At the time we analyzed Anderson Painting, the company held over 250 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating, along with 96% recommended on Facebook across over 20 reviews and 3.9 stars on Yelp across 10 reviews. The Google profile alone carries over 250 ratings, a high review count for a regional painting company.
The company earned a Chooz Score of 89.7%. Anderson Painting is family owned and operated, has served the Raleigh area and the greater Triangle for nearly two decades, and is registered in North Carolina as Business Entity No. 1088021. Its crews are trained for EPA lead-safe work on older homes, and the company handles carpentry, siding, and drywall repair alongside interior and exterior painting.
The reviews we analyzed are concentrated on Google, with single reviews on Facebook and Yelp, and describe interior and exterior painting most often, alongside carpentry and wood repair, deck and fence staining, and cabinet and door refinishing. Praise across the reviews we read centers on crew workmanship and on named individuals such as Scott, Mohammad, and Wells, several of whom appear across more than one job and more than one year. The company runs its own crews rather than subcontractors, and we found at least a dozen reviewers describing repeat projects or neighbor referrals. The owner responds to reviews individually, including several of the critical ones. The recurring thread in the critical reviews concerns office communication and follow-through on agreed touch-ups, which we cover below.
"This was our second time using Anderson Painting. They are our 'go to' painters, and we appreciate their quality work and professionalism. Thank you to the entire team, Mohammad, Noaman and Wells!" - Lisa F., Google Review
A handful of reviews describe agreed touch-ups or callback items that were promised but slow to be completed, and at least one received no response from the company. Confirming how punch-list items and post-job fixes are scheduled is worth doing before you hire. Ask them directly: "If something needs a touch-up after the crew leaves, who owns that and what is the timeline for coming back?"
"They offered to come fix it and remove it, said 4 times they would come to do it and never showed up to do it even after us reminding them. For the price we paid this felt somewhat unacceptable." - Chelsea J., Google Review (no owner reply)
Want us to do the work for you and find you the best painting contractor?
Get StartedFREE SERVICEAt the time of our analysis, Garner’s Painting Service held over 350 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, along with 4.1 stars on Yelp across over 10 reviews and 100% recommended on Facebook. Nearly all of that volume sits on Google, where the sample is large and the average high, while the Yelp and Facebook profiles rest on much smaller counts.
The company earned a Chooz Score of 88.2%. It operates as a long-established Fayetteville painting contractor, has been Accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2008, and is registered in North Carolina as Business Entity No. 0823451. The business is family-run under owner Steve Seitz, and it serves Fayetteville and the surrounding eastern North Carolina communities.
The reviews we analyzed point most consistently to named, recurring crews. We found at least a hundred reviews that name individual painters, with Don, Beto, Richard, Kenny, Tim, Nick, and Fernando appearing across projects and years, a pattern consistent with an in-house crew rather than rotating subcontractors. Interior and exterior painting are the most common projects described, with drywall and surface repair recurring alongside them. Repeat and long-term hiring shows up as well, and we found at least a dozen reviewers describing prior or ongoing work, including one who reports using the company for 14 years. The owner replies to most reviews, usually addressing the reviewer and the project by name. The recurring criticism in our sample concerns communication and follow-through after the initial work, which we cover below.
"Were here on time and did some awesome work. Richard was very professional. Garner’s has been to my home multiple times and I will continue to use them in the future." - Ceferino L., Google Review
A handful of reviews describe difficulty reaching the company or getting follow-up scheduled after the initial work, with a few noting that promised touch-ups were slow to happen. The painting itself is praised even in these accounts, so the point worth raising is how the company stays in contact once a job is underway. Ask them directly: "Once we’ve agreed to move forward, who is my point of contact, and how will you keep me updated on scheduling and any touch-ups?"
"Poor communication. Hard to get hold of after you agree to hire. Would not recommend because of this. On the other hand, painters did an excellent job." - Mary Ann P., Google Review
100% Recommended (9 Reviews)
Every painter listed on this page has been evaluated using the Chooz multi-step quality process. We combine data analysis with human review to identify companies that consistently deliver strong results for property owners in Elizabethtown, NC.
The Chooz Score is a 100-point rating built on platform reviews, review quality and engagement, website and digital presence, and business authority and operations. We use the same scoring framework nationwide while evaluating each contractor's performance specifically within Elizabethtown, NC.
