3 Best Painters Near Anthony, NM Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Anthony, NM and the surrounding southern New Mexico region have access to several well-reviewed painting contractors with strong track records across multiple platforms. These companies consistently earn praise for their attention to detail, professionalism, and willingness to go the extra mile on both interior and exterior projects.

New Mexico's Painting Specialists leads with a Chooz Score of 89.5%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 65 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp and 100% recommended on Facebook. They also hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. What stands out in their reviews is the number of customers who describe whole-home projects completed in remarkably short timeframes - multiple reviewers mention entire interiors painted in a single day. If you're looking for a family-owned company that can handle large-scale projects efficiently, this is a strong choice.

Owners Eddie Gaxiola and Mandi Loudenback run a tight operation with three generations of painting expertise in the family. Customers frequently comment on how comfortable they feel leaving the crew to work unsupervised, and several mention using the company for multiple projects over the years.

• Multiple reviewers describe receiving same-day or next-day estimates with no pressure sales tactics
• Commercial clients note the crew's ability to work around business hours without disrupting operations
• Several customers highlight the crew's willingness to tackle challenging repairs like grease stains and water damage before painting

"They did such an excellent job! They took their time to ensure everything was done correctly and their attention to detail was outstanding." - FRA Muniz Plumbing & Mechanical LLC, Facebook

With over 9 years in business serving the Las Cruces area, Knight's Painting has built a loyal customer base that keeps coming back. They earned a Chooz Score of 88% with over 110 Google reviews at a 5.0-star rating. Owner Gary Knight takes a hands-on approach that shows in the reviews - he's mentioned by name in the majority of feedback, often praised for explaining the process step by step and checking in daily during projects. If you want an owner who stays personally involved from estimate to final walkthrough, Knight's Painting delivers that experience.

The same crew names appear across years of reviews, including Bear, Eric, Ernesto, and Rene, suggesting genuine employee retention rather than rotating subcontractors. Customers with historic homes specifically praise the team's ability to handle delicate stucco repairs and match existing finishes.

• Repeat customers describe using Knight's for multiple homes and referring family members
• Reviewers mention Gary making unscheduled return visits to address minor touch-ups at no extra charge
• Several note the crew's habit of arriving earlier than scheduled rather than keeping customers waiting

"I'm a super picky person, Gary and his team were amazing! Came not only on time but came earlier than they said. Gary came back after the job was done and checked all the work." - Martha Wilson, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Anthony, NM, Innovative Coatings LLC brings a different strength to the table - speed and responsiveness. They earned a Chooz Score of 85% with over 125 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating. Founded in 2019, owner Josh Santos has built a reputation for quick turnaround times that appeals to homeowners with urgent needs, including insurance-related repairs. If you need a fast estimate and quick project completion, this team consistently delivers.

What makes Innovative Coatings stand out is their versatility. In addition to traditional interior and exterior painting, they handle roof coatings, cabinet refinishing, and restoration work. Fellow contractors in the Las Cruces area actually refer clients to Josh, which speaks to his reputation among peers.

• Multiple customers describe receiving same-day quotes followed by next-day project starts
• Reviewers mention Josh personally explaining what work is needed and why, creating trust through transparency
• Several note using the company for three or four separate projects, indicating work that holds up over time

"Santos and his team exceeded my expectations. Very professional crew. Finished before the expected finish date and had my house looking brand new." - Gabriel Montoya, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality and attention to detail are the most frequently mentioned themes in reviews for painting contractors serving Anthony, NM. Customers across all three top-rated companies describe finished results that exceed their expectations, with particular praise for careful prep work that ensures paint adheres properly and lasts longer.

New Mexico's Painting Specialists receives consistent feedback about their texturing abilities, with customers noting flawless blending between new and existing surfaces. "The quality of the paintwork and especially the texturing is amazing," notes Amy Ames in a Google review. Knight's Painting earns similar praise, particularly for historic home restorations where matching original finishes requires genuine skill. "Very professional, on time, quality work and very accommodating if you want to make changes," shares Katrina Sonniksen. Innovative Coatings LLC rounds out the quality marks with reviewers highlighting their cabinet refinishing work - Israel Valenzuela describes how "the quality and attention to detail is what really stood out to me." Across all companies, reviewers consistently mention that the finished product looks even better than they imagined.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp

Professionalism and communication rank as the second most common theme in reviews for Anthony, NM area painters. Customers value contractors who explain the process clearly, respond promptly to questions, and maintain a respectful presence in their homes.

Knight's Painting owner Gary Knight sets the standard here - reviewers describe him answering questions thoroughly, providing detailed estimates with photos, and checking in daily during projects. "Gary explained the process and answered my questions. He made suggestions I didn't even think about," writes Cheryl in a Google review. New Mexico's Painting Specialists earns praise for their friendly crew members, with Teri Farley noting they're "friendly, efficient, detail oriented professionals." Innovative Coatings LLC owner Josh Santos personally handles estimates and takes time to explain what work is needed and why. Antonio Gonzalez describes how Josh "broke it down for me what was needed and why it was needed." All three companies respond to the majority of their online reviews with personalized messages, another sign of their commitment to communication.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Timeliness and punctuality appear frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Anthony, NM. Customers consistently report crews arriving when promised, with several noting painters showed up early rather than making them wait.

Knight's Painting receives particular praise for their punctuality, with Martha Wilson noting the team "came not only on time but came earlier than they said." Supervisor Ernesto and his crew reportedly arrive at 7:00 AM sharp and work efficiently throughout the day. Innovative Coatings LLC stands out for fast project completion - Israel Valenzuela describes them as "fast and friendly while providing the best and smooth customer experience." Gabriel Montoya adds that they "finished before the expected finish date." New Mexico's Painting Specialists impresses customers with their efficiency on large projects, with multiple reviewers describing whole-home interiors completed in a single day. Across all companies, reviewers appreciate that schedules are kept and deadlines are met.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value and pricing receive positive mentions across reviews for Anthony, NM painting contractors. Customers describe receiving detailed estimates upfront and finding the final costs reasonable for the quality of work delivered.

New Mexico's Painting Specialists earns praise for affordability, with Kim Nguyen calling them "super affordable and professional." Cindy Carroll adds that "their pricing was phenomenal." Knight's Painting customers describe Gary Knight's estimates as thorough and transparent, with Cheryl noting "the price I felt was very reasonable." Innovative Coatings LLC receives similar feedback about their pricing structure - Israel Valenzuela shares that "the price was really good for the quality of work they provided" while Leo P mentions "very friendly staff and great prices." Customers across all three companies note that quotes matched final invoices with no surprise upcharges.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and preparation work earn consistent praise in reviews for Anthony, NM area painters. Customers appreciate crews who protect furniture and flooring, maintain tidy work areas, and leave homes spotless when the job is complete.

Knight's Painting stands out for cleanliness, with Ruben Fernandez calling them "the cleanest most professional service I have experienced in my entire life." The crew's quality control process includes supervisor Rene inspecting work and marking any areas needing attention with blue tape before sign-off. New Mexico's Painting Specialists receives similar praise, with Amy Ames noting they "kept everything clean and left my kitchen looking flawless." Innovative Coatings LLC earns feedback about clean work habits as well - Joseph Rawls describes their work as "very clean and professional." All three companies demonstrate that professional painting involves more than just applying paint, with careful prep work and thorough cleanup being standard practice.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google