Top-Rated Painters South Toms River, NJ (Chooz Score Ranked)
Showing 3 painters servicing South Toms River, NJ
About
With well over 150 five-star Google reviews and a flawless 5.0 rating across all platforms, ProEdge Painting has established itself as Ocean County's most consistently praised painting contractor since 2018. Owner Chris Fernandez leads a team that has transformed hundreds of Toms River, Brick, Manchester, and Jackson properties through their distinctive blend of speed, precision, and remarkable attention to detail.
The company specializes in comprehensive residential transformations, from intricate cabinet refinishing that breathes new life into dated kitchens to the challenging task of popcorn ceiling removal that modernizes entire homes. Their expertise extends to complete interior and exterior painting projects, deck and fence staining, and even light carpentry work including flooring installation. What distinguishes ProEdge is their ability to compress typical project timelines without sacrificing quality – multiple reviews describe entire houses painted in just three days, with crews of up to 16 painters mobilizing when deadlines demand it.
Beyond technical skill, ProEdge has built its reputation on reliability that customers find refreshingly rare in the contracting world. Crews arrive precisely when promised, send morning confirmation texts, and protect every surface before beginning work. The team's commitment to leaving properties "cleaner than when they arrived" appears repeatedly in reviews, alongside praise for their willingness to accommodate last-minute additions and picky furniture placement requests. Fully licensed (#13VH09970800), insured, and bonded, ProEdge serves the greater Ocean County area from their Toms River base, offering what customers consistently describe as exceptional value – professional craftsmanship at prices that frequently undercut competitors by significant margins.
Want us to do the work for you and find you the best painting contractor?
Get StartedFREE SERVICEJaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting
About Jaime's Renovation LLC Professional Painting
When Kaela DiBella needed her home painted with minimal disruption, Jaime's Renovation LLC completed the job so seamlessly she called the process "incredible" and immediately began recommending them to family and friends. This balance of speed without compromising quality defines how Jaime Villanueva operates his painting and renovation business from a modest shop on Norwood Avenue, understanding that behind every project timeline is a family eager to reclaim their space or a business losing revenue during renovations.
The numbers tell one story: over 150 Google reviews averaging 4.9 stars, projects ranging from $500 touch-ups to complete commercial transformations like their featured work on FOX's Kitchen Nightmares at Max's Bar. But the reviews reveal something different. A contractor who protects furniture without being asked, who stays late Friday to ensure families have their kitchens for the weekend, who sends morning confirmation texts so customers never wonder where their crew is. These aren't services advertised on their simple website; they're simply how Jaime's team of fully insured professionals has operated for over twenty years.
What's notably absent speaks volumes: no BBB accreditation, minimal web presence beyond Google, no Angi listing despite being in business since the early 2000s. Yet Jeffrey Spitzer recommends them "1000%," and multiple customers describe experiences that exceeded expectations with work that made neglected rooms look "virtually brand new." From their unassuming Long Branch location, Jaime has built something that operates more on trust than marketing, where EPA RRP-certified crews handle everything from delicate cabinet refinishing to complete bathroom transformations, creating relationships where customers like Deb Reilly still call after ten years because, as she notes, he was her "first customer" and the trust never wavered.
Richard K. Moore Professional Painting
About Richard K. Moore Professional Painting
When Nancy Remini needed her Long Beach Island house painted after two decades of using the same contractor, she didn't expect Rich Moore to make the trip. But he did, tackling extensive prep work on a weathered shore property that would make most contractors decline the job. Twenty years of trust earned through consistent performance. That timeline reveals something most painting companies never achieve: customers who call back not just for touch-ups, but for entirely new properties, second homes, family members' projects.
The numbers tell a surface story. Over 145 Google reviews averaging 5.0 stars. Forty years operating from a Freehold Township base since 1985. Licensed with NJ Division of Consumer Affairs (13VH04229900), EPA Lead-Safe certified. But the Google reviews expose patterns that paint catalogs can't capture. A contractor who texts morning confirmations unprompted. Painters who rehang artwork without being asked. Crews that arrive with M&Ms at estimates, not just to sweeten deals but because Rich and Diane Moore genuinely enjoy the human side of home improvement. When a customer notices one missed spot and calls, Rich doesn't schedule a callback. He's in his truck immediately.
What's missing is equally revealing. No BBB accreditation despite a verified license. Facebook page with 148 followers but virtually no reviews. One lonely Yelp review. This is not a company built on digital marketing sophistication. Instead, customers like Leonard Gray write unprompted essays about painters who need no masking tape for cutting, who clean obsessively, who complete complex cathedral ceiling beam work with flawless lines. His son hired them for a million-dollar Millstone home first, setting expectations sky-high. Rich and his team (Marty, John, Tommy, Brian) met them anyway, project after project, customer after customer, year after year.
