6 Best Painters Near Brockport, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Brockport, NY have access to several highly reviewed painting contractors serving the western Monroe County area. Across hundreds of verified reviews, customers highlight crews that show up on time, communicate clearly, and deliver consistent results. Here are the top-rated companies based on the Chooz Painters scoring system.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook. This company earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%. Owner Chris Sekula leads a team where individual painters are frequently called out by name, and reviewers describe being comfortable leaving the house while crews work inside. The company also offers virtual color mock-ups to help homeowners visualize choices before committing. If you need interior and exterior painting from a company with established crews and strong office communication, Sekula's is a solid choice.

• Multiple reviewers mention feeling safe leaving pets and children around the crew during interior projects
• The company has been recognized as the Greater Rochester Chamber of Commerce Business Person of the Year

"If I could give them more stars, I would! Chris and his team are consummate professionals. They ticked every box: prompt, hard-working, skilled, friendly, and respectful of our home." - Elizabeth Palmer, Google Review

For homeowners who want an owner personally involved in every estimate, R&R Painting & concrete coatings stands out with a Chooz Score of 87.5%, over 200 Google reviews, and a perfect 5.0-star rating. Owner Mark Rivoli is mentioned by name in the vast majority of reviews. R&R also handles concrete coatings as an authorized Penntek dealer. If you are preparing a home for sale or need railings and staircases refreshed, R&R is a strong fit.

• Commercial clients, including an orthodontic office, praise R&R's ability to work around business schedules
• Homeowners in Rochester's historic districts highlight their experience with original materials on multi-story exteriors

"We have had a number of painters through the years. R&R really listened to us the customer, the paint job looks astounding, we are getting so many compliments!" - Alison B, Google Review

When it comes to older homes with plaster walls and layered paint, Monarch Painting has built a reputation for careful surface preparation. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 95 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0-star rating. Fully insured and lead-safe certified for pre-1978 homes, Monarch was named a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in 2021 and 2023. If you have a century-old home that needs special care, Monarch is a great option.

• Several reviewers hired Monarch specifically to fix problems left by previous painters, praising the crew's patience with damaged walls
• Owner Eric checks in on job sites daily, even when multiple projects run simultaneously

"Eric and his guys did a great job in our kitchen. They were tidy during the painting and cleaned up completely afterwards." - Anthony Giovinazzo, Google Review

Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Painting Plus Professionals, with a Chooz Score of 86.5%, over 75 Google reviews at 5.0 stars, and 4.8 stars on Angi across over 35 reviews. They are accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2016. If you are considering cabinet refinishing rather than full replacement, Painting Plus is worth a call.

• Their cabinet specialist brings physical sample doors to estimates so homeowners can see the finished product before committing
• Epoxy garage floor customers describe the crew leveling severely sloped concrete before coating, going beyond what others offered

"I was skeptical when Painting Plus told me they 'were not like all the others' and take great pride in their work. We've been burned before and were looking for someone we could trust." - Cathie Wright, Google Review

A hands-on, owner-operated company, Colors of Rochester earned a Chooz Score of 85.1% with over 55 Google reviews at a 4.8-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook. Owner Hope Worthington took over in late 2023 and is Monroe County MWBE certified. If you want a painter who walks you through color selection personally, Colors of Rochester fits that need.

• One reviewer had color anxiety after day one and was impressed that Hope adjusted the plan on day two without hesitation
• Several customers note same-day completion for smaller jobs like kitchens and bedrooms

"Hope and Makayla did an excellent job painting our kitchen and bedroom! It was all done in one day and it looks amazing!" - Amy Toric, Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Brockport, NY, Whelehan Painting brings nearly 50 years in business since its founding in 1977. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.0% with over 175 Google reviews at a 4.9-star rating, 98% recommended on Facebook, and 5.0 stars on Yelp. Run by Pat Whelehan and partner Jeff, with 16 in-house employees, their crew size lets them finish jobs in a day or two that would take smaller companies a week. No deposit required.

• One customer has used Whelehan for 17 consecutive years and notes consistent quality throughout
• Homeowners with historic properties, including an 1880s house, praise the crew's careful prep on older surfaces
• Several reviewers hired Whelehan after receiving higher bids from competitors and found the quality exceeded expectations

"This is the second time we have hired Whelehan Painting. Pat and his team are professional, detailed, and neat. They have always gone above and beyond." - John, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Angi, BBB

Painting quality is the most frequently praised aspect across reviews for contractors serving the Brockport, NY area. Customers describe finished walls that look smooth and even, with clean lines, no drips, and careful attention to edges and trim.

Monarch Painting receives some of the most detailed praise for workmanship, especially on challenging surfaces. Reviewers describe walls that had been poorly painted by previous contractors coming out perfectly smooth after Monarch's prep and painting process. "You would have no idea how terrible rough they looked beforehand. The walls came out so smooth!" - Stephanie Leonardo, Google Review. R&R Painting & concrete coatings earns similar praise, with customers noting owner Mark's habit of correcting even minor imperfections before calling a job complete. "The painting was of exceptionally high quality - edges perfectly cut-in." - Kate Rubin, Google Review. Painting Plus Professionals is particularly noted for their cabinet refinishing craftsmanship, while Whelehan Painting impresses with historic home expertise. "The job was by far the best I have had, and I have had my house painted three times." - Howie Less, Google Review.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Communication is one of the highest-rated qualities among painting contractors serving Brockport, NY. Across hundreds of reviews, customers describe prompt responses to initial inquiries, clear timelines, and daily updates while work is underway.

Sekula's Precision Painting stands out for their office staff, with multiple reviewers praising the team for quick responses and smooth scheduling. "This company runs as a business should - prompt response time, great communication from start to finish." - Suzanne Calia, Google Review. R&R Painting & concrete coatings customers highlight owner Mark Rivoli's responsiveness and follow-through on commitments. Painting Plus Professionals earns praise for keeping homeowners informed daily. "The communication on the project was outstanding throughout, starting with the estimate, color recommendations, and through the execution of the job." - docfisher97, Google Review. Whelehan Painting owner Pat is described as always accessible, while Colors of Rochester owner Hope Worthington is praised for direct, personal communication throughout each project.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, BBB, Angi

Cleanup and preparation are among the most frequently praised aspects of painting contractors serving Brockport, NY. Reviewers across multiple companies describe crews that protect floors, furniture, and fixtures before starting, and leave homes cleaner than they found them.

Whelehan Painting receives consistent praise for their organization, with reviewers noting furniture is carefully moved and everything put back at the end of each day. "They cleaned up every night and came through on everything they said they would do." - Dan Lash, Google Review. Monarch Painting customers describe drop cloths covering every surface and crews vacuuming after sanding. Sekula's Precision Painting reviewers mention crews keeping equipment neatly organized during multi-week exterior projects. "The team kept their equipment neatly organized over the weeks they were on site." - Kathleen Meisenzahl, Google Review. Painting Plus Professionals earns specific praise for their prep work, with customers noting not a drop of paint ended up on appliances or floors. R&R Painting & concrete coatings is also noted for tidy work, with commercial clients appreciating clean job sites.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi

Timeliness is a consistent strength across the top painting contractors serving Brockport, NY. Reviewers frequently mention crews arriving on time, sticking to quoted timelines, and completing projects faster than expected.

Whelehan Painting is particularly noted for speed, with their 16-person crew completing entire home interiors in two to three days. "Whelehan Painting painted the entire interior of my home in just 3 days!" - Kathie Ryan, Google Review. Sekula's Precision Painting reviewers describe crews arriving at the same time every morning and completing projects within quoted timeframes. R&R Painting & concrete coatings customers note that Mark sticks to scheduled start dates, which matters when coordinating with other contractors. "He was able to start the job on time, which was huge because he got it done just ahead of a graduation party." - Eric Ekstrom, Google Review. Colors of Rochester impresses with same-day completion on smaller projects, while Monarch Painting is praised for quick turnarounds on urgent pre-listing paint jobs.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook

Value and fair pricing come up regularly in reviews for painting contractors serving Brockport, NY. While most reviewers do not list exact dollar amounts, a common theme is that the finished work exceeded what customers expected for the price.

Whelehan Painting stands out on pricing, with one reviewer noting the company came in as the lowest bid yet delivered results that drew compliments from neighbors. "The price was fair and reasonable comparatively. The other recommended contractors estimated 2 weeks. Whelehan completed the job in 2 and a half days." - Howie Less, Google Review. R&R Painting & concrete coatings customers describe reasonable pricing with no surprise charges. Painting Plus Professionals earns praise for cabinet refinishing that costs significantly less than full replacement while looking brand new. Sekula's Precision Painting reviewers mention fair pricing for both interior and exterior work. Colors of Rochester is described as reasonably priced with detailed estimates upfront. Both Whelehan Painting and R&R Painting do not require deposits before starting, which reviewers appreciate.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, BBB, Angi

Repeat business and referrals are a defining pattern across the top painting contractors serving Brockport, NY. Many reviewers mention being on their second, third, or even fourth project with the same company.

Whelehan Painting has some of the most striking loyalty examples. One customer has used them for 17 consecutive years, while another hired them three times over six years. "I keep coming back for many reasons: high quality, fair pricing, and a crew I trust inside my home." - Greg Rowe, Google Review. Sekula's Precision Painting shows a similar pattern, with one customer hiring them for exterior work in 2021 and returning in 2024 for a full interior project. R&R Painting & concrete coatings customers mention planning future projects with Mark before the current one wraps up. "Will definitely hire him again." - Toula Beane, Google Review. Monarch Painting has multiple reviewers describing second and third projects, while Painting Plus Professionals and Colors of Rochester also have reviewers describing plans to hire again, with word-of-mouth referrals running through many reviews.

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Yelp