Homeowners in Jefferson Valley, NY have access to several highly rated painting contractors, each with strong review histories and proven track records across multiple platforms. Whether you need a full interior refresh, cabinet refinishing, deck restoration, or exterior painting, these companies consistently earn praise for their quality, communication, and professionalism.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Paint Track Painting Services had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 89.7%. With over 20 years in business since 2004, this Westchester County company is PCA Certified, EPA RRP lead-safe certified, and holds manufacturer certifications from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe. They also carry a 4.6-star rating on Yelp and a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation. A recurring theme in reviews is how many customers come back for second and third projects, from whole-home interiors to kitchen cabinets to deck staining. If you want a company with a dedicated project manager, a full-time crew you can trust in your home, and a structured process from estimate to final walkthrough, Paint Track Painting Services is a strong choice.
Customers frequently mention owner Ray Rahni and Project Manager Jess Molina by name, along with individual painters like Sergio and Alberto. Several reviewers describe handing over house keys to the crew for the duration of the project, comfortable leaving them unsupervised. The company also handles wallpaper installation, skim coating, and carpentry alongside painting.
- Multiple customers report that kitchen cabinets painted by the team are mistaken for brand-new installations by visitors
- Reviewers with older homes, including an 1880 Victorian, highlight the crew's ability to work with plaster walls and period details
- Several reviews describe the company fitting customers into the schedule on short notice when openings arise
"We were anxious to get work done and when they had an opening, Paint Track fit us in. We were recommended by a close family friend. The guys were extremely dependable." - Paige Stelzl, Google Review
For homeowners who want a responsive, owner-operated company that handles everything from interior painting to deck refinishing, Pro Painting Plus has earned a Chooz Score of 87.6% with over 75 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. Owner Rob McRae (also known as Bobby) is mentioned by name in the majority of reviews, and customers consistently note that he checks in daily during projects. The company handles interior and exterior painting, cabinet refinishing, deck staining, and power washing across the Hudson Valley and surrounding areas.
What stands out in the reviews is how often Rob steps in to rescue projects gone wrong with other contractors. Multiple customers describe hiring Pro Painting Plus after a previous painter left a job unfinished or did substandard work, and the team delivered results that exceeded expectations. Crew members like Dario, Luis, Miguel, Oscar, and Herbie are praised individually across reviews.
- A customer needed a four-bedroom house painted in 48 to 72 hours before a move-in, and the crew delivered on schedule with a cleaning crew on standby
- One reviewer had their cabinets done six months prior and reports being just as impressed as on day one
- The company took on a historic church shingle restoration, giving the building a new lease on life
"5 Stars is not enough for the impeccable service this painting company offers. The quote was fair, the communication was constant, and the finished product was beyond what I expected." - C R Bradbury, Google Review
Also serving the Jefferson Valley, NY area, MGP Painting Inc. brings a strong cross-platform presence with a Chooz Score of 87.2%. They have over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi, and are 96% recommended on Facebook. With over 13 years in business since 2012, they operate out of Rockland County and serve a wide area. Owner Moises is described in reviews as someone who personally visits the job site throughout each project to check progress and answer questions. If you are looking for a company that handles cabinet refinishing, wallpaper installation, and deck staining alongside standard interior and exterior work, MGP Painting Inc. is worth contacting for a quote.
A pattern that runs through their reviews is how many customers report being pleasantly surprised by the pricing after comparing multiple bids. Reviewers also frequently mention the company's willingness to take on complex spaces, including homes with popcorn ceilings, high vaulted ceilings, and multi-level staircases. Crew members like Galo and Orlando are praised for wallpaper work specifically.
- A local library hired MGP after noticing the crew's professionalism on a nearby project, and the homeowner followed suit after seeing the same quality
- One reviewer describes a hair studio project where the contrast and color selection drew constant compliments from clients
- Several customers mention Moises remembering them by name when they return for a second or third project
"Anyone who has done a major project involving their home knows how stressful it can be. Finding someone who will take the same care that you would take, if you could, is almost impossible. MGP did just that." - Deborah D Broderick, Google Review
When it comes to hands-on, owner-led service, Pier Painting Services stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.1% with over 60 Google reviews and a perfect 5.0-star rating. They also hold 5.0 stars on Yelp and are 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Johnny Acosta has over 25 years in business serving Westchester County and is a Larchmont Chamber of Commerce member. Johnny runs every estimate, supervises every job, and frequently works alongside his crew. If you value working directly with the business owner throughout your project, Pier Painting Services is an excellent fit.
Referrals between neighbors are a common thread in the reviews, with multiple customers mentioning they hired Johnny based on a friend's or neighbor's recommendation. The company also handles light carpentry, handyman repairs, drywall work, and power washing, making them a versatile option for homeowners who want one reliable contact for multiple home maintenance needs.
- A realtor hired Pier Painting to prep a client's home for the spring market and now recommends Johnny to all clients going forward
- One customer trusted Johnny enough to skip taking time off work, knowing the project would be handled properly without supervision
- Multiple reviewers mention Johnny providing helpful color selection advice and offering samples before committing
"In 25 years we have had a lot of contractors in and out of our house and we would rate this as one of our best experiences." - Richard Davidson, Google Review
Rounding out the top contractors in Jefferson Valley, NY, Bryan Pro Painting has earned a Chooz Score of 85.2% with over 60 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. They also hold 5.0 stars on Yelp. Owner Santiago brings over 20 years of hands-on painting experience and operates across Northern Westchester, including Cortlandt Manor and Yorktown Heights. Pricing is the most common topic in their reviews, with customers consistently describing Santiago's quotes as among the most competitive they received. If you are looking for a skilled, competitively priced painter for interior, exterior, or deck work, Bryan Pro Painting is a solid option.
A first-time homeowner describes being guided through the entire process by Santiago, including help choosing materials and understanding what the house needed. The company also takes on jobs other contractors decline, including difficult exterior restorations where sun-damaged paint was flaking badly. Repeat customers and referral patterns are strong, with one reviewer using the company for over a decade.
- Customers who compare multiple quotes consistently find Bryan Pro Painting among the most reasonable without sacrificing quality
- A real estate professional refers Santiago to all of her clients and has hired him personally for her own home
"As a first time homeowner, I did not know many things about buying or maintaining a house. One thing I did know, however, was the house needed a paint job. I was very fortunate to have come across Santiago." - Vasco Lima, Google Review
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp
