7 Best Painters Near Newburgh, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Painting contractors serving Newburgh, NY cover a wide stretch of the Hudson Valley, reaching into Orange, Ulster, and Dutchess Counties. The companies listed here work on everything from pre-Civil War exteriors and original plaster interiors to modern kitchen cabinets, commercial storefronts, and outdoor decks. Across hundreds of customer reviews, the top performers share a few consistent traits: reliable scheduling, hands-on crews, and results that hold up over time.

Ryan's Painting holds the top spot with a Chooz Score of 88.6%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 110 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Angi with over 30 reviews, 100% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Based out of New Windsor and accredited with the BBB since 2025, Ryan's Painting has been serving the Hudson Valley for 5 years in business. What shows up across the reviews is Ryan's involvement in the color selection process - customers credit him with helping refine paint choices before the job begins, sometimes steering them away from options that wouldn't have worked. The crew is also consistent: Dave, Jonathan, Cesar, Jorge, and Jose appear across multiple independent reviews covering different neighborhoods and project types. If you're dealing with a multi-room interior, selling a property remotely, or working on an older home that needs extra prep, Ryan's Painting is a strong option.

• Large whole-house projects covering ceilings, walls, trim, and doors have been completed in just 2-3 days without sacrificing results.
• Out-of-state clients managing a property sale trusted the team to work unsupervised, describing clear communication throughout.
• During one exterior project, the crew identified a roof leak and flagged it to the homeowner before it became a larger repair.

"Ryan's Painting painted the interior of our entire house; ceilings, walls, doors and trim. He, and his team, were professional, responsive and very easy to work with. He offered feedback and suggestions along the way. The results have blown us away." - Caryn W., Google Review

With 12 years in business and a home base in Warwick, CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY brings a scale and track record that few competitors in the area can match. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%, backed by over 175 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating, 4.9 stars on Angi with over 20 reviews, and over 15 Yelp reviews. Named a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in both 2022 and 2023, the team serves 27 communities throughout Orange County. Crew members Sean, Jose, Eduardo, Joanne, and Askold appear across independent reviews, with customers returning for cabinet painting, deck staining, power washing, and full exterior repaints over many years. Commercial clients - including a local vintage shop - have brought them back for multiple building projects. If you need a company with a long multi-year track record and experience across large-scale and commercial work, CertaPro is worth contacting.

• The team took on a full log home restoration and restaining - a specialty job that requires surface-specific knowledge beyond standard residential painting.
• Reviewers note the team remembered the exact paint used on a home from over a decade earlier, reflecting careful project documentation.
• Several customers mention being referred by neighbors, friends, or family members who had already completed projects with CertaPro.

"We've been with Brendan and CertaPro Painters for the last 3 iterations of paint jobs at our 3 story office building. They have all been done with professionalism, great communication, and outstanding results!" - Seely D., Google Review

For homeowners who want the owner on-site for every part of the job, Jays Pro Painting LLC offers something rare in the industry. Jason Pugliese handles every estimate and every brush stroke personally - no subcontractors, no rotating crews. The company earned a Chooz Score of 86.7% with over 80 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 5.0 stars on Yelp. Customers consistently describe feeling comfortable leaving Jay alone in their home, with several explicitly noting they headed out to work or ran errands without hesitation. New homeowners and first-time buyers appear throughout the reviews, citing Jay's patience and guidance through the process as a standout. If you want an owner-operator with a perfect rating who handles everything from start to finish, Jay is a strong fit.

• Several clients hired Jay for one room and expanded the project mid-job after seeing the initial results.
• Jay also handles drywall repair, wallpaper removal, and light fixture installation - useful for clients prepping a home before move-in.

"Jay painted three rooms of my new house prior to move-in and I can't say enough good things about him. Communication was on point, price was fair, work was excellent. I was comfortable being in the house with him and also leaving him there without anyone else present." - Lila M., Google Review

With over 25 years in the Hudson Valley, Kyle Stark Painting brings a depth of local experience that newer companies simply can't replicate. The company earned a Chooz Score of 85.0% with over 85 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 96% recommended on Facebook with over 20 reviews. Operating continuously since 1999, Kyle's team has worked on weathered multi-layer exteriors, historic wood trim fascia, commercial barbershops, and kitchen cabinets. Crew member Jorge is mentioned across unrelated reviews for careful, precise detail work. Several customers have returned for a second or third project over many years. If your home has older, complex exterior surfaces or you want a contractor with deep community roots, Kyle Stark Painting is a dependable choice.

• Multiple reviewers hired Kyle for their interior one season and came back for the full exterior project a year or two later.
• The team is specifically noted for handling older Hudson Valley homes with multi-layer peeling paint and weathered wood trim that other contractors pass on.
• A barbershop owner hired the team for a commercial space and described the finished results as better than he could have imagined.

"Once again, Kyle and his crew beautifully completed my outdoor painting tasks. They use high quality products, they know how to deal with all manner of surfaces and are painstakingly careful, thorough and tidy." - Joan J., Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for KB Quality Painting out of Highland Mills. The company earned a Chooz Score of 83.2% with over 120 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Kevin's response time is a recurring observation - customers describe same-day or next-day replies to texts and calls, often with scheduling available within a few days of the initial contact. Kevin and crew member Caesar are called out for clean edges and precise detail work on both residential interiors and commercial building exteriors. If responsiveness and fast scheduling turnaround are priorities for you, KB Quality Painting is worth a call.

• Kevin is credited by multiple reviewers with helping select the right color before work begins - going beyond just executing the chosen paint.
• The team maintains an active Instagram portfolio with over 190 project posts, giving prospective clients a visual preview of completed work before reaching out.

"I am so glad we hired Kevin to paint our home. He was professional and on time. I was really impressed by how quickly he responded to my texts and calls. The entire team was professional and polite. The pricing was most reasonable when compared to other estimates I received." - Kathleen W., Google Review

When it comes to specialty finishes and a wider project range, Precision Painting NY Inc. stands apart. Based in Monroe, the company earned a Chooz Score of 83.0% with over 65 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp and a Houzz Award. Owner Nakia Dunn handles estimates in person and explains the full scope clearly before starting - several reviewers specifically call out this upfront transparency as stress-reducing. With 10 years in business, the team has taken on historic homes over 100 years old, NYC commercial showroom renovations, wallpaper installation, deck work, and specialty finishes including Venetian plaster. Crew members Eduardo, Dwayne, and Lloyd are named across separate, unrelated reviews. If your project goes beyond a standard repaint - historic construction, specialty finishes, or commercial space - Precision Painting is a well-suited option.

• Customers describe the crew proactively catching issues beyond the original scope - coverage gaps, hidden wall damage - and addressing them without being asked.
• Eco-friendly paint options are mentioned by reviewers with sensitivity to fumes, reflecting flexibility in materials selection.

"Nakia and his crew were AMAZING! They are wonderful, caring people and great craftsmen. My house is over 100 years old, and they were so thoughtful and careful in the process of repairing and painting it. Their price is fair, and it feels good to support a local business." - Jac O., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in the Newburgh, NY area, Certified Painting LLC has built a loyal following across the Mid-Hudson Valley. The company earned a Chooz Score of 82.6% with over 100 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating, plus 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Brian Shannon has grown this Dutchess County operation over 4 years in business into a go-to for complex surface conditions - wood paneling, knot-bleeding ceilings, and historic plaster walls. He regularly sends progress photos to clients who can't be on site, a practice flagged by several out-of-state homeowners as especially valuable. Crew members Caitlin and Gavin are praised individually for precise edge work and finishing details. If you have challenging surface conditions or need someone who keeps you in the loop when you're not on-site, Certified Painting LLC is a solid option.

• Several customers brought Brian back for both interior and exterior projects on the same property, with some work spreading across multiple rooms over a couple of years.
• Reviewers in pre-1920 homes highlight Brian's experience with historic plaster repair and multi-coat priming on knot-heavy wood surfaces.
• Out-of-state owners credit periodic progress photo updates as an accountability step they didn't expect but found valuable throughout the project.

"We live out of state and Brian sent photos periodically to keep us updated on the project. Who does that? Brian does. We highly recommend Certified Painting, LLC." - Terry W., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook

Quality of work is the most consistent theme across customer reviews for painters serving Newburgh, NY. Reviewers who set out to write brief notes often end up detailing specific aspects of the finished product - clean paint lines, thorough surface prep, and results that look noticeably better than before. Multiple companies on this list have tackled the kinds of surface challenges common to the Hudson Valley: original plaster, multi-layer peeling exteriors, wood paneling, and historic trim that require more than a standard coat and brush.

Ryan's Painting earns repeated mention for handling complex multi-surface projects - ceilings, walls, trim, and doors in the same engagement - with careful, even results. One reviewer described extensive drywall repairs completed cleanly before paint ever went on. Jays Pro Painting LLC draws attention for Jason's precision on detailed trim work, with one customer describing a master bedroom with vaulted ceilings, tray details, and crown moldings that all came out exactly as planned, along with an irregular drywall repair handled midway through. Kyle Stark Painting is called out by multiple reviewers for successfully tackling weathered Hudson Valley exteriors with multi-layer peeling paint - jobs where surface prep carries as much weight as the final coat. Certified Painting LLC's Brian Shannon has a specific reputation for difficult plaster and wood surface prep, with customers describing careful caulking of wood paneling seams, shellac-based priming over knot-heavy wood, and multi-coat approaches on historic plaster. Precision Painting NY Inc. also earns praise for specialty surface work, with customers in pre-1920 homes calling out the team's thoughtful approach to repair and coating on aging structures that need careful handling.

"We hired Jay to paint the entire interior of our house; three coats to the walls and vaulted ceilings of every room, and even some unforeseen drywall repair including an irregular-shaped hole over 2 feet in length and recasing of a beam. Jay really came through for us and did a great job." - Ciana F., Google Review"We needed more than just painting. We had numerous cracks and blemishes in the Sheetrock. Kyle and his team not only repaired the walls and ceiling beautifully - we were impressed with their skill, their neatness, and their professionalism." - Roy P., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication before, during, and after the project is something customers across the Newburgh, NY area specifically call out in their reviews - not just as a bonus, but as a reason they'd hire the same contractor again. Reviewers describe receiving clear written estimates, realistic timelines, and ongoing updates without having to follow up repeatedly. The contractors that score highest for professionalism tend to handle the scheduling and communication side of the job as carefully as the paint itself.

Precision Painting NY Inc. owner Nakia Dunn is repeatedly described as walking customers through the full project scope before starting - explaining what will be done, in what order, and why - which several reviewers say reduced their anxiety considerably. Ryan's Painting earns mentions for staying responsive to questions throughout the project, with customers noting Ryan offers suggestions and answers without being prompted. CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY's Brendan McManus is credited across multiple reviews for prompt responses, clear appointment communication, and consistent follow-through from estimate to final walkthrough. KB Quality Painting's Kevin draws repeated praise for same-day or next-day replies to texts and calls - a quality that stands out in an industry where follow-through can be inconsistent. Certified Painting LLC's Brian Shannon sets a high bar for remote communication, with several out-of-state clients specifically noting periodic progress photos as an accountability measure they hadn't anticipated but found invaluable.

"Following my first contact with the company, Precision Painting promptly scheduled a walk-through to estimate my residential painting job, arrived on time, and provided a written, detailed quote within an hour of completing the walk-through." - Brenda M., Google Review"Brian and the Certified Painting team were incredibly professional and responsive from start to finish. From the initial quote to the final walkthrough, Brian is very detail oriented and will ensure you are thrilled with the work before he leaves." - Jon D., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Showing up when promised and finishing within the agreed timeframe are two of the most repeated points in reviews for painters serving Newburgh, NY. Customers who have dealt with unreliable contractors before specifically call out scheduling reliability as a reason they'd recommend one company over another. Across the top-rated companies on this list, punctuality and adherence to timelines appear less as a standout feature and more as a floor-level expectation these crews have set for themselves.

Kyle Stark Painting is noted for fitting clients in on short notice while still delivering on the agreed timeline - one reviewer described a significant job completed within a tight window after Kyle responded quickly to an urgent request and worked the crew's schedule to accommodate it. Ryan's Painting earns mentions from clients who needed a project done before a deadline, with multiple reviewers citing jobs that started exactly when scheduled and finished cleanly within the promised window. KB Quality Painting customers describe arrival times that match what was scheduled, with one reviewer noting the team completed a large 5-to-6-day project right on schedule without slipping. Jays Pro Painting LLC earns praise for combining scheduling flexibility with reliability - Jay is described as accommodating tight timelines while still finishing work to a high standard. CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY reviewers note the team completing projects before the given timeline on at least one occasion, with owner Brendan McManus credited for keeping commitments from the estimate phase through final cleanup.

"I was in a pinch and needed a pretty significant paint job completed in a short period. I reached out to Kyle, who had come highly recommended by a friend, and was pleasantly surprised by how quickly he responded. He fit me into his team's schedule, communicated with me throughout the process, and stayed on track." - Kait L., Google Review"Kevin and team exceeded my expectations. They were both professional and timely, so I will definitely be using them again in the future. Couldn't be happier to support them - they truly give off the small business feel; very responsive and friendly!" - Jason T., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work and cleanup are where some painters quietly separate themselves from others in the Newburgh, NY area, and customers across the top-rated companies notice the difference. Reviewers frequently describe arriving home to find the space cleaner than they left it, or watching crews cover furniture, protect floors, and mask off surfaces before any paint opens. The companies with the most consistent prep and cleanup feedback also tend to earn the most repeat business.

Jays Pro Painting LLC earns multiple mentions for thorough surface preparation before a brush ever touches the wall - customers describe protective covering of surrounding areas, careful edge masking, and post-project cleanup that required no follow-up from the homeowner. Precision Painting NY Inc. customers describe daily cleanup as a standard part of how the crew operates, not an afterthought at the end of the job, with one reviewer noting you'd never know the team had been there when they left. CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY is repeatedly described as tidying up at the end of each day on multi-day projects, with customers noting the house stayed organized throughout. KB Quality Painting customers describe the team covering everything before starting and leaving the space spotless, with crew member Caesar specifically named for focused work that avoids mess from the start. Ryan's Painting draws praise for prep that goes beyond painting - spackling holes, repairing drywall, and daily cleanup before the crew wraps for the day.

"He left my house spotless, was so diligent - he even passed along his discount at the paint store and picked up the paint I needed!" - Melanie B., Google Review"Kyle and his employee, Jorge, were very professional in all aspects of their work. They were neat, precise, and most of all hardworking. I highly recommend their services and expertise for any type of house painting." - Lorraine F., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Pricing is a regular topic in reviews for painters serving Newburgh, NY, and the pattern that comes through most often isn't about who charges the least - it's about who delivers a result worth the cost. Reviewers across multiple companies describe collecting several estimates and selecting a contractor who was mid-range or slightly higher because the communication and credibility during the estimate process stood out. Several explicitly mention value: the sense that what they paid matched what they received.

Ryan's Painting is specifically mentioned by one reviewer who collected five estimates and chose Ryan based on a combination of fair pricing, a solid guarantee, and confidence in the person providing the quote. KB Quality Painting earns mentions for competitive pricing relative to other estimates received, with customers noting Kevin explained the costs clearly and that there were no unexpected charges once the job started. Jays Pro Painting LLC is cited by multiple reviewers as reasonably priced for the level of work provided, with one noting Jay passed along his paint store discount to save the customer money on materials. Kyle Stark Painting customers describe getting very reasonable estimates and finding that the final cost matched exactly what was quoted. Precision Painting NY Inc. and Certified Painting LLC both draw mentions for providing detailed written quotes upfront, with customers crediting this transparency as a sign of professionalism that reduced concern about surprise charges later on.

"His pricing was fair, and we would recommend him for his professionalism and quality of work to anyone needing painting services. There were no unusual surprises, which can arise during projects like this." - Tommy D., Google Review"Nakia gives you a fair quote on the spot, regardless of how small or large your home is. He schedules you within a reasonable time frame, actually shows up and on time. Before starting my job he explained to me what he was going to do and why." - Tanya Y., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Repeat customers and referrals appear throughout the reviews for painters serving Newburgh, NY, and they're among the strongest signals that a contractor delivers consistently over time. A second- or third-time customer tells a different story than a one-time reviewer. Across the top-rated companies, multiple reviewers describe returning for follow-on projects, recommending the contractor to neighbors or family members, or describing the company as their standing go-to for any painting need that comes up.

CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY has the most documented repeat business on the list - reviewers describe using the company across multiple properties, project types, and in some cases a decade or more. One Pine Island family described CertaPro as the only painters they've used since moving to the area over 15 years ago. Certified Painting LLC's Brian Shannon is described by multiple customers as a family go-to, with some households returning for a third or fourth project across different rooms and properties. Ryan's Painting earns repeat mentions from customers who started with one room or one project and came back for a larger scope once they saw results. Kyle Stark Painting's repeat client roster spans well over a decade, with customers crediting consistent quality as the reason they never look elsewhere when another project comes up. KB Quality Painting's Kevin has customers who describe using him across many jobs and expressing certainty they'll continue calling him for future work.

"CertaPro Painters of Warwick are the only painters we've used multiple times over multiple years because there's no drama, just a great paint job." - Jerry Z., Google Review"As a repeat customer, I can't say enough good things about Brian at Certified Painting. The quality of work is top-notch, communication is fantastic, and the pricing is also very reasonable. We will continue to use Brian for all our painting needs." - Amanda S., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook