Don and Beto. Richard and Bill. Nick, Tim, Kenny, Fernando. Read through Garner's reviews and you stop seeing a faceless company and start recognizing a roster. The same painters turn up by name across hundreds of reviews, a pattern the Chooz Score's in-house crews component tracks directly, since a company that keeps its people on staff instead of rotating subcontractors leaves the same names on job after job.
That consistency isn't just cosmetic. One homeowner described a house last painted back in 2014 that needed serious prep, with two-man teams pressure washing, sanding, and priming before the final two coats ever went on. Another customer noted plainly that there were no subcontractors here, unlike the shady outfits he'd hired before. It's the kind of crew loyalty that earned full marks on the Chooz Score, and it's why so many reviewers ask for the same painters again by name.
"Our painting team, Brandon, Carl, Tim, & Kenny, working as 2-men teams on different days, performed their assigned tasks consistently in a superior manner." - judy norris, Google Review
Roger Owens has hired Garner's for 14 years, and he isn't the exception. Read enough of these reviews and a rhythm emerges, where people don't just hire Garner's once, they come back, and then they tell a neighbor. Cindy Rosado calls them "as always" the most trustworthy company she has used. Anna Roberts noted it was her second time and she had been pleased both. Ceferino Lopez said Garner's has been to his home multiple times and he will keep calling.
What's telling is how ordinary the loyalty sounds in their own words. Nobody's overselling. They just keep hiring the same painters, year after year, and mention it almost in passing.
"We have used Garner's Painting for 14 years. They are always on time and the work is excellent." - Roger O., Google Review
What stands out about Garner's reputation isn't only the rating, it's how current it is. The last time we ran our Chooz Score analysis, this Fayetteville painting business carried a 4.9-star rating across over 350 Google reviews, with the overwhelming majority sitting at five stars. More striking, more than 40 of those reviews landed in the trailing three months, a sign of a company actively on the job right now rather than one coasting on old praise. Garner's earned a Chooz Score of 88.2%.
The picture holds up beyond Google. Garner's is Accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2008, comes in at 100% recommended on Facebook, and operates as a registered North Carolina business entity, No. 0823451. It's a family painting operation that has worked the Fayetteville area for decades, and the paper trail backs up what the reviews already say.
"One of the best painting contractors I've worked with in a long time. Super professional, and great work." - nate A., Google Review
The painting itself earns near-universal praise, but a handful of reviewers describe a different experience once the contract was signed, with calls harder to return and touch-ups slow to get scheduled. It's the one theme that surfaces more than once, and the owner's replies to those reviews didn't always resolve it. Worth raising before you start. Ask them directly: "Once we've agreed on the work, who is my point of contact, and how do you handle scheduling any touch-ups or punch-list items after the main job is done?"
"Poor communication. Hard to get hold of after you agree to hire. Would not recommend because of this. On the other hand, painters did an excellent job." - Mary Ann P., Google Review
100% Recommended (9 Reviews)
Want us to do the work for you and find you the best painting contractor?
Get StartedFREE SERVICECrew members get called out by name in Erazo's reviews, and it's always the same names. Armando leads. Christian and Junior work alongside him, project after project, and customers refer to them the way they'd refer to a neighbor. The Chooz Score's in-house crews component picks up on exactly this pattern: the same names recur across separate reviews, which is what happens when a company keeps its painters on staff instead of rotating subcontractors through. One coastal homeowner had the team paint, hang a new shiplap ceiling, rework a shower, and swap out light fixtures on a single job, and still described them as detail oriented from the first day to the last. That range, painting plus carpentry plus finish work, tends to come from a tight team that has worked together for years.
"Armando, Christian, and crew are fantastic at their craft. Painting, putting up a new shiplap ceiling, creating a new shower environment, light fixtures, and pretty much anything else we ask of them. Very friendly, very prompt, detail oriented, and follow through on their work." - Carol C., Google Review
If you've ever hired a painter, liked the work, then had to start the whole search over the next time, this is the part that will stand out. Erazo's customers don't restart. They call back. High marks on the Chooz Score's customer retention indicators line up with what the reviews say out loud: people mention returning for a second job, a bigger job, a different property. One homeowner wrote about hiring the team for two separate projects, one large and one small, and made clear the next call was already coming. The signal repeats in different words, "will hire again soon," "will definitely use their service again," the quiet proof that the first project went right.
"These guys do a fantastic job. I don't normally recommend people but I have used them on two separate jobs. One was a very large project and another somewhat smaller. Both were finished professionally and in a timely manner. I'll definitely be using Erazo's on future projects." - Donald B., Google Review
Founded in 2004. Two decades on the North Carolina coast, and the record hasn't slipped. What stood out to us was the consistency: at the time of our analysis, Erazo's held a perfect 5.0-star rating across more than a dozen Google reviews, plus a matching perfect 5.0 across a dozen reviews on Angi, with not a single negative review on any platform we checked. The company earned a Chooz Score of 84.2%. Behind the ratings sits a real paper trail, too: Erazo's is a registered North Carolina LLC with over 20 years in business, serving Supply, Shallotte, Oak Island, and the rest of the Brunswick County coast.
"Excellent professionalism and compliance in everything. Highly recommended. Very good human and technical team." - Dulce M., Google Review
Every painter listed on this page has been evaluated using the Chooz multi-step quality process. We combine data analysis with human review to identify companies that consistently deliver strong results for property owners in Saint Pauls, NC.
The Chooz Score is a 100-point rating built on platform reviews, review quality and engagement, website and digital presence, and business authority and operations. We use the same scoring framework nationwide while evaluating each contractor's performance specifically within Saint Pauls, NC.