Our Chooz Score evaluates 44 factors across reviews, digital presence, and business credentials. Here's what stands out for A & L Painting
A & L Painting has built a ten-year track record in the Rochester, NY area by turning dated kitchens into modern showpieces and refreshing interiors and exteriors with the same hands-on precision. Owner Matt Coniglio started the company in 2015, and the crew that shows up to each job follows a numbered, door-by-door cabinet refinishing process that customers compare to factory-quality results.
The team handles interior wall and ceiling painting, trim and baseboard work, full exterior projects including decks and fences, and drywall repair. Matt personally estimates every project, answers color questions from the hardware store aisle, and conducts a final walk-through before the crew leaves. Customers like Marney Horvath, a local realtor, keep A & L Painting on their preferred-contractor list and refer the company to clients buying homes that need a fresh start.
BBB Accredited (A+ rating) since 2017 and fully insured, A & L Painting operates as a sole proprietorship with in-house crews who are identified by name in nearly every review. Free estimates are available throughout the Rochester metro area by calling (585) 478-4623 or visiting alpaint.com.
Updated: 06-17-2026
The crew arrives, removes every cabinet door and drawer face, numbers each piece, then preps and paints them using a multi-step system. Vincent Galione described a kitchen transformation "within a couple of days" with results "better than I ever expected." Michael Doty noted his cabinets were completed "in under 4 hours" with the team cleaning up as though "they were never there." Matt inspects the finished work with the homeowner before wrapping up.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Matt personally visits the home for a free estimate, walks through the scope of work, and sets a firm start date. Kimberly Richards noted Matt "answered all of our questions starting from the initial quote process all the way through the end." During the job, the crew stays responsive to changes. Phil Martello said Matt "always stayed in communication and was always responsive to changes and updates." An end-of-project check ensures satisfaction before the crew leaves.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
The crew returns to address it at no extra charge. Andrew Wadsworth "noticed a few touch-up spots and he was back to take care of them." Kimberly Richards had a similar experience and confirmed "Matt sent someone right away to fix those areas." Shawn Keeler noted the team was "more concerned about my satisfaction than getting to the next job." This follow-through pattern appears across multiple reviews.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Multiple reviewers compare the team to a well-oiled machine. Sue Wahl called them "a well oiled machine" whose "finished job was perfect." Bonnie Jenny used similar language, describing the crew as "a fine oiled machine." Matthew Sharman observed a four-week project where the crew "showed up ready to work with the same energy, enthusiasm, and attention to detail from start to finish." Reviewers consistently note punctuality, neatness, and friendliness.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Several customers have hired A & L Painting more than once. Ryan Ford wrote about his "third time" using the company and praised the interior work. Shelley Butts "invited them back to do a 2nd project after loving how our kitchen cabinets turned out." David Simpson has had "numerous jobs done by Matt and his crew." Marney Horvath, a local realtor, keeps A & L Painting on her "preferred painter list."
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
Karen Bee left a 1-star review after Matt missed two scheduled estimate visits. Matt responded publicly, took full ownership, wrote that he was "all about owning it whether you are right or wrong," explained personal and business challenges that led to the error, and apologized without deflecting. The transparent response and accountability pattern contrasts with the otherwise consistent punctuality noted across 40+ other reviews.
-Review Snippet Sources: Google Reviews
A & L Painting has been in business since November 2015 and has maintained a BBB A+ rating with accreditation since 2017. The company operates as a sole proprietorship under owner Matt Coniglio. New York State does not require a statewide painting contractor license. The company states it is fully insured.
-Verification Sources: BBB, NY Department of State
Updated: 06-17-2026