Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for Monarch Painting
Monarch Painting opened its doors in Rochester, NY, in late 2020, yet the hands behind every brushstroke carry far more history than those few years suggest. Owner Eric Anderson, a SUNY Brockport marketing graduate with deep roots in the retail painting industry, built the company on a crew of veteran painters he had worked alongside at his previous business, Colors and Colors.
That continuity shows in the details reviewers return to again and again. Drywall and plaster work that blends invisibly into hundred-year-old walls. Cabinet refinishing that customers compare to factory results. Thorough prep using No-VOC products and daily cleanup that leaves homes livable even mid-project.
Anderson runs a tight in-house operation. Crew members like Brent, Ben, Jimmy, and Jade appear by name across dozens of five-star reviews, praised for punctuality, friendliness, and meticulous attention to finishes. The company holds lead paint remediation certification and is fully insured, serving residential clients across the Greater Rochester area with interior and exterior painting, deck restoration, pressure washing, gutter cleaning, and wallpaper removal.
Updated: 06-11-2026
Multiple homeowners describe repair work on homes built in the early 1900s where seams, patches, and old damage vanish under Monarch's hands. Lydia P detailed a hallway and stairwell project where the repairs blended seamlessly with the existing walls and ceiling, noting that most other companies wanted to tear everything out rather than work with the original surfaces. Nancy Kaproth praised a similar level of care on her 1954 ranch, highlighting a vacuum-sander system that kept dust under control over a three-week project.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The name Eric surfaces in well over a hundred reviews, and the pattern is consistent. Salil Athalye's family noted that Eric communicated with us each phase of the project and was helpful with color selection. Joseph Smith called him friendly and helpful throughout a three-week interior transformation. Lydia P also appreciated that Eric checked in daily and provided a clear hourly rate and estimated timeframe from the beginning.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Customers routinely single out painters like Brent, Ben, Jimmy, Jade, Brian, and Rob. Jerry ODell praised Ben and Brent for great attention to detail and quality workmanship. Heather Nenadic credited Ben, Jimmy, and Jade for their professionalism and kindness toward her elderly pets during a multi-room project. Roger Smith listed five crew members by name, calling the entire team tremendous to work with. That level of name recognition signals a stable, skilled in-house roster.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The scope of documented work runs well past standard wall color changes. Jeffrey Vuillequez hired the crew for a whole-house repaint including cabinet painting before a home sale. Ann Pompa had textured ceilings removed while she was away for the winter. Marilyn Iulianella's family used them for ceiling repair and basement waterproofing. Richard Guerino described a kitchen project where the crew took great care in prepping the surfaces, protecting our cabinets and floor and delivered results he called amazing.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Exterior projects get the same detail-oriented approach. David Larrison was referred for floor repainting after pulling up carpet and called the crew very professional and detailed. Steve Xenias praised a deck staining job along with various touch-ups. Alisa Hall had her house, garage, two porches painted and deck stained, with some carpentry included. Andrew Cooke described a full exterior sequence of power washing, patching, repairing stucco, and painting on a historic home.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Only one review in the two-year window falls below five stars. Nan See gave four stars but still concluded that the owner truly stands by making the customer happy, noting the walls looked great and that the crew treated her home with respect. That single data point, paired with a 97.8 percent owner-response rate across 90 Google reviews, suggests a business that monitors feedback closely and acts on it.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Monarch Painting, Inc. is an active Domestic Business Corporation registered with the New York Department of State under DOS ID 5866065, filed on 10-27-2020. New York does not require a statewide painting contractor license. The company carries an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau of Upstate New York and states on its Facebook page that it is fully insured. Eric Anderson serves as president and principal contact.
-Verification Sources: NY Department of State, Better Business Bureau, Facebook
Updated: 06-11-2026