4 Best Painters Near Fishkill, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Fishkill, NY have access to several highly reviewed painting contractors, many of whom have earned strong reputations for reliable work, fair pricing, and attention to detail. Whether you need a full interior refresh, an exterior update, or specialty work like cabinet refinishing or deck staining, the top-rated painters serving the Fishkill area consistently deliver results that earn repeat business and word-of-mouth referrals.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Ryan's Painting had over 110 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating. This New Windsor-based company earned a Chooz Score of 88.6%, with additional ratings including 5.0 stars on Angi with over 30 reviews, 100% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Ryan Clarkin runs the operation personally, handling estimates and staying involved throughout each project. What stands out in the reviews is how often customers mention color guidance - Ryan regularly helps homeowners choose palettes and even talks them through options when they feel unsure. If you have a large interior or exterior project and want a team that communicates clearly from estimate to final walkthrough, Ryan's Painting is a strong choice.

Multiple reviewers describe hiring Ryan's crew for one project and immediately adding more work once they saw the quality. Customers also frequently mention the crew by name, particularly Dave and Jonathan, which speaks to the stability of the team.

• Customers regularly note that Ryan offers helpful color advice, steering them toward combinations that work well together
• Several reviews describe projects completed ahead of schedule, with one customer noting a full interior and exterior job finished in just two days
• Repeat business is common, with homeowners returning for second and third projects after positive experiences

"This has been the most positive experience I have had with a contractor. From my first contact with Ryan, to when his crew just left, the communication and quality of the work could not have been better." - Ann Davison, Google Review

For homeowners who prefer a single painter handling the entire job rather than a rotating crew, Jays Pro Painting LLC offers an owner-operator approach that customers love. Based in Beacon, this company earned a Chooz Score of 86.7% with over 80 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Jay (Jason Pugliese) personally completes every project, from the initial estimate through final cleanup. Customers consistently highlight the comfort of knowing exactly who will be in their home. If you value a one-on-one experience with the person doing the actual painting, Jays Pro Painting LLC is an excellent fit.

Reviews reveal a pattern of customers hiring Jay for one room and then immediately scheduling additional work. His specialties include interior painting, deck staining, and wallpaper removal, and several reviewers praise his skill with high ceilings and detailed trim work.

• Jay passed along his paint store discount to one customer and picked up the materials himself, saving them time and money
• One homeowner mentioned being comfortable leaving Jay alone in the house while she ran errands
• Customers new to the area describe Jay as patient and helpful with guidance on local options

"Jay painted three rooms of my new house prior to move-in and I can't say enough good things about him. Communication was on point, price was fair, work was excellent. I was comfortable being in the house with him and also leaving him there without anyone else present." - Lila McDowell, Google Review

With over 20 years of hands-on painting experience, Bryan Pro Painting brings deep expertise to every project. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.2% with over 60 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Santiago handles estimates directly and is known for clear communication about the process and costs. If you are looking for an experienced crew that consistently comes in at a competitive price, Bryan Pro Painting is worth contacting.

What stands out in the reviews is the loyalty of returning customers. Several homeowners describe using Santiago for over a decade, and real estate professionals in the area refer him to clients regularly.

• Multiple customers mention getting quotes from several contractors and choosing Bryan Pro Painting for better value
• Final costs consistently match or come in below the original estimate

"Bryan Pro Painting is legit! They provide quality services. I have been using them for over a decade. Trustworthy, professional and the work is always amazing." - Ali D, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Kyle Stark Painting. Operating since 1999 with over 25 years in business, this Kingston-based company earned a Chooz Score of 85.0% with over 85 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. They are also 96% recommended on Facebook with over 20 reviews. Kyle serves both residential and commercial clients across the Hudson Valley. If you want a painter with decades of local experience and a perfect review record, Kyle Stark Painting is a reliable option.

Reviewers frequently describe Kyle as someone who listens carefully during the estimate, provides honest feedback, and follows through exactly as promised. His employee Jorge is mentioned by name across multiple reviews for precise, careful work.

• One customer noted that Kyle took the time to speak with her grandson during the project, showing a personal touch that goes beyond just painting
• Several reviews mention Kyle squeezing in last-minute jobs to accommodate tight timelines
• Both residential homeowners and commercial clients, including a barbershop owner, praise the results

"Definitely recommend! Kyle squeezed in a job for me last minute and went above and beyond to complete it in the limited time frame that I had. He did beautiful work and even let my dog out for me when I wasn't home." - Angela Flanagan, Google Review

When it comes to long-term client relationships, Firefly Painting Inc stands out. Owner Matt Mason brings over 30 years of painting experience, and the company earned a Chooz Score of 83.9% with over 85 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. They are also 100% recommended on Facebook. With over 19 years in business, Firefly has built a loyal following in the Poughkeepsie and Fishkill areas. If you are looking for an established company with deep roots in the community, Firefly Painting Inc is a solid pick.

What makes Firefly unique is the depth of customer loyalty. Multiple reviewers describe working with Matt for years, even decades, and continuing to return. His crew member John is frequently praised for careful prep work and clean edges.

• One customer has hired Firefly for 18 consecutive years, describing results that consistently meet expectations
• Kitchen cabinet refinishing is a specialty, with several customers noting their cabinets looked brand new after the work
• Matt and his wife Sarah handle communication together, ensuring quick responses and smooth scheduling

"This is the 4th time I've had Matt and John do work at my house. They are always professional, prompt and courteous. They show great respect to you and your home." - Mark Webber, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Fishkill, NY, Precision Painting NY Inc handles everything from residential interiors to commercial spaces and specialty finishes. They earned a Chooz Score of 83.0% with over 65 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp and a Houzz Award. Owner Nakia Dunn is named in nearly every review for his hands-on involvement and clear communication. With over 10 years in business, the company serves the broader Hudson Valley. If you need specialty work like Venetian plaster, lime wash, or cabinet refinishing alongside standard painting, Precision Painting NY Inc is a great option.

Customers consistently describe Nakia as someone who gives fair quotes on the spot and schedules work quickly. His crew members Eduardo, Dwayne, and Lloyd are mentioned by name across multiple reviews, confirming a stable team.

• Several customers describe daily cleanup so thorough that it felt like no one had been working in their home
• The company handles both residential and commercial projects, including a showroom renovation on the Upper East Side
• Multiple reviewers note that their results held up well months after the project was completed

"Best painting crew I've ever used. Hard-working and thorough, they went above and beyond. Quick update: It's been almost a year later, and our home still looks great." - Dennis Fitzgerald, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality and workmanship are the most frequently praised aspects of painting contractors serving Fishkill, NY. Across hundreds of reviews, customers describe finished results that consistently meet or exceed expectations, with many noting that their homes feel refreshed and updated after the work is complete.

Ryan's Painting customers often highlight the crew's ability to handle complex projects with care. One reviewer hired them to correct the work of a previous painter and was impressed with how quickly and professionally the team addressed the issues. "Ryan and his team painted the interior of our entire house - ceilings, walls, doors and trim. He offered feedback and suggestions along the way. The results have blown us away." - Caryn Willems, Google Review. Jays Pro Painting LLC earns similar praise, with customers noting Jay's skill on challenging surfaces. "We hired Jay to paint the entire interior of our house, three coats to the walls and vaulted ceilings at about 14 feet at the peak, and even some drywall repair. He did a masterful job." - Ciana Frenze, Google Review. Kyle Stark Painting is frequently praised for exterior work, with one customer describing how Kyle and his team restored a weathered home with multiple layers of peeling paint to like-new condition. Certified Painting LLC owner Brian Shannon is known for tackling difficult prep work, including skim coating walls with severe imperfections and refinishing kitchen cabinets that customers say look brand new. "Brian and his team did an amazing job prepping and painting our circa 1938 home. It wasn't an easy task, but they knocked it out of the park." - Arthur T. Rollin, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication and professionalism are among the most consistently praised qualities of painting contractors serving Fishkill, NY. Customers across multiple companies describe painters who respond quickly to inquiries, explain the process clearly, and keep homeowners informed throughout the project.

Jays Pro Painting LLC owner Jay is described by reviewers as exceptionally communicative, with one customer noting he explained each step of the process before starting work. "From our first call, he was incredibly helpful and responsive. We had to move in sooner than planned, and Jay was able to adjust his schedule to accommodate us." - Ray Huerta, Google Review. Ryan's Painting earns similar marks, with owner Ryan Clarkin known for responding to estimate requests quickly and following up throughout the project. Certified Painting LLC stands out for owner Brian Shannon's transparency, with one out-of-state customer noting that Brian sent photos periodically to keep them updated on progress. "Brian went above and beyond. He was fair, honest and very professional with his quote and timeline. We live out of state and Brian sent photos periodically to keep us posted." - Terry Wolfson, Google Review. Precision Painting NY Inc owner Nakia Dunn is praised for giving quotes on the spot during walkthrough visits, and Firefly Painting Inc customers note that owner Matt Mason and his wife Sarah both respond to communications promptly, creating a seamless scheduling experience.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness and reliability are strong points for the top painting contractors serving Fishkill, NY. Across over 150 reviews mentioning scheduling and punctuality, customers consistently describe crews that arrive when promised and complete projects within the estimated timeframe.

Ryan's Painting is frequently praised for fast turnaround, with one customer noting the team completed an interior and exterior job in just two days. "Called on Monday and Ryan came to our home on Thursday for the estimate. He arrived a few minutes early, gave us a fair estimate that day, and started the following Wednesday as agreed." - Wallace Grahn, Google Review. Kyle Stark Painting customers describe a similar experience, with Kyle arriving on time for estimates and scheduling work promptly. "I was in a pinch and needed a pretty significant paint job completed in a short period. I was pleasantly surprised by how quickly Kyle was able to get the job done." - Kait Logan, Google Review. Jays Pro Painting LLC owner Jay is known for accommodating tight schedules, with one reviewer noting he completed an entire room before her child came home from daycare. Firefly Painting Inc customers note that Matt and his crew show up on time every day throughout multi-day projects, and Precision Painting NY Inc is praised for scheduling work within a reasonable window after the initial estimate.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Fair pricing is one of the most frequently mentioned positives across reviews for painting contractors in Fishkill, NY. Customers consistently describe receiving competitive quotes, with final costs that match or come in below the original estimate.

Bryan Pro Painting stands out for value, with multiple customers describing how they received quotes from several contractors and chose Santiago for better pricing without sacrificing quality. "Santiago and his team are terrific. They are honest, professional, and highly skilled. Their prices were reasonable and the workmanship was excellent." - Paul G, Google Review. Ryan's Painting is similarly praised, with one customer who received four quotes choosing Ryan not because he was the cheapest, but because the combination of communication, professionalism, and price made him the best overall option. Jays Pro Painting LLC customers frequently use words like "fair" and "reasonable" when describing Jay's rates, with one reviewer noting that Jay passed along his paint store discount and picked up the materials himself. Certified Painting LLC owner Brian Shannon provides detailed estimates that customers appreciate for their transparency. "His quote provided a lot of detail, which was very helpful and reassuring. The final price matched exactly what we were told." - Elena Dyer, Google Review. Kyle Stark Painting and Firefly Painting Inc are both described by customers as reasonably priced, with several reviewers noting that the quality of work made the investment well worth it.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and home protection are consistently praised across reviews for painting contractors serving Fishkill, NY. Customers describe painters who cover floors and furniture carefully, clean up at the end of each day, and leave homes looking as though no work had taken place.

Certified Painting LLC receives some of the strongest cleanup praise, with multiple reviewers independently describing the same experience. "Brian and his team were professional, reasonably priced, did amazing work, and best of all cleaned up as if they were never there." - Gus Letterii, Google Review. Precision Painting NY Inc customers describe a similar experience, with one noting that the team put everything back in place after painting as though they had never been there. Jays Pro Painting LLC owner Jay is praised for thorough drop cloth coverage and leaving work areas spotless. "He put drop cloths down over the entire area and cleaned up when the job was completed. You would never even know he had been here." - Joseph Pietroluongo, Google Review. Ryan's Painting crews are noted for cleaning up at the end of each day during multi-day projects, and Kyle Stark Painting reviewers describe efficient work that minimized disruption to daily routines. Firefly Painting Inc customers highlight Matt and John's careful prep work, including protecting surrounding surfaces before any paint is applied.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google