Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Garner's Painting Service
Led by owner Steve Seitz and supported by a skilled crew including Richard, Kenny, Tim, Don, Beto, Ron, Fernando, and Omar, Garner's Painting Service has built a business with over 250 five-star Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. Since 1978, this BBB A+ accredited company has specialized in both residential and commercial painting throughout Fayetteville and Eastern North Carolina. Their portfolio spans everything from single-room interior updates to complete exterior transformations, cabinet refinishing, drywall repair, and pressure washing.
What distinguishes Garner's Painting is their systematic approach to customer service. Crews arrive on time daily, often completing projects ahead of schedule. Reviews consistently mention the "extreme professionalism, thoroughness and high expertise" that team members demonstrate. Isaac handles consultations with detailed estimates, while project coordinators like Malissa keep customers informed throughout the process. The fully licensed and insured team protects property extensively, covering floors and furniture before work begins, then conducting thorough daily cleanup.
With competitive pricing that reflects quality materials and skilled labor, Garner's Painting has become the choice for property owners seeking reliable results. Their approach combines 47 years of experience with modern communication practices, including progress updates and owner responses to virtually every customer review. From Fayetteville to Sanford, Aberdeen to Lumberton, they serve communities across the region with the same commitment to excellence.
Updated: 04-06-2026
Multiple customers emphasize punctuality throughout their reviews. George notes that Tim and Kenny were "always on time, every single day" and completed repairs and painting a day earlier than planned. Bob mentions Omar's crew stayed "on schedule the whole time" during his interior project. Service manager Malissa coordinates scheduling to ensure crews arrive when promised, and customers receive confirmation updates before each workday.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Property protection receives extensive praise in reviews. Bob specifically describes how the team "went above and beyond on protecting all of my furniture, rugs, and wood flooring" during his interior painting. Multiple customers mention comprehensive floor and furniture covering before any painting begins. Vanessa notes Ron and Fernando "covered the floors and furniture so that the paint did not cause any damage" and treated the home respectfully throughout the project.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Customers frequently recognize individual painters for their professionalism and skill. Bette describes Don and Beto showing "extreme professionalism, thoroughness and high expertise" throughout their four-day interior project. George praises Tim and Kenny for keeping everything mellow with music while maintaining professional standards. Jessica specifically requests Mrs. Oji K for future work, noting she was "so detail oriented and thorough" when addressing ceiling imperfections. This personal recognition reflects consistent quality across different crew combinations.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Steve maintains active involvement from consultation through completion. Multiple reviews mention his personal handling of estimates and his accessibility throughout projects. The owner responds to virtually every Google review with personalized messages, often using customer names and heart emojis to express appreciation. K Gerald specifically notes "Owner Derek's communication and understanding of exactly what was desired" ensured the work was done with perfection, though this may reference a manager rather than Steve.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews, Yelp
While the reviews provided don't extensively detail cabinet refinishing specifically, Trinity Pace mentions the company's work on new construction homes with "meticulous attention to detail" and "flawless finishes with crisp, even lines, smooth coverage, and not a trace of mess left behind." The company lists cabinet painting and refinishing as a core service, and reviews consistently praise the quality of trim and detail work, suggesting similar standards apply to cabinet projects.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The single detailed negative Yelp review from March 2025 describes quality concerns, with the customer stating the work appeared "shoddy and steps were skipped." While no owner response is visible for that specific review, the company's response pattern on Google shows professional engagement. When issues arise, reviews indicate crews return to address concerns. Jessica Tydeman mentions that after expressing concerns about the first crew's detail level, "that's when they sent Mrs. Oji K" who corrected everything to perfection.
-Review Snippet Sources: Yelp, Google Reviews
Reviews consistently describe pricing as reasonable, great, or competitive. Ruby emphasizes "The price was amazing" while praising the crew's transformation of her green house to alabaster. Ada specifically mentions "very competitive pricing" in addition to professional service. Multiple reviews use the tags "Reasonable price" and "Great price" when rating the company, suggesting customers feel they receive strong value for the quality delivered.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Cleanup receives frequent mentions as a standout feature. Paula describes how after Ron and Henry painted ceilings, walls, doors and trim, everything looked "bright and beautiful" with no mess. Geralyn emphasizes "No paint mess. Beautiful clean up" after Don and Beto completed their interior work. Mark notes the crew "left our rooms clean and looking new" after completing ceiling work. This consistent cleanup pattern appears across different crew combinations and project types.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Updated: 04-07-2026