4 Best Painters in West Newton, MA - Chooz Score Ranked

Why Customers Choose ProTEK Painters

Communication & Responsiveness

If you're a first-time customer who wants guidance, this company delivers. Owner John Guarino responds personally to every single Google review with customized messages that mention your specific project, your city, and your name—not generic thank-yous. This responsiveness carries through to the actual work:

• John personally handles estimates and often does on-site visits himself
• Same-day or next-day communication throughout projects
• Owner stays accessible via phone throughout the entire process

"John kept in contact thru the whole process. He made me feel confident in my choices." - Debby D., Google Review

Proven Track Record

If you want a company with a solid reputation built over decades, ProTEK Painters has an exceptional foundation. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 100 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating (Source: Google Reviews), plus an A+ BBB rating (Source: Better Business Bureau) and a perfect 5.0 stars on Yelp (Source: Yelp). They earned a Chooz Score of 90.2% and have maintained quality since 1999:

• Over 25 years in continuous operation under the same ownership
• Fully licensed (MA HIC #190428) and EPA Lead-Safe Certified
• Two-year workmanship warranty clearly stated

"ProTEK painted our house 11 years ago. It held up really well which is an example of the quality work." - Melissa H., Google Review

Competitive Pricing

If you're budget-conscious but still want quality, customers consistently highlight the value they receive. Several reviewers specifically mention ProTEK offering the best prices they found—sometimes by considerable margins compared to competitors:

• Detailed, itemized quotes allow you to see exactly what you're paying for
• Honored a quote even after an 8-month delay for one customer
• No deposit required for projects under $2,000

"Pro Tek offered me the best price by a considerable margin in comparison to 5 competing vendors." - Emily E., Google Review

Quality & Attention to Detail

If you're particular about craftsmanship and the details matter to you, customers repeatedly praise the thoroughness of this crew. Reviews frequently mention specific crew members by name—Rita for door work, Eduardo for power washing, Breno for interior projects—indicating consistent quality across the team:

• Thorough surface preparation before any paint goes on
• Car covers to protect your and your neighbors' vehicles during exterior work
• Daily cleanup that leaves properties looking better than when work started

"Obvious that the crew takes pride in their work, their daily clean up, very considerate and professional. Tarps, masking and car covers to protect my and close by neighbor's cars." - B W., Google Review

Why Customers Choose Catchlight Painting

Credentials You Can Check

With 30 years in business, Catchlight Painting has built one of the most credentialed operations in the Greater Boston area. The Chooz Score's business authority component verified multiple industry certifications that set them apart:

• MA Home Improvement Contractor License No. 117508 verified through state records
• EPA Lead-Safe certified, with all crew members trained for work in historic homes
• PDCA PIPP Award winner (2016) for Residential Exterior Restoration

"Catchlight has competent employees who take pride in doing long lasting quality work. They actually believe in participating in continuing education." - Kevin F., Google Review

Guaranteed Work

All Catchlight work comes with a clear, written 3-year warranty covering both interior and exterior projects. The Chooz Score's warranty component reflects this commitment, and customers consistently praise the follow-through:

• Comprehensive warranty terms stated clearly on their website and marketing materials
• Owner Nigel personally responds to virtually every review with project-specific details
• Repeat customers like Rachel Garity have completed 4 projects together, demonstrating trust

"We've worked together for 29 years! Thank you for your continued business." - Owner Nigel, in response to a review from Thom Mulhern

A Reputation Built Over Time

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Catchlight had over 95 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 85.6%. Reviews span multiple platforms with strong ratings across the board:

• 100% recommended on Facebook with over 10 reviews
• 4.5 stars on Yelp with over 25 reviews providing detailed project feedback
• Consistent praise for work on historic Cambridge and Brookline homes

"What stands out about them is the team approach. The members of the team, from the initial planning to completion, were always identified to me and available whenever I needed them." - Cathy G., Google Review

Questions to Ask Catchlight Painting

Project management and communication expectations

While the majority of reviews are positive, a couple of customers noted frustration with project management communication during their jobs. One customer felt they had to personally manage the painters daily, while another experienced delays and invoicing confusion on an exterior project. Ask them directly: "Who will be my main point of contact during the project, and how often can I expect updates?"

"If it weren't for me directing the painters each day, we would've had a number of areas that were either not painted at all, not properly prepped, or painted the wrong color." - Jennifer U., Google Review

Why Customers Choose CertaPro Painters of Newton

Easy to Reach, Quick to Respond

Jeff Chin's responsiveness stands out in nearly every review. Customers consistently praise how quickly he addresses inquiries, schedules site visits, and follows up on concerns. The Chooz Score's review response quality component reflects this dedication to customer communication:

• Jeff responds to initial inquiries within days and schedules site visits quickly
• When issues arise, Jeff personally ensures they're resolved, even returning to redo work if needed

"We encountered an issue where the paint color was not to the liking of the LL, and Jeff got his team back out and resprayed the area with a new color. He was very accommodating and did his best to help with the issue." - JJ L., Google Review

Hundreds of Happy Customers

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, CertaPro Painters of Newton had over 135 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 85.7%. With 8 years in business, they've built a solid reputation in the Newton area:

• Strong recent activity with over 10 reviews in the last 3 months alone
• Active on both residential and commercial projects

"From start to finish, Jeff was incredibly responsive, quickly addressing our initial inquiry and scheduling an on-site visit just a few days later to provide a detailed quote. Within three weeks of the site visit our space was transformed." - Rebecca's Culinary Group, Google Review

Licensed, Insured, and Verified

As part of the CertaPro franchise network, this local operation benefits from national standards while maintaining local ownership. The Chooz Score's business authority component verified their credentials:

• EPA Lead RRP Certified for work on homes built before 1978
• Professional franchise backing with established systems and warranties

"CertaPro Painters of Newton painted the front and side of our multi unit condo building. Their quote was competitive. Jeff was professional and easy to work with. His team was respectful and did a good job on both the painting and dozens of carpentry items." - Susan O., Google Review

Why Customers Choose Big Dog Painting | Woburn Painters

Familiar Faces, Consistent Results

What sets Big Dog apart is the consistency of their crews. The Chooz Score's in-house crews component shows the same crew names appearing across dozens of reviews, and customers frequently request specific team members by name for return projects:

• Jake, Leo, and Kali are praised repeatedly for cabinet refinishing work
• Ever, Carlos, and Marcelino lead exterior painting crews with consistent five-star results
• Customers mention Denis, Charlie, Derek, and Wagner by name for their attention to detail

"Words cannot express what a great experience we had with Big Dog Painting. Huge thanks to Carlos, Nick, Daniel, and Wesley, you are all amazing. The house looks absolutely incredible." - Meghan M., Google Review

Craftsmanship You Can See

Customers consistently mention the same thing: meticulous prep work and flawless finishes, especially on cabinet refinishing and historic home restoration. The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators are strong, with reviewers mentioning specific project details and realistic timelines:

• Cabinet painting receives particular praise, with customers saying their 35-year-old cabinets now "look brand new"
• Historic home restoration on an 1840s property drew special recognition for "preserving the charm and character"

"I had my kitchen cabinets refinished. Big Dog Painting did a meticulous job. It was fast, masterful and so much more efficient than getting new cabinets. It looks like I had a complete renovation." - Chelsea M., Google Review

Years of Consistent Results

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Big Dog Painting had over 185 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 85.5%. With 16 years in business serving the Greater Boston area, they've established deep roots:

• MA Home Improvement Contractor License verified active
• EPA Lead Certified for work on older homes

"This is the 2nd time I've used Big Dog, they will forever be my 'go to' for all things Paint." - diga133, Google Review

Questions to Ask Big Dog Painting | Woburn Painters

Response time on concerns

While Big Dog delivers consistently excellent work, their review response rate is lower than average. One detailed negative review on Yelp raised concerns about communication during the estimate process that went unaddressed. If clear communication is important to you, ask directly: "What's your typical response time on emails, and who will be my main point of contact throughout the project?"

"When we didn't get our estimate on time, I followed up a couple times. When it still didn't arrive, I figured they didn't want the project and weren't telling me." - X Y., Yelp Review (no owner reply)