6 Best Painters Near Spencerport, NY Ranked by Chooz Score

Homeowners in Spencerport, NY have access to a strong field of professional painting contractors serving the greater Rochester area. Based on our Chooz Score analysis, here are the top-rated painters currently serving Spencerport, NY.

The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, Sekula's Precision Painting had over 75 Google reviews with a 4.6-star rating and 100% recommended on Facebook across over 50 recommendations. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.9%, the highest on this list. Accredited with the Better Business Bureau since 2017 and over 8 years in business, owner Chris Sekula leads a team of named, consistent crew leads - Ray, Nick, Uriah, Christian, and Dave - who appear in reviews spanning multiple years. The company accommodates multi-phase projects, large exterior crews of six or more, and challenging older homes with plaster surfaces and intricate trim. If you're looking for a contractor with proven long-term reliability across both residential and commercial work, Sekula's Precision Painting is a strong fit.

• Office staff (Caitlyn is mentioned by name across multiple reviews) and crew leads maintain consistent contact throughout a project - from estimate and color coordination through final walkthrough.
• Several customers have returned for a second or third project years after their first job, with the same crew names reappearing in their later reviews.
• The company handles large exterior jobs with coordinated crews, managing multi-day schedules and weather-related adjustments without losing momentum on the job.

"If I could give them more stars, I would! Chris and his team are consummate professionals. They ticked every box: prompt, hard-working, skilled, friendly, and respectful of our home." - Elizabeth Palmer, Google Review

While Sekula's Precision Painting built its loyal base over 8 years, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings has amassed one of the highest review volumes among Rochester-area painters in a much shorter window. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings had over 200 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating - a perfect score at that volume is uncommon. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.5%. Owner Mark Rivoli personally attends most jobs, walks through projects before and after, and reviewers describe him returning the next day to correct any details that were not right. Beyond painting, the crew handles deck staining, concrete coatings, chimney refinishing, and commercial projects. If you are looking for an owner-operated company with a wide range of services and a flawless review track record, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings is a strong option.

• Mark Rivoli personally handles estimates, attends jobs regularly, and reviewers describe him returning the next day when any detail needs attention after completion.
• The crew has completed everything from historic district exterior work on three-story homes to commercial painting for a VFW post - including their display helicopter on the grounds.
• Customers who gathered multiple competing quotes consistently report that R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings offered the most competitive pricing alongside strong communication and follow-through.

"R&R Painting was fantastic from the first interaction to the last. Mark and his crew provided excellent customer service, clear communication and timelines, and the house looks incredible. So many neighbors have shared with us how much they like it too." - Glen Dornsife, Google Review

For homeowners with older Rochester-area properties, Monarch Painting has earned a reputation as the go-to crew for surfaces that need extra care. They earned a Chooz Score of 87.3%, and the last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 95 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus recognition as a Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite in 2021 and 2023. Owner Eric Andersen checks in personally during longer projects and follows up after completion when details need attention. Named crew members Jimmy, Brent, Angelica, Brian, and Charlie appear across different reviewers in different seasons. Beyond painting, the team handles wallpaper removal, floor refinishing, exterior stucco repairs, and original wood door restoration. Good fit for older or historic homes that need more than a fresh coat.

• The same crew names appear across different reviewers in different years, confirming consistent in-house staffing across the company's 5-plus years in operation.
• Projects extend beyond painting to include wallpaper removal, textured ceiling removal, floor refinishing after carpet is pulled, and exterior repairs on century-old homes.

"Eric and his team did an excellent job painting and repairing our 90 year old Dutch colonial home and garage! From replacing worn cedar shakes to wood trim needing repair they paid great attention to detail and everything looks completely revitalized." - Jim Murphy, Google Review

When cabinet refinishing, garage epoxy floors, or specialty finishes are part of your project, Painting Plus Professionals brings capabilities that most painters on this list do not. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 75 Google reviews with a 5.0-star rating, plus a 4.8-star rating on Angi across over 35 reviews and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau since 2016. They earned a Chooz Score of 86.5%. Tyler's practice of bringing physical sample cabinet doors to estimates is cited by multiple independent reviewers as the reason they chose the company over competitors. Crew member Alex has saved homeowners from costly concrete replacement through epoxy garage floor solutions. Good fit if your project involves specialty surfaces or finishes.

• Tyler brings physical sample cabinet doors to every cabinet estimate - multiple reviewers cited this hands-on demonstration as the deciding factor in their hiring decision.
• Alex has handled heavily pitted garage floors that competing companies quoted for full concrete replacement, delivering epoxy solutions at a fraction of the cost.

"Tyler brought over sample cabinet doors when he came to do our estimate and was the only company to do so. Seeing a finished product and being able to feel the quality of the paint and how it is applied really helped us understand what we were paying for." - Emily Audet, Google Review

Also serving the Spencerport, NY area, Colors of Rochester takes a personal, owner-on-site approach. They earned a Chooz Score of 85.1%, with over 55 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating, plus 100% recommended on Facebook across over 20 recommendations. Owner Hope Worthington took over the company in late 2023 and maintained its strong reputation through the change. The company holds Monroe County MWBE certification and OSHA 10 Construction credentials, with crew certifications in Lead and Silica Awareness and Fall Protection. Hope is named in nearly every review and works on-site alongside her crew. If you want an owner-led team with flexibility for older homes, mid-project decisions, and scheduling changes, Colors of Rochester is a good choice.

• Hope personally handles estimates, works alongside her crew on most projects, and customers describe flexibility that larger companies often cannot match - including color changes requested mid-project and properties managed remotely with photo updates sent while owners are away.
• Monroe County MWBE certified, OSHA 10 Construction certified, with crew credentials covering Lead Awareness, Silica Safety, and Fall Protection.

"Working with Hope and her crew was a breeze! The quoting process was fast and detailed. We have an old house with a good amount of chipping trim, and they handled it with care and expertise." - Andrea P., Google Review

Rounding out the top contractors in Spencerport, NY, Level Up Painting brings the largest review base of any company on this list. The last time we conducted our Chooz Score analysis, they had over 275 Google reviews with a 4.8-star rating, plus 84% recommended on Facebook. They earned a Chooz Score of 84.5%. Co-owners Jacob Rabideau and Clyde Miller have built the company over 8 years in business around in-house crews and a brush-first exterior painting approach. The company is EPA RRP Lead-Safe Certified and backs workmanship with a limited warranty of up to 4 years. Crew leaders Jon, Anthony, Rebecca, and Calvin are each mentioned by name across dozens of independent reviews. Good fit for homeowners with historic or preservation-district properties, or those who want a well-staffed, high-volume operation with a documented warranty behind the work.

• The company backs workmanship with a limited warranty of up to 4 years - one reviewer described the crew returning months after completion to address exterior door bubbling at no charge, under warranty.
• The brush-first exterior approach earns specific praise from customers who have had sprayed work done by other companies before, with reviewers noting cleaner lines and better coverage on older homes with complex trim.
• Co-owners maintain consistent in-house crew teams - the same leads (Jon, Anthony, Rebecca, Calvin) appear across dozens of independent reviews spanning multiple seasons and years.

"Level up painting painted multiple rooms in my house, including ceilings, kitchen cabinets, and walls/trim. Everything looks amazing! My kitchen looks brand new! All of the painters were incredibly respectful, arrived on time, worked super efficiently, and kept all the work areas very clean." - Jennifer Leone, Google Review

~Review Snippet Sources: Google, Facebook, Angi, BBB

Across the painting contractors serving Spencerport, NY, quality and craftsmanship are the themes that come up most consistently in customer reviews. Companies like Sekula's Precision Painting, Monarch Painting, and R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings each earn praise not just for finished results, but for the process that produces them. Reviewers commonly highlight thorough prep work - patching holes, sanding uneven walls, and priming difficult surfaces - as what separates these crews from less experienced painters. The same crew names appear across multiple reviewers and different years, suggesting consistent quality rather than one-off results.

Painting Plus Professionals and Level Up Painting draw similar comments, with customers describing finished work that exceeded what they expected from the estimate. Colors of Rochester earns specific recognition for precision on trim lines, ceiling cuts, and edges - details that determine whether a room looks professionally done or merely repainted. Level Up Painting's brush-first exterior approach is frequently cited by reviewers who have had sprayed exteriors done before, with customers pointing to better coverage on older homes with complex trim and fascia.

• "They did a truly wonderful job from start to finish. They were professional, careful, and paid great attention to detail in every room. The colors came out beautifully and completely refreshed the space." - Luanne Strasenburgh, Google Review (Sekula's Precision Painting)
• "Very talented painters. They have done a beautiful job with our ceilings, walls, and trim in several rooms and hallway. A pleasure to do business with and to have in our home." - Kara Cilano, Google Review (Monarch Painting)
• "Most amazing was their attention to detail in the prep work. There was not even a drop of paint on the appliances or the floor or anywhere where it shouldn't be." - James Maxwell, Google Review (Painting Plus Professionals)
• "The painting was of exceptionally high quality - edges perfectly cut-in, leaving a pristine backdrop for hanging my pictures." - Kate Rubin, Google Review (R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Communication is one of the most consistently praised qualities among painting contractors serving Spencerport, NY. Reviewers across companies like Sekula's Precision Painting, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings, and Level Up Painting describe a pattern of proactive updates - notifications before work begins, daily check-ins during the job, and quick responses to questions or concerns. Sekula's Precision Painting stands out for having office staff mentioned by name alongside crew leads, reinforcing that communication is built into the company structure rather than left to individual painters on site.

Monarch Painting and Colors of Rochester take a more owner-direct approach - Eric Andersen and Hope Worthington personally field questions, provide estimates, and stay in contact throughout projects. Painting Plus Professionals earns recognition for crew members who brief homeowners at the start and end of each workday, keeping customers informed without requiring them to follow up. For homeowners managing busy schedules or those away from home during a project, this communication consistency makes a meaningful difference in the overall experience.

• "This company runs as a business should - prompt response time, great communication from start to finish. Team arrives on time, does professional work and they neatly store their tools each day." - Suzanne Calia, Google Review (Sekula's Precision Painting)
• "He was always responsive leading up to the job and he was able to start the job on time, which was huge because he got it done just a few days before my son's birthday party we hosted in our new house." - Eric Ekstrom, Google Review (R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings)
• "They were very responsive to my husband and I, thorough in planning and executing the job, and completed final touches before finishing." - Navpreet Singh, Google Review (Painting Plus Professionals)
• "Excellent communication with the customer. Everyone was friendly and congenial. My house never looked better!" - Carol Lanterman, Google Review (Level Up Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Cleanup and property protection are recurring themes in reviews of painting contractors serving Spencerport, NY. Customers consistently describe crews that arrive with drop cloths and protective coverings, move furniture carefully before work begins, and leave spaces in the same condition - or better - at the end of each day. Reviewers of Sekula's Precision Painting frequently note that crews store equipment neatly each day on multi-day projects, making it easy for families to continue using their homes without disruption. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings draws specific praise for thorough end-of-day cleanup, with customers describing job sites left clean and organized overnight.

Monarch Painting customers highlight careful coverage of floors, counters, and cabinets during interior work, with multiple reviewers noting they could not find a stray paint mark after the crew finished. Painting Plus Professionals earns recognition for zero-mess kitchen and cabinet projects - customers describe appliances, floors, and counters left completely clean. Level Up Painting's exterior crews are noted for removing gutter downspouts before painting, cleaning up scraping debris before it can reach landscaping, and reinstalling everything neatly when the work is done.

• "They made sure to cover every square inch of floor, counter, cabinets, etc. and we have not found a stray splash of paint anywhere after they left." - Nicole Nezelek, Google Review (Monarch Painting)
• "Very professional and friendly crew, with quality prep, painting, and cleanup. Went the extra mile to ensure high quality work, and everything looks great as a result." - Bruce McClellan, Google Review (Sekula's Precision Painting)
• "We've had other painters before who have been sloppy and left messes. Not this company - the dining room looks fantastic now thanks to them! When we need more paint jobs done, we know who to call." - Ashley Cummings, Google Review (R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Pricing competitiveness is a consistent theme in reviews of painting contractors serving Spencerport, NY, with customers frequently reporting that these companies hold up well against multiple competing quotes. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings receives frequent mentions for fair pricing - one reviewer who gathered seven quotes reported that R&R offered the most reasonable estimate while matching or exceeding the quality of higher-priced competitors. Sekula's Precision Painting earns similar praise, with customers describing pricing as fair for the level of service, crew quality, and finished results delivered.

Monarch Painting and Level Up Painting are each described by customers as delivering value that exceeded their expectations given the price point. Colors of Rochester stands out for competitive rates given the level of owner involvement - Hope Worthington personally works each job alongside her crew, a hands-on service that typically commands a premium at larger companies. Painting Plus Professionals adds value through specialty finishes: cabinet refinishing and epoxy garage floors deliver significant visual upgrades at well below the cost of full cabinet replacement or concrete work.

• "We found their prices to be very fair and they were a breeze to work with. We highly recommend them for any project large or small!" - Elaina Caven, Google Review (Sekula's Precision Painting)
• "On top of doing an amazing job they were by far the most reasonable quote and we gathered 7 quotes total." - Juliana Baratta, Google Review (R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings)
• "They do exceptional work, they are extremely kind and responsive, they go above and beyond and always offered to help with additional tasks as they arose, and they are VERY reasonably priced." - Cami Goldowitz, Google Review (Monarch Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Scheduling reliability is one of the most praised qualities among painting contractors serving Spencerport, NY. Across companies like Sekula's Precision Painting, R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings, and Level Up Painting, customers describe a consistent pattern: advance notice before a project begins, proactive updates when weather or logistics cause changes, and arrival times that match what was promised. Level Up Painting stands out for pre-job communication - multiple reviewers describe receiving phone calls days before the start date, and again the morning work begins, so there are no surprises on either end.

R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings earns specific mentions for finishing projects ahead of schedule - a meaningful outcome for customers who planned around a specific completion date. Sekula's Precision Painting has managed large exterior jobs on tight coordinated timelines even during extended rainy stretches. Monarch Painting reviewers note that the company communicates clearly when weather affects outdoor work, keeping customers informed rather than leaving them to follow up on their own.

• "They finished the project even earlier than promised! I always received answers for ALL of my questions and felt that they were very personable." - Kaily LaForce, Google Review (R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings)
• "They were on time every morning and completed the job when they said they would. The crew was very friendly and respectful of the items in our home." - Makini Beck, Google Review (Sekula's Precision Painting)
• "Their attention to detail and communication were exemplary and they extended hours to meet the job requirements even with terrible weather." - Nate Driscoll, Google Review (Level Up Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google

Repeat customers and word-of-mouth referrals are strong indicators of contractor quality, and several painting companies serving Spencerport, NY score high on both. Sekula's Precision Painting has a notable number of reviewers who returned for a second or third project years after their first job, often naming the same crew leads they worked with previously. Monarch Painting's Eric Andersen has cultivated a loyal base - one reviewer has relied on the company for all painting needs for over 20 years, while others describe booking their next job before the current one wraps up.

Level Up Painting shows a similar pattern, with customers describing their second, fifth, and even sixth project with the same company and calling out specific crew leads for return visits. R&R Painting & Concrete Coatings benefits from referrals within customer networks - multiple reviewers describe being introduced to Mark Rivoli through a neighbor, colleague, or friend with their own positive experience. Sekula's Precision Painting also draws professional referrals, with a remodeling contractor who routes all painting work for his own clients to the company.

• "They did an excellent job and the crew was polite, professional and very attentive to detail. I had a number of interior painting projects that I wanted done during this winter (2024) and so I contacted Sekula again about doing it." - Lisa Woodhouse, Google Review (Sekula's Precision Painting)
• "Great experience working with Eric and his crew. Have used Monarch for years and plan to do so again. Highly reliable and attentive to detail." - Christopher D'Angelo, Google Review (Monarch Painting)
• "I have gone to Level Up Painting for 2 projects now. I continue to be satisfied with the quality, price, and speed. I will call Level Up again when I have another project!" - Philippe Boulanger, Google Review (Level Up Painting)

~Review Snippet Sources: Google