Painting contractors serving Scottsville, NY draw from the broader Rochester market, where a competitive local industry has produced some of the most reviewed and consistently rated crews in western New York. The contractors listed here cover the full range of residential painting needs, from historic home exteriors to kitchen cabinet refreshes and specialty floor coatings.
The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating and earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%. With 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 Facebook recommendations and recognition as a Greater Rochester Chamber of Commerce Business Person of the Year, the company's credibility spans platforms. Owner Chris is named across many reviews, and what stands out from a close read of them is how consistently customers describe communication throughout the entire experience - from the office staff (Kaitlyn is named in multiple reviews for handling scheduling and updates) to crew leads keeping clients informed on-site. Commercial projects appear alongside residential ones in the review history, including work at a family business setup and a daycare center.
- The office team handles scheduling proactively and communicates weather delay updates to customers before they have to ask
- Crews consistently cover and protect furniture and belongings before starting, then return items to their original positions afterward
- Named painters like Ray, Nick, and Uriah appear independently in reviews spanning multiple years of the company's history
- Commercial and multi-family projects are part of Sekula's portfolio alongside standard residential work
"We used them for our family business when we were setting up our store. I wish more businesses were run like this. Professional, honest, and follow through!" - Hadi Sattari, Google Review
If you want a well-organized crew with proven commercial and residential experience, Sekula's Precision Painting is a strong choice.
While Sekula's Precision Painting covers a wide scope of work, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings has built particular depth in deck staining and exterior restoration. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5% and, at the time of our analysis, had over 200 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score across that volume is genuinely rare. Owner Mark Rivoli is mentioned by name in nearly every review, and customers describe him helping with color decisions, adjusting schedules around weather for best results, and addressing any issues without pushback. The company has also handled historic district work, including cedar shake replacement and three-story exteriors with original materials.
- Deck staining and restoration make up a significant share of R&R's workload, with dozens of deck-specific reviews across the company's history
- Mark is consistently described as personally responsive - returning texts and calls quickly throughout the estimate and project stages
- Several reviewers independently describe R&R as among the more competitive quotes they received for comparable work
- Both residential and commercial jobs appear in the review history, including an orthodontic office and a VFW post exterior
"There is a BIG DIFFERENCE. Painting is mostly about the prep work. And Mark and his team did a fantastic job. They also showed up on time and worked ALL DAY." - Nicholas Benedetto, Google Review
If you have a deck in need of staining or an exterior job with specific material requirements, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings is worth a close look.
Repeat customers and referrals tell the story for Monarch Painting. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3% with over 95 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating. Owner Eric Anderson has been recognized as a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in both 2021 and 2023, and over 5 years in business the company has cultivated a following that keeps coming back. One reviewer, Joan Termini, noted she has had all of her painting done by Eric and Monarch since moving into her home 20 years ago - a level of client retention that is genuinely unusual in the contractor world.
- Wallpaper removal is a frequent add-on service that Monarch handles alongside painting work
- Eric often suggests additional small touch-ups or improvements beyond the original project scope
- Customers working out of town have trusted Monarch to complete work unsupervised, with photos sent for project updates
- Monarch is fully insured and lead-safe certified for work on pre-1978 homes
"I could not be happier with the work done by Eric and his Monarch Painting crew! Their attention to detail and thoroughness set a high standard for painting professionals. They are efficient with their time, and the walls are prepped perfectly before painting. When they completed the job, the clean up was thorough." - Kathryn Fiske, Google Review
For homeowners who want a painter they can build a long-term relationship with, Monarch Painting consistently earns that loyalty.
When it comes to specialty finishes beyond standard painting, Painting Plus Professionals stands out. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5% with over 75 Google reviews and a 5.0-star rating, along with a 4.8-star rating on Angi across over 35 Angi reviews, BBB accreditation since 2016, and the 2022 Best of Rochester Award in the Painting category. What differentiates Painting Plus from most contractors on this list is a dedicated line of work in epoxy garage floor coatings - several customers who were told their floors needed full replacement found a far more affordable solution through the company's epoxy process.
- Tyler brings physical sample cabinet doors to estimates - a practice multiple reviewers single out as unique among all the contractors they evaluated
- Epoxy floor installations have rescued garage floors that other companies quoted for costly full replacement
- Multiple reviewers note zero paint mess - not a drop on appliances, floors, or surfaces outside the painted area
- Full exterior house painting is in their portfolio alongside cabinet and flooring specialty work
"Tyler brought over sample cabinet doors when he came to do our estimate and was the only company to do so. Seeing a finished product and being able to feel the finish helped us move forward with confidence." - Emily Audet, Google Review
If you're weighing cabinet repainting, epoxy flooring, or full interior painting, Painting Plus Professionals is well-suited to handle all three.
For homeowners focused on exterior and deck work, Golden Boys Painting & Staining brings over 13 years in business and some of the most experienced crew-level talent on this list. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.0% with over 75 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating, plus 94% recommended on Facebook and 5.0 stars on both Angi and Yelp. One pattern that surfaces in reviews and doesn't appear as often for other companies: customers noting that owner Dan honestly assessed what didn't need painting rather than recommending an unnecessary full job - a quality one homeowner with a log cabin specifically appreciated after other contractors had pushed for a complete re-stain.
- Crew chief Aaron Palmer brings over 20 years of painting experience, and Tadd Tilton has been with the company since its founding
- Final invoices consistently match estimates, per multiple independent reviewers
- Angie's List Super Service Award winner in 2014, 2015, and 2016
- Cabinet work, deck staining, exterior painting, and wallpaper removal are all represented in the company's reviews
"Our site manager communicated every step of the way. Listened to and addressed any concerns or questions we had each day. And the paint job was perfect. Spot on the estimate! Best contractor experience by far." - Jennifer Forrest, Google Review
If you want an honest assessment of what your exterior or deck actually needs, Golden Boys Painting & Staining is worth contacting.
With the largest Google review base on this list, Level Up Painting has built a reputation that holds up at scale. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 275 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating and earned a Chooz Score of 84.5%. Co-owners Jacob Rabideau and Clyde Miller have built a team with multiple named crew leaders - Anthony, Jon, Rebecca, Jake, and Calvin each appear by name across independent reviews - which means customers are getting structured crews rather than whoever is available. With over 8 years in business and EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certification for pre-1978 homes, Level Up is one of the stronger options for historic Rochester-area properties.
- Level Up honors its warranty without friction - at least one reviewer describes door bubbling addressed promptly and properly under warranty coverage
- Long-time repeat customers account for a notable share of the review base, including one reviewer noting it was their sixth engagement with the company
- The company uses a brush-only approach for exterior work rather than spraying - a quality differentiator that Yelp reviewers specifically call out
- Projects on 100-year-old, 200-year-old, and preservation district homes appear across the company's review history
"Level Up painted our large 200 year old three story house and it looks beautiful! Jon and his team of Ryan, Jamel and Doug all did an excellent job of prepping and painting. Everything was done as they said it would be and in the timeframe they gave us." - Sandra Smith, Google Review
For homeowners with older or historic properties, or anyone who wants a well-staffed crew with a proven track record across hundreds of reviews, Level Up Painting is a reliable choice.
Rounding out the top contractors serving Scottsville, NY, A & L Painting has built a particularly strong reputation for kitchen cabinet work. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.3% with over 80 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating. At the time of our analysis, the company was 100% recommended on Facebook across over 85 Facebook recommendations, held a 5.0-star rating on the BBB, and carried BBB accreditation since 2017. With over 10 years in business, owner Matt Coniglio has built a crew that works at consistent speed - one-day cabinet jobs are mentioned across dozens of reviews, and several customers who had cabinets painted years earlier note the finish has held up with no need for touch-ups.
- Matt contacts customers after job completion to confirm satisfaction - several reviewers note this happened without prompting
- Full kitchen cabinet repainting is routinely completed in a single day
- Multiple customers have returned for third and even fourth projects after strong cabinet experiences
- A & L also handles exterior painting and full interior projects beyond cabinet work
"Hire Matt & his crew (this is our third time)! We just recently moved and had A&L paint the entire interior of the home. They worked tirelessly and completed the project in two days!! The level of detail is top notch as well!!" - Ryan Ford, Google Review
If cabinet repainting or a full interior project is on your list, A & L Painting is a practical and proven option.
~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, BBB, Angi, Yelp
