3 Best Painters Near Dover Plains, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Dover Plains, NY and the surrounding Harlem Valley area have access to several highly rated painting contractors who consistently earn praise for reliable scheduling, clean job sites, and finished results that exceed expectations. Whether you need interior walls freshened up, cabinets refinished, or a full exterior overhaul, these companies have built strong reputations across multiple review platforms.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Ryan's Painting had over 110 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. They earned a Chooz Score of 88.6%, the highest among contractors serving the Dover Plains, NY area. Owner Ryan Clarkin runs the operation out of New Windsor and covers Orange and Dutchess Counties, offering interior and exterior painting, staining, drywall, and carpentry. If you are looking for a contractor who handles everything from color consultation to drywall repair and hardware updates in one visit, Ryan's Painting is a good choice.

What stands out in the reviews is how many customers describe Ryan helping them pick colors that work together. Multiple homeowners mention that Ryan adjusted their palette choices and offered alternatives they had not considered. Crew members like Dave, Jonathan, and Cesar appear across different projects over several months, suggesting a stable team rather than rotating subcontractors. The company also holds 5.0 stars on Angi with over 30 reviews, is 100% recommended on Facebook, and carries 5.0 stars on Yelp.

• Several customers hired Ryan's Painting after getting multiple quotes and chose them for competitive pricing combined with a clear explanation of the process
• Homeowners with older properties praise the crew for catching hidden issues like leaks or wall damage before they became bigger problems
• Repeat customers mention returning for additional rooms or switching from interior to exterior projects with the same crew

"Ryan was easy to work with and professional. His crew did a fantastic job painting, caulking and sealing where the office walls needed. Would 100% hire again." - Dan Casella, Google Review

With over 19 years in business, Firefly Painting Inc takes a detail-first approach that shows up clearly in their reviews. They earned a Chooz Score of 83.9% with over 85 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Matt Mason brings over 30 years of hands-on painting experience, and the company is 100% recommended on Facebook. If you have a project that requires careful surface preparation on older walls, cabinet refinishing, or work on a home with historical details, Firefly Painting Inc is a good fit.

Customers frequently mention Matt and crew member John by name, describing them as a reliable pair who show up on time and keep the workspace clean throughout the day. Several reviewers note that Matt provided detailed written proposals before starting, which set clear expectations for scope and pricing. The company specializes in interior work across Dutchess County and is based in Poughkeepsie.

• Multiple homeowners describe Matt helping them select colors and even hardware for cabinet projects, going beyond just the paint work
• Reviewers with complex projects like wallpaper removal and plaster repair praise the patience and thoroughness of the prep work
• Several customers mention being referred by their realtor when purchasing a new home in the area

"First off, 5 stars does not nearly begin to capture the overwhelming satisfaction I have with the work that Matt and his team have completed in my new home." - A Meyer, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Dover Plains, NY, Certified Painting LLC has built a loyal following in the Mid-Hudson Valley. They earned a Chooz Score of 82.6% with over 100 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Brian Shannon left a career in middle school teaching in 2021 to pursue painting full-time, and his small team - including painters Caitlin, Gavin, and Charlie - gets called out by name across dozens of reviews. The company is also 100% recommended on Facebook. If you want a hands-on owner who personally manages every project from estimate to final walkthrough, Certified Painting LLC is a solid option.

A pattern that appears often in the reviews is Brian sending photos to out-of-state or out-of-town homeowners to keep them updated on progress. Customers also describe receiving highly detailed written quotes that break down every aspect of the work. The team handles everything from deck staining and porch restoration to full interior repaints and cabinet refinishing, with several reviewers noting successful work on homes built before 1920.

• Property managers and homeowners with historic estates specifically praise the crew for handling difficult surfaces like old plaster, wood paneling, and multi-layer paint removal
• Brian is described as patient with indecisive customers, offering samples and returning to adjust colors until the homeowner is satisfied
• Multiple reviewers mention finishing ahead of schedule, with some large projects wrapping up days earlier than quoted

"We hired Brian to resurface and repaint our bathroom. The previous owner had removed wallpaper and left the surface full of imperfections. He skim coated it and recommended a paint from Ben Moore. Caitlin painted it. The finished product is absolutely beautiful." - susan sanderson, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Professionalism and communication are two of the most frequently praised qualities across painting contractor reviews in the Dover Plains, NY area. Homeowners consistently describe contractors who respond quickly to initial inquiries, provide clear written estimates, and stay in touch throughout the project. Ryan's Painting earns frequent mentions for owner Ryan Clarkin personally handling the estimate process and being easy to reach by phone or text. "Ryan was responsive when we first reached out and answered all of our questions, explaining the process." - Diana Tantalos, Google Review. Certified Painting LLC owner Brian Shannon is described by several customers as someone who communicates directly rather than through office staff, with one reviewer noting that no text went unanswered within the hour it was sent.

Firefly Painting Inc also stands out for communication, with owner Matt Mason and his wife Sarah both handling customer outreach. Reviewers appreciate receiving detailed proposals that spell out exactly what the job will include. "Matt and Sarah do a fantastic job of communicating with their customers. This is the 4th time I've had Matt and John do work at my house." - Mark Webber, Google Review. Across all three companies, customers note that the painters show up on time, introduce themselves, and keep the homeowner informed about daily progress and any issues that arise. "Throughout the entire process, Brian, Caitlin, and Gavin collaborated closely with us. They provided valuable input and brought large samples to help us make color choices." - Michelle Harris, Google Review. For homeowners in Dover Plains, NY who value clear and responsive communication, these contractors set a high standard.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Cleanup and preparation are among the most commonly praised aspects of painting contractors serving Dover Plains, NY. Reviewers across all three top-rated companies describe crews that protect furniture, cover floors, and leave the workspace clean at the end of each day rather than waiting until the project is complete. Ryan's Painting customers frequently use words like "neat" and "organized" to describe the crew. "They were very neat, cleaning up at the end of each day. We barely knew they were here." - J Weatherstone, Google Review. Several homeowners mention that the painters moved furniture carefully and replaced everything exactly as it was found.

Prep work also gets significant attention in the reviews. Certified Painting LLC customers describe extensive surface preparation including skim coating, plaster repair, and multiple coats of primer before any paint is applied. "I was so impressed with the detailed prep work he did to keep our home clean throughout. Drop cloths everywhere, tape on every edge." - Monica Enright, Google Review. Firefly Painting Inc earns similar praise, with reviewers noting that crew member John is especially careful with surface preparation on older homes. "Matt and John were friendly and did careful work. They also kept the work area very clean." - Steve Saslow, Google Review. For homeowners in Dover Plains, NY who worry about the mess that comes with a painting project, these contractors consistently deliver clean, well-protected work areas.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value and fair pricing come up frequently in reviews for painting contractors serving Dover Plains, NY. Homeowners do not describe bargain-basement prices, but rather competitive quotes that reflect quality work and thorough preparation. Ryan's Painting customers often mention comparing multiple estimates and choosing Ryan for the combination of fair pricing and clear communication. "Ryan was the best quote I had received for painting our house. He was able to squeeze us in earlier as well." - Debbie Williams, Google Review. Other reviewers describe the pricing as "very reasonable" and note that budgets were respected with no surprise charges at the end of the project.

Certified Painting LLC customers similarly highlight Brian Shannon's detailed written quotes, which break down every step so homeowners know exactly what they are paying for. "His price was competitive and he quoted a price that we think very fair. They showed up on time and did what they said they would." - Barb C, Google Review. Firefly Painting Inc reviewers note that Matt's proposals are among the most transparent they have received, with one customer explaining that while the quote was neither the cheapest nor the most expensive, it was the most detailed. Across all three companies, customers in the Dover Plains, NY area describe getting strong value for their investment, with finished results that justify the cost.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Painting contractors serving Dover Plains, NY handle a wide range of residential projects, from single-room refreshes to full interior and exterior overhauls. Ryan's Painting covers interior and exterior painting, deck and fence staining, drywall repair, cabinet painting, and even light carpentry like crown molding installation. Reviewers describe projects ranging from kitchen cabinet refinishing with hardware updates to painting the exterior of homes over 100 years old. "We hired Ryan's Painting to paint the interior of our home, walls, all trim, and ceiling. A big job! They repaired holes and damage and skim coated the ceiling." - J Weatherstone, Google Review. Ryan's Painting has also handled commercial work, including a church sanctuary painting project.

Firefly Painting Inc specializes in interior painting and cabinet refinishing, with customers praising their work on kitchen cabinets, bathroom vanities, and wallpaper removal. Several reviewers with historic homes note that Matt's team handled plaster imperfections and ornate trim with care. Certified Painting LLC covers a similar scope, with notable projects including deck staining, porch floor refinishing, exterior painting on homes from the 1700s and 1930s, and complete interior repaints of large colonials. "Brian and his team did an amazing job prepping and painting our circa 1938 home. It wasn't an easy task - lots of mature bushes, trees, a steep hillside, tricky gables." - Arthur T. Rollin, Google Review. Whether you have a small touch-up or a full-scale renovation in Dover Plains, NY, these contractors have the experience to handle it.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google