The painting contractors serving Shrub Oak, NY cover a wide range of projects - from full-house interior refreshes and exterior repaints to cabinet refinishing, wallpaper installation, and light carpentry repairs. Across more than 300 reviews, a few consistent themes emerge: owners and project managers who stay personally involved, named crew members who reappear in review after review, and results that hold up well enough to bring customers back for second and third projects. Here are the top-rated contractors currently listed on Chooz Painters.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Paint Track Painting Services had over 150 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score that is difficult to sustain at that volume. They earned a Chooz Score of 89.7%, the highest among contractors serving Shrub Oak, NY. Ratings span multiple platforms, including 4.6 stars on Yelp and a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite designation, and the company has been in business for over 20 years. Paint Track is PCA Certified and EPA RRP lead-safe certified, with manufacturer certifications from Benjamin Moore and Fine Paints of Europe. What stands out from the reviews is the crew's ability to handle unusual or technically demanding projects: customers mention plaster walls, a staircase where two different wood types needed to be stain-matched precisely, and the exterior of an 1880 Victorian. Owner Ray, Project Manager Jess, and estimator Sarah are each praised by name for communication and transparency throughout the process.
- Several customers highlight the crew's approach to dust-sensitive environments, including one reviewer who noted minimal dust generation throughout a plaster project in a home with an asthmatic child
- The same crew names - Sergio, Alberto, and Chris - appear across reviews spanning multiple years, pointing to a stable, long-term team rather than rotating contractors
- Stain-matching work receives specific praise, including a staircase project where two different wood types were matched so closely the results were described as flawless
"Ray and crew were great to work with. Professional, friendly, efficient, quality work. An excellent job on the exterior of our 1880 Victorian home and several interior rooms." - Susannah Johnston, Google Review
If you want an established crew that brings the same people back every time and handles detail-sensitive work with care, Paint Track Painting Services is a strong choice.
With over 27 years in business, CertaPro Painters of Westchester NY and Southern CT has built one of the largest review profiles in the region. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 500 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, along with 94% recommended on Facebook, 4.3 stars on Yelp with over 30 reviews, and a 4.7 rating on Angi. They earned a Chooz Score of 88.4%. Operating out of Bedford Hills, they cover Westchester, Putnam, and Dutchess counties as well as Southern Connecticut. What separates CertaPro from smaller operations is a layered project management structure: account managers, production managers, and named crew leads all appear in customer reviews, coordinating work from estimate through warranty follow-up.
- Multiple reviews specifically mention garage floor finishing as a service - enough volume in the review data to suggest it is a meaningful part of their work, not a one-off offering
- Several homeowners noted CertaPro's willingness to adjust start dates and accommodate scope changes mid-project without disrupting the timeline or pricing
"As always, a great experience with this CertaPro team. From Kevin Ponce all the way to the actual painters, their attentiveness to detail and the care in which each interaction was handled. Solid team, solid results. Five star rating all around!!" - Curtis Minnis, Google Review
If you have a multi-phase project or need both painting and specialty surface work like garage floors, CertaPro Painters of Westchester is a reliable option.
Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for MGP Painting, Inc. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, 5.0 stars on Angi, and were 96% recommended on Facebook. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.2%. Based in Orangeburg, MGP has been operating for over 13 years. Owner Moises handles estimates personally and conducts a final walk-through on every job. One customer described first noticing the MGP crew working on a local library, walking in to introduce herself, and hiring them for her own home shortly after.
- Moises visits in person for estimates and returns for a final walk-through at project completion, a consistency that appears in multiple reviews as a key reason customers come back
- The team takes on work beyond standard painting, including brick painting, a hair studio, and full interior work in a historic landmarked home
- Rachel in the office is cited by name in multiple reviews for prompt scheduling communication and clear coordination before work begins
"MGP Painting, Inc. has been a pleasure to work with. They painted several rooms in my home and my mother's town house that we are selling. The owner made suggestions for the town home that ended up saving us over $2000." - Barbara McConnell, Google Review
If you want an owner who stays hands-on from the first call through final walk-through, and you have specialty surfaces or multi-location jobs, MGP Painting, Inc. is worth considering.
For homeowners who want the owner present at every stage, Pier Painting Services earns consistent praise. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 60 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp and 100% recommended on Facebook. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.1%. With over 25 years in business, owner Johnny Acosta runs every estimate, supervises every job, and frequently works alongside his crew. Reviewers describe the kind of trust that comes from a single consistent face on every visit.
- A local Westchester realtor now recommends Pier Painting to all her clients preparing homes for the spring market, describing the team as completely dependable and excellent at communication
- Beyond standard painting, the crew handles skim coating rough plaster walls, floor refinishing, built-in removal and wall patching, and chandelier installation
- Reviewers with high vaulted ceilings specifically mention the crew handled the scale and access challenges without issue, finishing quickly while maintaining attention to detail
"Johnny and his team did an excellent job. The quality of the work was great, and they were professional, neat, and attentive to detail. We've had a lot of work done in our home, and it's refreshing to work with a contractor who genuinely cares about the quality of their work." - Dina Almazan, Google Review
If you have an older home with a mix of painting and handyman needs, or you prefer working directly with an owner-operator on every visit, Pier Painting Services is a strong match.
Rounding out the top contractors in Shrub Oak, NY, Bryan Pro Painting brings over 20 years of hands-on painting experience under owner Santiago. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 60 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating and 5.0 stars on Yelp. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.2%. Santiago estimates every project personally and explains the full scope of work upfront. One reviewer considered replacing deteriorated siding on the front of their home before Santiago assessed the surface and restored the finish to near-new condition instead.
- Santiago handles estimates personally and explains the full scope upfront, with multiple reviewers noting that final costs matched or came in under the original quote
- Wallpaper removal and skim coating before painting comes up in more than one review, pointing to a crew prepared for full prep work before any brush hits the wall
"Santiago and team did an amazing job with the front of our home. Due to sun damage, the old exterior paint was flaking off to the point we were considering residing the entire house. Reassuringly, Santiago stated he could get the finish almost back to new. Within a few days of hard work, I could not believe the results." - Daniel Marrione, Google Review
If you're looking for a contractor with competitive pricing, an owner who stays personally involved, and a proven track record in exterior restoration, Bryan Pro Painting is a solid option in the Shrub Oak, NY area.
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Facebook
