Best Painters Near Pomona, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

The painting contractors serving Pomona, NY and the surrounding Rockland County area have built their reputations through reliable crews, thorough prep work, and communication that keeps homeowners informed from estimate to final walkthrough. Whether tackling historic exterior surfaces, full interior repaints, or specialty finishes, the top companies here show a consistent pattern of customers calling them back for second and third projects.

Pro Painting Plus leads the area with a Chooz Score of 87.6%. Owner Rob McRae personally handles estimate walkthroughs and visits job sites throughout each project to confirm customers are satisfied as work progresses. Reviewers describe him spotting wall damage, nail pops, and surface imperfections during that first walkthrough - repair needs many customers hadn't noticed themselves. The company covers a wide range of surfaces: cedar siding, tin roofing, weathered dock wood, cabinet refinishing, and full interior repaints. Crew members Dario, Luis, Miguel, Herbie, and Juan appear by name across multiple reviews, pointing to a stable, consistent team. If you want consistent owner involvement and a crew with documented experience on both interior and exterior challenging surfaces, Pro Painting Plus is a strong fit.

• Rob McRae (also referenced by customers as Bobby) visits job sites throughout each project, checking in daily on progress and confirming satisfaction before moving to the next stage
• Several reviewers turned to Pro Painting Plus after a previous contractor left a job incomplete - each account describes the team stepping in and resolving the situation fully
• Exterior work on demanding surfaces - an 1865 tin roof, aged lake dock wood, and cedar homes with multiple wood types - appears across reviews, with customers noting results that looked significantly younger

"Rob quickly assessed and identified my needs and wants during the estimate and the next day Dario and Eric executed the job beautifully. The wall repairs and paint job were done with precision, professionalism, and quality." - Taryn Dibble, Google Review

For homeowners seeking a full-service contractor with specialty capabilities well beyond standard painting, MGP Painting, Inc. is worth a close look. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.2%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, MGP Painting, Inc. had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Angi with over 10 reviews and 96% recommended on Facebook. Founded by owner Moises in Rockland County in 2012, the company now carries over 13 years in business and serves Rockland, Westchester, Orange, and Bergen counties. Services extend well beyond standard paint: patterned wallpaper installation, spray-applied cabinet finishes, Venetian plaster, sheetrock repair, skim coating, epoxy flooring, and deck staining. If your project involves specialty surfaces or a multi-trade scope, MGP Painting, Inc. covers it.

• Owner Moises personally handles estimates and checks in during active projects; office coordinator Rachel is praised by name in multiple reviews for keeping scheduling and communication smooth
• Specialty capabilities including patterned wallpaper, spray-applied matte cabinet finishes, and Venetian plaster set this company apart from general residential painters in the area
• Multiple customers describe discovering MGP Painting, Inc. by noticing the crew on a public or commercial project before hiring them for their own home

"I noticed the professionalism and detail-oriented crew of MGP painting my local library; I went in to hire the company to paint part of my house. The price was fair for such a quality job." - Loretta Jara, Google Review

With nearly 40 years in business since 1987, Aquinas Painting Contractors rounds out the top painters in Pomona, NY. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.3%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Aquinas Painting Contractors had over 80 Google reviews with a perfect 5.0-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Yelp and 5.0 stars on Angi with over 9 reviews. All painters carry OSHA certification and the company holds Rockland County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H-25-030. Partner Alex Solis leads the current operation across Rockland, Westchester, Bergen County, and Orange County. For homeowners who want a long-established company with verified credentials, consistent crews, and a proven track record across residential and specialty scopes, Aquinas is a solid choice.

• Reviewers consistently describe the crew going beyond the stated scope: ceiling repair after water damage, pool deck power washing, sheetrock patching, and replacing exterior light bulbs too high for the homeowner to reach
• Named crew members Miguel, Manuel, Pablo, and Roberto appear across multiple reviews for precise, professional execution on projects ranging from single rooms to full exterior repaints
• Multi-property customers appear throughout the review history - one reviewer brought the company back for a convent exterior, a kitchen, and multiple bedrooms across separate visits

"Aquinas painted the outside of my house last year and just finished my basement. They are the best painters I have ever worked with. So professional, reliable and immaculate. The work is outstanding. I wish I could do ten stars." - Robert Ebel, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Quality and workmanship rank among the most frequently praised elements across reviews for painters serving Pomona, NY. Pro Painting Plus draws repeated attention for how the quality process starts before the first coat: owner Rob McRae's estimate walkthroughs are described in multiple reviews as thorough enough to identify wall damage, nail pops, and surface flaws that customers hadn't spotted themselves. When the work begins, the results earn descriptions like "precision" and "impeccable" from reviewers writing independently across years of projects. MGP Painting, Inc. earns similar recognition for detailed prep on complex jobs - customers describe the crew's approach to rooms with popcorn ceilings, recessed-light fixtures, and multi-level layouts, noting that every surface was handled without shortcuts before the final color went on.

Aquinas Painting Contractors rounds out the quality picture, with reviewers frequently describing results that exceeded what they expected going in. One homeowner who had the team repair a wall damaged during a refrigerator delivery noted she could not tell any damage had ever existed once the work was finished. Others describe exterior surfaces on older homes looking dramatically renewed. What connects all three companies in the review record is that quality praise traces back to prep, not just the final coat - customers describe the difference as coming from surface work done before the paint, and that consistency is what keeps them coming back.

"5 Stars is not enough for the impeccable service this painting company offers. The quote was fair and the crew did an outstanding job from start to finish." - C R Bradbury, Google Review

"MGP is exceptional - from the initial meeting, detailed quote, and ability to select just the right color to the completion of the job." - Kim Busel, Google Review

"Alex and his team painted our entire interior roofline while also ensuring everything was spotless afterward. Their work was impeccable, and we couldn't be happier." - Jodi Frisch, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication is one of the most consistent strengths across the top painting contractors serving Pomona, NY. Pro Painting Plus receives repeated praise for responsiveness from first contact through project completion - multiple reviewers describe Rob McRae as personally reachable throughout each job, with questions answered same-day and no need to follow up twice. A few reviews specifically mention calling Pro Painting Plus on short notice and getting a response within hours. MGP Painting, Inc. builds communication into the structure of their operation: owner Moises handles estimates and checks in during active projects, while office coordinator Rachel manages scheduling and day-to-day contact. Multiple customers single out the office side of MGP by name, noting that the communication from the office matches what they experience with the on-site crew.

Aquinas Painting Contractors draws consistent praise for making the entire process feel organized and low-stress, particularly from repeat customers who describe a pattern of straightforward scheduling and reliable follow-through from the first call to final walkthrough. Alex Solis is credited in several reviews for being willing to rearrange his schedule to accommodate customer timing, including instances where the project needed to start sooner than originally planned. Across all three companies, the pattern in the review history is consistent: professional in the field and easy to reach off it - a combination that explains the high rate of repeat business and referrals each company shows across their review sets.

"From the very beginning until completion, communication and follow through was top notch! We are very happy with the job and our new exterior paint!" - Shannon Bostwick, Google Review

"Moises communicates clearly, sticks to the projected timeline and does a great job!" - Sally Goldberg, Google Review

"They were responsive and quick but did an excellent job. Consistent communication throughout the entire process." - Conor Kennedy, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Punctuality is one of the most frequently mentioned positives across reviews for painting contractors in the Pomona, NY area. Pro Painting Plus earns repeated mentions of crews arriving at the scheduled time and completing projects within the timelines discussed during estimates. What stands out from the review history is the ability to perform well under tight conditions - one customer described needing a full four-bedroom house painted within 48 to 72 hours of moving in, reached out to owner Bobby, and arrived to find the crew already at work and on pace to finish. MGP Painting, Inc. receives similar feedback on punctuality, with multiple customers describing consistent crew arrivals across multi-day projects. Owner Moises is specifically credited for sticking to quoted timelines and communicating clearly when any adjustment to the schedule became necessary.

Aquinas Painting Contractors rounds out the timeliness picture, with reviewers noting crews that finish on schedule or ahead of it. One customer described the team completing a full townhome interior ahead of the projected finish date. Many reviewers across all three companies use similar language: crews that showed up when they said they would, every day of the project. That consistency - not just arriving on time once but maintaining punctuality throughout multi-day jobs - is what stands out across the Pomona, NY area painting contractor review history.

"Bobby and his team arrive on time their work ethic is above and beyond. You will not be disappointed." - Alla Staszewski, Google Review

"Moises and his crew were always on time, always kept us updated, very professional, and did a great job." - Alan J. Rein, Google Review

"Aquinas personnel were very skilled, professional and reliable. They finished the job ahead of schedule!" - George Moraitis, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Prep work and cleanup are two of the most praised operational elements across reviews for painting contractors in the Pomona, NY area. Pro Painting Plus customers consistently describe a crew that treats surface preparation as its own phase of the job: walls sanded, cracks filled, nail pops addressed, and surfaces primed before any finish coat goes on. The cleanup that follows earns equal praise - floors protected throughout, furniture covered, and the workspace left clean at the end of each day rather than just at project completion. MGP Painting, Inc. draws similar recognition, with multiple customers describing how the crew covered furniture, protected floors, and handled personal belongings carefully from the first day to the last. Reviewers with particularly detailed accounts note that surrounding areas were covered before any work began and that daily cleanup was standard practice, not an afterthought.

Aquinas Painting Contractors receives frequent mention for cleanup that goes beyond expectations, with reviewers noting the crew returning furniture to its original placement after work, organizing the space daily, and leaving areas cleaner than they found them. One customer described a ceiling and wall repair where the finished result left no trace of the original damage. For homeowners with furniture, finished floors, and personal belongings to protect during a painting project, prep and cleanup practices consistently rank among the most appreciated aspects of the experience across contractors serving the Pomona, NY area.

"The workers showed up on time, protected all of my plants, cleaned up afterwards. Overall a pleasure to work with this company." - Andrea Volpe, Google Review

"The crew was great! They were neat, thorough and cleaned up like they were never there. The few punch items were corrected ASAP." - Eric Dallendorfer, Google Review

"They were punctual, clean and professional. Will definitely use them again." - Kathleen Miller, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google