3 Best Painters Near Southfields, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners and businesses in Southfields, NY have access to some of the Hudson Valley and Orange County's most-reviewed painting contractors, with several teams earning consistent cross-platform ratings for interior, exterior, and specialty work. Based on the latest Chooz Score analysis, here are the top-rated painters serving the area.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Ryan's Painting had over 110 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, earning a Chooz Score of 88.6%. Based in New Windsor and serving the region surrounding Southfields, NY, Ryan's has also earned 5.0 stars on Angi with over 30 reviews, is 100% recommended on Facebook, and holds 5.0 stars on Yelp. They are accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2025. Reading through the customer reviews, one standout pattern is how often homeowners mention Ryan identifying problems they hadn't noticed - a roof leak, an uneven surface - and flagging them proactively. Multiple customers describe starting a project intending just one or two rooms and expanding the scope because of how smoothly the initial work went. If you're looking for a team that communicates proactively and catches details before they become bigger issues, Ryan's Painting is a strong fit.

• Several reviewers hired Ryan's Painting for multiple project types within the same engagement, including wall painting, drywall repair, trim work, and floor installation
• Ryan personally stays in contact with customers throughout the job, and homeowners who were away during the project describe feeling fully updated by phone and photo
• Historic property owners in the area specifically mention Ryan's Painting for careful work on older structures, including an 1865-era tin roof and Second Empire exteriors

"Ryan and his team are true professionals. They are prompt, courteous, and efficient. They took the extra time to ensure the project was done to the highest standard." - Richard B., Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY. With over 12 years in business based in Warwick, they earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%. At the time of our analysis, they had over 175 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating, along with 4.9 stars on Angi with over 20 reviews and over 15 Yelp reviews. They were also named a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in both 2022 and 2023. What stands out most in the actual reviews is how many clients describe returning year after year for entirely different project types - exterior staining one year, kitchen cabinets another, deck cleaning and power washing the next. One reviewer notes the team remembered paint colors from a job completed 13 years prior. CertaPro also handles commercial accounts with multi-year relationships spanning several building types. If you have a property with ongoing painting needs or want a contractor who keeps careful records over time, CertaPro is a reliable long-term partner.

• Owner Brendan McManus personally handles estimates with color recommendations and detailed walkthroughs, then follows up during and after each job
• CertaPro handles commercial properties alongside residential accounts, including multi-story office buildings and retail spaces with active operations during painting
• Site manager Askold is individually praised across multiple reviews for cabinet painting, ceiling repairs, and thorough prep work
• Customers across many years describe consistent crew quality, suggesting stable staffing and low turnover across seasons

"We've been with Brendan and CertaPro Painters for the last 3 iterations of paint jobs at our 3 story office building. They have all been done with professionalism, great communication, and outstanding results!" - Seely D., Google Review

While CertaPro has built its reputation on long-term client relationships, Pro Painting Plus, led by owner Rob McRae and based in Monroe, has earned its following across a wide range of specialty project types. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.6%. Reviewers consistently describe Rob arriving at the job site every day throughout the project - not just at the estimate - and flagging repairs customers hadn't identified. Crew members Dario, Eric, Herbie, and Juan receive individual mentions across reviews for clean prep and finished surfaces. The project types in the review record are notably varied: an 1865-era tin roof restoration, lakeside dock staining, log cabin exterior work, and historic church shingle restoration. If your project is non-standard or involves a surface that requires research before any brush is lifted, Pro Painting Plus has demonstrated that range. If you want an owner who walks through every detail of a job with you and surfaces issues ahead of time, Pro Painting Plus is a good fit.

• Pro Painting Plus serves a wide footprint, with crews traveling to Sullivan County and other out-of-area locations for residential and specialty projects
• Rob is specifically praised during estimate walkthroughs, with multiple reviewers describing him identifying issues they had not noticed on their own
• Deck and dock staining, cedar siding, historic roof restoration, and church shingles all appear alongside standard interior and exterior work in the review record

"Absolutely gorgeous results, done by friendly and skilled painters, led by the owner of ProPaintingPlus Rob McRae, who knows the business inside and out." - Elizabeth G., Google Review

With over 13 years in business, MGP Painting Inc., based in Orangeburg and led by owner Moises, has built one of the most substantial review records in the region. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.2%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 200 Google reviews with a 4.9-star rating, along with 5.0 stars on Angi with over 10 reviews and 96% recommended on Facebook. Moises is praised across the review record for providing detailed, itemized quotes quickly and visiting job sites personally during projects to check on progress. The scope of work in the reviews is notably varied - a hair studio owner describes the crew producing bold, dramatic results in a commercial space, while others describe complex multi-level homes with high ceilings, recessed lights, and mixed surface types handled cleanly throughout. Wallpaper installation is a specialty that appears across multiple reviews. If you have a demanding project with varied surfaces, specialty finishes, or significant scope, MGP has shown it can handle that volume without losing quality on the details.

• Wallpaper installation is a recurring specialty, with crew member Galo praised for precise, clean application across multiple customer accounts
• MGP has served customers across county and state lines, with projects in Mahwah, NJ and Goshen, NY both appearing in the review record
• Moises personally visits job sites during projects to check on progress, not just at the start and finish

"Moises is very professional, fast, and willing to help you in any way he can. He gave me a detailed, itemized quote same day! He makes the toughest job look easy, and he's sure to follow up and get the job done right." - Nina M., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors serving Southfields, NY, KB Quality Painting, led by owner Kevin and based in Highland Mills, earned a Chooz Score of 83.2%. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 120 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score across every single review. Kevin is praised for personally assisting with color selection, working alongside his crew on site, and staying reachable by text and phone throughout every project. Reviewers describe an overall small-business feel with a contractor who is personally invested in the finished product. Repeat customer Devon K. has used Kevin for "many jobs" and describes consistent, reliable results across all of them. KB Quality Painting also handles commercial work and specialty surfaces alongside standard residential projects. If you want a hands-on owner personally accountable from estimate through final walkthrough, KB Quality Painting is a good choice.

• Kevin is praised for same-day responsiveness by text and call, with multiple reviewers describing communication as a standout part of the experience
• KB Quality Painting handles stucco exteriors, which require specialized prep and product selection beyond standard siding work
• Reviewers consistently describe Kevin's crew as neat and organized, leaving job sites clean at the end of each workday

"KB Quality Painting painted the exterior of our stucco home. The crew was on time and they were very polite. They are true professionals and work closely with you to achieve the best possible outcome." - Jordan A., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Customers in Southfields, NY consistently describe results that go well beyond a fresh coat of paint. Reviewers frequently call out precise edge work, careful surface repairs, and finished projects that look significantly better than expected. Ryan's Painting earns regular praise for drywall repairs completed as part of the painting scope, with homeowners describing multiple wall imperfections addressed before a single coat was applied. Elise M. describes Ryan's team working through "MANY" drywall repairs alongside the main floor painting, trim, ceilings, and doors - all completed quickly and cleanly. Pro Painting Plus draws similar feedback, with crew members Herbie and Juan called out specifically for addressing cracks, seams, nail pops, and other blemishes as a standard part of the prep process before any painting began. For homeowners with older properties, these finishing details make a significant difference in the final result.

MGP Painting Inc. and Certified Painting LLC round out the quality picture in the area. MGP reviewers describe carefully protected floors, furniture, and fixtures before work begins, along with crew members like Galo and Caesar called out for precise wallpaper installation and edge work on specialty finishes. Certified Painting LLC draws repeat customers specifically because of what Brian Shannon does with older and historic homes - plaster repair, multi-coat priming, and careful finish work on properties with significant surface complexity. Several customers with 1930s and pre-1920 homes describe Brian's team handling historic plaster and original woodwork with real care throughout. If finished quality and surface prep are your primary concerns when choosing a painter, any of these four teams have demonstrated strong results across their review records.

"Ryan and his team did an incredible job painting our main floor, to include drywall repairs (of which there were MANY), painting the trim, ceilings, walls, as well as doors. They made very quick work of it." - Elise M., Google Review"Brian and the certified painting team were incredibly professional and responsive from start to finish in all of the painting jobs at my house. From the initial quote, to the final walkthru, Brian is outstanding." - Jon D., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication is one of the most consistently praised qualities across painting contractor reviews in the Southfields, NY area. CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY stands out for offering multiple points of contact throughout a project - owner Brendan McManus handles the estimate and stays involved on larger jobs, while office administrator Joanne manages scheduling and handles calls and emails promptly when Brendan is on site. Mary Ann G. describes Brendan taking time to help select porch and accent wall colors, with Eduardo delivering a result that matched exactly what was discussed. For business owners and busy homeowners, that kind of structured, multi-channel communication removes a lot of stress from the process. Ryan's Painting earns similar marks, with multiple reviewers noting Ryan answered questions throughout the project and kept homeowners updated even when they were away from the property during work hours.

Certified Painting LLC brings an additional dimension to the communication story: owner Brian Shannon managed a project for an out-of-state client who couldn't be present, sending periodic photos throughout so they could follow progress from a distance. For homeowners coordinating a paint job while traveling or managing from afar, that kind of proactive updating is rare. KB Quality Painting owner Kevin consistently earns praise for same-day responsiveness by text and phone, with multiple reviewers describing him as "always" reachable throughout the project. Mekenzi M. describes Kevin's knowledge of products and fine details as impressive from the very first quote conversation. For homeowners who value being kept informed and involved, all four of these teams show a consistent commitment to that kind of transparency.

"Brian of Certified Painting, LLC went above and beyond in our view! He was fair, honest and very professional with his quote and timeline. We live out of state and Brian sent photos periodically to keep us informed of the painting's progress." - Terry W., Google Review"I am so glad we hired Kevin to paint our home. I was really impressed by how quickly he responded to my texts and calls. The entire team was professional and polite. The pricing was most reasonable when compared to other quotes I received." - Kathleen W., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Timeliness is a theme that comes up consistently across painting contractor reviews in the Southfields, NY area, with multiple teams praised for arriving when they said they would and finishing within the expected window. Ryan's Painting receives particular praise for quick turnarounds without sacrificing quality - one customer describes Ryan adding extra crew members toward the end of a two-week project to ensure they wrapped up on time. Wallace G. describes Ryan arriving a few minutes early to the estimate appointment, then following through on the promised timeline throughout the job. CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY earns similar feedback, with one reviewer noting the team completed the full job before the promised deadline - an outcome that came as a pleasant surprise given the scope of the project. CertaPro's office keeps customers updated on scheduling, so there are no unexpected delays or last-minute changes without communication.

Pro Painting Plus draws attention specifically for showing up on time even when traveling significant distances - Kimberly A. notes the crew arrived "first thing in the morning both days" despite traveling to Sullivan County for the job. That kind of reliability across geographic distance stands out. KB Quality Painting earns consistent five-star feedback for punctuality, with Maureen K. describing a crew that arrived exactly when they said they would and cleaned up at the end of each day before leaving. For homeowners who have had bad experiences with no-shows or shifting timelines, these teams have built track records in the region that are worth noting.

"Very Happy with Ryan's Painting. Called on Monday and Ryan came to our home on Thursday for the estimate appointment. Arrived a few minutes early, professional, courteous and gave us a fair estimate." - Wallace G., Google Review"The crew showed up first thing in the morning both days even while traveling to Sullivan County. The finished product is amazing and the attention to prep and detail was over the top!" - Kimberly A., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and prep work are topics that appear across nearly every review for painting contractors in the Southfields, NY area, and several teams stand out for the care they bring to the work before any paint goes up. Certified Painting LLC earns repeated praise for thorough prep on older homes - one customer with a 1930s colonial describes Brian and his team fixing a significant number of imperfections in historic plaster walls as they moved through each room, addressing surface issues before painting to ensure a clean and even finished result. Multiple other reviewers with pre-1920 homes describe the same approach, with plaster repair, multi-coat priming, and careful edge work all noted as part of the standard process. MGP Painting Inc. customers consistently describe crews protecting floors, furniture, and fixtures before any work begins - Valerie G. specifically notes the team patched every hole in her ceilings and walls while also protecting newly refinished floors throughout the entire job.

Pro Painting Plus receives specific feedback on prep from crew members Herbie and Juan, with one customer describing them addressing cracks, seams, nail pops, and other wall blemishes as a standard part of the process before painting began. Ryan's Painting earns similar marks, with several customers noting the crew addressed drywall issues they hadn't originally planned to fix as part of the project scope, completing that repair work without affecting the overall timeline. For homeowners in older properties or houses that need surface work before paint, these teams have demonstrated that prep and cleanup are built into the process rather than treated as extras.

"Brian and his team at Certified Painting did a wonderful job painting the interior of our 1930s home. The thoroughness of their job included fixing a lot of imperfections in the house's historic plaster walls as they worked through our home. We couldn't be happier." - Skip W., Google Review"MGP gave us a fair estimate and provided a detailed explanation of what they would cover. They seamlessly patched all of the holes in our ceiling and walls and took great care prepping the interior and our newly refinished floors to avoid any damage." - Valerie G., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Value and competitive pricing come up consistently across reviews for painting contractors serving Southfields, NY, with multiple teams praised for delivering results that customers feel were fairly priced relative to the quality of work. Ryan's Painting receives consistent feedback on pricing transparency, with customers describing Ryan's estimates as clear and competitive compared to other quotes received. Michael W. describes getting four quotes for a deck and fence staining project and choosing Ryan - not because he was the cheapest, but because the combination of detailed communication, product knowledge, and fair pricing made the overall value clear. CertaPro Painters of Orange County, NY earns similar marks, with Don B. describing the proposal price as "very good" and the finished result as even better than expected - a pattern that appears across CertaPro's reviews, where the outcome consistently matches or exceeds what the quote described.

KB Quality Painting is praised across many reviews for pricing that customers describe as "reasonable" and "excellent" given the quality delivered. Kathleen W. compared Kevin's quote to several others in the area and found it "most reasonable." MGP Painting Inc. earns praise from customers who vetted multiple painting companies and chose MGP based on a combination of track record, detailed estimate format, and competitive price. Mike M. specifically describes choosing MGP for deck sanding and staining because they offered the best combination of price, service, and results. For homeowners balancing budget with quality expectations, these teams consistently deliver work that customers describe as worth the investment.

"I received four quotes for the project, and while Ryan was not the cheapest or most expensive option, he was the best option. Easy to communicate with, very detailed in explaining the process, and offered a fair price." - Michael W., Google Review"For the sanding and staining of my deck, MGP provided me with the best price, best service and I got amazing results! The deck looks brand new." - Mike M., Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google