Question 1

Who are the top-rated painters in South Farmingdale, NY on Chooz Painters?

Accepted Answer

Painting contractors serving South Farmingdale, NY have built strong reputations across Nassau County for careful prep work, consistent crews, and job sites left spotless at the end of every day. The companies reviewed on Chooz Painters reflect a high standard, with track records built on repeat customers and word-of-mouth referrals. Below are the top-rated painters in the area, ranked by Chooz Score. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Teall Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating and a Chooz Score of 87.6% . Based in Massapequa Park and led by owner Charlie Teall, the company runs a crew-based operation where the same painters return across projects - a consistency customers notice and frequently mention in reviews. The company carries Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. 204692 and backs all workmanship with a 2-year Iron-Clad Warranty and 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. Review coverage also includes 5.0 stars on Yelp . If you want a contractor where the owner stays actively involved from estimate to final walkthrough, Teall Painting is a strong choice for the South Farmingdale, NY area. Reviewers describe a wide range of project types handled by the Teall team: full house interiors after major renovations, western red cedar home and deck restoration, stucco and siding work, cabinet refinishing, and deck staining. Several customers note that Charlie walked through the completed job with them and checked in regularly by call or text while work was in progress. The estimate process stands out as unusually thorough, with itemized write-ups and same-day follow-up common across multiple reviews. First-time homeowners and long-term repeat customers alike describe the crew as professional and easy to have in the home, with several noting they left for hours during a project and came back to find the work progressing without any issues. Teall handles specialty restoration work alongside standard residential painting, including wainscoting installation and mahogany door refinishing that previous contractors had been unable to complete to the customer's satisfaction. Multiple reviewers note that final costs matched the original quote, even when additional materials or extra trips to the hardware store were needed during the project. "His team is courteous, timely and did an excellent job restaining and restoring our home/deck. Charles himself is very responsive and his painting team lead Omar was always on hand during the project even when we weren't home." - Rhoderick B., Google Review A hands-on owner is the defining quality of Big Expert Painting LLC . Owner Denis personally handles every estimate, stays in direct communication throughout each project, and is mentioned by name in the vast majority of reviews. The company earned a Chooz Score of 87.0% . The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Big Expert Painting LLC had over 130 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating , along with 5.0 stars on Yelp . The company holds a Suffolk County Home Improvement License verified active through 2027 and carries EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for work on pre-1978 homes. If you want an owner who picks up the phone, responds on weekends, and shows up for the estimate rather than dispatching a salesperson, Big Expert Painting LLC fits that profile well. The range of work Denis and his crew take on goes well beyond standard painting. Reviews cover full basement buildouts from sheetrock to final coat, wallpaper removal followed by skim coating on difficult walls, crown molding installation, kitchen cabinet refinishing, pool painting, and exterior deck restoration. Reviewers from across Nassau and Suffolk County - including Levittown, Massapequa, Baldwin, Brentwood, and Selden - describe similar results and competitive pricing. Denis is known for same-day responses, including weekends, and multiple reviewers describe him checking weather forecasts before scheduling exterior work to avoid weather-related delays. Several customers describe starting with a smaller scope and immediately expanding the project after seeing the initial results, booking Denis and his crew for additional rooms or services before the first job was finished. EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification is a relevant credential for homeowners in older Long Island neighborhoods where pre-1978 construction is common. "Used Big Expert Painting to remove wallpaper in our bedroom and to paint two other rooms. The job was completed in the time estimated and totally exceeded my expectations! The walls look amazing, one would never know there was wallpaper up for 15+ years! Painters were all friendly, courteous, and timely!" - Karen C., Google Review Rounding out the top contractors in South Farmingdale, NY , Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting brings over 25 years of service to Long Island homeowners. The company earned a Chooz Score of 85.7% . The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Walker Painting had over 245 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating , along with 4.8 stars on Yelp from over 25 Yelp reviews and 5.0 stars on Angi from over 80 Angi reviews . The company holds Nassau County Home Improvement Contractor License No. H3807630000 and a NYC DCWP Home Improvement Contractor License, with zero complaints and zero violations on file through Nassau County Consumer Affairs. For homeowners who want an established company with a verifiable long-term track record, Walker Painting is a reliable choice. Dave Walker and Sal Sciame co-run the business, and Sal's name comes up constantly in reviews - customers describe him arriving on-site each morning, sending progress photos to homeowners who cannot be present, and returning after job completion to check in. Named crew members like Hugo, Alfonso, Miguel, Luis, and Alfredo appear across dozens of reviews, with customers requesting the same individuals for return work. One reviewer described how the crew came back after movers damaged freshly painted walls to touch things up at no additional charge. Walker Painting employs full-time, in-house crews rather than subcontractors, with most team members having been with the company for over 15 years. Sal personally supervises jobs, often arriving each morning to review progress and check in with customers before the day's work begins. The company covers a wide service area across both Nassau and Suffolk County, with reviews coming from Massapequa, Levittown, Seaford, Wantagh, Bethpage, and surrounding communities. "After we moved back in, they returned without hesitation to touch up areas that had been dinged or damaged by the movers and other subcontractors. That kind of follow-through and dedication to quality is rare, and we are so grateful for it." - Jillienne J., Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Yelp, Angi, Facebook

Question 2

What do customers say about quality and workmanship from painters in South Farmingdale, NY?

Accepted Answer

Quality of finished work is the theme that comes up most consistently across reviews for painters serving South Farmingdale, NY . Customers of Teall Painting frequently describe results that go beyond standard residential painting - the company takes on specialty projects like western red cedar restoration, stucco exteriors, and mahogany door refinishing, with reviewers noting the precision applied to surfaces that had stumped previous contractors. At Big Expert Painting LLC , reviews highlight cabinet refinishing results customers describe as showroom-quality, as well as wallpaper removal followed by skim coating that left walls looking like they had never had paper on them - with several customers noting that even people who knew about the original wallpaper could not tell it had been there after the work was done. Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting earns similar praise for surface preparation and application standards on homes ranging from recent construction to properties that are 85 years old. Reviewers describe crisp, clean lines at trim and ceiling intersections, proper prep work including caulking and priming before paint goes on, and the kind of surface attention - filling holes, sanding, skimming where needed - that shows up in how the finished result holds over time. One customer described the Walker crew noticing a cracked basement window during an exterior project and flagging it before the job was done. Across all three companies in South Farmingdale, NY , the clearest pattern in reviews is that attention to prep work drives the quality of the finished result. "Excellent job! Neat and professional. We have used BigExpert Painting to paint 3 bedrooms so far and install crown molding, doors and trim. Will absolutely be calling them for future home projects!" - Joseph M., Google Review "Its about the prep and the time they took filling holes, sanding and skimming where necessary made all the difference. Our walls look like new!" - Anne C., Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Question 3

How do painting contractors in South Farmingdale, NY handle customer communication?

Accepted Answer

Responsiveness and clear communication are recurring themes in reviews for painters serving South Farmingdale, NY . At Teall Painting , customers describe owner Charlie providing itemized estimates with same-day follow-up and staying in contact regularly by call or text while work is in progress. Multiple reviewers mention that Charlie addressed concerns the same day they came up and checked in at the end of each day to confirm everything was on track. Big Expert Painting LLC owner Denis is known for answering calls directly, responding to quote requests the same day - including weekends - and maintaining clear communication throughout each project from estimate through final walkthrough. At Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting , Sal Sciame's communication approach stands out in reviews. Customers describe Sal arriving on-site in the mornings personally, sending photos to homeowners who cannot be present during the day, and returning after project completion to check in on satisfaction. One reviewer noted that Sal came back after the job was finished to touch up additional holes the customer had forgotten to mention - at no extra charge. Another described the Walker painters arriving at 7:50 AM and waiting for the agreed 8:00 AM start time before ringing the doorbell. These patterns reflect a standard of follow-through shared across all three top-rated companies serving South Farmingdale, NY . "It was a pleasure dealing with Charles. He was extremely professional and helpful. He advised me on the best type of paint and color for the job. The painters showed up right on time each day and worked diligently to finish the project." - Nadia S., Google Review "Sal was always easy to reach and responded quickly to all my inquiries via call or text, both before and during the job. Even though I wasn't home most of the time, he sent photos to keep me updated on the progress." - Leslie, Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Question 4

Do painting crews in South Farmingdale, NY clean up properly after finishing a job?

Accepted Answer

Site protection and end-of-day cleanup come up in reviews for every major painting company serving South Farmingdale, NY , and the pattern is consistent across all three top-rated contractors. At Teall Painting , customers describe floors being covered with drop cloths and plastic sheathing before work begins, and rooms left spotless at the end of each day with no paint drips or debris. At Big Expert Painting LLC , reviewers note that furniture is covered and moved before work starts and returned to its original position when the job is done. One reviewer specifically mentioned that Denis's crew swept up leaves they had tracked in on the way to the job site - a small detail that reflects the overall standard the company holds itself to. At Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting , customers offer particularly specific cleanup descriptions. One reviewer described the crew placing tarps from the front door all the way to the work area on each day's arrival. Another - an elderly homeowner - noted that Walker's team moved bookshelves and carefully returned every book to its proper place after painting was complete. Customers across all three companies describe leaving the house during a job and returning to find it cleaner than expected. For homeowners in South Farmingdale, NY with new floors, fresh carpets, or existing furniture they want protected, all three companies on this list have track records worth reviewing. "Jose and his team arrived on time both days and left our home spotless. We are so happy with the finished product and HIGHLY recommend Teall Painting!" - Michelle S., Google Review "The painters were on time, polite and friendly, cleaned everything up before they left and went above and beyond." - Nina J., Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Question 5

What do customers say about pricing and value from painters in South Farmingdale, NY?

Accepted Answer

Pricing and value come up consistently in reviews for painting contractors in South Farmingdale, NY , and the feedback across all three top-rated companies reflects a similar pattern: transparent estimates, final invoices that match what was quoted, and results customers describe as worth the cost. At Teall Painting , multiple reviewers describe comparing estimates from several contractors and choosing Teall for the best combination of price and quality. One homeowner preparing to sell described getting about half a dozen estimates, finding most too expensive, and ultimately selecting Teall for both competitive pricing and strong workmanship. At Big Expert Painting LLC , customers describe Denis's pricing as fair and clearly communicated, with scope and costs discussed upfront and no surprises at the end. At Long Island Painting Company - Walker Painting , customers note that despite the company employing full-time, in-house crews and using premium paint products, their pricing remained competitive with contractors using subcontracted labor. One reviewer noted that Walker's quote was the most reasonable among multiple estimates received, and that Sal returned after the job to handle additional touch-ups at no extra charge. Across all three companies serving South Farmingdale, NY , transparent, upfront estimates and no-surprise final bills appear as a consistent theme and a key reason customers return for future projects. "They not only had the best pricing but the workmanship was amazing!! and they finished before the estimated time!!" - Greg S., Google Review "Dennis and his crew were on time and prepared to go each day. Did a wonderful job on the interior and exterior stairs. A very thorough and clean job at a VERY reasonable price. Highly recommend this company!" - Chris B., Google Review ~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Question 6

Who are the humans that helped create the South Farmingdale, NY Chooz Painters listing page?

Accepted Answer

This page was created by our dedicated team members. Chooz Listing Page & Profile Creator: Cher B., Almira A.. Chooz Score Reviewer: Ed Anthony D., Mike N.. Each team member contributes to ensuring the accuracy and quality of our painter listings and reviews.

Best Painters Near South Farmingdale, NY - Chooz Score Ranked

Big Expert Painting LLC

Chooz Score 75.8%

Why Customers Choose Big Expert Painting LLC

Hands-On Leadership

The Reviews Speak for Themselves

Customers Keep Coming Back

Other Reviews & Ratings

Q&A Based On What Customers Are Saying About Painting Contractors in South Farmingdale, NY