3 Best Painters Near Pembroke, MA Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Pembroke, MA have earned strong reputations through consistent quality and responsive customer service. Local homeowners praise these companies for thorough prep work, professional crews, and results that hold up over time.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, CertaPro Painters of the South Shore and Boston had over 250 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. They've earned a Chooz Score of 89.3% with strong ratings across multiple platforms including 97% recommended on Facebook with over 35 recommendations. Owner Paige NeJame personally responds to virtually every review with specific details about the project and crew members involved. If you're looking for a large, well-established company with a proven track record on the South Shore, CertaPro is a solid choice.

What stands out in the reviews is how CertaPro handles complex projects. Customers describe Victorian homes with detailed trim, historic properties requiring lead paint removal, and multi-story exteriors all completed with care. Several reviewers mention being repeat customers over more than a decade, returning for both interior and exterior work. The company also offers free color consultations and financing options that customers frequently appreciate.

• Crews like Ed, David, Angelo, and Sanderson receive individual praise for their attention to detail
• Customers note that estimates include detailed breakdowns with no surprise costs
• Licensed Home Improvement Contractor verified active in Massachusetts

"I first hired CertaPro to paint my house more than a dozen years ago. They did such a good job and were so nice to work with that I hired them again this year to repaint my house." - S Fung, Google Review

Customers consistently mention the same thing about Stewart Painting: you get the same crews every time, not random subcontractors. They've earned a Chooz Score of 87.7% with over 95 Google reviews and strong presence on Yelp and Angi. Tim and Rabi handle house washing, Wayne leads painting crews, and Jeremy and Matt handle carpentry. If you want a contractor who uses W2 employees rather than contract painters, Stewart Painting delivers that consistency.

Looking through the reviews, Stewart Painting has built a loyal customer base on Cape Cod and the South Shore. Multiple customers describe using them for over 30 years for various projects. The company offers house washing, exterior staining, carpentry repairs, and full painting services, often bundled together for complete exterior refreshes.

• Tim and Rabi mentioned by name in dozens of reviews for house washing excellence
• Earl's painting crew praised repeatedly for exterior work on historic and antique homes
• Carpentry team led by Jeremy handles rot repair and custom trim replacement
• Paint it Forward contest winner demonstrates community involvement

"Wayne and his crew did incredible work to make our antique house look new again. They were super nice, courteous and very hard working." - Amy Alberti, Google Review

With over 65 years in business since 1960, Nelson Painting has built a legacy serving the South Shore and Cape Cod across three generations. They've earned a Chooz Score of 85.7% with over 60 Google reviews maintaining a 4.9-star rating. Owner Marc Nelson is frequently mentioned by name for being responsive and personally involved in projects. If you want a family-owned company with deep local roots, Nelson Painting fits that profile.

The pattern in Nelson Painting reviews is clear: customers who hire them once tend to hire them again. Multiple reviewers describe using them for both interior and exterior work over many years. The company applies paint with traditional brushes rather than sprayers on exterior wood siding, a detail several customers specifically call out as the right way to ensure paint works into all crevices.

• MA Home Improvement Contractor License verified active
• Customers mention returning for second, third, and fourth projects
• Softwash and deck refinishing services complement painting work

"Working with Nelson is one of the best contractor experiences we have ever had. They were friendly, timely, professional and the quality of the work was exceptional." - Kevin Patterson, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi

Painting contractors serving Pembroke, MA consistently receive praise for the quality of their finished work. CertaPro Painters of the South Shore and Boston customers highlight careful attention to detail, with one homeowner noting their Victorian home's detailed trim was handled with precision: "My house has a lot of detailed trim and adornments, and the team handled it all with care and precision." Another customer described how the crew went beyond basic painting: "They even did some extras for us, like replacing a lightbulb that was very high on the house and fixing a sagging gutter."

Stewart Painting earns recognition for thorough work on antique and historic homes. One reviewer shared "Earl and the crew at Stewart painting were excellent. Attention was paid to all details and the effort did not go unnoticed." Nelson Painting receives similar praise, with customers noting their traditional approach: "They applied the paint with traditional brushes, not sprayers, to work the paint into all the crevices of wood siding - in other words, the RIGHT way." Multiple reviewers across all three companies mention results that look like brand new houses when finished.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Painting contractors in Pembroke, MA receive consistent praise for professional service and clear communication. CertaPro Painters of the South Shore and Boston customers frequently mention responsive estimates and regular updates throughout projects. One customer noted "The estimating and bidding process was efficient, professional, and timely. The paint crew was on time each day and they communicated effectively throughout the project." Another shared "Great communication throughout the process. The painter that did the actual work was punctual, did a great job and left our home spotless."

Stewart Painting customers appreciate the coordination between different crews handling washing, carpentry, and painting. One reviewer described their experience: "The entire Stewart Painting team has been incredibly professional across the board - communication, scheduling, organization, prep work, punctuality, craftsmanship, attention to detail, and cleanup." Nelson Painting earns similar recognition, with one customer noting "The scheduling process was easy. They arrived on time and got the job done quickly with excellent quality." Owner Marc Nelson is frequently mentioned for being personally responsive to questions before, during, and after projects.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Painting contractors serving Pembroke, MA receive strong marks for punctuality and efficient scheduling. CertaPro Painters of the South Shore and Boston customers frequently mention projects completed on time or ahead of schedule. One reviewer shared "They worked long hours to get the house done in the shortest time possible." Another noted their basement renovation was finished in just a day and a half despite multiple rooms. Nelson Painting customers report similar experiences: "They finished ahead of schedule, on budget and didn't miss any small details."

Stewart Painting customers praise the coordination between specialized crews. One reviewer described "Between the two crews the exterior of my house and shed were completed in two days." Across all three companies, reviewers consistently mention crews arriving when promised and keeping homeowners informed about weather delays or schedule changes. When weather does interfere, crews reschedule promptly rather than pushing through unsafe conditions.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Painting contractors in Pembroke, MA receive positive feedback on pricing transparency and overall value. CertaPro Painters of the South Shore and Boston customers frequently mention clear estimates with detailed breakdowns. One homeowner shared "The proposal we received was extremely thorough. John our salesman worked with us to refine the proposal to meet our budget and needs." The company also offers financing options that customers appreciate. Another reviewer noted "Their price was the most affordable compared to several other quotes we got."

Nelson Painting earns recognition for fair pricing, with one customer describing "On time on budget great job." Another noted they received multiple quotes and chose Nelson based on their thorough approach rather than being the cheapest option. Stewart Painting customers acknowledge their pricing may be higher than smaller operators but cite the value of consistent crews and quality results. One reviewer shared "We got 4 quotes from various painting companies in the area. We ultimately decided to hire Nelson Painting not because of price, but because of procedure."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google