Best Painters Near South Toms River, NJ Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving South Toms River, NJ have earned strong reputations through consistent quality and personal attention to every project. Homeowners across Ocean County praise these companies for reliable communication, skilled crews, and results that exceed expectations.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Richard K. Moore Professional Painting had over 150 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating. This company earned a Chooz Score of 91.9% and has been serving the area for over 40 years since 1985. Owner Rich and office manager Diane handle every project personally, from the initial estimate to the final walkthrough. What stands out in the reviews is how many customers become repeat clients. It's common to see reviewers mention this is their second, third, or even fourth time hiring the company. If you want a family-run business where the owners stay hands-on throughout your project, Richard K. Moore is an excellent choice.

Reviews consistently highlight specific crew members by name. Painters like Marty, Tommy, Brian, and John receive individual praise for their skill and professionalism. Several customers describe how Rich uses a color scanner to match existing paint colors exactly, which proves especially helpful when touching up older work or coordinating with existing finishes.

• Named crew members Marty, Tommy, Brian, Rich, and John receive consistent individual praise across reviews
• Over 80 reviews on Angi with a 5.0-star rating in addition to Google presence
• Customers frequently mention Diane's responsiveness and personal touch when scheduling
• Benjamin Moore paint used exclusively, which reviewers note for long-lasting results

"Rich Moore and his crew are skilled professionals who come in prepared and clean up when they leave. Diane is so nice to deal with on the phone and in person. He has painted almost every room in my house and we are not done yet!" - Jody Grant, Google Review

Customers consistently mention the same thing about ProEdge Painting: thorough prep work and results that look like new construction. They've earned a Chooz Score of 87.9% with over 165 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Chris Fernandez stays involved in every project and is frequently mentioned by name in reviews. If you need work done quickly without sacrificing quality, ProEdge delivers impressive turnaround times.

What sets ProEdge apart is their ability to handle complex projects at scale. One customer described having 16 painters in their home to finish a job before moving day. Beyond painting, the company handles popcorn ceiling removal, cabinet refinishing, and flooring installation. Reviewers with older homes frequently mention how ProEdge made 40-year-old walls look flawless after proper spackling and prep work.

• 100% recommended on Facebook and 5.0 stars on Yelp
• Cabinet refinishing praised repeatedly, with customers noting results look factory-fresh
• Projects frequently completed ahead of schedule, sometimes finishing two-day jobs in one day

"I am a bit of a perfectionist, so I was looking to hire a team who would execute the work flawlessly. Somehow, Chris and the team did perfect work. I couldn't find a single flaw when they were done." - Kelli Loebs, Google Review

With strong roots in Monmouth and Ocean counties, Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting rounds out the top contractors in South Toms River, NJ with a Chooz Score of 85.5%. Jaime and his team handle both painting and broader renovation work, making them a good fit for homeowners who need multiple services coordinated under one contractor. If you're updating a kitchen, bathroom, or entire home and want painting integrated with other improvements, Jaime's team can manage the full scope.

Looking through the reviews, repeat customers appear frequently. Multiple homeowners describe using Jaime for several projects over the years, from interior painting to deck replacement to bathroom remodels. The crew receives consistent praise for showing up on time every day and cleaning up thoroughly at the end of each workday.

• Full renovation services including flooring, molding, and fixture installation alongside painting
• Customers praise Jaime's communication and quick response to text messages
• Multiple reviewers describe the crew as polite, friendly, and respectful of their homes
• Fair pricing mentioned repeatedly, with no hidden fees or surprise charges

"From start to finish, the process was seamless, professional, and stress-free. They were punctual, detail-oriented, and respectful of our home, going above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect." - Kaela DiBella, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Painting contractors in South Toms River, NJ consistently receive praise for delivering exceptional quality and attention to detail. Richard K. Moore Professional Painting customers frequently describe work that exceeds expectations, with one noting "The team of Marty and Rich were professional, neat and courteous. I love the work they did!" Another homeowner shared "Rich painted our exam rooms and did a wonderful job. He scheduled this job quickly and showed up on time, completed job as expected. No supervision needed." The company's use of Benjamin Moore paint and careful prep work contribute to results that customers describe as flawless.

ProEdge Painting earns similar recognition for craftsmanship that makes homes look brand new. One customer reported "This is the best paint job I ever had done. He goes above and beyond. My family room came out amazing. It looks like brand new construction." Another reviewer with a 100-year-old craftsman home noted "The amount of trim we had was overwhelming and the team made it look flawless and really upgrade our space." Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting receives praise for thorough work on challenging projects, with one customer sharing "My house was in need of tremendous work. I had seams that were way off and broken. Some rooms were neglected for many years. After Jamie and team came in they look virtually brand new."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Punctuality and efficient scheduling stand out as consistent strengths among South Toms River, NJ painting contractors. Richard K. Moore Professional Painting customers frequently mention the team arriving exactly when promised. One reviewer noted "They arrived and finished the work on time as per their commitment." Another customer praised "Both Brian and Mike arrived on time and promptly set up and began painting. They were professional, quality work, finishing in a timely manner." The company's ability to accommodate tight timelines shows up repeatedly, with one homeowner sharing that they prioritized a job to finish before a move-in date.

ProEdge Painting has built a reputation for fast turnarounds without cutting corners. One customer with a 2,250 square foot home and high ceilings reported the job was completed in three days as promised, with 16 painters showing up on the final day to ensure the deadline was met before moving trucks arrived. Another reviewer shared "ProEdge moves fast! The day after Chris sent me my quote, he sent a crew to complete the job." Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting receives similar praise for reliability, with customers noting "They were always on time every day till the job got done" and "One of the things that stood out most was their punctuality, every single day, the crew arrived right on time, just as promised."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Clear communication and professional conduct appear throughout reviews for painting contractors serving South Toms River, NJ. Richard K. Moore Professional Painting stands out for the personal involvement of owners Rich and Diane. One customer shared "From the first phone call with Diane to having the job done was a total pleasure. Diane was very friendly and professional." The company responds to every Google review personally, and customers consistently mention how questions are answered promptly. Another reviewer noted "Rich & Diane provide a custom experience to all of their clients. I felt so badly about wanting to change the color I had chosen after the first room was painted, but when I asked if I could, they were so accommodating!"

ProEdge Painting customers praise owner Chris Fernandez for clear communication throughout projects. One homeowner reported "Chris addressed my every concern and was extremely patient with me, and I was not easy to please." The company's responsiveness shows up in multiple reviews, with customers noting quick turnaround on quotes and flexibility when project needs change. Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting earns recognition for keeping customers informed, with one reviewer sharing "Most outstanding in our dealing with Jaime is his communication. He responded within minutes." Another customer noted "Jaime was prompt with all communication. All of his staff were not only polite and friendly but also very neat."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Thorough cleanup and careful prep work receive consistent praise from homeowners in South Toms River, NJ. Richard K. Moore Professional Painting customers frequently mention how the crew protects furniture and leaves spaces spotless. One reviewer noted "They covered everything so that no paint or dust would get on anything in my home. They were very thorough and the job was done to our full satisfaction." Another customer shared "Can't say enough good things about Richard's crew. Clean, professional, thorough, on time. Everything you'd want in a painter and his crew." The attention to protecting belongings shows up repeatedly, with one homeowner noting the team even hung pictures back in place after finishing.

ProEdge Painting earns similar recognition for leaving homes cleaner than they found them. One customer reported "When the project is done, you'd never know they were there. They'll leave your home cleaner than when they came." Another reviewer with an older home praised how the team "cleaned up every night after themselves, a rarity with a lot of hired help we've had." Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting customers note the crew cleans up thoroughly at the end of each day, with one sharing "The men were very professional and cleaned up each and every time they left." Another homeowner praised "They took care to protect our floors and furniture and cleaned up after themselves."

~Review Snippet Sources: Google