they re-coated our original vinyl siding from 1996 and brought it back to life with a fresh look. Our home looks better than new." - Mitchel Thompson, Google Review

With a perfect 5.0-star rating across over 165 Google reviews, Gomez Painting LLC. has earned a Chooz Score of 89.0%. Owner Berto and project managers like Joshua are frequently praised for their thorough approach and attention to detail. If you're particular about prep work and want a team that fixes underlying issues rather than painting over them, Gomez Painting delivers.

What comes through in the reviews is a company that refuses to cut corners. Customers describe crews repairing drywall imperfections, caulking trim, and addressing problems other painters would simply cover up. The team also handles fire and water damage restoration, with customers praising their ability to bring damaged homes back to life.

• Named crew members Joshua, Dayma, and Heriberto receive consistent praise
• 5.0 stars on Facebook with customers highlighting the team's professionalism
• Known for moving furniture and protecting belongings with extra care

"Gomez Painting did a fantastic job repairing a horrible contractor drywall and painting mess. I was ready to cry over all the issues that there were. They came in and saved the day on everything." - Jenny Ludack, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Shelbyville, KY, CertaPro Painters of Louisville brings a larger operation with dedicated project coordinators and multiple experienced crews. They've earned a Chooz Score of 88.3% with over 220 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating, plus an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and over 14 years of accreditation history. If you want a company with established systems and a track record spanning decades, CertaPro is a solid option.

Reviewers consistently mention returning for second, third, and even fourth projects. Project Coordinator Vicki Waterbury appears in dozens of reviews, praised for guiding customers through every step. Named crew members like Elvin, Ben, Francisco, and Armando get called out for their skill and professionalism.

• 4.8 stars on Angi with over 20 verified reviews
• Multiple reviewers describe using CertaPro across several homes over 10+ years
• Commercial and residential projects handled with equal care

"We were nervous about hiring a residential exterior painter because we had been scammed on a garage build in the last few years. We hired CertaPro and Steve and Jose made the experience smooth. I would definitely recommend them." - Melissa Mann Bean, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi, Yelp, BBB

Painting contractors serving Shelbyville, KY consistently receive praise for their attention to detail and quality results. Alarcon Pro Painting customers highlight careful work on kitchen cabinets, with one reviewer noting: "My kitchen cabinets look like they came straight from the factory. I'm amazed with the results." Another customer shared that the team completed six rooms in just six hours while maintaining excellent quality. Gomez Painting LLC. earns similar recognition for their refusal to cut corners, with one homeowner describing how: "Everything was way above expectations. They are the best."

Spray-Net Lexington receives praise for exterior work that holds up over time, backed by their 15-year warranty. One customer noted: "From dated red brick to modern neutral gray in 3 days! Even a random driver by stopped to comment how amazing it looks." CertaPro Painters of Louisville also delivers consistent quality, with reviewers describing results that exceed expectations. One customer who had wallpaper removal and painting work wrote: "We've had some tricky projects and they've completed them professionally with attention to detail."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Painting contractors serving Shelbyville, KY earn high marks for keeping customers informed throughout their projects. Alarcon Pro Painting customers frequently mention owner Bryan's responsiveness, with one noting: "Great communication and excellent paint job. Team was very professional and friendly." CertaPro Painters of Louisville assigns dedicated project coordinators, with Vicki Waterbury receiving particular praise for helping customers select colors and guiding them through every step of the process.

Gomez Painting LLC. owner Berto is praised for prompt communication, with one customer sharing: "Berto came out and I was given an estimate the very next day. My project was scheduled within a week, and I was kept updated throughout the process." Spray-Net Lexington owner Chris keeps customers informed through every step: "From day one, Chris was very informative and transparent about the work that they could and would do. Chris was great at communicating updates and changes." Across all four companies, reviewers consistently mention receiving detailed estimates, regular updates during work, and follow-up calls after completion.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi

Timeliness is a common theme in reviews of Shelbyville, KY painting contractors. Spray-Net Lexington frequently completes work ahead of schedule, with one customer noting: "They arrived earlier to do our home, a couple of days ahead of schedule. The work was completed in a day." Gomez Painting LLC. receives similar praise, with reviewers describing fast start and turnaround and crews that show up on time every day.

Alarcon Pro Painting customers mention efficient work without sacrificing quality. One reviewer shared: "They were organized, prompt and completed the job in a professional and timely fashion." Another noted the team completed painting six rooms in just six hours. CertaPro Painters of Louisville is praised for meeting deadlines even on large projects, with one customer noting: "Did a beautiful job in record time. Highly recommend."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Customers across Shelbyville, KY describe painting contractors who deliver strong value for the price. Spray-Net Lexington stands out for competitive pricing and their 15-year warranty adds significant value for homeowners planning to stay long-term. One customer noted the work was done "without breaking the bank." Alarcon Pro Painting customers praise detailed estimates that break down exactly what they're paying for, with one noting: "Their quote was significantly lower than the three other estimates I had received and they did a great job."

CertaPro Painters of Louisville receives positive feedback for competitive pricing on larger projects. One customer shared: "I was very happy with the work performed and their very competitive prices. They painted practically the entire interior of my house." Gomez Painting LLC. owner Berto is described as offering affordable pricing, with one reviewer noting: "The price was very fair, and they did the job as quickly as possible."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Angi

Thorough prep work and clean job sites are hallmarks of Shelbyville, KY painting contractors. Gomez Painting LLC. is especially praised for refusing to cut corners, with one customer sharing: "They covered ALL of my furniture and took extra special care with dust because I have asthma." Another noted: "They moved all the furniture out and back. They were on time and very quick." Alarcon Pro Painting receives similar recognition, with one cabinet refinishing customer noting: "Throughout the entire 5-day process they were clean, both inside and out!"

CertaPro Painters of Louisville customers praise crews for protecting furniture and cleaning up daily. One exterior project customer wrote that the windows were covered in plastic and when they left at the end of each day everything was neatly covered and secured. Spray-Net Lexington also earns cleanup praise, with one reviewer stating: "Service was always their priority and they left the place even better than it was before."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Several painting contractors serving Shelbyville, KY specialize in kitchen cabinet refinishing. Alarcon Pro Painting is known for factory-quality cabinet finishes, with customers describing results that make dated cabinets look brand new. One reviewer shared: "I added cabinets to the top of my existing cabinets so I had lots of new boxes, doors, and trim. The team did an excellent job of making everything look original and seamless." The company handles everything from painted cabinets to bare wood refinishing.

Spray-Net Lexington offers a unique approach with their 15-year no-peel warranty on cabinet work. One customer described their dated 90s cabinets being refreshed in just two days: "Job took 2 days which I almost didn't believe them because every other quote we got was going to take more than a week." Gomez Painting LLC. also handles cabinet projects, with crews praised for matching paint colors on existing cabinets and hanging new doors. One reviewer noted: "Gomez Painting did my kitchen cabinets, hung and painted 7 new interior doors. They were neat, clean, and proficient."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook