This is an image from Firefly Painting Inc, located in Colorado. The logo for Firefly Painting Inc features a stylized glowing firefly above gradient green and black text.

Firefly Painting Inc

This is an image from Firefly Painting Inc, located in Colorado. The logo for Firefly Painting Inc features a stylized glowing firefly above gradient green and black text.
Firefly Painting Inc gallery image 1
Firefly Painting Inc gallery image 2
Firefly Painting Inc gallery image 3
Firefly Painting Inc gallery image 4

Chooz Score Insights

Scored by
Cher B.
Ed Anthony D.
April 2026

Built on Loyalty

Nearly two decades of full-time painting builds a client list, but what Firefly Painting Inc has built is something deeper - a base of customers who come back year after year, project after project. The Chooz Score's customer retention indicators scored at the top of the scale: reviewers don't just recommend this company, they describe relationships spanning 5, 10, and even 18 years:

  • One long-term client has hired Firefly Painting Inc for 18 consecutive years, describing results that consistently meet expectations
  • Mark W., on his fourth project with the company, highlights the respect shown to customers and to the home itself throughout every job

"I have used Firefly Painting for 18 years. Matt couldn't be more professional and detailed oriented. He always does an exceptional job and takes so much pride in his work." - bermuda, Google Review

Years of Consistent Results

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Firefly Painting Inc had over 85 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score maintained across every single review. This company earned a Chooz Score of 83.9%. With over 19 years in business and 100% recommended on Facebook, the consistency extends well beyond a single platform:

  • Owner Matt Mason brings over 30 years of hands-on painting experience, with the company incorporated in New York since 2015
  • The Chooz Score's review authenticity indicators are strong: reviewers mention specific project details, crew members by name, and realistic timelines

"In the almost 40 years I've owned my house, I've hired many contractors, but Matt and Firefly Painting stand out. They are a pleasure to have in the house, exhibit exceptional courtesy and attention to detail, and are very reasonably priced." - Bonnie F., Google Review

The Details Matter Here

Crew members like John get called out by name across multiple reviews for meticulous prep work, clean edges, and careful attention to trim and architectural details. Customers with complex projects - cabinet refinishing, wallpaper removal, historic homes with tall ceilings and ornate features - consistently describe results that exceed expectations:

  • Multiple reviewers praise surface preparation as thorough and deliberate, with imperfections addressed before any painting begins
  • Cabinet refinishing earns specific praise, with customers describing finished results as transformative and crediting the team with guiding color and hardware selection

"Matt was the only one to ask questions! He researched similar homes and drew out a floor plan by hand. The quote was neither the least nor most expensive, but was 100% the most transparent." - A Meyer, Google Review

Find out more about how we Firefly Painting Inc

Worked with this company?

All verified feedback is published, positive or not. Identity and project verified before publication. Direct submissions are unpaid; invited customers may receive a disclosed $50 thank-you that never depends on their answers.

Additional Questions Answered

What keeps customers returning to Firefly Painting Inc for years or even decades at a time?

Long-term relationships define Firefly Painting Inc's client base. Reviewer bermuda has hired the company for 18 consecutive years, describing work that "always comes out beautiful." Mark Webber marks his fourth project with the company, praising consistent respect shown "for you as a customer." Amy Thrasher identifies herself as a repeat client who would "strongly recommend Firefly and would use them again," while Tammy Maier, a multi-year client, calls the team "timely, friendly and trustworthy."

Source: Google Reviews · Reviewed April 2026
Why do customers at Firefly Painting Inc consistently mention the crew's end-of-day cleanup?

Daily cleanup is a documented pattern across multiple reviews. Catherine Varunok notes the crew left her home "very clean" at the end of each day, and Alexandria Williams describes how the team "cleaned up beautifully every day" across a three-day project. A Meyer confirms no mess throughout a two-week job. Mark Webber highlights the respect shown "for you as a customer and making sure the house is protected" from start to finish.

Source: Google Reviews · Reviewed April 2026
How does Firefly Painting Inc approach estimates and client communication?

The estimate process earns praise from customers who gathered multiple quotes. A Meyer describes Matt as the only contractor who "asked questions" during quoting, researching comparable homes and sketching a floor plan by hand before arriving on site. Pat Boerman calls every step from "initial contact with questions, to detailed quotes, scheduling, prep, painting, and clean up" excellent. Mark Webber adds that "Matt and Sarah do a fantastic job of communicating with their customers."

Source: Google Reviews · Reviewed April 2026
What makes Firefly Painting Inc's cabinet refinishing results stand out in customer reviews?

Cabinet refinishing earns specific praise from multiple customers. Julianne Graffam describes the outcome as "like new" and credits the team with guiding her through color and hardware selection. Catherine Varunok had kitchen cabinets painted alongside wooden door staining and a front door refinish, calling Firefly Painting Inc "the utmost professional company." The gallery at fireflypainting.com documents several completed cabinet transformations featuring Benjamin Moore finishes across Dutchess County homes.

Source: Google Reviews · Reviewed April 2026
Does Firefly Painting Inc use its own painters or send subcontractors to customer jobs?

Reviews name the same crew members across multiple years, consistent with the company's use of full-time employed painters. Alfredo names "Matt, John and Tom" and describes them as exceeding expectations in every way. Dave Stewart, a decade-long client, names "Matt and Jonathan" on his most recent project. Tammy Maier, a multi-year client, calls the crew reliably consistent and notes that "the guys that work for them are great."

Source: Google Reviews · Reviewed April 2026
How does Firefly Painting Inc approach older homes with complex architectural features?

Historic Hudson Valley properties with unusual layouts appear repeatedly in reviews. A Meyer, the owner of a historic home with "an excessive amount of nooks, crannies, historical features, and very tall ceilings," describes Matt researching comparable properties and sketching a detailed floor plan before arriving. Surface preparation work throughout the two-week project was addressed before painting began. Pamela Van Tuyl describes Matt and John as "craftsmen" who brought knowledge and care to every aspect of the job.

Source: Google Reviews · Reviewed April 2026
How do customers describe Firefly Painting Inc's pricing after comparing multiple contractor quotes?

Pricing transparency comes up favorably across several reviews from customers who sought multiple bids. A Meyer, after contacting several contractors, describes Firefly Painting Inc's approach as "neither the least nor most expensive, but was 100% the most transparent." Bonnie Faughnan, who has hired contractors for nearly 40 years, calls the team "very reasonably priced." JC notes that "the reviews online do not lie," citing a final result that exceeded the original project scope.

Source: Google Reviews · Reviewed April 2026
Is Firefly Painting Inc licensed and registered in New York State?

New York State does not require a state-level painting contractor license. Firefly Painting Inc is incorporated in New York as a Domestic Business Corporation under DOS ID 4722125, filed with the New York Department of State Division of Corporations on 03/09/2015, with a registered address of 114 N. Grand Ave., Poughkeepsie, NY 12603. Entity status is listed as Active, though the record notes a biennial statement as past due. No Dutchess County municipal painting contractor license requirement applies to this jurisdiction.

-Verification Sources: New York Department of State Division of Corporations - https://apps.dos.ny.gov/publicInquiry/EntityDisplay

How Firefly Painting Inc Was Evaluated

Every painting company listed on Chooz Painters is evaluated using our multi-step quality framework. We combine structured data analysis with human review to understand how Firefly Painting Inc performs across the key signals that matter most to property owners.

How the Chooz Score Works

The Chooz Score is a 100-point rating based on four core pillars:

  • Platform reviews & ratings from sources such as Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi, BBB, and others
  • Review quality & engagement, including depth of customer feedback, photos, and how the company responds to reviews
  • Website and digital presence, which helps indicate professionalism, transparency, and communication quality
  • Business authority & operations, including years in business, licensing, insurance, and other operational standards

Each contractor is evaluated using the same framework nationwide, and the score reflects Firefly Painting Inc’s performance within its local market.

A Chooz Score represents real-world performance, verified signals, and human-reviewed context.

Chooz Score Award Levels

80–86.9: Chooz Certified87–93.9: Top Painter Award94–100: Best Painter Award

Scores are determined through more than 40 evaluation factors across our four pillars.

If you want a deeper explanation of how our scoring system works, you can view the full breakdown on our Chooz Scoring page.