Firefly Painting Inc
About Firefly Painting Inc
Serving Dutchess County's mix of historic homes and newer construction, Firefly Painting Inc has built a steady presence as a residential and light commercial painting contractor based in Poughkeepsie. Owner Matt Mason brings over 30 years of professional painting experience to every project, having run the business full-time for over 19 years.
The company focuses primarily on interior residential painting, with considerable expertise in cabinet refinishing, wallpaper removal, and drywall repair. Firefly also accepts a limited number of exterior projects depending on scope. Color guidance is part of Matt's estimate process, with multiple customers crediting his knowledge for their final paint and finish selections.
The fully insured team (general liability and workers compensation) consists of full-time employed professional painters, not subcontractors. Matt works alongside longtime crew member John on most projects, with Sarah managing scheduling and ongoing client communication. Based in Poughkeepsie, the company serves the Dutchess County area including Beacon, Wappingers Falls, Hyde Park, Red Hook, Millbrook, and surrounding communities.
Updated: 02-20-2026
Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Firefly Painting Inc
Q: Why do customers consistently mention Firefly Painting Inc's cleanup process?
Daily end-of-day cleanup is a pattern across multiple reviews. Catherine Varunok notes the crew left her home "very clean" at the end of each day, and Alexandria Williams describes how the team "cleaned up beautifully every day" over a three-day project. A Meyer confirms no mess throughout a two-week job. Mark Webber praises the respect shown "for you as a customer and making sure the house is protected."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What has kept customers coming back to Firefly Painting Inc for years at a time?
Several reviews document long-term repeat relationships. Reviewer bermuda notes using Firefly Painting Inc for 18 years, describing Matt as "professional and detailed oriented" with work that consistently comes out "beautiful." Mark Webber's review marks his fourth project with the company, and Amy Thrasher identifies herself as a repeat client, adding she would "strongly recommend Firefly and would use them again."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Firefly Painting Inc approach cabinet refinishing projects?
Cabinet refinishing is a featured specialty with multiple reviews documenting the finished results. Julianne Graffam describes the outcome as "like new" and credits the team with helping select colors and hardware. Catherine Varunok had kitchen cabinets painted alongside wooden door staining and a front door refinish, calling Firefly Painting Inc "the utmost professional company." The gallery at fireflypainting.com documents several completed cabinet transformations using Benjamin Moore finishes.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: What does the estimate and communication process look like with Firefly Painting Inc?
The estimate process earns praise across multiple reviews. A Meyer describes Matt as the only contractor who "asked questions" during quoting, going so far as to research similar homes and sketch a floor plan by hand before arriving on site. Pat Boerman calls every step from "initial contact with questions, to detailed quotes, scheduling, prep, painting, and clean up" excellent. Mark Webber adds that "Matt and Sarah do a fantastic job of communicating with their customers."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Do reviews show Firefly Painting Inc uses its own crew or subcontractors?
Reviews consistently name the same crew members across years, consistent with the company's confirmed employment of full-time painters. Matt Mason and John appear together in reviews spanning 2024 through 2026. Alfredo names "Matt, John and Tom" and describes them as exceeding expectations in every way. Tammy Maier, a multi-year client, calls the crew consistently "timely, friendly and trustworthy," adding that "the guys that work for them are great."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How does Firefly Painting Inc handle older or historically significant homes?
Older homes with distinctive architectural features are a recurring context in reviews. A Meyer, the owner of a historic home with "an excessive amount of nooks, crannies, historical features, and very tall ceilings," describes Matt researching comparable properties and sketching a floor plan by hand before arriving. Surface imperfections throughout the two-week project were addressed before painting began. Pamela Van Tuyl describes Matt and John as "craftsmen" and praises their knowledge and care from start to finish.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: Does Firefly Painting Inc take on commercial projects alongside residential work?
Light commercial work is accepted on a selective basis alongside the company's primary residential focus. Dave Stewart, a decade-long client who has used Firefly Painting Inc in both his home and business, describes a recent exterior commercial building transformation as a "TOTAL transformation in a week." He credits the result as "THE BEST Hands down" and names both Matt and Jonathan. Customers with commercial projects are encouraged to contact the company to discuss scope.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Q: How do customers describe the value of hiring Firefly Painting Inc?
Pricing comes up favorably across multiple reviews from customers who gathered multiple quotes. A Meyer, after contacting several contractors, describes Firefly Painting Inc's pricing as "neither the least nor most expensive, but was 100% the most transparent." Bonnie Faughnan, who has hired many contractors over nearly 40 years of homeownership, calls the team "very reasonably priced." JC sums up the experience with "the reviews online do not lie," noting the final results covered more work than originally planned.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Updated: 02-20-2026