3 Best Painters Near Stormville, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners and business owners near Stormville, NY have strong options when it comes to professional painting contractors. The companies listed on Chooz Painters in this area cover a wide range of projects - from interior refreshes and kitchen cabinet refinishing to challenging historic exteriors - and reviewers consistently highlight strong communication, thorough prep work, and results that hold up over time. Here are the top-rated painters serving the Stormville, NY area.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Ryan's Painting had over 110 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, along with a 5.0-star rating on Yelp, over 30 reviews on Angi, and is 100% recommended on Facebook. The company earned a Chooz Score of 88.6%. What stands out across the review base is how often customers describe Ryan as a genuine resource throughout a project - not just executing the work, but helping select colors, catching issues before they become problems, and offering suggestions that clients hadn't thought to ask about. With 5 years in business and BBB accreditation since 2025, the company also handles drywall repair, crown molding, and minor renovation work alongside traditional interior and exterior painting.

• Multiple reviewers report booking Ryan's Painting specifically after previous negative experiences with other contractors - and consistently noting the process was far smoother than they expected.
• Color consultation comes up as a specific strength: Ryan is credited across reviews with steering clients toward choices they would not have considered on their own, and talking customers through paint colors that wouldn't have worked for their spaces.
• The team has handled projects for remote and out-of-state clients managing Hudson Valley properties, communicating throughout and delivering finished results without requiring the owner to be present on site.

"Ryan and his team did tremendously professional work while we were out of state managing a home we were selling. They were easy to communicate with, arrived on time, and were extremely professional." - Erin S., Google Review

If you're looking for a contractor who brings a consultative approach and can handle scope beyond just paint, Ryan's Painting is a strong choice.

With over 19 years in business, Firefly Painting Inc has built the kind of reputation that comes from decades of consistent results. Owner Matt Mason brings over 30 years of hands-on painting experience, and the company earned a Chooz Score of 83.9%. At the time of our analysis, Firefly held over 85 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating and is 100% recommended on Facebook. What's notable here is the frequency of reviews from people who just purchased a home and arrived via a referral from their real estate agent - suggesting Firefly has strong professional relationships within the local real estate community. Owner Matt and his wife Sarah handle customer communication directly, and reviewers consistently describe scheduling and project updates as smooth from start to finish.

• Crew member John is called out by name across multiple reviews for careful edge work, thorough prep, and close attention to trim and architectural details.
• The company has served both residential and commercial clients, with reviewers including business owners who hired Firefly for commercial building exteriors.
• Matt's approach to estimates stands out: several reviewers describe receiving a detailed, research-backed quote that was more transparent than competing bids they received.
• New homeowners show up repeatedly in the review base, often arriving via a realtor recommendation and returning as long-term repeat clients.

"Matt came highly recommended by our realtor when we purchased our new home. Honestly, I do not think I could ever call anyone else now for our painting needs after such an incredible experience." - Alfredo, Google Review

If you're a new homeowner or looking to build a long-term relationship with a dependable painter in the area, Firefly Painting Inc is a well-matched choice.

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Certified Painting LLC. Owner Brian Shannon earned a Chooz Score of 82.6%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, the company held over 100 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating and is 100% recommended on Facebook. The range of work covered is notable: Brian and his crew have handled everything from kitchen cabinet refinishing to a full interior of a large colonial repainted room by room over two years, to serving as the selected contractor on a centuries-old estate in Millbrook after a competitive bid process. Several reviewers describe trusting Brian with every room in their home, and out-of-state clients appear across the reviews - with Brian regularly sending progress photos to keep remote owners informed.

• Crew members Caitlin and Gavin are praised individually across separate reviews for clean lines, detailed prep, and strong finishing work.
• Brian provides thorough, itemized estimates that customers frequently describe as more detailed and transparent than competing quotes.
• The team has completed projects on historic properties requiring careful surface preparation, from pre-war homes to 18th-century structures.

"Brian and his crew did an amazing job prepping and painting our circa 1938 home. It wasn't an easy task - lots of mature bushes, trees, a steep hillside, tricky gables and unbearable heat but they knocked it out of the park." - Arthur T. R., Google Review

If you're tackling an older property, a large-scope project, or need a contractor comfortable working with remote owners, Certified Painting LLC is a dependable option.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Quality of finished work is among the most frequently mentioned themes across reviews for painting contractors serving the Stormville, NY area, and the pattern holds across all three companies. Customers describe results that hold up under close inspection - clean lines, smooth surfaces, and details addressed before the crew leaves. Ryan's Painting earns particular recognition for work that goes beyond the painted surface: reviewers describe Ryan's team completing drywall repairs, installing crown molding, and tiling a backsplash as part of broader projects, with the overall result coming together as a cohesive finished space. One reviewer who had previously attempted to achieve professional results on their own described the work from Ryan's crew as the experience they wished they had started with. The team has also taken on larger-scale commercial work - one reviewer described a full church sanctuary repaint, noting the team delivered a bright, welcoming interior from what had previously been a dark and dated space.

For homeowners dealing with older or more demanding properties, both Firefly Painting Inc and Certified Painting LLC receive strong marks for quality on challenging jobs. Firefly's crew is praised across reviews for careful surface preparation before any paint is applied - wallpaper removal, plaster repair, and thorough sanding that customers credit with elevating the final result. Reviewers with historic homes describe outcomes that went beyond what they expected. Certified Painting LLC earns similar praise for its work on older properties: one reviewer described hiring Brian to tackle a circa-1938 exterior with steep terrain and complex features, noting the crew delivered results that matched the difficulty of the project. Cabinet refinishing earns consistent praise across both Firefly and Certified, with customers describing finished surfaces that look factory-fresh rather than painted over.

"First off, 5 stars does not nearly begin to capture the overwhelming satisfaction I have with the work that Matt and his team have completed in my new home. I have an older home, with historical features." - A M., Google Review

"Brian and Kaitlin were a joy to have here at our house and the finished product was absolutely perfect." - Robert, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Across all three painters serving the Stormville, NY area on Chooz Painters, communication is one of the most consistently praised aspects of the customer experience. Reviewers describe contractors who respond to inquiries promptly, show up when scheduled, and keep clients informed throughout the project - not just at the beginning and end. Ryan's Painting draws consistent mention for pre-project responsiveness: multiple reviewers describe Ryan answering questions thoroughly during the estimate phase, walking through the process before work begins, and remaining accessible throughout. One reviewer managing a property sale from out of state specifically noted how straightforward communication remained without being present for any of the work. Firefly Painting Inc handles client communication through both owner Matt Mason and his wife Sarah, and customers describe never feeling uninformed - from initial inquiries and detailed estimates through scheduling updates and job completion.

For Certified Painting LLC, communication is a theme that appears across nearly every review. Customers describe owner Brian Shannon as easy to reach, responsive to texts and emails, and proactive about sharing updates. Several reviewers - including those who hired Certified for properties they couldn't be present at - describe Brian sending progress photos throughout the project to keep owners informed. For all three companies, punctuality is a consistent thread: reviewers across platforms describe crews arriving as scheduled and completing work within the agreed timeframe, with any changes communicated in advance.

"Throughout the entire process, Brian, Caitlin, and Gavin collaborated closely with us. They provided valuable input and brought large samples to help us make color choices." - Michelle H., Google Review

"Matt and his crew were all great people, and they did great work! The communication from them through each phase was also much appreciated. I'll definitely be calling them again!" - Brian C., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Cleanup and prep work are two areas where the painters serving Stormville, NY consistently earn recognition across reviews. Customers describe crews that take protective measures seriously before a brush touches a wall - covering furniture and floors, masking trim and hardware, and protecting surfaces that shouldn't receive overspray. Ryan's Painting receives repeated mention for how the crew leaves a space at the end of each day: reviewers describe rooms returned to order, drop cloths removed, and work areas left cleaner than expected. Firefly Painting Inc earns similar notes: customers describe crews that clean thoroughly as they move through a project, with completed spaces showing no trace of the work beyond the fresh paint. One reviewer noted that the Firefly crew went as far as checking door latch alignment and hardware fit as they wrapped up - a level of care that extended well beyond just painting.

For Certified Painting LLC, prep work is a recurring theme that customers connect directly to the quality of the final result. Brian is described across reviews as taking the time to properly prepare surfaces - sanding, priming, and addressing imperfections before painting begins - which customers credit with elevating outcomes on older and more demanding properties. One reviewer noted that the crew moved all furniture before starting and replaced everything when the job was done, leaving the space clean and undisturbed. Out-of-state clients and property managers describe appreciating how thoroughly the team restored spaces to order, reducing the need to inspect or follow up after the project.

"I was also very impressed by how clean they were! From start to finish, Certified Painting kept everything orderly and protected." - Zander M., Google Review

"Matt and John did a fantastic job removing wallpaper, sanding the wall down and painting it. The wall had a lot of imperfections but they made it look beautiful! They are detail oriented and I couldn't be happier." - Amy K., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp

Value comes up consistently in reviews for all three painting contractors serving the Stormville, NY area, and the pattern that emerges isn't simply about low prices - it's about customers feeling that what they paid matched or exceeded what they received. Ryan's Painting is frequently described as fairly priced within the local market. One reviewer who gathered four separate bids for a deck and fence project described Ryan's pricing as neither the lowest nor highest, but credited his detailed explanation of the project scope and flexible approach as the deciding factors. Firefly Painting Inc earns similar notes around transparency: multiple reviewers describe receiving a research-backed estimate that stood out from competing bids for its clarity, with Matt described as the only contractor who asked detailed questions and presented a thorough written scope before the project began.

For Certified Painting LLC, pricing transparency is a specific and repeated theme. Brian Shannon provides itemized estimates broken down by room and scope, and customers describe this level of detail as unusual among the contractors they contacted. Multiple reviewers note that the final cost matched the quoted price with no surprises, and several describe Brian working within a customer's timeline or constraints without reducing the quality of the work. Across all three companies, the consensus in reviews is that customers feel they received strong value - and many specifically mention they have already recommended the same contractor to family and friends based on their experience.

"Ryan was easy to work with and professional. His crew did a fantastic job. Would 100% hire again." - Dan C., Google Review

"His quote provided a lot of detail which was very helpful. He made sure the job was perfect and that we were satisfied. His level of professionalism and care was truly impressive." - Elena D., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp